11 ms·
How not to build a ship: the USS Ford
- sosuke 9y agoUnrelated to the content ... Their ad setup is very interesting it all appears to be served through subdomains.
- vermontdevil 9y agoSeems these problems comes down to selecting a contractor with no experience in building these type of systems (whether steam or electrical).
- ceejayoz 9y agoDefinitely sounds that way. I wonder if there'll be any significant consequences for General Atomics having these 5-10x cost overruns?
- clock_tower 9y agoThe worst that can happen to General Atomics is that they don't get any new contracts after they're done building 3 (3!) fleet carriers. But building 3 carriers will give them enough expertise that they'll be able to bid on future shipbuilding contracts, and will probably land a few -- the Pentagon doesn't like letting contractors go out of business, and they'll recognize that General Atomics' giant Ford is at least half their own fault. It wasn't General Atomics that put out a contract for a fleet carrier that used every innovation at once... Besides, I'm sure General Atomics had the sense to build factories in rustbucket towns and subcontract out to at least 26 states, preferably about half red and half blue; once your procurement system turns into a big enough jobs program, no one will dare to touch it. Welcome to the cozy, comfortable world of defense contracting, dedicated to equipping the US to fight another world war, but only if the enemy is at least as cronyist as we are. The good news is that our only likely enemies for a world war actually are as cronyist as we are, or significantly worse -- but if any new Prussia ever rises in the world, we are _so_ dead.
- hengheng 9y agoI mean at least you guys don't have a welfare system.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 9y agoI agree that the procurement system is dysfunctional, because of dynamics unrelated to suitability, but there are (at least) another two things in play: 1. Nobody really knows what you'll need until the fighting starts. 2. Once the fighting starts, the necessities of wartime production begin to dominate the necessities of peacetime politics. But frankly, I hope never to find out whether the USA's carriers are necessary, sufficient or useful in a roughly-equal bunfight. (edited for wording)
- nradov 9y agoAny potential future naval conflict will be over one way or another long before any new ships are built. The construction lead time on those vessels is years.
- jacques_chester 9y agoGranted, but as WW2 demonstrated, there are industrial learning curves and economies of scale that can take you from months per ship to ships per month. Not a perfect analogy in the details, but I think reasonable in the dynamics.
- nradov 9y agoNo this is impossible. Ships today are an order of magnitude more complex than in WW2. And there is very little spare industrial capacity capable of doing the specialized work necessary.
- jacques_chester 9y ago
- gozur88 9y agoThe military is always in a bind with contractor selection. If the don't choose the lowest bidder they get hauled up in front of a Senate committee full of people grandstanding for the next election accusing them of taking care of cronies. Particularly at the rate we build ships these days, if you only chose companies that have done it before you're not going to have many bids to choose from.
- stcredzero 9y agoThe military is always in a bind with contractor selection. If the don't choose the lowest bidder they get hauled up in front of a Senate committee full of people grandstanding for the next election accusing them of taking care of cronies. Isn't there some famous economics paper somewhere that shows strategies like median bid produce much better outcomes?
- teddyh 9y agoDo you have a reference to this? I’m particularly curious if they address the secondary effects this will have on bids, and if the strategy then remains viable.
- ams6110 9y agoCould you do something like adjust the bids by the average percentage overrun the contractor has on prior projects?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The military is always in a bind with contractor selection. If the don't choose the lowest bidder they get hauled up in front of a Senate committee full of people grandstanding for the next election accusing them of taking care of cronies. No, they (or, rather, contractors) solved that problem by assuring that all contracts are divied up between as many states and Congressional districts as possible, so that anyone in Congress attacking any procurement is attacking jobs in their own district, and cost controls are less important because the overruns are also producing work, often also widely distributed. Of course, this also produces the problem (for the military, not contractors) that any attempt to impose accountability on contractors has political problems that are similarly widespread.
- jlarocco 9y agoI partly agree, but it doesn't sound like the Navy did their homework to check that the systems would even work. From the article: > It was also supposed to increase the lifespan of aircraft by putting less stress on their airframes. Unfortunately, recent tests of land-based prototypes showed that the system actually overstressed F-18 airframes during launch. How do they just now discover that? Nobody thought to build a prototype on land first before agreeing to put it on a carrier? It sounds like some defense contractors sold a bunch of neat ideas to the Navy and decided they'd work the kinks out as they came up. The other problem is that there just aren't many companies that build aircraft carriers, and it's a very small market. According to Wikipedia there are only 37 aircraft carriers in the whole world, so nobody's going to do the R&D if they're not getting funded to do it.
- taneq 9y ago> Nobody thought to build a prototype on land first before agreeing to put it on a carrier? Sure, but that put their bid 10% above the bid of the guys who just ran FEA on it and said "she'll be right."
