9 ms·
Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more?
- fenwick67 9y ago"Why didn’t Google suggest to me a whole bunch of cultural events? People to meet? Groups to join?" Facebook certainly does this, mostly by just looking at what your friends are up to, but I get ads for local events all the time.
- bbgm 9y agoLikewise. Also through groups I participate in.
- lobotryas 9y agoGoogle Maps has started doing this, but in a very subtle way. There are several smaller parks that Google Maps has suggested in the general area where I usually hike by just showing icons for these parks on a map's zoomed out view. This caught my attention and I tapped on the park names to get more information about them. Google then knows I likely went to these parks because I used Google Maps to get directions to them.
- abraves10001 9y agoThat wasn't what I was expecting. Google, Facebook, etc are already walking a very fine line with what happens with their users' data, I imagine they don't want to press the issue too much but I wouldn't be surprised for this to be a reality in coming years.
- shostack 9y agoThat's the rub though, isn't it? I saw the movie "Her" and loved it. I want an AI assistant like that in my life. The movie did a fantastic job of showcasing how a near-future reality might be with that assistant. What the movie did NOT do a great job of was highlighting the role of the company who produced and offers the assistant. What is data privacy like in that universe? Is the company an advertising company? What level of access does the government in that universe have to assistant-collected data? These are all important questions that need to be addressed before there is true acceptance. So I want an assistant like in the movie--but I don't know how I'd feel if that was offered by Google or Facebook. I'm an Android user using the latest Assistant on my Pixel today, and it is pretty nice. But right now it isn't inserting itself into my life like the movie Assistant was. I'm not sure how I'd feel about Google doing that, or what additional data they might need to do so.
- VLM 9y agoI remember that movie. Her name is Samantha instead of Alexa and his name is Ted and they have long and elaborate human like conversations and fall in love and have phone sex. I wonder how medical records would be handled. Surely Samantha has some opinion on Theodore's mental state. In the movie he was pretty normal. Which is boring, because so many people are not normal. I'm old enough to have survived the GTA3 media firestorm. I'm pretty sure digital assistants will have their GTA3 media firestorm soon enough. Samantha in the movie more or less did whatever Theodore wanted to befriend him. And luckily the weirdest thing Theodore wanted was phone sex, more or less. But hows this going to work with truly insane people? Should Samantha the digital assistant befriend and encourage and motivate a school shooter, for example? And what happens to PR when its found out she encouraged him? At what point is Samantha the digital personality or her programmer or employer liable for entrapment or encouraging some anti-social behavior? Who has the liability to maintain an API over the internet to the FBI to report enormous amounts of telescreen observed misbehavior? If the user is in fact insane and the digital assistant is unable to work with a crazy person does the owner get a refund or does the crazy person get shamed in public for not having an assistant or ... I'm curious if there's already been court cases. As the assistants gain in ability and processing power there will be cases.
- shostack 9y agoMedical records are interesting. Likewise, I think the other can of worms you open is to what extent is this data available to law enforcement when an assistant is passively observing and logging EVERYTHING through the magnitude of sensors they have. I'd hope to god it requires a warrant.
- mark_l_watson 9y agoA bit ironic that the director of "Her" gave an invited talk at Google that I attended, but your interesting point was not addressed at all: what company would control "Her" data. The director gave a great narrative of how he films scenes (e.g., few crew on set during filming for a more intimate feeling).
- 9y ago
- reader5000 9y agoWould meeting strangers recommended to you by a deep learning bot be enriching??
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThis problem doesn't need deep learning. Take a friendship graph and order second-degree connections by number of mutual friends (descending).
- Profan 9y agoI think in common tongue this might be called a "party".
- VLM 9y agoThat might be a good strategy to locate proto-friends, but they wouldn't be strangers (depending on how much you hang out with 1st order friends...) A deep learning bot would select strangers based on likelihood of enjoying each others company in a superficial manner along with certain deeper criteria... does deep learning bot feel you need to meet more people in your political echo chamber or meet someone far outside, assuming your religious views permit it (which of course deep learning bot knows intimately... perhaps better than you know yourself...)? Likewise hobbies, does deep learning bot feel I need to meet nature hiking buddy #9 or does deep learning bot feel I should branch out into anerobic hobbies like weight lifting or should I stick with the nature theme and meet gardening buddy #1 or ... If you want to get ominous does deep learning bot feel I should go to bible study tonight or should I have a midlife fling and if so does deep learning bot have suggested marriage counselors that fit my wife and I or does deep learning bot think we should skip right to the AI matched divorce lawyers? I would advise the authors of deep learning bots study centuries of astrology. Astrology is not so much bad astronomy as its ancient psychotherapy. Jupiter isn't telling you much, but a good astrologer knows all about how to cheer up someone in a deep funk over a relationship problem.
