6 ms·
Android's fragmentation leads to a digital security divide
- gruez 9y agoAt the risk of sounding like a libertarian, what's the issue here? Clearly the consumers/market has spoken and they place a very low value on security.
- pdog 9y agoNegative externalities. The cost of poor security isn't included in the price of an Android phone but it's paid for by society. Libertarianism doesn't have a good answer for economic externalities.
- zanny 9y agoTheir answer is supposed to be perfect economic information and all actors acting rationally and fully informed in all transactions. We have seen cultures adopt and change wildly, quickly, and fundamentally - just look at Russia, China, Japan, and Germany in the last 100 years - but the real libertarian breakthrough would be a reproducible way to shift a nations conscience to perfect information and absolute rationality in all business affairs.
- 1123581321 9y agoLibertarian view is essentially 1) all negative externalities are some kind of property/personal infringement, 2) the same values that urge regulation also urge externality-free purchasing preferences, 3) people free of large tax/regulatory burdens have an easier time fixing social problems, 4) sometimes the externality is worth bearing (e.g. it may be worth temporary security problems to get a billion smartphones into the developing world now.) I found these pretty easily by googling 'mises' and 'externalities' and while I could debate the specifics of the points, they seem to be just as legitimate an answer as regulation, which we know has its own negative externalities.
- pwthornton 9y agoI don't think I would say that consumer ignorance counts as consumers speaking via the market. Computer security is complicated stuff and no one really explains to users what the vulnerabilities are and how to mitigate them. The fact that we don't have chip and pin credit cards in the U.S. is hardly evidence that consumers don't want them or that they somehow prefer a system that makes it much easier for them to be defrauded. It's simply that the few credit card companies we have don't want to spend the money to provide chip and pin (or another secure payment system).
- NikolaeVarius 9y agoThat's untrue. The problem is that because once you get a chip and pin machine customers are obligated to use it. Businesses were wary that this would scare customers away due to "difficulty" so slowed down adoption.
- pwthornton 9y agoOther parts of the world have been using chip and pin systems for a long time. Clearly, customers understand it. Americans know how to use similar technology from ATM cards (and many make purchases this way). I have no doubt that businesses don't want to change and invest in new technology, but I have never met an individual credit card user who has professed love for our current credit card system.
- ars 9y agoChip is not especially hard to use, but it's unquestionably a worse and slower interface. With a swipe you can do it while they are still scanning your items, and you can swipe and immediately put it back in your pocket. With a chip you have to wait till they are done, and you have to wait about 5 to 10 seconds for it to do its thing - then sign it, while the card is still in there (so you can't really keep holding your wallet since you'll need two hands, one to hold the machine, the other for the pen). Then finally it lets you remove the card. And you have to take out your wallet again and put it back. Swipe uses exactly zero time, since you do it while you are anyway waiting. Chip takes about 30 seconds. It adds up. It's also more annoying since you can't just put the card right back in your wallet.
- pwthornton 9y agoThere is no technical reason that Android phones aren't up to date with patches. Apple is not doing something magical here. This is something that could be remedied if Google forced phone makers and carriers to support the latest patches ASAP. iOS may be more security-focused in general than Android, but this article is centered on updates and un-patched phones. That part of the security equation is very solvable.
- FussyZeus 9y agoExcept that they haven't solved it, and show no signs of nor have any financial motivation to solve it.
- euyyn 9y ago> show no signs of nor have any financial motivation to solve it _You_ haven't seen signs ;) Project Treble was announced at Google I/O.
- pjmlp 9y agoIt will fail like the previous initiatives if not followed by legal requirements on the Play Services contracts or gated access to Google servers.
- pfranz 9y agoI remember hearing a bunch of initiatives and plans to keep Android phones up to date over the years[1]. They all quickly disappear and a year or two later there's some new plan. There has been signs, but financial motivation and followthrough is missing. [1] http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/05/10/io-2011-android-alliance-promises-timely-android-os-updates-for-18-months-after-device-launch/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/05/10/io-2011-android-alli...
- euyyn 9y agoThat alliance sounds like just the motivation/PR part. Treble is the "remove the actual technical hurdle that made it hard" part.
- niftich 9y agoAndroid devices, as deployed in the wild, consist of a bewildering array of offerings, from shovelware-equivalent throw-over-the-fence devices, to pricey flagships whose makers command some brand awareness. Google has known for years that the Android security patch situation is awful, and has been slowly trying different approaches -- from shipping its own hardware, to moving portions of the OS out of the base image and into Google Play Services-updatable components (much to the chagrin of those who lament the increasing disparity between stock AOSP and Android-as-shipped-on-devices), to its newest: Project Treble, a HAL and vendor interface. But a big part of Android's headaches is the long tail of devices that have been functionally abandoned by all involved parties: the device maker, the carrier, and Google. These devices are trapped in time and in a cesspit of an ever-increasing number of vulnerabilities. It's like unpatched WinXP, except these devices were once bought new a mere two or three years prior. Because all involved parties have dropped the ball, and at the lowest end of the market, the consumer can't really punish the these parties because they're reliant on the exact same names to get access, this sad state of affairs continues until Project Treble ships for real. At that point, all pre-Treble devices are still doomed, but post-Treble devices at least have a fighting chance.
- pjmlp 9y agoAs I mentioned in another comment, I doubt Treble will succeed if not followed by legal requirements on the Play Services contracts or gated access to Google servers. They will keep not providing updates, because they don't come from Google anyway, even with Treble.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoI agree. It's now come to the point where OEM's must now be legally required to update their devices for a certain amount of time to be granted access to GMS. There are no financial incentives for these OEM's to do anything once their device is out the door.
- petra 9y agoAnd this results directly from the fact that most users not seeing value in updates, otherwise, maybe some small OEM's who offer updates , would be more successful.Or the major OEM's would offer paid updates.