8 ms·
I've been sort of amazed at how brazen people are in cryptocurrencies about pyramid schemes. They'll even call themselves ponzi schemes. And how many people wil
by empath75 9y ago
I've been sort of amazed at how brazen people are in cryptocurrencies about pyramid schemes. They'll even call themselves ponzi schemes. And how many people will join them, knowing that it's a scam, just assuming they won't be the last suckers in.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoPeople have argued that cryptocurrencies themselves are pyramid schemes - the people who start mining early win out, and the people who join later to speculate on the currency have less and less chances of striking it rich. (Obviously this is based on the view of cryptocurrency as purely speculative, not as an actual currency with which to buy things, but even now, it's still pretty difficult to buy a lot of things with Bitcoins.)
- joosters 9y agoA great explanation of crypto coins (ethereum in particular, and carrying on to its DAO fiasco) is here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4uzw81/eli18_ethereum/d5ucyca/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4uzw81/eli18_ethe... - it basically comes down to people trying to persuade you that their shiny new tokens (that they created from nothing) are really worth something.
- jimmyswimmy 9y agoThis is not so different from any fiat currency. It's only worth something if you believe it's worth something. For that matter, any valuable thing. But at least you can't print gold. (No I'm not a goldbug) Bitcoin, ethereum, dollars, euro - there isn't anything fundamentally different. Printed money is just that, and the guy who controls the printer can choose to print more and inflate the currency. But we all believe it's worth something... Because we believe it. It's a tautology. Cryptocurrencies are no different.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fivestar 9y agoExcept they are different. Gresham's Law--bad money chases out good. We do have a problem with fiat and who controls the issuance, no argument there. However, "money" or "currency" is also based on history. The dollar has a reasonably good history up until 1971 when Nixon took it off the partial gold standard, the value plummeted. Consider this: Would divers risk their lives to recover paper money from a sunken 1930s era shipwreck? Yet for gold or silver, they will readily do that. I'm not gold bug, but I can understand why--gold and silver have a loooong history as stores of wealth. That's probably more important than any other consideration--how long has the "money" been "money?"
- clarkmoody 9y agoThose people don't understand what a pyramid scheme is. The acquisition of bitcoin by newcomers in no way enriches earlier adopters, as in a classic pyramid scheme. Miners continually invest huge sums in capital equipment with the hope that the price continues to rise. If it does not, they are toast. This is not gambling or a Ponzi; this is just a risk/reward business decision. It's the exact decision that the capitalist makes when she decides to build a new production line at the factory. Buying bitcoin early is like investing early in any new technology: it could be worth nothing, or it could go bananas. Many alt-coins have trickled down to very low prices over time or stopped functioning altogether. There are no sure things in this space, even for the early adopters.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- matt4077 9y ago> The acquisition of bitcoin by newcomers in no way enriches earlier adopters, as in a classic pyramid scheme. Of course it does. Bitcoin used to be at $1, now it's at $1,xxx. What happened in between was a massive influx of newcomers. The difference to, for example, the stock market is in the "underlying value". If I buy some stock and it's price collapsed the next day, I'm still entitled to my share of future profits etc. If the company is sound, I have lost nothing. A ponzi scheme's underlying value is only the future growth of the scheme itself. I'd say the jury is still out for bitcoin et alt: how much of the growth is being fuelled by speculation, and to what extend is that speculation actually speculating on future speculation?
- splintercell 9y ago> The difference to, for example, the stock market is in the "underlying value". If I buy some stock and it's price collapsed the next day, I'm still entitled to my share of future profits etc. If the company is sound, I have lost nothing. Bitcoin is a payment network (Even if the price collapses to really low). Ethereum is a smart contracts platform, so you can still build certain kind of apps on it even if it's price collapses. A ponzi scheme as NO business model (or the business model claimed, isn't a valid one). Using bitcoin I can actually transfer wealth from one part of the world to another, similarly using Ethereum I can create decentralized applications funded by payment (like pay-to-seed bit torrent network).
- api 9y agoBitcoin is a finite supply store of value like gold. To argue that's a Ponzi scheme reduces down to arguing that the entire economy is a Ponzi scheme. There are some Marxists who argue that. If that's true we have bigger problems.
- tertius 9y ago> the people who start mining early win out, and the people who join later to speculate on the currency have less and less chances of striking it rich. Replace "mining" with investing and currency with stock and tada. That's not a pyramid scheme, that's risk/reward investing 101.
- joosters 9y agoThe difference being that companies are meant to be trying to make money and give that to their investors, whereas cryptocoins are nothing but a string of numbers.
- zenlikethat 9y agoI agree having a company trying to produce revenue is arguably more valuable, but keep in mind cryptocurrency isn't _just_ a string of numbers -- what you're buying into is a massive network of machines verifying your transactions and protecting the system from things like double-spends. Sure, Bitcoin has scaling issues, but there is still an insane amount of computing power backing it, and that isn't changing. I'm not 100% sure I see as much value in Ethereum, for sure -- since throwing that much computing power at verifying programs is more dubious to me, as is the switch to proof of stake.