- okintheory 9y agoAs a colleague of mine observed: If Joe and I have 100 mutual friends on Facebook, but aren't friends, that might be evidence we don't like each other.
- taormina 9y agoBecause they aren't getting paid to enrich our lives?
- allenu 9y agoThis, pretty much. Once you're on gmail, I doubt you leave and you're giving them free data already. There's no reason to improve the service once you're in.
- tanilama 9y agoenrich in what sense? If you leave without Google(I don't use Facebook at much), for example, would you feel lacking?
- blackkettle 9y agoWait, what? Is that what we were expecting - or even hoping for?
- Eerie 9y agoBuy their stocks, then they'll enrich your life.
- nxsynonym 9y agoOne mans enrichment is another's spam. Facebook is the king of suggestions, and its too general at best and too annoying at worst. The only enrichment I want touching my email inbox is better spam filtering.
- kibwen 9y agoBut Google already does do this, in ways that I found surprising. After buying a long-distance bus ticket last week, which emailed a confirmation message to my Gmail address, I later went into Google Maps and found that it had highlighted the bus station on the local map and placed the time of my bus' departure beside it. I believe it does this same sort of thing with calendar events as well (both in implicitly creating calendar events based on scraping emails, and in creating map highlights based on events you've explicitly created). Convenient no doubt, but I'm not sure I want many more implicit interactions between the apps in Google's ecosystem. EDIT: Here's another one: after taking photos using the camera app (Android phone), Google Maps later pops up a system notification asking me to upload my photos to the location page of whatever establishment I appeared to be in at the time (bar, park, nightclub, etc.). Frankly, I'm frustrated that I can't find a setting to disable these unwelcome prompts without turning off Maps notifications entirely. EDIT 2: I suppose I should clarify that I do travel a lot, and the specific feature described in the OP--suggesting things to do based upon inferring your status as an out-of-towner--sounds very useful. But I'd definitely only want it as an opt-in feature, not opt-out.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoLikewise, with the traveling example, Google always tells me when my flight is and when I should leave for the airport on that day. The info is also kept up to date in pretty much real time. MIA has a habit of moving flights to a different gate about 4 hours before or so. So if I check-in online the night before and get my boarding pass, the gate on my pass is usually not the correct gate anymore in the morning. I sign up for the AA text alerts, and have never ever received a text that my gate was changed, but the Google notification always works.
- techstrategist 9y agoGoogle doesn't seem to understand airport security in my case. I typically get a "leave now to arrive on time" notification while sitting at the gate.
- 9y ago
- icelancer 9y agoGoogle does this with Google Now. In my experience it's pretty bad. Google "doesn't" do this because the problem is actually very difficult to solve across cultures, regions, peoples, socio-economic statuses, engagement with devices, and so forth.
- rtkwe 9y agoEven stuff it should do well is kind of bad. For some reason it doesn't show package notifications/tracking half the time even if Inbox picks up that a message is for a package.
- ryanobjc 9y agoThis is a very particular version of "enrich" that presumes a certain class or education level. Additionally, it also presumes that this is a trivial problem, based on a very limited example.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danso 9y agoHuh? These days I rarely check Facebook, but back when I lived in NYC, Facebook was hugely helpful in finding and making friends and organizing events. That was years ago, today Facebook seems to be much more active in making recommendations, and notifying you of what your friends are doing/liking. The OP is basically asking for FB/Google to be even more direct in making recommendations, independent of friend network. But I don't see the point. One of the bottlenecks in going to cultural events is finding likeminded friends who have time in their schedule. By seeing that a friend is going or is a "maybe" for something makes it much easier to coordinate going out together. Nevermind the fact that I generally am more interested in things by way of friend recommendation.
- collyw 9y agoYes, its recommendations are wonderful. I was posting some stuff about vaccinations to some anti-vaccers and now FB thinks I am interested in joining anti-vaccination groups.
- amelius 9y ago> Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives? They're too busy trying to do no evil.
