3 ms·
While I do think the rules should be fixed, I don't think it's fair to call it theft. They do have lawyers to make sure it's legal. There are desks at banks wh
by lordnacho 9y ago
While I do think the rules should be fixed, I don't think it's fair to call it theft. They do have lawyers to make sure it's legal.
There are desks at banks whose entire reason for existence it tax arbitrage. It's not really a great use of people's education and time, but it's real and it's legal. I don't know the specifics of how it's done, but I do know these desks exist.
There was another case in Denmark where the tax department basically neglected to check that the claimants actually owned the shares and just sent them a huge amount of withheld dividend tax.
The underlying issue is that the rules can be gamed, but only by entities who can pay for the professionals who understand them. There's gotta be a smarter way to arrange the tax system.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoIf I Pay lobbyists to change the law in my favor, at the expense of the tax payer, and then I do something like this. It is correct to say its legal? Yes it is. Is it correct to call it Moral, ethical, decent, good for society thing to do? No! Do things like this appeal to the Randian Masterbatory section of the HN "Libertarian" on here? Yes it does sadly. Its clear that "loophole" exploitation that lobbyists create is an issue. Perhaps analysis software could be created to counter balance this global gaming issue.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoThere is a better way probably, but we will never know it, because I'm sure that lobbyists have been paid to buy and pay for the politicians who will never implement it.
- verinus 9y agoThere is something in Law that is the sprit of the law and if you use loopholes you clearly understand the intent of the law and decide to abuse it for you personal gain- and I think of this as theft...