- DennisP 9y agoEthereum does the same thing as Bitcoin. It's just that you can also have scripts on the network that move money around.
- zenlikethat 9y agoThat's as much a liability as it is an asset -- for instance, https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/6eruqb/if_your_exchange_is_related_to/?st=j3gfi7i8&sh=b5673c95 https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/6eruqb/if_your_ex... ("QuadrigaCX exchange lost 60000 Ether due to smart contract problems").
- ajflkjasdf777 9y ago"the people who start mining early win out, and the people who join later to speculate on the currency have less and less chances of striking it rich." The people that were born early win out, and the people who are born later have less and less chances of striking it rich. So human societies in general.
- kpommerenke 9y agoNot true: the general trend is that later generations are richer than earlier generations. Just compare yourself to the average person in your country 100 years ago.
- ajflkjasdf777 9y ago"less and less chances of striking it rich." Never said we weren't generally better off. But none of us have a shot at being oil barons, logging millionaires, retail moguls, etc. Striking it rich now generally means achieving a higher level of knowledge and education first, then you can try to make your mark. The previous generation hordes vast sums of wealth from endeavors that required less up front preparation and less capital (which was often provided rather no strings attached by the government, a tap which is being shut off (look at IBM's history of being gifted government funded inventions, among others)).
- DennisP 9y ago> people who start mining early win out, and the people who join later to speculate on the currency have less and less chances of striking it rich If that's all it takes to be a pyramid scheme, then any high-growth stock is a pyramid scheme. I could have struck it rich by buying Apple in 1999, but I don't think it would happen now.
- fivestar 9y agoA stock is part ownership in a corporation. There are laws and rules that govern stock issuance and stock investing. You have proxy voting rights with many stocks. You can go visit the physical corporation which has a "book value" and you can determine worth based off that value plus revenue and earnings minus operational costs and decide whether you want to invest. There have been stock swindles in the past--the 1800s up to the 1920s were full of them. There have been insurance and bond swindles, too. High growth stocks may be bubbles, but are not pyramid schemes.
- DennisP 9y agoHence my clause "if that's all it takes." My point is that outsized rewards for early investors do not make something a pyramid scheme, which is a specific illegal structure. Neither stocks nor cryptocurrencies are pyramid schemes.
- f055 9y agoIf you knowingly join a ponzi scheme, it's pretty much like a casino - you go there knowing there's a pretty good chance you will loose your money, and a slim one you will win some. Some people like the rush.
- just_one_time_ 9y agoUSD and stock market are in the same boat. The ONLY difference is bitcoin has a limited known supply, the others are 100% ponzi.
- conanbatt 9y agoThis was eye-opening for me. This explains actually the adoption scammy operations that are ponzis have: people are not against participating in a ponzi scheme at all, its just the lottery effect ("i wont be one of the losers").
- smacktoward 9y agoThe dumb money is always, always, always 100% certain that it is actually the smart money.
- fivestar 9y agoLook to your left, look to your right. If you can't spot the sucker--it's you!
- richtr 9y agoCrytocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum are legitimate stores of value and have been compared to the use of other finite stores of value such as precious metals. The market capitalization of gold currently stands at 7.5 trillion USD. All cryptocurrencies combined currently stand at a market capitalization of 87.6 billion USD (1.14% of the market capitalization of gold). Cryptocurrencies with a finite supply can supplant other finite stores of value and actually provide a number of benefits over existing finite stores of value (instant exchange to sterling currencies, improved transactional ability, traceability and general liquidity). It is likely we are just getting started. Calling any legitimate store of value a Ponzi scheme is missing the point.
- empath75 9y agoi was talking about literal ponzi schemes: Search for ponzi: https://dapps.ethercasts.com/ https://dapps.ethercasts.com/
- tomp 9y agoOP isn't calling cryptocurrencies a Ponzi scheme, but specific contracts (e.g. in Ethereum you could make a "smart contract" that acts as a Ponzi scheme).
- uberrr 9y agoThe market cap was $25 billion one month ago [0]. $60 billion in growth in one month. Sound a bit fishy? [0] https://cryptolization.com https://cryptolization.com
- rhino369 9y ago>Bitcoin and Ethereum are legitimate stores of value What does legitimate mean? The only difference between monopoly money and bitcoin is that people right now believe in bitcoin. But that belief could easily falter. The same could be said about gold, but gold a very long history and has somewhat strong demand for use in jewelry. At this point in time, essentially all demand for cyrpto is for speculation purposes. There is some use for illicit markets but it's very minor. I wouldn't call it a ponzi scheme because those are intentional. But the current pricing for cryptos is definitely an embodiment of the Great Fool Theory of investing.
- louprado 9y agoThe last ICO I attended totally felt like an MLM meeting. Just like in MLM, one does not talk about the pyramid but instead talks about the commodity product/service/asset that enables the pyramid to be built. But everyone knows it's about making money through the pyramid. The commodity is just a distraction to give it some legitimacy.