19 ms·
Google Contributor: Buy an ad removal pass for the web
- yellowsir 9y agothe question is do i want to get tracked by google contributor or google ads?
- netzone 9y agoI can just imagine; try contributor once, get drowned in invasive ads because you've already shown you're willing to pay for less ads.
- nsebban 9y agoHey, do you remember that time when people thought Google would never do any sketchy or annoying stuff to their users ? That's now so far away...
- isoprophlex 9y ago"Don't be evil" Yeah right...
- criddell 9y agoIf Google contributor also came with a promise to not track you then I would consider. Until then, I'm using uBlock. I don't mind advertising at all.
- mrweasel 9y agoYeah, the main issue with the "scheme" is "works with your Google account to remove ads". So not only am I paying, I'm also inconvenienced by having to have a Google account and I have to be permanently logged in. This is online music all over again. I'm not being presented with an option that is superior to the unprofitable solution I'm currently using. As long as using adblockers is a better experience than paying for content, it simply isn't going to work.
- gabrielgoh 9y agoim not sure this is a good idea (as a consumer) anything which injects extra buying decisions in my life seems like a bad idea. Imagine having to wonder if I really wanted to spend that 0.01 cents on the next page of popular mechanics or not. I'd rather pay more for say, unlimited monthly access
- onion2k 9y agoThis has been the predominant reason for micro-transaction services failing in the past - when something costs more than zero there has to be a conscious decision made on the part of the consumer, and that decision making process is often enough of a barrier to stop them purchasing. For something very cheap the financial cost itself may be irrelevant but the cognitive cost of making a decision definitely isn't. That problem is compounded by the fact a very low cost equates to a very low value in the mind of the purchaser. This manifests as a thought process like "if this only costs 0.01c then it's probably not worth buying", and the user leaves. That's hard to work around. As far as I'm aware no one has ever implemented micro-transactions successfully. The best example to date, which is mobile gaming in-app purchases, isn't really micro-transactions in the usual sense. In a game like Candy Crush you buy tools to help you advance more quickly so you don't have to grind through a hard level dozens of times. You're really buying your own time (so you can play the game less, which is kind of weird really). Time is something people value, so they're very happy to pay. The model doesn't really apply to other purchases.
- kelnos 9y agoThat's the thing that really annoys me about human psychology (to which I myself am of course not immune). I don't subscribe to any sites that offer subscriptions because I rarely visit any one particular site to make it worth it (I rarely, if ever, run into, for example, the NYT free article limit). I block all ads, but I certainly wouldn't mind paying a reasonable per-article price all the same. By not offering per-article pricing, they're actually _losing_ money from me, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if going to per-article pricing would result in less revenue than monthly subscriptions overall.
- time4tea 9y agoYou can use pihole or pyhole to just block them for your home, then vpn from your phone. No more ads. Then buy subscription to sites you like. Dont give google a percentage of everything.
- rtpg 9y agoa lot of people get a percentage of everything. Credit card processors, the post office, transportation companies. ISPs, kinda. "A percentage of everything" is another way of saying "in the infrastructure business".
- kelnos 9y agoThe problem is that most (all?) site subscriptions now are all-or-nothing, and even if you do like a site, you probably like several, and paying $10-$30 per month (or whatever) each for even 5 different sites starts adding up real fast. If sites were to offer an "article bank", it might be more compelling: you put in $X and that buys you Y articles, which you can read over the span of days, months, or years. But no one seems to be doing that, probably because they believe the economics of breakage is better.
- resf 9y agoOr just buy a games console. Articles on the internet exist primarily as free entertainment. If I am going to spend money on entertainment, there are much more fulfilling options.
- majewsky 9y agoThat's dismissing all the genuinely insightful articles that I discover through my subscription [1] to HN. [1] Read: Addiction. :)
- resf 9y agoPerhaps read a book. Just visit your local real or virtual library. My point is not that articles on the internet are useless. But there is a certain tunnel vision in these discussions where we forget there are other _even better_ ways to spend our time. Whether you want education or entertainment, paying $x/month to Google is not the right way to achieve it. Go paintballing instead.
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoGood idea, extremely poor execution. Nobody is going to want to use it if different sites are charging you different amounts per page. People want predictable bills.