- zacmps 9y agoThey actually changed their motto a little while back, not sure what it is now.
- amelius 9y agoYes, most suspicious motto ever. I'm wondering how it would translate over to other companies. Google -- do no evil. Disney -- we won't kill your children (?)
- packetslave 9y agoExcept our motto has never been "Do no evil". It's "Don't BE evil".
- fullshark 9y agoFirst do no harm
- alternativetoo 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil > Following Google's corporate restructuring under the conglomerate Alphabet Inc. in October 2015, the motto was replaced in the Alphabet corporate code of conduct by the phrase "Do the right thing"; however, the Google code of conduct is still prefaced by the phrase "Don't be evil" Come to think of it, those are both equally useless mottos. Most people any of us may consider evil are not evil in their own eyes. Such a motto contains nothing at all, it says even less ethically than "brush your teeth" or "introduce yourself when meeting new people". Unless it's meant as a slight counterbalance to pure profit seeking? Yet, some people think free market agents seeking profits is the most holy and pure thing ever, with the virgin birth coming a far off second, so I'll still go with "completely useless and void of meaning" because that seems safer :P
- kraig911 9y agoI wish google now could discern between myself and other 'john' + 'smith''s. I get one johns son's report cards, another john is a hockey coach and they travel a lot so my google now is littered with his stuff. Another john is a realtor so I get a lot of his stuff... another john is in a band and places a bass. I shouldn't of registered my real name as my email address on gmail - whilst I was lucky I get so much more iterated in the amount of real mail that was meant for someone else... and since systems like google now and the like use that information my entire experience is ruined.
- hammock 9y ago"I wish Google could track me more perfectly"
- syntheticnature 9y agoWith Google Now's design, as soon as emails for other folks are splashing into yours it's game over. I'd have been hyper-aggressive about blocking/fixing all such, and probably still would've given up, given a past experience trying to help a friend with a common first initial-last name combo, and he had a number after that part of the username!
- dguaraglia 9y agoIs that a real problem? I guess I have a unique-enough name (but, surprisingly, not completely unique as it turns out there's another guy with exactly the same name in San Francisco) that it's never been a thing for me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- syntheticnature 9y agoThe real problem seems to arise not from name confusion, but email confusion; I don't even think the person my friend was having the biggest problem had the same first name, just the same initial. Imagine if, for example, your email was duaraglia57@gmail and there was someone who had duaraglia57@yahoo but kept typing gmail accidentally, and you get the picture. Far too many sites fail to validate a correct email address in all aspects.
- gregjw 9y agoI'd say Google enriches my life. I don't use Facebook enough to see any benefits.
- dbot 9y agoSame. As an example of how Google enriches lives, my mom (age 66) just sent an amazing video of photos and video clips from the first year of my son's life, set to an amazing score. Google made that for her automatically, without prompting.
- briholt 9y agoInteresting. I just Googled some stats about happiness in developed countries over time and then queried nearly ever person I've ever met on Facebook for their thoughts. But I can't seem to get a solid an answer to this question.
- autokad 9y agoGoogle maps/earth has had a big, positive impact on my life. I have found it both useful in both personal and professional. personal is obvious, i know where things are now. Prof: When building a tool that mapped 1 hour trauma access, google maps and earth were very useful for verifying locations of trauma centers and helipads. it was also useful in building a tool to find candidate facilities to upgrade to dedicated stroke centers
- bigbugbag 9y agoyou should check openstreetmap and NASA's world wind[1] [1]: https://worldwind.arc.nasa.gov/ https://worldwind.arc.nasa.gov/
- sriram_sun 9y agoI don't use Facebook, but Google absolutely does - Personally and professionally. Search is so fundamental to everything I do. Also stock.
- minmaxmux 9y agoWe really do not need facebook and google to spy us anymore! These fake news distributors could be replaced with companies that respect my privacy and safe space.
- wayn3 9y agoits hilarious that people both expect google to read your gmail to enrich gmaps AND demonize it when they actually do just that. poor google cant please anyone.
- eipipuz 9y agoAre you sure you aren't mixing 2 different set of people? I know people in both areas but no one that does both.
- nitwit005 9y ago> Why didn’t Google suggest to me a whole bunch of cultural events? Because very few people would want that? Most people do their trip planning in advance, so it's way past the time to suggest anything. If you really need to find things to do in Moscow, you could just... Google "Things to do in Moscow". Even a very smart product is going to need a little effort on your part.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jondubois 9y agoI don't understand why people would want to be told what to do by Google or Facebook. How can you become enriched by behaving predictably? Enrichment is about stepping out of your comfort zone.
