14 ms·
While this seems drastically unrealistic from the viewpoint of someone in the US, from a European point of view, I can totally see that electrics become very vi
by r00fus 9y ago
While this seems drastically unrealistic from the viewpoint of someone in the US, from a European point of view, I can totally see that electrics become very viable - take a look at the new cars from Citroen, Renault and Hyundai in terms of decent to serious range (200-300km+) and Europe seems more likely to push regulations than a Trump-administration US.
- gsnedders 9y agoHow many people drive more than 300km regularly? Even in the US, I doubt it's actually that many.
- r00fus 9y agoWell, the calculation I made is to put 150% of my highest most recent daily usage - i.e., commute + pickup kids + store + random errand. Combined with wear/tear range reduction, I add a buffer of 50% so reduce advertise range by 1/3 for "usable range". So 200km*1/3 is somewhere around my comfortable range. That might be higher for other folks...
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoA car that gets 250 km on the European NEDC test cycl will only get 150 km when driving at leisurely highway speeds with AC loaded (for example Nissan admits to this on their very own website for the Leaf); and even less than that at actual motorway speeds. But it's all right. I mean, just for road safety you should take a 30 min break after every hour on motorway unless you're some sort of superhuman. Who could argue it's not a perfectly decent range for travelling? (edited for clarity) And you can spend that time just thinking where to invest all the money you save from oil changes.
- greglindahl 9y agoI don't think you'll see anyone saying that a car with 150km of actual highway range is good for long-distance trips. Which is why a bunch of carmakers are building or planning cars with much longer ranges, similar to Teslas, which are fine for road-tripping.
- KirinDave 9y agoYeah uh, you don't lose 40% of your range on the AC even in a Leaf.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoOf course not, nor did I claim that. However, driving at highway speeds contributes the other part and these figures are pulled straight from Nissan's own web page. (The exact figures are: driving at highway averaging 88 km/h with outside temperature 30 degrees Celsius and using AC – cabin temp is not told – would give you a range of 152 km. Rated at 250 km NEDC.) Driving at highway speeds obviously isn't a big part of NEDC rating for EVs.
- greglindahl 9y agoThat's why nobody claims NEDC rating is useful for highway trips. You first replied to gsnedders, and I don't think he was talking about a NEDC rating, he appeared to be talking about an actual range.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoMaybe. I don't know. NEDC rating is what you can sort of get in slow city driving, and city driving is what a car with that sort of range is made for.
- greglindahl 9y agoWe were talking about cars with 200km-300km of actual range... the whole point of the discussion is that newer electric cars have significantly improved range compared to the previous generation.
- KirinDave 9y agoI think Nissan's being a bit conservative there. But I deliberately avoided the Leaf because it's such a first gen car. The Leaf is much worse off than the Bolt or even a 500e when it comes to this. My bolt, I've worked out it is about a 7% range loss using A/C on those hot MtV 280 commutes. I've driven to Watsonville then back to SF in one day and been comfortably in my range in a Bolt. So... it's getting good very fast. I really do like my car.
- linkregister 9y ago> What do you think: do inconvenient facts go away with a down vote? Whining about internet points is annoying. I agree that a Leaf isn't practical for longer trips. EV viability will improve with easier access to rental cars for longer trips. Zipcar doesn't have the coverage necessary to do this in most cities. Maybe Getaround will improve to the point where it's practical. I consider most EVs to be equivalent to being 100% reliant on public transit; good for commutes, but unacceptable for recreation. And that's okay.
- cr0sh 9y ago> I mean, just for road safety you should take a 30 min break after every hour on motorway unless you're some sort of superhuman. No need for being a "superhuman". All you need is plenty of Mountain Dew, a gas station burrito, a few No-Doz, the window rolled down and the music turned up! The miles just fly by. I've easily done 10 hour, 800 mile trips only stopping for gas once or twice. I'll grant that was in the past when I was younger, but even today two or three hours at a stretch would be no problem (heck, just to drive from here in Phoenix to Tuscon would take that long - why stop?). > And you can spend that time just thinking where to invest all the money you save from oil changes. I do my own oil changes, and maybe spend a grand total of a few hundred dollars a year doing them. Honestly, I probably spend more on fast food per year (now that is really something I would love to drop - if only it wasn't so tasty at times).