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoCompletely disagree. I want to be able to pay more for quality content and pay less for buzzfeed articles. I want content creators to be able to charge based on the the content they are producing. I prefer a world where I can stop in a fine dining restaurant or a fast-food place, get the experience I want and be charged appropriately. I don't want a top of the line steak-house to have to find a way to serve my meal, while only receiving McDonald's priced payments. That's the problem with the current web.
- kelnos 9y agoAgreed. As long as it's clear what I'm going to pay before I open each article, I have no problem paying more for an article from a trusted news source than from a tabloid.
- seanp2k2 9y agoWhere are the steakhouses? That's my problem with the current state of the paid content web; it seems to be a race to the bottom, with few exceptions (and the exceptions in my experience seem to be mostly enthusiasts doing it not for a living).
- RunawayGalaxy 9y agoIs it not the point that this system will incentivize better content by allowing creators to charge what the market is willing to pay for content?
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoHaving choices is all well and good, but I worry that making the pricing hard to predict will reduce the reach of this feature. But I guess they are only expecting a small subset of users to use it anyway. Why not let the users choose what they want to pay? Because Google needs this to be net-positive for their revenue, but it would be a much better web if there was some kind of mechanism to automatically give small amounts of money (say 1/10th of a cent per page view) to site owners.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoRemember when we were sold that ads payed for content so that could be free? Now you can pay extra to get ads anyway, the non Google networks don't care. The web is turning into cable, and it only took a few years.
- geraltofrivia 9y agoSo, this is kinda like Blendle, but for the open web. I'm not too sure if this'll fly. Personally, there's a certain flinch, a certain decision before opening any article in Blendle as I evaluate if it's worth the price mentioned. I'm sure the same will manifest itself, perhaps in uglier forms if I set out to use Contributor. Do you guys think so?
- ghostbunnies 9y agoHmmm - the service sounds a little bit like Flattr, the logo looks quite a bit like Flattr - now what?
- LoSboccacc 9y agothey should be flattrd, obviously
- rawfan 9y agoYeah, this is totally Flattr. Except for the even-split concept.
- chr4004 9y agoDon't know, feels a bit like ransom when coming from Google, not the publisher.
- H4CK3RM4N 9y agoI think that the ideal here is that something like this manages to supplant AdSense as Google's main actual business.
- jacquesm 9y agoGood luck with that.
- Bartweiss 9y agoBut the issue is that for AdSense, Google solicits ad buyers, removes scams, and distributes traffic. If you're paying to not see ads, it's unclear what good Google is doing compared to just paying the publisher. It's not zero-value, since the transaction costs of paying every publisher are crippling. But there's no definitive reason to look to Google for this value.
- a3_nm 9y agoAlso what I thought. If this starts becoming widely used, then Google would be essentially getting a share out of the tip that readers would be giving to publishers, only for the service of "not showing ads and redistributing money".
- netsharc 9y agoI think sites are still free to offer "register and pay us to see no ads" model, like many already do. Implementing that will cost them money too (especially dealing with accepting payments), or they can just use Google's implementation and just give Google their bank account information, Google takes care of the rest.
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoWhether it comes from Google, or someone else I believe this is the only way the web survives. Content creators need to be able to charge different amounts for different quality content. In depth, well researched reporting needs to be able to earn more than a buzzfeed article. That's not possible with a flat "per-eyeball" cost, where the revenue to the content creator is uncorrelated with the cost to create or the value/quality of the content. I wish it weren't google (who also already owns advertising), but someone large is the only one who can make it happen. A model like this is necessary to support quality content online.
- mathw 9y agoAnd it has to come from the ad networks, because the infrastructure to make this work is already there - hopefully the ultimate form of this wouldn't require site admins to really do anything special, other than twiddling a few settings in their Google advertising accounts. The real trouble being the more people who use that kind of thing, the more the value of adverts goes down...
- BoiledCabbage 9y ago> And it has to come from the ad networks That is a truth. You need to already have the infra to make this change. I think it'd be too much to both successfully grow a business and try to change browsing behavior at once. > ...The more people who use that kind of thing, the more the value of adverts goes down... Not necessarily a bad thing. If the value of adverts drops, and this is a well known alternative it provides even more incentive to move to model where there is still money to be made. Not to mention there probably is a bit of "recapture". Of people who ran ad-blockers for the experience (ie zero-revenue providers) who are willing to pay for content. Similar to people who torrented, but instead became Netflix/Hulu subscribers when it became an option.
