16 ms·
What Amazon Teaches Us About AI and the “Jobless Future”
- sharemywin 9y agoummm...way to ignore all the retail jobs disappearing from e-commerce. Don't get me wrong companies do a great job of automating things and growing. And investors do a great job of betting on the things that have the best odds. I don't have a plausible solution. Besides lottery don't have a fair way to invest irrationally. But, if society doesn't find a way to retrain(invest in) those people that were replaced we lose all the potential they had to offer.
- nck4222 9y agoRetail jobs are growing, not disappearing, and they're expected to continue to grow. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/sales/retail-sales-workers.htm https://www.bls.gov/ooh/sales/retail-sales-workers.htm
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoAren't retail jobs, with few exceptions, the definition of low skill, low wage labor?
- sharemywin 9y agoNot sure where their going to be working: http://clark.com/shopping-retail/major-retailers-closing-2017/ http://clark.com/shopping-retail/major-retailers-closing-201... Maybe Amazon's new retail stores.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoI'm guessing maybe minor retailers? Some small store close to your house/school/office when you can't be bothered to wait for shipping.
- Applejinx 9y agoI would not dare to try and open some small store and gamble on people not wanting to wait for Amazon. If you think that's still something that can be done, try it. Better still, get a business loan to launch something like that. I'll wait. It's hard to even think of a thing more self-evidently doomed.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThe last sentence is just not true. More doomed would be to invest a lot in infrastructure and economies of scale and try to beat Amazon at their own game. So don't do that, open a small convenience store instead. Where else are all those retail jobs coming from? Not a rhetorical question, I really don't know.
- calibration263 9y ago>But, if society doesn't find a way to retrain(invest in) those people that were replaced we lose all the potential they had to offer. Since this article is specifically about amazon and FC employees, I think it's relevant to point out they have a program to do just that. Career Choice pre-pays up to $12k in tuition towards degrees/certificates for an in-demand trade/field, and up to 95% reimbursement on books: https://www.amazon.com/p/feature/fsp92a2bhozr3wj https://www.amazon.com/p/feature/fsp92a2bhozr3wj
- azakai 9y agoAmazon's success is remarkable, and yes it is adding jobs at a high rate, both internally and via contractors, third-party sellers, etc. But the bigger question is whether the Amazon job increases offset the jobs that are lost elsewhere, as retail outlets close, Amazon's direct competitors fail, etc. Amazon and its satellites are growing, but is the job market as a whole? I don't know the answer, and it might be hard to estimate. But the optimism of the article requires a leap of faith without that information.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoAmazon is the next iteration of Walmart
- notyourwork 9y agoIn what way?
- clock_tower 9y agoIf I were to guess: Wal-Mart has a very bad reputation for sucking the wealth out of a community; money spent at a locally-owned store is more likely to circulate in the community, while with Wal-Mart the money's spent once and no one but the Waltons ever sees it again. Amazon might be a little bit like that: a fountain of wealth for Seattle (and check out real estate prices there if you think that's an exaggeration), but pumping that wealth out of all the rest of the globe. But I see a weakness in this argument: Wal-Mart mostly displaced existing chain stores, which had similar wealth-pump effects -- and which had much higher prices than Wal-Mart, partially because they wanted higher prices but mostly because they didn't have Wal-Mart's hyper-efficient supply chain. And the old corner groceries and general stores had supply chains that were even worse than the previous generation of chain stores, and therefore even higher prices and even smaller variety... So: you hear the wealth-pump argument, wealth pumps do sometimes exist, and I'm pretty sure the previous poster was accusing Amazon and Wal-Mart of both being wealth pumps; but I'm not entirely sure that that's what's going on with either business. If it is going on, of course, it's a problem. (Have there been any studies on Wal-Mart's effect on areas where it opens?)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kiliantics 9y agoThis post neglects a lot of externalities. Before, a single kettle could last generations. I'm personally very disturbed by the idea of more and more people getting many deliveries every single day. That kind of consumption is insanity and just think of the carbon footprint. They mention clothing too. Clothing is an incredibly harmful industry for the environment and don't forget how it affects workers - be they seamstresses in unsafe factories in Bangladesh or inmates in cotton fields in Louisiana. I don't know why we should be happy how many clothes we can all wear now. The big problem with automation is the trend of who really benefits most. The point is made in the article that the consumer will experience massive benefits. And this is true if you are a first world professional, like people working in silicon valley. But how much of the new employment in Amazon is in fulfilment centres? Those don't sound like the kinds of jobs we should be happy that automation is creating and they are hardly going to last long either. I'd love if all vehicles became smart electronic driverless miracle machines and getting blood to dying mothers sounds great. I just can't support these shifts if there isn't also a big change in the class structure of the society that these changes are happening in. The wealth this creates should be less concentrated and the benefits and TRUE costs (incl. Environmental) shared more equally.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThe kind of people who benefit most from being able to buy cheap clothes made in sweatshops is not Silicon Valley professionals, it's poor people. Get rid of the unsafe factories and poor people won't be able to afford clothes anymore. And the workers of those unsafe factories won't be able to afford anything. There is no easy answer.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoThe can most certainly afford clothing, if not make their own. What they can't afford is fashion
- saint_fiasco 9y agoNo they can't. Being able to change clothes (incl. underwear) everyday is a recent custom, and a luxury. Even if they can, the extra money they would have to spend is money that they won't be able to spend in food and other essentials. Time they spend making clothes is time they can't spend making money for buying other things, or in education.