- simplicio 9y ago> Nobody thought to build a prototype on land first before agreeing to put it on a carrier? The article does talk about "land testing" so I assume they have a mock-up somewhere in the desert to test this stuff in a place where failure doesn't send the pilot/plane into the ocean. I think the problem is that they were still testing these technologies at the same time that they were building the ship, so now there's only so far they can go in modifying them from their original assumptions while still staying withing the power/space/layout specifications the ship was designed around.
- cottsak 9y agoYes I believe this is correct. When they do get it working on land (http://www.henselphelps.com/projects/electro-magnetic-aircraft-launch-system-emals-land-based-test-site-facility http://www.henselphelps.com/projects/electro-magnetic-aircra...) it will very likely deviate so far from the original assumptions incorporated into the design of the carrier that huge retrofits will need to be made to the carrier to apply the changes. Either they will do that, or simply cut corners and fail to report it accurately. This will fly under the radar until some tragedy. But the root cause of that will likely be covered up too.
- dubyah 9y agoA big problem is the concurrency of development and production. I'm unaware of programs that have gone right, but the more substantial boondoggles have had that issue.
- redthrowaway 9y agoSounds like General Atomics has a good lobbyist.
- cottsak 9y agothey can afford it
- Shivetya 9y agoSo in other words, just as the current Administration is finding fixing one ship will be met with great resistance, a war of buts, and gnashing of teeth the same can be said for any attempt by anyone in fixing the government. there are just so many excuses to throw money at it and worse they are used to it. they purposefully create holes that are too expensive or painful to get out of. being ex military and a Libertarian I always get the same result, we spend too much on the wrong stuff "just because". the sad part is neither party up there wants to fix it, it is not that they can't, they are just to invested in not
- CaveTech 9y ago> The new EMALS stores an enormous electrical charge -- enough to power 12,000 homes for three seconds It's hard to not love how prevasive arbitrary metrics are in modern day sports and reporting.
- yongjik 9y agoIn other words, enough to power half a home for 20 hours. :/
- WillPostForFood 9y agoThe time used isn't completely arbitrary, the system launch time is ~3 seconds.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoAlso lovely how carefully they avoided the pedestrian 'one home for ten hours', or the overwrought '36,000 homes for one second'. Goldilocks and Aristotle on board.
- ghshephard 9y agoIt's because the charge is delivered over 3 seconds, that they used 3 seconds.
- ghshephard 9y agoI don't think this is that arbitrary - presumably the charge is delivered over 3 seconds, and the question is, how much power did that represent - 12,000 homes is a pretty good way of mentally visualizing how much power is being delivered.
- llukas 9y agoIf only we could have arbitrary units that everybody would understand without ambiguity? Like kWh/MWh or Joules... no?
- johan_larson 9y agoRobert Farley has a good explanation of how difficult it would actually be to sink one of the fleet carriers: http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/what-it-would-really-take-to-sink-a-modern-aircraft-car-1794182843 http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/what-it-would-really-take-t...
- Spooky23 9y agoYou don't need to sink an aircraft carrier, just keep it at long range. A country like Egypt, Iran or China could keep carriers out of territorial waters or block key choke points in their region with diesel subs or mine. A moderate projection of force could block the straight of Malacca and damage operations. Even if you didn't sink the carrier, you could wound it, which would be worse than a sinking in some ways. At best you can keep it a few hundred miles away, which will render its future complement of short-range F-35s safely neutered. Alternatively, you probably just need to sink a few container ships to get the desired outcome.
- vacri 9y ago> You don't need to sink an aircraft carrier, just keep it at long range. At which point you haven't neutralised it; it's just become a 'fleet in being'. You still have to account for it. You may be able to protect your home waters from it, but you can't project power when it's around.
- Analemma_ 9y agoIt doesn't matter how difficult it is to sink them if they can't launch any planes because the catapult is broken.
- meric 9y agoZumwalt F-35 USS Ford It reminds me of Qing China in the 1890's. "On paper, the Beiyang Fleet had the superior ships,[2] included two pre-dreadnought battleships, Dingyuan and Zhenyuan, for which the Japanese had no counterparts. "....."Though well drilled, the Chinese had not engaged in sufficient gunnery practice beforehand. This lack of training was the direct result of a serious lack of ammunition. Corruption seems to have played a major role; many Chinese shells appear to have been filled with cement or porcelain, or were the wrong caliber and could not be fired." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Yalu_River_(1894) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Yalu_River_(1894... "Li wanted to delay the battle against the Japanese fleet, thus allowing the Chinese more time to equip their ships with additional ammunition. However, the imperial court called him a coward and his recommendation was turned down." "Defense spending analyst Winslow Wheeler concluded from flight evaluation reports that the F-35A "is flawed beyond redemption";[196] in response, program manager Bogdan suggested that pilots worried about being shot down should fly cargo aircraft instead."https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II#Concerns_over_performance_and_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning... I don't think U.S. is at the terminal stage yet, as Qing China was at that time - but it certainly rhymes.