- kbob 9y agoI'm not seeing an issue. How is it worse than ad blockers?
- deleted 9y ago
- ktta 9y agoI feel like I'm going to remember visiting this website for years to come. Either because this is will be future, or this is one of the biggest bets Google has made and failed.
- peteretep 9y agoI love the idea, but go to some lengths to try and stop Google sucking in my web history, and I don't think this will help.
- sdrothrock 9y agoI wonder what kind of reaction site owners will have to this; I can think of a lot of smaller sites or forums that rely on Google ads + premium access with no ads for revenue.
- Fiahil 9y agoI already have an ad removal pass, it's called uBlock origin.
- fredley 9y agoI use uBlock too - it's great. Sometimes a site will have an obnoxious popover or something that's usually relatively easy to create a rule for, but generally it works, and in combination with Ghostery I'm confident it's protecting me from most tracking, which is what I really want to avoid. However it is an ethical dilemma, especially in a World where Contributor exists. Content is not free, hosting is not free, development and the application of security patches is not free. Currently sites are monetised using ads, and by using uBlock you're getting for free something that is not free. You are also inevitably causing people who do not have uBlock to 'pay' more, or contributing to putting the site out of business. While Contributor obviously doesn't prevent Google from tracking your every step, and I'll still take steps to avoid data harvesting, I'll be buying it the moment it's available on any of the sites I read regularly.
- sundvor 9y agoI want a UBlock where in place of ads a single micro tipping facility is inserted. Maybe the website can remember this for the future, etc. I've done a few PayPal tips but it's just too clunky / unfit for purpose.
- tannerwj 9y agoThis comes just after the BAT ICO? Interesting
- foepys 9y agoDo you really think that Google cares about somebody's niche blockchain tech? Google Contributor is older than the whole ICO fad and has just been overhauled.
- tannerwj 9y agoSo you think the timing is just a coincidence then?
- andirk 9y ago"You obviously don't know enough about Bitcoin to argue the way you did." -- foepys I think BAT makes more sense than Google's response to waning ad bucks. None of it has got off the ground so age doesn't mean too much to me.
- nextlevelwizard 9y agoI like how Google doesn't remove ads from it's own sites
- a2decrow 9y agoTheir own ads of course fit the "standards" that they themselves designed. Any other way and they'd only harm their own business model. This is a defensive move against full-scale ad-blockers, nothing more.
- Leynos 9y agoThis doesn't seem that useful to me as only a small number of sites (none of which I visit) support it. Hypothetical question: If I were allowed to bid on my own ad impressions - and if I won an auction, no ad would be shown - how much would it cost a month for me to see no adverts? (I realize this is heavily dependent upon the type of sites that are involved, so I guess take the average HN user as an example).
- kuschku 9y agoThe old version of Google contributor did exactly that, it cost around 7$ a month.
- arjie 9y agoBut you weren't guaranteed to win the auction, were you?
- lrem 9y agoAccording to my first search result [1], average CPC is 2.04$ with 1.16% CTR. Say you see 200 pages a day, 2 ads each. You end up at 9.5$/day. https://www.hochmanconsultants.com/cost-of-ppc-advertising/ https://www.hochmanconsultants.com/cost-of-ppc-advertising/
- beojan 9y agoShouldn't you multiply by your specific click through rate? For many people, this is 0.
- coldpie 9y agoIndeed. I'm almost 30 and I don't think I've ever clicked on an ad in my life. Cost per impression seems more relevant.
- pythonaut_16 9y agoI only click ads when the content jumps at the last second and suddenly it's an ad under my cursor, and other such fun mistakes.
- r3bl 9y agoMaybe if Google went with "Pay us $10 per month for us not to show you any AdSense anywhere on the web", this would be successful. In this form, I highly doubt it.
- cJ0th 9y agoSounds a bit like good 'ol protection money, though ("You don't want some malware on your pc, do you?"[0]). A business classic but not exactly what you'd want from a tech company. [0] http://www.businessinsider.de/android-malware-spreads-using-google-adsense-advertising-network-kaspersky-researchers-2016-8?r=US&IR=T http://www.businessinsider.de/android-malware-spreads-using-...