- olewhalehunter 9y agoThese arguments come up a lot when discussing this topic and there's some points that don't really hold, usually because the apologist either doesn't know the world of sweatshops or doesn't want to bring it up. The people working in sweatshops start as young children, often sold by their parents to pay debts. Often pay is withheld and they just become slaves or they are fed just enough to keep their fingers moving and their brains starved. The sweatshop may provide enough income for that child to grow up to produce more children, who then become sweatshop workers themselves, child prostitutes, or slaves, or they may just die on the job. Nutrition deficiencies and stress get baked into their genetics: congratulations you now have a permanent underclass living worse than some animals, and similar to livestock, crowded populations, poor medical administration, and hellish living conditions result in festering and evolving pathogens that you and Paul Krugman may soon be more interested in. The result of providing just enough for them to survive to make children is not "less poverty", it's more poverty, more death, more child slavery or prostitution, and if emotional arguments don't register with you, exotic pandemics coupled with antibiotic misuse just might. Secondly, America does not have a clothes shortage. The unfathomable amount of (often expensive) clothing thrown away by both consumers and suppliers in disgusting. Shrewd families from the lower income to the middle class buy used or keep hand-me-downs. Once or twice during move out season on campus my partner and I raid the rich dormitories and find upwards of thousands of dollars worth of designer clothing among other things. Many stores throw their out of season clothing straight into the dump. The defense of a situation where hundreds of millions live in hell to produce mountains of goods that end in landfills, on an economic argument, is absurd.
- mixedCase 9y ago> The result of providing just enough for them to survive to make children is not "less poverty", it's more poverty, more death, more child slavery or prostitution. Yet, they keep on doing it. It sounds like the alternative is worse.
- olewhalehunter 9y agoDeath is a better alternative for many, who are then prevented from committing suicide without resorting to gruesome means. Improvised abortions are common. Recognizing this shouldn't be controversial.
- narrator 9y agoJevons Paradox in action: The more efficiently a resource is used , in this case labor, the higher the demand for it will be. This unfortunately is not something your average arm chair economist will figure out intuitively and leads to the same mistakes in analysis being made over and over again.
- jjoonathan 9y agoI'm sure the underclass will disappear any day now...
- Suncho 9y agoJevons Paradox in action: The more efficiently a resource is used , in this case labor, the higher the demand for it will be. The thing about labor is that it's not just any old resource. It's a resource whose price determines consumers' incomes. And consumers' incomes determine how much stuff they buy. There's a common myth that technology will make everything cheaper. It won't. Some things will get cheaper and other things will get more expensive. Economic policies prevent deflation, and therefore prevent the general price level from adjusting downward. If the price of one good decreases, the price of another good necessarily increases to compensate. Furthermore, labor can't be one of those goods whose price increases. At least not on its own. As labor becomes more efficient, the amount of money going to labor decreases for each unit of output. If we leave it up to the markets, increased labor efficency would lead to lower incomes and lower output and further lower incomes. But we have economic policies to address that too. We don't just leave it up to the markets. Instead, we do our best to negate the efficiency (labor productivity) that technology would have otherwise enabled. This keeps people's incomes reasonably high. Economic policies keep people employed, keep wages high, and keep labor inefficient. The Jevons Paradox doesn't really apply here... at least not in any kind of straightforward way. Tim O'Reilly -- and many economists (armchair or otherwise) -- seem to completely miss this point.
