3 ms·
I think x86 is to processors what facebook is to social networks and any competitors seeking to eat facebooks lunch: once you hit critical mass -- consider all
by gigatexal 9y ago
I think x86 is to processors what facebook is to social networks and any competitors seeking to eat facebooks lunch: once you hit critical mass -- consider all the applications both high and low level that have had effort into optimizing down to the assembly level, guess what more often than not the processor family was targeted: x86. So whilst I'd love ARM to compete or even the openPower initiative to take off I doubt it because the cost to switch all the legacy software won't pan out in various cost-benefit analyses.
- MBCook 9y agoThe problem with your theory is that there are way more ARM processors in the world. Not only that, they are striking fast at high performance. Apples top end iPad chips are close to/better than recent laptop chips at this point. And clearly Apple can do that at scale. The x86 world is having a harder time getting more performance out of each revision, and there's enough going on on the ARM side that we could be within reach of something interesting happening. This isn't like Transmeta or the G series chips from Motorola/IBM.
- gigatexal 9y agoI fully agree. Just when do you think games and PCs and macs or anything or firm will make the first move all in on an arch not x86?
- pjmlp 9y agoThey already started to slowly move. On UWP applications, if written in .NET Native, the MSIL gets uploaded to the store and is AOT compiled to native code for all existing supported architectures. Apple has LLVM bitcode, which while still having a few leaky abstractions, there are plans among LLVM devs to eventually have a more clean architecture independent version of it. When using a .NET based engine like Unity, the processor specific bits are part of the engine itself, so the majority of developers usually don't t write native plugins themselves.
- pcwalton 9y agoIntel sold 300-400 million chips in 2015. That year the number of ARM CPUs sold was 15 billion. I find it hard to frame that as "ARM can't compete with Intel", especially since PCs aren't a lucrative market anymore. You want to be in mobile, IoT, etc., and Intel threw in the towel there a while ago.
- gigatexal 9y agoI don't think anyone was saying ARM can't compete with Intel at all. ARM, can't currently, compete with Intel in the desktop and server space in the same verticals that Intel does. Show me an 18-core general purpose server grade cpu from ARM. OR a 4.4ghz 8 thread gaming cpu for desktops? My hope is that some vendor (possibly Apple) takes the ARM IP and makes a wide instruction general purpose desktop ARM cpu. And until that happens my original point was: business software, operating systems, etc., have been written and / or optimized for the x86 platform so much so and said software is so pervasive that leaving x86 will take a revolution or a big player to push it, again maybe Apple.
- pcwalton 9y agoARM can win even if it doesn't have the capability to penetrate the PC market right now. As PC margins shrink more and more, Intel's situation looks more and more precarious. Gaming CPUs are only a tiny sliver of the market, and one that is not nearly as profitable as mobile. This is great for consumers, by the way: we're long overdue for healthy competition in the CPU market. ARM is not an open architecture, so it's not ideal, but at least the various licensees compete with each other, which is an improvement over what we have with Intel. > And until that happens my original point was: business software, operating systems, etc., have been written and / or optimized for the x86 platform so much so and said software is so pervasive that leaving x86 will take a revolution or a big player to push, again maybe Apple. The operating systems that matter are all ported to ARM. And perhaps the most important consumer OS today--Android--has virtually no x86 penetration. In 2017, looking at the overall market, ARM has the advantage in terms of software compatibility, not x86.
- 9y ago