- underyx 9y agoHuh? Do participating sites need to pay to be included? How is this protection money?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThis is protection money from the user's POV. Protection against malware delivered to user through ads. Particular site that displays the ads is utterly irrelevant here.
- cJ0th 9y agoMy comment, as TeMPOraL points out, was looking at it from the user's perspective and it was a little tongue in cheek. However, google certainly is aware that its AdSense service has been used to spread malware (see my link above)
- majewsky 9y agoGoogle is the one ad network I'd expect to at least make an effort to scan for and filter malware-infested ads, for one reason: They're a household name and they have other products that actual consumers use. If there were a headline tomorrow that some random ad network distributed malware onto consumer's computers, everyone would say "never heard of them before" and move on. If the headline were "Google spreads malware onto consumer's computers", it's reasonable to expect that at least a few people would get mad (such as those affected by the malware) and stop using some other Google product(s). So that's a risk that Google has to consider when asking whether malware scanning is a justified expense. Of course, this doesn't take into account the follow-up question whether malware scanning at the ad-network level (or anywhere, really) offers any sort of protection. (It doesn't appear to be effective, as evidenced by your link.) I, for one, have not whitelisted Google ads (or anything else) in any of my ad/tracking/malware blockers.
- justinjlynn 9y agoWow, how much does this have to do with their announcement to add ad blocking to Chrome (only for other networks ads, I'm sure)? How have they not attracted regulator action yet? You'd think the EU would be all over that kind of behaviour.
- reaktivo 9y agoWhich announcement are you talking about?
- sohkamyung 9y agoI believe it might this one about Chrome support for the Better Ads Standards [1] [1] https://blog.google/topics/journalism-news/building-better-web-everyone/ https://blog.google/topics/journalism-news/building-better-w...
- justinjlynn 9y agohttps://www.wsj.com/articles/google-plans-ad-blocking-feature-in-popular-chrome-browser-1492643233 https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-plans-ad-blocking-featur... https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/19/google-said-to-be-planning-a-built-in-ad-blocker-for-chrome/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/19/google-said-to-be-planning...
- chx 9y agoThis is ancient? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8637365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8637365
- 2sk21 9y agoI had never heard of this until this posting!
- sohkamyung 9y agoThis appears to be a new iteration. According to this Android Police post [1], Contributor was discontinued in late 2016, with Google saying that an improved version would become available in "early 2017." [1] http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/06/01/google-launches-funding-choices-way-users-pay-sites-hide-ads/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/06/01/google-launches-fund...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ctz 9y agoSo, does this work with YouTube and all the other google properties?
- arjie 9y agoYouTube already offers a different ad-free plan. I have YouTube Red through Google Play and you don't get ads.
- comm1 9y agoOne has to mention the Brave browser for comparison: https://brave.com/ https://brave.com/ -- similar concept but using Bitcoin. The accounting at https://brave.com/publishers.html https://brave.com/publishers.html looks like you as the reader can DECIDE whether you want to issue micropayments to a particular site or not, and publishers don't have to explicitly opt-in beforehand (thereby instantly including all of the web). A publisher won't be able to charge different prices, but a publisher with goodwill (hence users opting on their own to pay that publisher) will make money. This seems like a better execution.
- ElijahLynn 9y ago+100 for Brave. Also worth noting you can still block ads without paying with Brave. But if you want to contribute, then you can.
- fudged71 9y agoThey also just raised $30M+ with an ICO :)
- ff_ 9y agoHow is this different from paying for an adblocker? There is lots of good free ones. I pay publishers I like for their content (buying newspapers, subscriptions, etc) and I don't get why Google should be the middleman in this.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt's not that Google "should" be the middleman in this, it's that Google "wants" to be be the middleman in this, since you paying for a subscription directly cuts them out of that sweet ad revenue.
- davb 9y agoI'm not sure how much value I derive from ad-funded websites, besides maybe Google Search. There was a time most websites were free and run for the good of the community, not for profit and not as a full-time job. I could buy my high-quality content in the form of magazines and newspapers. Maybe that's the paradigm worth investigating - community generated, ad-free content on the web but paid-for, bundled (magazine-style) high quality content for sale. Delivered not through the browser but through some other, open platform (think zines, PDFs, epub/mobi). For me, this is what an ideal web would look like. My ad-blocker would barely get a workout, and I'd happily pay for bundled (not pay-walled, bundled, downloadable) content as I did for many years with magazines. No-one wants high quality content to disappear, but advertising and web paywalls are not the only options.