- abraves10001 9y agoOn another failed warship note, the Vasa, built in Sweden in the 1620's barely made it off the dock before sinking but was amazingly well preserved. Worth seeing if you are in Stockholm. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship)
- myrandomcomment 9y agoThis story lacks perspective. They are 25% over budget. For a government defense program that just is not that bad. The reason they are over budget is because they are using a ton of new systems and new technology and guess what it is buggy. NASA blew up a ton of rockets before they got one to work, and blew up even more getting them to work reliably. Given the new technology 25% is pretty damn good. They will work out the issues. There are numerous military technologies that where less then stellar in the 1st run. It is like anything else, it gets better over time and effort. If you say hey, this worked for the last 50 years we should not change then I guess we should be flying bi-planes?
- maxerickson 9y agoThey choose to push the capabilities envelope pretty far. The maintenance hours per flight hour of military aircraft are huge.
- ozgune 9y ago+1. Many large scale projects (for example the Boeing 787) end up over-budget and with delays. Does anyone have statistics on how projects of similar complexity performed in terms of their budgets and timelines?
- taneq 9y agoYeah, it all sounds like tuning / refinement issues rather than fundamentally flawed systems. "Rip it all out and replace it with steam" is a non-technical kneejerk, not a reasoned response.
- mturmon 9y agoBingo: https://www.navytimes.com/articles/trump-says-navy-should-ditch-carrier-emals https://www.navytimes.com/articles/trump-says-navy-should-di...
- jessriedel 9y agoObviously we'd need expertise to tell if (say) the budget was already hugely cushioned in expectation of bugs so that the overrun really is outrageous. But agreed, this is not obviously bad at all, and the author hasn't given us detailed info to think otherwise. More importantly: the Ford is the first in the new generation of as many as ten aircraft carriers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_R._Ford-class_aircraft_carrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_R._Ford-class_aircraft_... Basically, all carriers currently in service are of the Nimitz class, and will be replaced one-by-one over the next 40 years with ships based on the Ford. Lessons learned and tech developed will be amortized over those future ships.
- ghshephard 9y agoReferenced from a recent HN posting on "What really happened to Vista" - seems amazing prescient about precisely this sort of situation, master writing and a super quick read: http://www.mayofamily.com/RLM/txt_Clarke_Superiority.html http://www.mayofamily.com/RLM/txt_Clarke_Superiority.html Just a short sample (It's all worth reading - and it involves battleships!): "...do you realize that there has been no basic change in armaments for over a century? It is, I am afraid, the result of a tradition that has become conservative. For too long, the Research Staff has devoted itself to perfecting old weapons instead of developing new ones. It is fortunate for us that our opponents have been no wiser: we cannot assume that this will always be so."
- andreasgonewild 9y agoWait, I think I heard this story before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship)
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI have a little different take on this. We aren't fighting a major war right now. We aren't facing off against a similarly-powerful navy. So if you see the need for carriers at all, going forward, then now's a good time to experiment. Throw all the new systems in one carrier. If some of them take years to make them work right, well, we learned at a time when we could afford to learn.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe existing fleet is being stretched pretty hard: https://news.usni.org/2015/11/04/navy-half-the-carrier-fleet-tied-up-in-maintenance-other-5-strained-to-meet-demands https://news.usni.org/2015/11/04/navy-half-the-carrier-fleet... http://www.foxnews.com/us/2016/12/30/no-us-carrier-at-sea-leaves-gap-in-middle-east.html http://www.foxnews.com/us/2016/12/30/no-us-carrier-at-sea-le... They could have deployed something like 2 Nimitz class ships for the unit cost of the Ford (more when you consider the money spent on developing the Ford class). Work has started on the second one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_F._Kennedy_(CVN-79) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_F._Kennedy_(CVN-79)
- Animats 9y agoThe EMALS system's big problems seem to be with the motor-generator-flywheel system used to power them. The ship doesn't generate enough power to drive the catapults directly from ship power. They have to wind up a flywheel, and then dump that energy using a generator when launching aircraft. The hardware for that weighs 12 tons. Whatever problem they're having has resulted in damage to the motor/generator windings, requiring pulling out the rotating component. This is apparently a difficult repair. That has to create huge stresses on the windings. You wind up the flywheel, and then suddenly apply field current to activate the generator. They may be trying to ramp up field current slowly to reduce the stress. Some articles mention problems with a voltage regulator causing machine damage. Maybe the rotating machinery can't take a full-power turn-on. Details on the system seem rather vague. Some published articles say there are four motor-generator-flywheel sets; others say only two. Isolating failed units electrically for maintenance is apparently difficult. Unclear why. This unit "passed factory acceptance testing" in 2008.