6 ms·
Older Adults Learning Programming: Motivations and Frustrations
- cafman 9y agoI've had a few students who were retired and were learning just for their own interest but most of my "older" students are going to school to get themselves to a paycheck. As someone who has learned programming on my own for some hobby projects, learning programming is probably not the fastest way to a stable income. Math, Sciences, and Computer Science are very demanding programs and can be challenging for "older" students, not because they can't do the work but because college is hard for someone with kids, mortgage, car payment etc.
- fivestar 9y agoYes, if you choose that path, you need to reduce your distractions--similar to how you would sell everything and become a Buddhist monk or something. The journey of 1000 miles begins with a single step. You need that level of dedication, which, sadly, 99.8% of adults lack.
- axaxs 9y agoI am really fascinated by this article, and hope more research is done. I'm not near as old as those candidates, but still feel the effect. The older I have gotten, the harder it is to remember things or learn on the fly. I remember being 21 at a company, and claimed, and could, write anything they wanted. The older members slowed me down with their inability to understand, well, to me. But I was writing awful code. To me it was beautiful and worked fine, but as I learned more in years coming I learned design practices and testability, which were nonexistent. I think this is normal, but to me, sad. I have learned some bit of wisdom in these years, but can admit my brain isn't as fast as it once was. Where's the divide, where do I go? I'm a software engineer, that one day will be replaced with a much younger, headstrong kid, who is much more productive, just as I was back then.
- Consultant32452 9y agoFluid intelligence decreases with age, but crystallized intelligence continues to grow. You (metaphorical you) really are slower than the younger, headstrong kid. All hope is not lost though, you're still valuable on the market, you just present a different value proposition than you did in your youth. https://www.verywell.com/fluid-intelligence-vs-crystallized-intelligence-2795004 https://www.verywell.com/fluid-intelligence-vs-crystallized-...
- axaxs 9y agothank you very much for the confidence.
- amorphid 9y agoAs I get older, I desire to be less random and more precise. I don't think I am smarter or dumber than I was 20 years ago. I used to "ship it" faster, but now I realize it's because I didn't really understand the problem.
- RickS 9y ago> You (metaphorical you) really are slower than the younger, headstrong kid It pains me to think that others are put off by this. My old self was indeed much faster, and had plenty more stamina, but all that means I could make the wrong decision at half the speed for twice the time. I wouldn't go back if I could.
- c517402 9y agoI don't think I ever knew where this quote came from, but it stuck. "Computers let you make more mistakes faster than any invention in the history of mankind, with the possible exception of tequila and hanguns."
- Consultant32452 9y agoAnd employers recognize this. There's a reason senior developers get paid more than junior developers. And there's also a difference why those two groups are often given different roles.
- kruhft 9y agoI feel the problem is that people are not using the correct metaphors. Everyone is a programmer; every time you ask someone to do something for you you are programming. I direct one to the opening of Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs to really learn what programming is: https://mitpress.mit.edu/sicp/full-text/book/book-Z-H-5.html#%_chap_Temp_2 https://mitpress.mit.edu/sicp/full-text/book/book-Z-H-5.html...
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe primary task of a programmer is to abstract, not instruct. But everyone does that also.
- analog31 9y agoWe all instruct and abstract, but imprecisely, because the people we're dealing with can either fill in the blanks, or they're inclined to agree with and follow us even if we're wrong. I remember one of the first things my programming teacher said was: Computers are stupid. They can only do what you tell them. That's a hurdle.
- kruhft 9y agoThe primary task of a programmer is to direct with abstraction being a tool of linguistic direction, or simply the compression of lower level ideas into higher level concepts.
- hackermailman 9y agoThe only way I remember is by doing exercises. I'll read examples and understand immediately then not bother with the exercises only to forget later unless I've done X instead of just learning X. If I have 20mins to spare I'll often grab a text I've done and try and redo a few of the exercises to see if I can remember and that also helps, I learned that method from an older post here from somebody who suggested redoing material 6 months after to help remember.
- rimliu 9y ago> I'll read examples and understand immediately then not > bother with the exercises It's a trap a.k.a. the illusion of understanding. When you actually try to do something you think you understood from just reading/watching, it turns out a lot of small but essential parts were missed.
- epalmer 9y agoThe author of the study is on a recent Talk Python to Me podcast that I just finished listening to. https://talkpython.fm/episodes/show/112/geeking-out-in-the-golden-years https://talkpython.fm/episodes/show/112/geeking-out-in-the-g...