- andy_ppp 9y agoA little concerned, I'm bootstrapping my own version of what they have built, but with a clearer charging model and no need to block Ads IMO. If you care about blocking ads you are already doing it. It'll be launching in literally a week or two... it's very simple to integrate and comes with it's own Wordpress plugin (and instructions to integrate your own CMS). What advice do people have about this per article payment space; I have a load of ideas I want to try so maybe while Google concentrate on ads I'll be able to look at various optional payment models. Initially I want to just charge a flat 5% + whatever Stripe fees you use to top up your wallet, but I'm concerned I'll get a lot of noise/scaling issues if I don't charge a monthly fee? Thoughts?
- wehadfun 9y agoI had an idea for something similar to this as well. Have not put code behind it though. Could you post link to your solution?
- andy_ppp 9y agoIt's not finished yet! Just Stripe Connect (50% done) and testing everything and a couple of small features that probably shouldn't be in version 1. Send me an email (see profile) or check paypip.com in the coming weeks...
- a_imho 9y agoI'm sure there will be people taking this seriously because it is Google, but they are getting a bit desperate.
- waterflame 9y agoEveryone is forgetting that Google can provide such tool because of Chrome (60% market share); they don't need to track you. They already are. Google it's tightening it's grip on the web. Yesterday the announced that they will apply the Better Ad Standard by 2018. They said they'll ban intrusive ads that block the user from the content, ads that play sound automatically, and flashy ads... Now "flashy" is so vague.
- cyphar 9y agoI really think a much better system would be for websites to adopt GNU Taler, and allow people to conduct micropayments using digital cash. The system is about as seamless as Flattr, except that the website can actually charge an amount rather than a fraction. But, most importantly, Flattr guarantees the anonymity of consumers' transactions. So the big G won't have a log of what websites you paid to access.
- spiderfarmer 9y agoCancelled already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor Google Contributor was a program run by Google that allowed users in the Google Network of content sites to view the websites without any advertisements that are administered, sorted, and maintained by Google. The program started with prominent websites, like The Onion and Mashable among others, to test this service. After November 2015, the program opened up to any publisher who displayed ads on their websites through Google AdSense without requiring any sign-on from publishers. Since November 2015, the program was available for everyone in the United States. Google Contributor stopped accepting new registrations after December 2016 in preparation for a new version launch in early 2017.[1] On January 17th, Google Contributor was shut down. As of January 17, 2017 8:40 AM no replacement had been announced.
- d2kx 9y agoThe first iteration was cancelled, this is the new iteration that launched yesterday.
- mh- 9y agoThis was already going to be a tough sell with major publishers. If Google isn't willing to promise they'll keep it around for a couple years, it simply won't be worthwhile for publishers to invest the engineering (and legal resources) to do these deals and the integrations. I don't expect this latest incarnation to gain traction in its current form. I do have hope for this subscription model still. If Google or someone else makes a serious go of it, I'll be cheering them on.
- nilved 9y agoWhy should we trust it this time?
- mankyd 9y agoI'm not sure where the "trust" issue is. You pay $x/month, you see less ads. If they shut it down, they stop charging you money and you start seeing the ads you saw before.
- HXFIVE 9y agoI like the technology and pricing model, but I don't think that it is being put to its best use. I think a better use would be for news sites that require a login to view articles. At present I usually just go without viewing many as I can't afford to sign up to 10 different sites where I might view a couple of articles each week. If I could make a one off payment per article then I'd be all over it.
- intoverflow2 9y ago>a small portion is kept by Google to cover the cost of running the service This is incredibly cheeky.
- majewsky 9y agoWell, there certainly is a cost involved in running (and developing) the service. It would be more credible, though, if they disclosed the size of that "small portion".
- sbergot 9y ago"sorry, contributor is not available in your country" (france)
- whyagaindavid 9y agoInteresting choice of background image with a macbook air!
- themihai 9y agoI guess you also need a google account...how does it work with "do not track"?
- nottorp 9y agoIs it me, or the pricing per page view isn't displayed anywhere in the overview? Of course, if i click on the links to the actual enrolled sites i get 'this service is not available in your country' so it may be there.