- mahyarm 9y agoIt's about round trips in large cities. For example, if I want to drive from san jose to sf and then come back that is about 220km in one day for 2 hours on the highway.
- KirinDave 9y agoI drive SF to SJ on the reg in a Bolt. With a 220 charger I recover charge overnight. My other commute is SF to Mountain View, I can recover that at night with a standard outlet set to 12A mode. That's well within the range of most electric vehicles on the market.
- irrational 9y agoWhat is regularly? We probably take 2 road trips of 3500km a year, probably 4 trips of 1000km a year, and probably 10 trips of 350km a year. In the Western US things are very spread out. We live in a city of nearly 3 million people, but the next three closest cities of comparable or larger size are 300km, 700km, and 1000 km away. And if your wondering why we don't fly, it's because we have 7 children so it's cheaper to drive.
- gsnedders 9y ago> What is regularly? That's really the relevant point here: at what point do the savings of an electric car make it such that renting another car for the longer trips still ends up with that coming out on top? There's definitely a long tail of people who drive further regularly for whom electric cars won't be so practical.
- jcranmer 9y agoI think nothing of a 250km one-way jaunt--to go to supper with family on Easter. On average, every other month, I either make that trip or a 1000km one-way trip. When I was younger and did a lot of camping, a 300km jaunt (again, one-way) for a monthly camping trip was typical. 300km is a bit much for a commute (I've only had a 50km one-way commute personally, although I do know a few people with 100km commutes), but it's not really that far for a trip you might take on a 3-day weekend to the beach or the mountains. The US really is that large: I might describe myself as living "close" to Chicago since it's the closest city that most people stand a chance of putting on a map, but it's basically as far away as Brussels is from Paris.
- Johnny555 9y agoMy wife and I have a small hybrid commuter car (we'd probably have an EV if we could reasonably install a charger at our Condo). When we go on a significant trip, we generally rent a bigger car or minivan for a more comfortable trip. We get the advantage of an easy to park and fuel efficient car for the daily commute, but also can take advantage of a larger car for the big trips.
- netcan 9y agoThe way we regulate in a lot of Europe, may hit some issues as more electrics go on the road. Petrol taxes are a pretty important revenue source. Exempting electrics from that (by default) and all the other taxes help make them viable will eventually result in a meaningful revenue loss. It's also problematic to selectively benefit people who buy new cars and can afford to pay more upfront but less in running costs. We'll have to tax them eventually.
- omegaworks 9y agoDisposal costs will likely be higher for electric cars. Huge battery packs with lots of lead-acid and/or lithium inside. Seems like a good externalized cost to target.
- abraae 9y agoLead-acid batteries are the poster boys of recycling.
- douche 9y agoTrue. Almost every bullet that is produced today is made from recycled car batteries.
- pi-rat 9y agoCells from EVs will likely be downcycled for use as stationary storage (think Tesla's Powerwall and similar). Often only a couple of cells go bad in a pack, so they are easy to repurpose. In Norway some of the larger charging sites have huge stationary batteries as buffers (evens out spikes and act as phase balancing). You can recycle 100% of the lithium in a li-ion battery, but atm it's more costly to recycle than just mine the stuff - hopefully this will change in the near future.
- _pmf_ 9y ago> Cells from EVs will likely be downcycled for use as stationary storage (think Tesla's Powerwall and similar). Highly unlikely due to liability reasons. Remember the Galaxy 8? QC for batteries is demanding; QC for refurbished batteries is impossible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KirinDave 9y agoI have an electric car in the US and a 60+mi/day commute. My new electric car is so so so much cheaper to operate. It's actually below half the cost of using my older but still quite efficient Prius. It'll still take time for me to see savings over a car in the $20-$30k range. But in terms of daily operating costs for equivalent priced cars I'm there. Gas prices can only go up and electrical storage is on a downward trend.
- Aloha 9y agoYou must own a home? I live in a place that prides itself on being 'green' - but at-home charging stations for apartment dwellers are just a not-thing.
