12 ms·
Bitcoin mining companies face shutdown in southwest China
- howscrewedami 9y agoChina banning bitcoin would have a huge negative impact on cryptocurrencies worldwide. But what if... that's exactly what the chinese government wants? What if this is all a scheme to short sell bitcoin?
- throwaway2048 9y agoShort selling requires a counter party. There is no short selling counter party in the BTC ecosystem that holds anywhere close to the amount that would make such a move worth it. Even if the moves china makes somehow extracted the entire wealth of the bitcoin economy, it wouldn't make much sense for them to bother.
- howscrewedami 9y agoNice try, chinese government.
- splintercell 9y agoLol reminds me of this meme: http://imgur.com/a/KDwtE http://imgur.com/a/KDwtE
- howscrewedami 9y agoIt's an Older Meme, Sir. But It Checks Out.
- isubkhankulov 9y agoyet still relevant
- matt4077 9y agoCountries aren't usually in the business of manipulating small, illiquid markets for negligible financial profit.
- howscrewedami 9y agoBitCoin isn't illiquid. There are numerous people out there making a living out of it.
- isubkhankulov 9y agoliquidity in this case is market liquidity. like how much or little one can sell without moving the price and/or slipping your own price. Bitcoin compared to most other currencies and many stocks, has fairly low fragmented worldwide liquditity.
- ericd 9y agoAnd China is one of the largest economies in the world, with well over a billion people making a living in it. The profit from shorting it would not even a bug splatter on the windshield of their economy. The evasion of capital controls is a much, much larger concern for them.
- mahranch 9y agoAnd it should be a larger concern for bitcoin proponents, too. Imagine if China decided to wage a covert war on bitcoin. I mean, is it really so hard to believe that China wouldn't like bitcoin because it literally (not figuratively) runs antithesis to their own fiscal policies? And how would they run a covert war against it? An open war or public attack would immediately raise the defenses of everyone involved, from miners to developers, to bitcoin holders. But what if they played nice while all the while poisoning the well or setting the stage to gain trust. They could do this through third party companies (cough bitmain cough) which could cause damage to bitcoin by delaying vital upgrades and sowing the seeds of uncertainty and doubt.
- lawless123 9y ago
- justicezyx 9y agoSo everything Chinese government does, eventually leads to some malicious grand scheme...
- Analemma_ 9y agoThe Chinese government holds $3.5 trillion in U.S. treasuries. The profit from "short-selling bitcoin" wouldn't even qualify as a rounding error to them.
- endless1234 9y agoIf we assume the Chinese government manages to short ALL current bitcoin (16.5 million), and that the gain from shorting will be $2000 per BTC (current value is about ~2300), it'll still not be even a percentage of 3.5 trillion.
- SimonPStevens 9y agoIt might be insignificant to China the country. But a government is made up of individuals. It's entirely possible that in an already corrupt environment, the dozen or so individuals on the crypto committee may be convinced to make decision that benefit them personally. Make a few impactful decisions at your day job, block a few exchanges, short bitcoin personally, profit personally. Wouldn't be hard to make a million or two if you knew of a price fall coming up in advance, there are plenty of ways to get leverage on the bitcoin markets these days.
- dreamthtwasrome 9y agoSeems like the operative gambit would be one-or-more miner/exchange pays govt official(s) lots of money to "crackdown" on BTC, except not as much on them. win-win
- petre 9y agoChina is shutting down miners, Yet the price is still going through the roof.
- runeks 9y agoWhy would I care whether bitcoins are illegal in China? The Bitcoin network will adjust to the reduction in hash rate, and after that it will impact my use of Bitcoin as much as China's great firewall impacts my use of the internet. China is an oppressive regime. It's standard practice for oppressive regimes to ban what they feel they can't control. If Bitcoin ever becomes really useful, they will be forced to ban it -- if they want to maintain monetary control.
- andy_ppp 9y agoWon't the bitcoin miners just move to Vietnam or Thailand or Taiwan or Macau or some other place? It's not like these bitcoin miners have no money to relocate...
- pmorici 9y agoThey will relocate to where ever electricity is the cheapest. Labor costs aren't a factor.
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoPerhaps the electricity use might be something the Chinese government cares about? "That power plant is polluting our place and you guys aren't employing anyone. Sooo..." Just sayin.
- pmorici 9y agoIt's almost all hydro power every thing else is too expensive to be competitive.
- Phlarp 9y agoIf the miners weren't tapping all the hydro power they wouldn't have to burn as much coal to power the rest of the country.
