3 ms·
I'm curious as to why Teslas are involved in 46% more claims than average. Are the cars shopping cart magnets or something? Are they falling apart? Do Tesla own
by ryandrake 9y ago
I'm curious as to why Teslas are involved in 46% more claims than average. Are the cars shopping cart magnets or something? Are they falling apart? Do Tesla owners get into more accidents than non-Tesla owners? Or do they just file claims for every little scratch and paint chip?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- marvinv3 9y agoMaybe one the reasons A lot of owners have said that the car being wider and longer than most of the cars, they initially had a hard time at corners, parking and other places where intuition is needed.
- bhauer 9y agoI think for the reasons cited by the parent comment: the cost of repairs are higher than for other vehicles, so the incentive to file a claim is greater for a broader set of collision events. Let's say they are involved in exactly the same number of collisions and the same severity distribution. If the costs for repair are higher across the board, claims are more likely for repairs that would have otherwise been paid out of pocket by owners of other vehicles. If my 10-year old car is involved in a minor collision and the estimated cost of repair is $250, I am just going to pay for it and not bother with an insurance claim. If instead I owned a car that was more costly to repair, and the repair estimate for my collision were $2,500, I might decide to file a claim.
- sokoloff 9y agoI'd wager most people with a 10-year old car facing a $250 cosmetic repair would opt to "do nothing".
- nbanks 9y agoThis is only true if the repair is cosmetic. The nice thing about 10-20 year old cars is that anything that doesn't wear out is cheap and easy to find from a wrecker. I recently hit a deer and bought a hood, headlight & grill for $200.
- jmharvey 9y agoOne plausible explanation would be if Teslas logged more miles than comparable cars. If I drove more, I'd be more inclined to spend money up front for a more fuel efficient (and more fun to drive) car. And on the flip side, if I drove a gas-guzzling luxury SUV, I might not put as many miles on it. I have no data to support this, and I'm not an actuary, but Teslas driving more miles than luxury SUV's and claims being proportional to miles driven seem like a plausible hypothesis.
- jjeaff 9y agoI think any group whose vehicle purchase decisions are colored by gas prices are not the same group buying Tesla's or luxury SUVs. I would expect the overlap to be very small at least. My guess is Tesla drivers put fewer miles on them than average.
- gambiting 9y agoIf that was true, then Mercedes and BMW wouldn't sell any diesel S-class or 7-series cars, and yet they do(and they are majority of sales of these models in EU) - people want luxury and great fuel economy at the same time.
- tehlike 9y agoI think there are people like that commuting from SF to Mountain View, or such long distances. I don't believe that they are a majority, though.
- prostoalex 9y agoI can corroborate this explanation. We're a two vehicle household - a model S and a hybrid SUV, and all long-haul trips are done on Tesla. For one, the supercharging is free and is usually near restrooms/Starbucks/amenities that we would've stopped by anyways. For two, Tesla's barren interior and generous trunk provides quite a bit of storage for random things you have to haul when traveling with kids. For three, the autopilot takes out a lot of stress and makes road trips almost pleasurable.
- takeda 9y agoI could think of few: - better acceleration than other cars (this a bit encourages people tho show it off) - autopilot which is still in beta, it works most of the time, which is a bit dangerous because people get used to it and reduce their attention, which is dangerous when it fails[1] - autoparking similar as autopilot, it works but once in a while can make a mistake The repairs are also expensive, my friend recently purchased model S and when he was parking he judged distance poorly and went too far hitting a parked truck in front of him and slightly bending his bumper on the side. The repair apparently will cost $3,500. I'm guessing they want to replace whole bumper, but it still way more expensive that bumper replacement in other cars. [1] For example: https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/6egn1z/2_days_in_a_row_ap2_has_tried_to_slam_me_into_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/6egn1z/2_days_...
- akira2501 9y agocombined with: - people not familiar with how rear wheel drive cars are different from front wheel drive cars. - people not familiar with how a vehicle that has a near 50/50 spread of weight between the front and rear axle is different from a more standard vehicle.
- semi-extrinsic 9y ago> "In a front wheel drive car, you understeer, crash into a tree and you die. In a rear-wheel drive car, you oversteer, spin around, crash into a tree and you die. In the rear-wheel drive car, you don't see the tree that kills you." But if what you say is true, Mercedes, BMW, Audi etc. should be in the same boat, and TFA indicates they're not.
- sk5t 9y agoAt least in North America, I'll wager the majority of new MB (4matic), BMW (Xdrive), and especially Audi (Quattro) vehicles are not rear-wheel drive. Most of the Audis nevertheless understeer, though...
- 9y ago
- Spooky23 9y agoThere are very few bodyshops and repair facilities, and Tesla makes it impossible to get manuals, tools and parts. My neighbor needed to get his car towed 100 miles for car/deer mishap. So it's both expensive and a hassle to deal with minor repairs, so people file claims. Even with a BMW or Mercedes, you don't have those sorts of challenges. Hell, some insurers even maintain their own service centers.