[1] These problems should have been discovered and fixed years ago. The manufacturer is Kato Engineering, part of Emerson Electric, acting as a subcontractor to General Atomic. They make a range of generators for various applications. So this is coming from a company with a long history of making generators. But generators are usually continuous-duty, not something that experiences shock loads like this flywheel rig. Apparently nobody insisted on some serious testing like running this thing through 50,000 cycles into a dummy load. The linear motor of the catapult itself seems to be working OK. The new arresting gear shouldn't have been a problem. That's mostly a paddles-in-water brake, something that's centuries old. How did that get screwed up? Overall, the Ford series of carriers uses electricity for functions that, on other carriers, involve piping steam around. Most newer Naval ships are Diesel or gas turbine powered, and don't generate steam as a by-product. Nuclear plants do generate steam, which has been convenient for carrier catapults. The new British carrier series (if it gets built) is to be non-nuclear, and they want to use the EMALS launcher on some of the ships (maybe). That's part of a big mess - without a catapult, they have to buy the VTOL/STOL version of the F-35, which has its own problems. There's an amusing book, "Ships, Machinery, and Mossbacks", by H.G. Bowen, from WWII. Bowen was a U.S. Navy engineering officer and eventually was in charge of most Naval propulsion systems during WWII. He was a real hard-ass on contractors, and often sent back large, expensive items like final drive gears back as rejects. Admiral Arleigh Burke ("31 knot Burke") wrote that his ships wouldn't have been able to go 31 knots without Bowen's work. When it really has to work, you need people like that who can say no. [1] http://www.ga.com/emals-motor-generator-passes-acceptance-testing http://www.ga.com/emals-motor-generator-passes-acceptance-te...
- hangonhn 9y agoWow, one of the contributors is Pierre Sprey. I would take his criticisms very seriously. He's basically the father of the A-10, which he came up with when he studied WWII records and interviewing soldiers the aircraft was meant to support. The Air Force hated it and still does to this day but that plane proved to be cheap, durable, and useful. The A-10 is pretty much the opposite of these fancy weapons projects.
- throwaway7645 9y agoI understand that ground troops love the power of the A-10, basically the "tank of the skies". Not sure why we can't have classes of distinct planes now like bomber, fighter, ground-support, and reconnaissance. Pick 1 area and be the best possible plane at doing that. The jack of all trades plane seems to perform poorly at all those things.
- dingaling 9y agoThe USAF could transfer the A-10s to the US Army ( as has been proposed many times since the 1970s ) and focus on the supra-tactical missions, but that would require them to swallow their pride and end the Johnson-McConnell 'agreement'. That dates back to 1966 and forbids the Army to operate armed fixed-wing aircraft. The USAF would rather keep the A-10s, no matter how unenthusiastically, than ever permit the Army to take control of the air-support mission. It is ridiculous that such 'pride' has any part in national security decisions.
- throwaway7645 9y agoNever heard of that before. Pretty crazy.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoThe Air Force hates the A-10 because it's ugly and low-tech, and the AF is all about sexiness. The A-10 is the most Soviet-looking piece of hardware in America's arsenal. But it works very, very well.
- dten 9y agoSeems to be a more concise version of the warisboring article from a couple of days ago (the author is the same): https://warisboring.com/how-not-to-build-an-aircraft-carrier/ https://warisboring.com/how-not-to-build-an-aircraft-carrier...
- nategri 9y agoTomorrow on HN: How not to ship a build
- rndmize 9y agoI think we're at a point where the value of a traditional aircraft carrier is questionable (for the cost), and likely to decrease in the coming decades. A smaller, possibly submersible craft that could launch and catch drones would probably be able to replace carriers in a variety of missions at vastly reduced cost. Pilots can be offloaded to military bases; launching/catching systems can be as powerful as the drones can be engineering to support, for shorter landing and takeoff distances; required storage space is less, crew is less, and cost is less for drones. DARPA has already done a little work in this direction - http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/darpa-develops-system-launch-retrieve-large-drones-travelling-speed-midair-1605298 http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/darpa-develops-system-launch-retrie...
- Robotbeat 9y agoThis article is a bit too one-sided for me to take seriously. The cost overruns seem modest compared to what I see occur regularly in big aerospace projects (not just 25% or 50% but 300 or 500%). F35 cost is absolutely absurd, for instance. I saw basically no mention of the extra capabilities that a fully electric ship like this could provide, it all was just a long list of down sides.