- bluesteel44 9y agoMiner is an ideal consumer of the electricity, doesn't have peak hours, can put equipment near the hydro power plant, so it is very likely a lot of this energy has been just wasted before c. 2013-2014.
- oh_sigh 9y agoThe entire Bitcoin network consumes about 2GW at the moment, which is something but not much compared to China's total generation capacity which iirc is something like 900GW
- pmorici 9y agoA little context for this. China cracked down on Bitcoin exchanges earlier this year and stopped all withdrawals of Bitcoin from exchanges. Reports just in the past few days are that they have finally re-enabled Bitcoin withdrawals at the major exchanges in China. Some mining operations are closely linked to exchanges so perhaps these shutdowns are related to the scrutiny of the exchanges. Also shutting down one miner just makes the remaining miners more profitable in the long term. In the short term though ~1 week it has the effect of reducing the rate at which Bitcoins are generated until the difficulty re-target is reached.
- modeless 9y agoSeems to me as though Bitcoin mining is kind of a backdoor way to move Chinese money offshore circumventing capital controls. Pay for your electricity in yuan, then sell your Bitcoin anywhere in the world. In fact I speculate that may be the main reason Bitcoin mining is so popular there; it's essentially subsidized by people wanting to move money offshore. Perhaps this is cracking down on that? There's so little detail in the article it's impossible to tell.
- chenster 9y ago100% correct.
- modeless 9y agoDo you have some knowledge of people doing this?
- Scoundreller 9y agoI suspect the same when I buy goods from China on Ebay: The money is going to an ex-China Paypal account. I may very well be paying less than cost because $1 outside is China is worth x%+ than inside of China.
- ada1981 9y agoCurious what the opportunities to help folks in China do this and profit as a person in the USA?
- chenster 9y ago> Mining Bitcoins is a global effort, so even if mining is banned somewhere, the total amount of Bitcoins does not change, and so the global price will not fluctuate, an industry insider said. This is not true. Bitcoin price swings like crazy.
- dantillberg 9y agoMaybe they mean to say that the amount of new bitcoin mined will not fluctuate? It's true that the amount of new supply per day is roughly constant -- even if half of the miners go offline, just as much new bitcoin is produced per day.
- MichaelGG 9y agoReally? I thought the difficulty took several days to adjust. Edit: The wiki says it takes 2160 blocks, about two weeks?
- sanswork 9y agoIt does. If half the miners went offline right after an adjustment half as much bitcoin would be mined everyday and the next adjustment would be a month away instead of 2 weeks. The number of available transactions for the month would drop by half as well.
- deftnerd 9y agoThe majority of Bitcoin mining is located in just a few geographic regions that happen to have inexpensive power. China, The Republic of Georgia (special backroom deal with the president and BitFury), North-East Canada, and parts of North-West US that have cheap hydro power. If China is really rooting out the bitcoin mining operations, it represents a huge change in the makeup of the mining/hashing industry
- bernardlunn 9y agoWhy does China have low cost power? I understand the others you mention, but is it from subsidies in China?
- chenster 9y agoChina Bitcoin Miners Documentary: https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/life-inside-a-chinese-bitcoin-mine/55b910f39820ecc47f68c306 https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/life-inside-a-chinese-bit...
- _pmf_ 9y agoIntervention from China will stabilize Bitcoin.
- neom 9y agoIs there anywhere to read about the probabilities of and implications of sweeping multinational policy around cryptocurrency/bitcoin? Also, could a country make it's own crypto currency somehow pegged to it's national currency? A lot of my friends are really deep in bitcoin now, I can't tell if I should worry or not.
- slindz 9y agoI haven't checked on it lately, but Iceland had introduced their own crypto currency (Aurora coin) a few years back. It began with an initial distribution to all citizens.
- cr1895 9y ago>but Iceland had introduced Not the government of Iceland, it should be noted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auroracoin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auroracoin
- simonebrunozzi 9y agoWorry for them? And "worry", in terms of their financial outcome? If they have been into bitcoin for some time, "worry" might be overstated - they are probably well off - financially - as of now.
- runeks 9y ago> Also, could a country make it's own crypto currency somehow pegged to it's national currency? Sure, but what would the point be? It would only be a cryptocurrency in name. No reason to go through the trouble of using a blockchain if you're just trading credit. The selling point of Bitcoin is decentralization, and pegging requires centralization (a counterparty who will transfer national currency to your account upon receiving crypto-coins).
- kristofferR 9y agoSmart Contracts, if fully supported by the government, could completely remove a lot of the avenues of small-scale governmental corruption.