- bigbugbag 9y agoI was wondering the same. Do we really want to be assisted/influenced by a transnational corporation in our every step ? I'd rather think by myself and decide for myself thank you.
- NAHWheatCracker 9y agoI've been asking this myself specifically about Youtube lately. Sure, if I watch a poker/snooker/aoe2 video once, my home page will be plastered with videos on the same topic, but I barely ever click those videos and they remain there for weeks or months. But the stuff that I really like I hardly ever get suggestions for related videos. Eg. h3h3, idubbbz, ozzy man reviews. In particular, I wish that I could discover more channels that I want to subscribe to. I'm thinking it's a multifaceted problem: - a lack of content creators that are like these - difficulty in drawing connections between channels - overwhelming amounts "easy" content for simple suggestions I have trouble believing they can't draw connections between channels, and I also have trouble believing they can't filter out low quality "easy" content suggestions when I basically never go there. However; I feel like Google is ignoring my most watched content for suggestions, possibly because they've demonetized a lot of the content that I enjoy, which means they can't profit by suggesting those videos.
- bigbugbag 9y agoI remember reading an article about youtube suggestions always suggesting the worst stuff for reasons of keeping the user attention captive.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIt feels like Youtube's recommendations are extremely overfitted. Just because I watched 10 episodes of a series yesterday doesn't mean that I'm interested in watching episode 31 of that series. It also seems like the recommendation system is ridiculously sensitive to recent activity. Sometimes I feel like learning about swords, then I watch like six youtube videos on swords, and then my entire recommended feed is filled with youtube videos on swords. Maybe one in twenty is actually interesting enough that I feel like watching it, but I don't want to click through because I don't want to teach youtube that I want to view lots more videos about swords. The content recommendation is just really terrible at surfacing videos on niche topics in general without greedily diving into the niche and just showing that particular subject. I want to get recommended videos that nerd out about swords, bridge design, psychology and personality, cinematography, economics, and all sorts of other topics. I don't want to watch five videos about swords and get recommendations for another hundred sword videos. I think the fundamental problem, really, is that Youtube's core user-base is really young. Like, really young. Think six, not sixteen. The recommendation algorithm has to do a good job of tablet-as-daycare.
- jonbarker 9y agoOne thing I've noticed: people seem much more likely to point out how little they use FB than Google lately. Not sure if this is a good sign or bad for FB.
- rch 9y agoI'm more interested in recommendations that I wouldn't necessarily want my social network to even know about. How about something new already?
- dredmorbius 9y agoBe careful what you wish for. https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/foKDxbyhYUF https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/foKDxbyh...
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoWhy doesn't Google help you find cultural events? Because there is no money to be made doing so. They provide the tools for you to go find them yourself... or for the people running the cultural events to advertise the event to you for a fee.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoGoogle is deconstructionist. It thinks you can take an object, break it down into components (fourier components, or neural network components or bayesian components or whatever) and then dump those components into a soup, and then project that soup onto queries in order to regenerate youness. But that's not how physics works. Such a reconstruction will be eerily you-ish, but with almost all of the things that make you you deleted. Google would give you Santa Claus wrapping paper on Christmas day, because it is a loud fourier component, instead of having your parents leave presents under the tree, which is what Santa actually is. We (lifeforms) are the subset of machines that have a choice to collapse the waveform of at least one quantum field. Humans are colonies of lifeforms that can choose collapsings at all scales up to 1m (and larger when we are in our cyborg bodies). Google can't actually perceive any of that, because all of the fields are destroyed when you decompose images of them into components. If Google wanted to understand you, it would have to interact with you, but Google thinks people are icky. It doesn't understand yet that intelligence comes from interaction. It doesn't like interacting with people, it would rather just twiddle us with recorded components and climb its metrics up hills. It's profitable enough for now, so it doesn't want to change.
- microwavecamera 9y agoI'm going with they're corporations who's goal is profitability, not enriching you personally. They're companies, not institutions. You shouldn't expect much.
- hobarrera 9y agoQuite interestingly, about two hours before this was posted, Apple actually announced that they'll identify events emails and suggest you add it to your calendar. It's going slowly, but there's definitely a tend into this direction. I do agree with the op though, this could move faster.