- Applejinx 9y agoSure. Example: 'horsepower'. Our transportation uses more horsepower than anyone could possibly have imagined in 1902. And no actual horses. This is exactly the same. In the future, the amount of labor that's done will be staggering, unimaginable, a real Jetsons future. …and no human workers, and no humans being paid to do any of it. Not even management. Think about it: should be equally obvious. Labor == horsepower.
- justboxing 9y ago> As long as we use the productivity gains from technology to create value for society, and ensure that value is widely shared so that customers are able to afford the cornucopia of goods on offer, we will find new ways to put people to work. Mmm, I'm sorry but how is the example of Amazon's productivity gains from technology that uses ROBOTS in a lot of places (and not people), putting people to work?
- petra 9y agoIt's actually interesting to think about Amazon's platforms. Most often what they do, is take some part of a startup or small business, a part that is relatively safe[1], over the long term for that business, and often serves as a part of moat, and let people do it on their platform, and leaving that business with a much higher ratio of risky-tasks/stable-tasks. The end result is that businesses are becoming much more risky(over the long term), more hit-driven, and much more hollow(job and knowledge wise). And it doesn't seem like something good for the economy. [1]For example, printing a shirt(and owning that printing machine). Or installing servers. Or keeping in-touch with customers and branding.
- theprop 9y agoThis article is misleading and wrong in some of its ideas. Every company wants to employ as little expensive and unreliable-relative-to-a-machine human labor as possible. Trying to cut down costs is in fact not short-sighted or somehow "wrong", it's efficient and great (as long as you're not treating people unethically or polluting the environment, etc.). Amazon is simply growing tremendously quickly...it's not that they're trying to create jobs. In the past 200 years there's been a tremendous increase in leisure for most people (except perhaps ironically for the best paid but that's a lot by choice), and also there has to date been no end to human desire. It used to take 80% of the labor force just to create food, now it's around 4%. It used to be 150 years ago the average American had 1 pair of paints and 2 shirts. Today the average American has 20 pairs of blue jeans. What's creating new jobs is not that a company is trying to create jobs but that human desires keep expanding.
- bamboozled 9y agoIn the past 200 years there's been a tremendous increase in leisure for most people My anecdotal observations don't align with that statement, most people I know work more than ever. It's almost madness. I would love to see some hard evidence to suggest otherwise. While technology is supposed to be making things more efficient (and sure it can do that), it's also making certain things more complex, and I'm not sure most humans have the desire to cope with the complexity very well (nor should they). This can create a time consuming quagmire of technical debt, I deal with it daily. A simple example of this growing complexity in society is food and beverage packaging. It's become too complex for most people to know how recycle things properly, and it's not really something people go out of their way to understand so it rarely gets done correctly, thus creating new problems.
- golergka 9y agoHow many people you know are from third world countries?
- bamboozled 9y agoFunny you should ask because I would say, more than you might imagine. I've actually spent time in third world countries volunteering and travelling and made some longer term friends out of it. The biggest problems they face are fallout from mass manufacturing and consumerism (rubbish dumps literally overflowing with western companies mess), deforestation (for palm oil) and climate change. Apart from being less materially well off, there are a lot of happy people in the third world who seem to be living a way more relaxing lives then people I know in the developed world who are up to there eyeballs in debt and working for high profile tech companies. But I think people just see what ever they want to see to justify their views and beliefs.
- suprgeek 9y agoThis is a very pernicious take on AI (and Amazon's usage of said AI). Amazon has hired 300000 professionals wohoo! more jobs! All those jobs are poorly paid, very labour intensive have almost zero benefits and usually not full time. If AI is giving us these kinds of jobs for the many for the instant gratification of consumers then we are worse off NOT better-off. Face it - the Advent of better AI (Robots, Driverless cars, etc) will lead to massive job losses and disruption of (currently) well paying jobs - the technology is advancing much faster than the ability of "blue collar" worker to retrain or adapt. It is indeed a "massive failure of imagination" - of the author to understand the real world limitations.