- perlpimp 9y agook heres my take on this, they do these random shut downs to keep miners on their toes. in some article it has been explained this is how china has implemented firewall policy. if they detect unknown traffic they constrict your flow gradually until you can't do anything. this might be one of those moves, not a clear restriction but rest of miners should be aware of impeding wave of problems caused by PRC oligarchs.
- timwaagh 9y agoi say it is about time government cracks down on this tax-avoidance ponzi scheme. bitcoin is a great achievement technically but it has only negative consequences for soceity at large.
- discombobulate 9y agoTax avoidance != tax evasion. At least get the basics right if you're going to make grand proclamations! And you obviously got upvoted. HN is full of libtards.
- sctb 9y agoNo matter what you're replying to, it never helps to post uncivilly like this. In particular, the claim that HN is full of <derogatory partisan flamebait term> is the worst kind of unsubstantive tedium.
- ybrah 9y ago>ponzi scheme Bitcoin is as much as a ponzi scheme as gold is.
- literallycancer 9y agoHow is it a ponzi scheme?
- vocatus_gate 9y agoThe whole "ponzi scheme" accusation is trotted out every time Bitcoin is brought up, and it's always by people completely unfamiliar with how Bitcoin actually functions. It's as much a "ponzie scheme" as much as any other limited-supply asset.
- timwaagh 9y agoponzi scheme is not to be taken literally. people say it because the people creating currencies benefit at the expense of everyone else, without offering much in return. i know more or less how it works and that is why i say this. the founders of bitcoin have huge stocks of bitcoins, artificially restricting the bitcoin supply to keep the price up. however if that was not the case the supply of bitcoin would be more or less fixed as it gets harder and harder to mine. also there is nothing of value behind a bitcoin, just people's belief it will stay valuable. because of the inherent impossibility to adjust the supply of bitc depending on demand, it cannot ever function as a currency, because its value cant be adjusted for demand. when demand lessens, as is inevitable, investors will lose their money and the major beneficaries will be those who created bitcoin and sold it for dollars. the only real value it currently offers, is it allows people to dodge tax and launder money. it also enables the criminal economy, with things like drug-ecommerce when the government does not approve (im all for legalisation, btw). so it undermines goverment authority and enables criminality. i get that i get downvoted because people here believe strongly in privacy and tend to dislike their governments. but i don't. you have to think about how much of your life depends on government authority in order to understand the danger anything that undermines it poses.
- known 9y agoBitcoin mining is a trap; Better late than never;
- Uberphallus 9y agoI'm surprised this comes out now, right in the middle of the noise about the UASF (User Activated Soft Fork) and Segregated Witness controversies. The community is pushing to enable larger blocks among other functionalities that would cult down on the fees that miners (read: Chinese miners) collect. Obviously the miners won't agree on that, but the network agreement depends on what the Bitcoin processing power decides, not on what the majority of the users do. At some point either the miners join, the users give up, or the chain forks in two (obviously with wildly different valuations). I'm not familiar with People.cn, but my first reaction with the headline is that the piece of news has second intentions.
- rebuilder 9y agoThis s a bit tangential, but it's not clear that larger blocks, or any other way of getting a higher on-chain transaction throughout, would result in less total fees collected by miners. The fees are set by the miners, after all.
- rc_kas 9y agoTHANK YOU FOR SPELLING OUT YOUR ACRONYM!!!! So many internet idiots just use acronyms all the time on the assumption that everyone speaks the same language as them. I wish more people would take your approach.
- njarboe 9y agoBitcoin to me seems like a great currency for oligarchical/plutocratic type governance systems. Authority can know what addresses are controlled by who, give people privacy and the feeling of security, and can create a hierarchy of knowledge where people get increasing insight into the country's(world's?) economy/social graph as they reach the top of the power pyramid. All transactions are recorded for all time. Great.
- hackeraccount 9y agoYeah but the block chain is available to everyone. So potentially anyone outside - or even worse inside - the oligarchical/plutocratic can have an idea of just what the heck is going on. Best keep that genie in the bottle. It reminds of what some Soviet leader (Krushchev, maybe?) said when asked why he was against an "open skies" Treaty. "We have nothing to hide. We have nothing and must hide it"
- problems 9y agoYeah, it's interesting because some alternatives like ZCash effectively solve this problem too, and provide full anonymity but they're fairly closely related and probably will get treated the same way by regulators in many places. Should be interesting to see what happens.
- kakarot 9y agoBitcoin promised transparency, the opposite of privacy. Users who feel their usage is private have been mislead by others.
- taoice 9y agoIs it reason of btc price down ?