- GabrielBerlin 9y agoWe also thought about this at Steady (www.steadyHQ.com). We built a system for recurring payments to independent creators and some of our publishers allow users to pay for not bugging them with their adblocker detectors. This generates additional turnover from users that normally do not get served any ads b/c they use adblockers, but I believe such an offering should encompass all ads, not just Google AdSense (why would you pay just to reduce the amount of ads), and it should include removing paywalls (e.g. at a higher price point, to monetize "superfans").
- youdontknowtho 9y agoWow. I'm really (sounds strange saying this to myself) excited about this Google project. I really hope this works out. As much as I dislike advertising...and Google...something has to happen. The "ad blocker" - "ad blocker blocker" arms race is patently stupid. There has to be a way to get money to content providers so they can opt out of the madness. Google will still be able to provide them with all the sweet sweet surveillance data that they thrive on. One problem at a time, I guess.
- obeleh 9y agoI've got a new productname for this: Google Paywall
- jerianasmith 9y agoGood content will always find it's audience. Readers are far more likely to come back, if the content is engaging enough.
- xchaotic 9y agoWith 12 websites out of which I visited 1, once, I suspect another Google abandoned project in 18 months.
- stephen123 9y agoIs this spotify premium for web pages ?
- bikamonki 9y agoIsn't this how the mob works? Pay us to protect you from us.
- factsaresacred 9y agoYou mean extortion. No. Google don't demand that you view ads, the content creators of the pages you visit do. This is an advertising company imaging a future of ad-blocking browsers and dabbling in a new revenue stream: providing a platform for patron/creator and taking a slice of the dough.
- technological 9y agoIn simple terms , is this a moral way rather than using ad blocker ? Rather than using ad blocker I get this pass , where I won't be seeing ads and at same time feel I am letting publisher earn some money ?
- a_imho 9y agoOnly if you accept ad providers are in charge of dictating morals and they are entitled to your money by default. Publishers can and should look for alternative monetization strategies.
- time4tea 9y agoHmm. Google gets money to show you ads. Google gets money not to show you ads. Who is winning? (Google) Who is losing? ( everybody else, especially you)
- cptskippy 9y agoI've been participating in Google Contributor since it's inception, this is like the 3rd relaunch of the service. I have no doubt it will fail just like the past iterations because the fundamental flaw is that Google is the heart of the system and they're unwilling to extricate themselves from it. I don't think this type of service is the way forward and the solution will not come from Google or any other ad provider for a number of reasons. The first is that Google is not the only ad network and no one wants to be cut out. The second is that this does nothing to address the privacy or security issues people have today that drive them to ad blockers. There aren't just a handful of Ad networks, there are thousands if not millions out there. On top of that, they utilize each other to push out ads in a horrid rat king like incestuous jumble. Any payments to avoid ads served by these companies would require compensating all of these companies, the end result predictably would be movie studio accounting that leaves the content provider with nothing in the end. This setup does nothing to address the privacy issues people have with companies like Google tracking their comings and goings. Google is still at the heart of this system and still knows everything about you. To get any benefit from this system actually requires you to embrace Google. People want to maintain their privacy, they don't want to login to Google to get rid of ads. It's easy to envision a system utilizing a crypto currency and a digital wallet held by your browser that you fill occasionally and that prompts you to pay a site similar to the manner in which Location Services work simply based on a meta tag a site provider puts in their page head containing their wallet and request pay amount and schedule. It's impossible to imagine Google, Apple, Facebook, or anyone who wants in your pants to allow themselves to be cut out of a revenue stream by such a system. Companies like this are double dipping by charging everyone else to be the broker and also by being the service provider being paid. I honestly don't know if an ad free web is allowable. It's technically possible but everyone who isn't the content creator is going to do everything they can to stop it form happening.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoI came here to say "bwahahahaha" but this is so much better. Thanks.
- kemonocode 9y agoI think the whole "fill up a digital wallet with cryptocurrency" thing is what Brave is (was?) attempting but without much success. I do think it's the future, they just took the wrong approach (Replacing others' ads with your own IS going to create bad blood no matter how you spin it) and were too early for it.