- greglindahl 9y agoSome parts of the bay area require new construction of homes and apartments to put in chargers, some apartment complexes have them, and there are a few chargers on the street and in public garages. It's all headed in the right direction.
- CalRobert 9y agoRequiring new apartments to have chargers is the wrong direction if you consider that it just increases costs for people who don't own automobiles (in my building of seven apartments one person owns a vehicle). Electric cars have a lot of advantages but they still have enormous negative externalities on cities.
- kalleboo 9y agoI'd be happy to pay a premium in cities if it meant all the cars were electric so the air was that much cleaner, even though I don't have a car of my own.
- CalRobert 9y agoSure, but is that a reason to force everyone else to do the same? The easier you make it to use a car in a dense place, the more people will do so, and the more people who walk and cycle will die.
- stcredzero 9y agoWhile this seems drastically unrealistic from the viewpoint of someone in the US... What!? So many people in the US live in urban environments where getting an oil change and emissions tested is yet another errand and yet another expense. Your "fuel" costs basically get halved. Factor in the time you save by never having to run the myriad errands required of petrol car owners, and if you want to have a shiny, great looking, fun to drive new model car, you're already out ahead! With the subsidy, it's been like that for years, and with the pace of improvements in battery tech and economies of scale, it will also be true without the subsidy.
- douche 9y agoGetting a state inspection and oil change costs about $50, once a year - if you're actually urban, you might not rack up 5k miles in a year, and could get by on a single oil change. Especially if you shelled out a little more for the newer, high-mileage motor oils. I don't know what this myriad of errands you speak of are...
- ryanmarsh 9y agoIf EV's are at least as reliable as Toyotas that's a lot of expensive errands avoided relative to your average American car. GMs and Fords spend a lot more time in the shop/parking lot of AutoZone.
- pixl97 9y ago>and oil change costs about $50, once a year - if you're actually urban, you might not rack up 5k miles in a year, and could get by on a single oil change Um, that's a really bad idea. Even if you are using 5k rated oil, you should get your oil changed every 2.5k or so if you are always in city driving. Why is that? Severe conditions. Pretty much every oil bottle and car manual says change your oil more often in "Severe conditions". Of course most people think of severe as stomping on the gas and going 100mph, or driving in mud and deep water, or something else just as crazy. Of course that's only part of what your manufacturer calls severe, this is also called severe conditions * Driving repeated short distances. * For extended periods of idling or low speed operation. * More than 50% of driving in heavy city traffic in temperatures above 90°F. * If using brakes extensively.
- xbmcuser 9y agoBattery capacity is also improving as well as the speed of charging. So a 350-400 mile battery that can be charged in 5-10min would be good enough for 99% of use. The way the market works though lets say 30% of the cars changed to electricity. Now some gas stations will be unprofitable so would change to charging stations or close down. It would become more inconvenient to find a gas station to fill up so more people would shift to electric as that is good enough for their daily use. The cycle would just accelerate the demise of the gas car I expect 2030 electric won't just be cheaper but more than 70-80% of the vehicles on the road. This does not take into account AI or self driving cars as if that happens majority of car owners would be corporations like Uber/Lift that would look at long term costs not upfront costs. Where repair and service cost savings some electric cars are already going to be cheaper in the next 2-3 years let alone by 2030.
- maxerickson 9y ago200 miles in 5 minutes would be fine for most uses. About 5 minutes per 3 to 4 hours of driving. 25 extra minutes on a 1000 mile trip. (Tesla seems to be at about 45-60 minutes for 200 miles with their Superchargers...)
- greglindahl 9y agoTeslas generally don't charge to 100% at a supercharger -- it's much faster to charge lower and more frequently.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah, I compared a 200 mile charge (I think estimating generously for Tesla), not a full charge.
- greglindahl 9y agoTesla owners usually stop more often than every 200 miles, in order to minimize charging time.
- 9y ago
- throwaway91111 9y agoWell, it's viable for cheap electric cars in the US now. Consumption—particularly outside of metropolitan areas—is another question altogether.