- epalmer 9y agoI'm 63 but learned to code a long time ago. My ability to see connections, abstractions and the like is better than ever. I do find that distractions like background noise or other competing tasks reduces my ability to solve the complex problems. I have to really isolate and focus. I also find benefit from listening to http://brain.fm http://brain.fm
- raarts 9y ago56 yo here. Since a year on a learning spree: Docker Swarm, CI/CD, React, RN after a life of C/PHP/Python and -later on -C-level management. Not aware that I'm slower these days, but slightly harder to focus, so using a headset.
- epalmer 9y agoI've got a two year plan. 2017 CSP (Certified Scrum Participant) then in 2018 take the http://fast.ai http://fast.ai course. Maybe the Stanford ai course as well. 63 and still learning.
- cleaver 9y agoI do notice that while I can't keep the 30th API I've used in my head for instant recall, I am much faster at finding the big picture. I'm a big fan of diverse teams. A younger programmer can just plow ahead without my careful consideration, but that helps keep me from stagnation. Similarly, I can contribute the big picture stuff to make the long term smoother and reduce technical debt. I haven't seen brain.fm, but there's so many tools that can help me improve the way I work.
- Quequau 9y agoI'm somewhat older and after retiring a little early I decided to return to university. I confess that the experience is both humbling and frustrating because I'm finding it much, much more difficult than the first time around. I had the fantasy of getting a degree in a completely unrelated field and finding a fun part time gig. Now, if I'm honest with myself, I'm not really sure that I'm up for the task... and that's really disheartening.
- elviejo 9y agoMy mother who was born in a time when typewriters were an innovation has just finished her highschool online in a program that lasted 2 years. She had to fight all her way from not having an email to do homeworks in video. She worked extremely hard 4 to 6 hours a day... Now she is enrolling in college... Hang in there you CAN do it.. It won't be easy but it will be Worthy.
- fivestar 9y agoI spent way too much time in higher education and I found that even in my late 20s I was already not a fit for the university campus--kept butting heads with petty tyrants, things like that. Colleges are designed for young adults. Also, there are no "fun, part-time gigs" that you need a degree for. There is only work.
- thegayngler 9y agoMy aunt was cleaning the houses of rich people for a living and then when she was in her late 40's she decided to return to school. She ultimately earned her degree in Accounting in her 50's and now she does all of the rich people's taxes that she used to clean for.
- corpMaverick 9y agoAwesome story!
- devoply 9y agoI don't want to sound discouraging but the problem with the profession is multifold. First the problem is that the domain is very large and is constantly changing. So the time investment is rather large to learn a significant enough chunk to be useful. Second problem is that it requires a lot of cognitive load in terms of remembering many different things and having a good intuitive sense of why things are not working, which again requires a lot of knowledge and experience. Third is the problem with the industry itself, it's not properly valued by employers. A sub-par programmer for many of the employers is completely useless. The low end employers all have no money to spend, but yet want one person to do a job that requires deep knowledge of many different things. All of these things taken together make a very difficult profession to get into in your 50s, 60s, or 70s as it will take you about a decade to get any good at it and then you will be fighting an uphill battle to actually get a proper job as businesses don't find you in their ideal demographic when hiring.
- hyperpallium 9y agoI've always had a terrible memory, both short-term and long-term. But this has been an advantage, in a way: I could never memorize material and bluff my way through. Instead, to remember it, I had to understand it. I think this helps partly because you can always work it out from first principles (and just remembering there's some tricky bit somewhere around here), partly the familiarity required for understanding helps embed it, but mostly that I've distilled it to a very simple model in my mind, that I've related to other systems I already know. The meta-model becomes the more interesting thing. It's hard work to uncover this model, often requiring chasing up foundations, to see what's really going up. And of course, sometimes you end up with the wrong model (or a limited one). Unfortunately, most subjects don't seem to be taught in terms of understanding - but I've had some rare lecturers and textbooks that are so clear, you can work out what they'll say next, and solve example problems the first time you see them. I've always thought this understanding-oriented approach is a strong long-term strategy, as I age. Although it means some subjects are too hard for me - like human languages, history, geography, biology, medicine... and enterprise application development (but I'm good at libraries).
- _e 9y agoI think most people are in the same boat as you in terms of learning. I think "bluffing your way" through classes or interviews only sets one up for failure later. Learning the basics might be boring but one will find trouble getting to the fun stuff without a strong foundation in the concept. You would really like the course, "Learning How to Learn" on Coursera [0]. The instructor wrote the book, "Mind for Numbers" [1] which is also great. The course and book teach a great framework for actually learning and comprehension. [0] https://www.coursera.org/learn/learning-how-to-learn https://www.coursera.org/learn/learning-how-to-learn [1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/039916524X/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/039916524X/
- jshelly 9y agoThanks for this, I thought I was the only person on the planet with this affliction/advantage.
- EternalData 9y agoSuper interesting reading -- thanks for this!