- skinnyTotonyo 9y agoThis is terrible. This is where Google is trying to control the web even more than they do already. If this sticks around, if this actually happens, then this will destroy what so many have worked to achieve. Let's actually sit down and think about this. If this happened, there would be some big changes to the web. (Note- this is a quick response. I should write a real paper about this) First of all, now that people would be paying for no ads, websites will overload their sites with ads, because Google will have the solution that "everyone is choosing anyway". It would make it "OK" to have tons of ads on your site, because there's a solution. Then, your web experience becomes terrible. For a "small fee", you can keep a "nice" experience- one that used to, and always should, be free. However, if you don't give Google your money, then your web experience is going to be so filled with ads that content will take forever to load. And even if it does load, it'll take 30 minutes to read an article, because every 30 seconds you'll have your regular add popups. Then, you'll have the sidebar ads that follow you. Or the mobile ones that get in your way as you scroll. You won't be able to view content, because ads will have taken over even more than they already have. Now, in this terrible future, what about those that can't afford Google's "small fee"? They'll be condemned to the ad version of the entire web- one that doesn't load properly, that people have started to discard. The true "web" will be the one where you pay to view. These people won't have access. And, if they aren't able to pay the small fee, then most likely they're accessing the internet from a slow connection. Maybe it's a library that can't afford the fee either. Or maybe it's in the home, and they can only afford small internet speeds and second hand computers. Not everyone has the money to buy a brand spanking new macbook /pro/air from Apple. So now, 5 years down the road, there's two versions of the web. The one that Google controls and tracks 100% (oh yeah, we didn't even get to that yet), and the one that is so ruined with ads, that the people make a decision. A big one. Let's just get rid of the ad version of the web. You can't use it anyway, so there's no use. The only way to go- is to give your monthly payment to Google, so that you can access the web. Now, you gotta pay to view the web at all. The free web is gone. Google took it away. There's also Google, sitting on their even exponential growth pile of money, tracking every web user. Sure, there may be other competing services that let you "into" the web, but they're also gunna track you. No doubt about that. There's so much more that I haven't even said. How will websites determine how much a "view" is? What about requests that are half loaded? How will you know how much it costs to view a webpage? Not all web content is created equal. Definitely not. There's so many more things. So many more. We can't let this happen.
- awinter-py 9y agoAlmost. I would pay money to NOT be tracked everywhere by a big company. It's easy to misunderstand. Thanks, as always, for understanding privacy big G.
- ISL 9y agoHow is this better than the old Contributor? I've always wanted a way to simply specify the minimum bid (by bidding myself) for my attention into the ad exchange. This peer-reviewed pricing seems like it adds lots of cognitive overhead for me?
- bunnymancer 9y agoSo it's Flattr but run by the same company that also serves ads.. Eh.
- mtgx 9y agoIt's U.S.-only? Are you kidding me? So this will actually restrict who can visit a website, as opposed to the ad-version? Whoever came up with that bright idea?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt just means people outside the U.S. will always see the ads, and won't be able to choose to pay with Contributor instead. I'm not saying this isn't a hilarious embarrassment for a global company like Google to keep launching products U.S. only, but it's not as bad as you're making it sound: It will simply not have a noticeable impact on international users.
- kemonocode 9y agoThen naturally, as soon as I try to sign up for it, I get told "Contributor is not yet available in your country" as it seems to be US-only at the moment. That's okay, uBlock Origin with its whitelist I compiled with sites I know won't violate my browser with ads is still available in my country.
- wnissen 9y agoDon't feel bad, there are literally only 1 dozen sites that it works on, and so you probably don't care about it right now anyway.
- freehunter 9y ago>with sites I know won't violate my browser with ads But that's one of the problems. You know they haven't violated your browser yet but that's no indication that they won't in the future. A lot of people trust/trusted Imgur and whitelisted their ads, and they were rewarded with an ad network that was redirecting them to malware sites. It's cleaned up now, but what's to say it won't happen again? Ars Technica suffered a similar situation a while back. Reddit has had it happen too. All seemingly trustworthy sites. It's not safe to turn off your ad blocker, there are no third-party ad networks you can trust. The only acceptable ads IMO are native sponsored content, which sites don't like because it's extra work. But guess what: you can't (easily) block native sponsored content.