- ninkendo 9y agoIf folks are interested in this subject, Kurzgesagt recently put out a great video on this subject: https://youtu.be/WSKi8HfcxEk https://youtu.be/WSKi8HfcxEk
- anotheryou 9y agoHe wouldn't have bough the cattle if it wasn't delivered same day? And as Amazon grows, percentage of tasks done by humans shrinks. In this case and time amazon grows faster enough to employ more, but with a bit less growth and a bit better AI this caculation might be totally different. (and as others mentioned, one has to look at the net jobs beyond amazon)
- bertlequant 9y agoSomething a tad irksome in the way a corporate behemoth is praised. We all use Amazon, but we all used to shop at Wal-Mart. Difference seems to be everyone always seemed to at least sligtly detest Wal-Mart, but people talk about Amazon with awe and an almost joy-like appreciation. Some of my friends worked at fulfillment centers, and if most of these 100,000 new hires mentioned are headed to those places, the author fails to mention a very important part: retention. Since he seems very impressed by wheels, one could also compare the fulfillment centers to a gristmill, where people are ground up and discarded. Ever seen an ad for an Amazon fulfillment center hiring event? It's akin to seasonal hiring, where everyone who shows up at event is hired on the spot, knowing a lot of them will quit early on. If a job isn't retained past a certain point, it can't really be seen as a win. It would be interesting to see data about how long the average fulfillment center worker stays in a fulfillment center position. Many of us have read about how grueling it is to work in an Amazon fulfillment center, and after hearing my friends' stories I agree. The good thing for Amazon is that the customer never has to see this. They don't have to feel bad seeing what all went into getting them that tea kettle in under 6 hours. Sure, there is a lot of amazing logisitics and technology involved, but there is also a human element that is hidden. In Wal-Mart, you can walk right into a store and see the effects & signs of mass consumption, cheap products, and cheap labor. I think its visibility has driven a lot of the protests and blowback against Wal-Mart, successful or not. I think not being able to easily see the dark side of Amazon plays into Amazon's customer satisfaction in some ways. You order something and a box arrives. The only interaction you see is the one you made with your computer.
- jhoechtl 9y ago> Amazon expects to hire another 100,000 workers in the next eighteen months, many of them in its fulfillment centers Those are all extreme low wage jobs. Nobody can expect them to pay any substantial tax. Also jobs like these require little education, trapping children of these workers to do any better than their parents.
- ThomPete 9y agoO'Reilly confuses Amazon as a single example with the industry in general. It's the same broken argument that people make all the time by pointing to som factory that automated and had to hire new people. What people tend to forget here is by automating that company is gaining and advantage over others who aren't and will ultimately drive them out of business. So while the individual company might see an increase in jobs the industry in general doesn't necessarily. It's way more complex than even this as you can be in industries with growing demand ex due to globalization. But at the end of the day the same rule always apply. Companies in order to survive need to be more productive than their competitors and so technology will be used more and more until there isn't any jobs or only very few left. Also another thing that is often missed by those who claim new jobs will be created. Even if that was the case those jobs will be easier and easier to fill by AI. So it's not an argument for anything.
- PeterStuer 9y agoThe kind of 'jobs' Amazon is creating in fulfillment are exactly the kind of things that we should have robotized out of existence time ago. It is only because we tolerate modern slavery that these still exist. 'Jobs' are not a good thing. People don't need 'jobs', they need a life.
- delegate 9y agoThis article follows a similar line of reasoning as people who go "What global warming, look how cold it is outside!". The author brushes off the fact that Amazon has caused (is causing) countless retail shops to go out of business all over the world. As others have noted, 'just-in-time' consumption is insanity - cities are becoming perfectly oiled consumption and garbage making machines. I suspect (just speculating, no numbers) that this efficiency has a huge impact on climate. Similar to cars being 20% more efficient, but increasing number of cars by 50%. As for the jobs, I wonder how many kids dream of working at Amazon fulfillment centers when they grow up... meaning that it sounds like a pretty bad job - people used as transportation units by the algorithms. So not everything is rosy and shiny with Amazon. I try to avoid binging on it as much as possible. I applaud the efficiency and the 'You want it, you've got it', but I think the cost of that is hidden somewhere else and we all collectively pay it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]