4 ms·
Well, my perspective would say that the system is corrupted(Fractional reserve banking a fraud, etc). Regulators sleeping at the wheels are probably in bed with
by kiba 16y ago
Well, my perspective would say that the system is corrupted(Fractional reserve banking a fraud, etc). Regulators sleeping at the wheels are probably in bed with the bankers. The hubris of the federal regulatory system and the people who manages it, thinks that they can manage the economy yet at the same time be non-corrupt. Then there are the big hubris of corporations that thinks they can manages risks with mathematical models and financial engineers.
Many of the same ideas is said in the article.
However, I propose a different, radical solution. Get rid of the banking regulatory framework, stop bailing out corporations, and get rid of legal tender law. Do nothing. Let the big guys fall. Let the economy readjust themselves to the fact of reality.
At this point in our economic development history, the interventions were so vast and deep that we don't know which way is up and which way is down. Democratic governments have produced thousands of new laws that complicated business dealing. Then lobbyists can sneak some laws in that prop up industries. When an intervention does goes wrong, another intervention is put in place to solve it. If there is an urgent social problem, the solution is to make new laws to solve it.
Wouldn't life be better with a few simple business laws that everyone can understand and follow?
Yet, those government people and their special groups managed to mess it up by padding taxation code, punishment for firing union workers, and punishment for alleged racial discrimination.
The more complicated a system of rules is, the more potential for corruptions, opportunities for conflict of interests, and regulators getting away not doing their job.(Hence the saying, "when a law is made, the first thing that will be brought is the law.")
I don't think the solution is more democracy. Voters are not really rational, nor will they have much interest in defending themselves from the myriad of special interest groups that permeates and compete in the democratic institution. Political and economic education is hard when you have million of citizens worrying about their own lives and competition within their section. Now they have to worry about what the local government, the state government, and the federal government is doing with these mega-corporations. Then they got to worry about the local regulators with their code, and finally have to face an IRS audit every once in a while. At that point, it become rational to become ignorant because of the cost of educating oneself is higher than the potential benefit would provide.
Is there a solution? I don't know. But I am content to let the system fall apart since political will is not going to acknowledge the reality about the many deficiency in economic policies(Which cause mass distortion of incentives in market actors), and the system of perverse incentive that exists within the government itself.
However, I am pretty excited about emerging technologies and the effort of libertarians to look for non-political means to solutions, especially the "anti-capitalistic free marketeers" varieties.(No, it does not involve warfare, or election of officials, and you don't have to worry about rioting)
I would say it involves a lot of makerbots, creativity, entrepreneurship. It is building a better economic foundation that isn't found on lot of debts, lies, and kickback. From there we can build a new framework of rules that's very strong on the basic. A framework that doesn't suffer from the mass confusions of laws added every years. Eventually, an alternative society would emerge out of a network of entrepreneurs, their connection with the community, and their customers. That alternative society would co-exists side by side and seamlessly with the other society at large.
But it requires a lot of stratagems and making a right of exits unknown or seemly nonthreatening to officials. It's a difficult problem to solve.
On the other hand, we could try to found a new country on the ocean sea, which is known as seasteading. It is probably a pipe dream, but the seasteading movement got some very realistic and pragmatic people. These individuals look for economic efficiency and business models in their seastead. They aren't try to build huge utopias complete with casino, strip club, and all the extravagances.
Again, seasteading and new countries are seen as a threat. Countries get nervous when there is a new neighbor on the scene. They will try to destroy the threat. It will require a brilliant amount of political stratagems and common sense on the behalf of the seasteaders to fend off nervous nation-states.
If the seasteading movement succeeded, no longer will we be restricted to an industry of 200 governments, many of them are not any good, and the best is mediocre at most. There would be a thousand governments, and that mean real competition. Terrestrial government now have to improve services and efficiency or face mass migration from their citizens to thousand of little nations on the high sea. We might not even need that many, as evidenced with the appearance of Firefox, opening up and intensifying the competition in the browser market.
Anyway, enough talking for me. The solutions if anything, is probably going to be hard to implement. It's probably deceptively simple. It will probably make the population mad. It might be something completely unexpected, even to me. But there is one thing that I am pretty sure, democracies doesn't work.
(Sorry for the wall of texts)
- joe_the_user 16y agoI think you've missed the point of the article. There are many conceivable solutions to our present problem. But any of these would have to be put in place or at least tolerated by America's ruling elites. The problem is that the ruling elites today have thrown their interests in with the financial elites. They don't get that the game is over. Until that happens, we'll have the same old game supported by more federal intervention. You notice for example, that the crisis intervention were exactly the same under Bush and Obama. The scary thing is that the US has more resources than any other country in history so this country's rulers can and probably will play the losing game of financial manipulation till things are really, really screwed up for the world (as now wasn't bad enough - now is bad but not bad enough). This last crisis was the dot-com crash writ large. The NEXT crisis will be this crisis writ large indeed...
- jackfoxy 16y agoCarroll Quigley,who Bill Clinton called "his mentor", spent much of his great tome "Tragedy and Hope", http://www.amazon.com/Tragedy-Hope-History-World-Time/dp/094500110X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1277172072&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.com/Tragedy-Hope-History-World-Time/dp/094..., writing the history of the intertwined relationship of the ruling and financial elites. Skip the second-hand histrionics you may read about the man and the book, and go right to the source.
- kiba 16y agoJesus, do I have to quote from my own post? I don't know. But I am content to let the system fall apart since political will is not going to acknowledge the reality about the many deficiency in economic policies(Which cause mass distortion of incentives in market actors), and the system of perverse incentive that exists within the government itself.
- cicada 16y agoIt was too long. For instance, I missed that quote which I would have replied to: What exactly is meant by letting the system fall apart? The economy is the system that keeps you fed. You as in yourself. As in your family. As in your friends. As in the people who live near you who will also be driven to desperation. As the solutions you pondered had intended, we have to minimize the human cost of fixing our problems -- as we are those humans.