- ptr_void 9y agoGoogle at it again to kill the web, now making commodization of web contents mainstream. You WON'T BELIEVE YOUR EYE what GOOGLE will do NEXT! - $0.5
- nrjames 9y agoSomebody should do this for mobile game advertising. A player buys a $5 card with allows them to skip ads in all participating mobile games until such time as the $ is depleted. If that card worked across lots of games, it would be a great convenience. Considering ARPDAU from ads for mobile games isn't often more than $0.01, it would be a win-win for gamers who hate ads and want to play free mobile games.
- catskull 9y agoWait so it only works on those 4 websites? I've only heard of Popular Mechanics, but I rarely (if ever) visit their site. If this was more like Youtube Red, I'd be all over this. I would love to pay to remove all google ads. I get that uBlock exists, but I want to support the sites I use. Unrelated: the sidenav thing is empty? WTF?
- SamBam 9y agoI don't understand why it doesn't work for all Google Ads. The content creator would just like the money. They don't actually want to display the ads. If they could get the money without displaying the ads, they'd be over the moon. Why doesn't Google make it work across all sites, and pay the sites using Google Ads the average revenue they were already getting per page view?
- zigzigzag 9y agoThey did that. It was the first iteration. The problem is that - as described above - many websites use ads from multiple networks, so actually even if you paid, most ads did not disappear. It was more or less random. Also, it turns out ads make sites a lot of money (who knew), so to get even that sketchy coverage required you to pay a LOT.
- sornars 9y agoI feel like your second point was a missed educational opportunity for users. Ad views are worth a lot more to advertisers (and consequently, publishers) than what you are willing to pay - 'free content' isn't free and if you as a user aren't willing to pay for it then it's probably not fair to complain about the ads. The thing that upsets me is when I am willing to pay for content (Washington Post, The Economist, FT, etc.) and I still get served ads. Online advertising reminds me of airline travel in the sense that people complain about the low quality service but are only willing to purchase the cheapest flights. The industry has shifted to accomodate what people actually want, not what they say they want.
- funkyy 9y ago
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoGoogle: Nice internet ya got there. It'd be terrible if something were to happen to it like, say, ads everywhere. But if you just give me a few dollars I'll protect ya from 'em. Edit: >How it works You load your pass with $5. Each time you visit a page without ads, a per-page fee is deducted from your pass to pay the creators of the website, after a small portion is kept by Google to cover the cost of running the service. The price per page is set by the creator of the site. You will be informed in advance if a site creator changes their price per page. Contributor is easy to update: change settings and add sites or remove them from your pass at any time. I love the sound of this, I just do not like the idea that it is Google doing it. It feels ... dirty somehow. A third party doing this I have no problem with.
- draw_down 9y agoProblem is you have to be logged in to use this, same problem as with Youtube red. As soon as you open something in an incognito window.... who are you??
- ryandrake 9y agoWhat's the advantage for the end user of this, over an ad blocker which is a free ad removal pass?
- elahd 9y agoThe advantage is that you financially support the creation of content you value enough to read.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 9y ago> What's the advantage for the end user of this, over an ad blocker which is a free ad removal pass? You are paying to support sites you visit with money, instead of advertisers doing that, so you are still providing incentive to create the kind of content you consume.
- azazel75 9y agoThat's like a Google tax, with the plus that you consciously agree to let it track you more than ever... wtf!
- diimdeep 9y agolaughable uBlock alternative.
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoThanks Google, but im going to stick with ublock/umatrix and get ad removal for free
- kraig911 9y agoIt simply isn't worth it as Google doesn't actually enable content creators unless you create content on their sites. We need a better way to say give content creators something akin to Patreon but easier.
- yolo66 9y agoPeople will likely hesitate as it comes from Google.
- redxblood 9y agoNope. Trash. uBlock origin.
- caogecym 9y agoIt's too expensive for consumers.
- designium 9y agoIt doesn't work for Canada.
- nsnick 9y agoThe reason this will fail is that it competes with free. Why pay google when you can install an ad blocker?
- spullara 9y agoMy idea in this space is to launch the no-ad-network. Basically you would pay them to bid on your behalf across all exchanges for your cookie. It would either display nothing, nice photos or maybe even some customized data about the site you are on. Everyone wins.
- subterfudge44 9y ago1c per visit ? That is like $10 CPM. that is crazy expensive when most publishers don't make more that $2 CPM.
- deavmi 9y agoI have adblock. Really good; you should try it.
- sandov 9y agoWhy not just donate to the sites whose content you value?