18 ms·
Electric Cars Soon Will Cost Less Than Gas Cars, Research Suggests
- eltoozero 9y agoI couldn't buy a Telsa for the total spent for my '03 Camry, currently pushing 380K miles, including fuel costs. In the 12 years I've had it I've put on 350,000 miles. Even at a conservative 25 mpg and a generous average fuel cost of $3 that's: $15,000 in car. $42,000 in gas. This excludes maintenance etc, but I fail to see how I'm saving money buying an electric car unless I'm already rocking solar. Maybe it's cheaper by the mile but my assumption is any fuel savings will be quickly erased in additional insurance costs.
- netcan 9y agoYou're a different market segment. They're not planning on selling cars to people working on their 400,000th kilometer. No carmaker is. They all sell cars to people who buy new cars, preferably every couple of years. If they succeed (and the cars can last as long as a well loved Camry or Hilux) You may be able to acquire a second hand one to your liking in a few years.
- linkregister 9y agoCustomers care about resale value when they're upgrading their new car; wouldn't manufacturers compete on this? Correct me if I'm wrong: cars' longevity is increasing. Doesn't this indicate an engineering push toward longevity?
- peter303 9y agoDepreciation, insurance, gasoline and maintenace have each been about a quarter of the cost of my small japanese car over 15 years. I keep a detailed spreadsheet.
- mandude 9y agoIt sounds like you bought it used? While I'm unsure of a Tesla's longevity, it looks like you could buy a used Tesla for $35k these days. Which is cheaper than your $15k + $42k. No gas -- but I'm not sure how much it would cost per kilowatt hour. Now if you were to get a Tesla $35k and install a solar roof for $10k then you're looking at $45k and a renewable energy system, taking power out of the oil companies' hands and actually cheaper than the $57k... and that would be "free" power indefinitely -- way cheaper than the fact that you will have to continue to put oil and gas in your car. Speaking of which, did you factor in the oil change costs? Assuming $30 an oil change, you're looking at $12k in oil changes. That's now $69k for your Camry. Plus, the Tesla looks cooler and has faster acceleration than your Camry.
- IanCal 9y ago> Assuming $30 an oil change, you're looking at $12k in oil changes. Do you change oil every 1000 miles?
- pwinnski 9y agoEvery 875 miles, by my math!
- dangrossman 9y ago> Assuming $30 an oil change, you're looking at $12k in oil changes If you change the oil every 5000 miles as suggested by Toyota, 350K miles is 70 oil changes, or $2100 not $12000.
- elihu 9y ago> [New] research from Bloomberg New Energy Finance indicates that falling battery costs will mean electric vehicles will also be cheaper to buy in the U.S. and Europe as soon as 2025. The article isn't predicting that we'll soon all be driving a Tesla Model S or claiming that electric cars are price competitive right now. There aren't a lot of cheap electric car options right now, but the situation is improving. The Chevy Bolt is available now, and the Model 3 should be out in a few months or so. They're still more expensive than I would care to spend on a car, but eventually as costs come down, it's not unreasonable to expect electrics will show up in lower cost vehicles. I'm kind of hoping someone puts out a well-engineered low-cost electric without any of the self-driving or always-on-phone-home-wireless-connectivity stuff, or any other features that aren't absolutely required. No infotainment, just an FM radio and window cranks. Maybe not even AC or power steering. Just a simple small car, kind of like the VW beetle was in the 1960s.
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoPresumably a 15K Camry is a used one (New ones start at 23K) so it would make compare also compare to a used Tesla. Used Model S' can be bought for as little as 40-46K, depending on where you buy[1]. Assuming electricity costs ~1/3 for the same distance as gas, then the used Tesla starts to make some sense, even when compared to the Camry (While being a much nicer car to drive). [1] https://www.tesla.com/preowned?sort=price%7Casc https://www.tesla.com/preowned?sort=price%7Casc https://www.truecar.com/used-cars-for-sale/listings/tesla/?sortOrder=PRICE_ASC https://www.truecar.com/used-cars-for-sale/listings/tesla/?s...
- eltoozero 9y agoCamry was purchased for 15K used w/ 30K miles in 2005; the new car market is for suckers.
- KirinDave 9y agoMy Bolt cost only slightly more to insure than my Prius. It cost about $45k USD and while small for a car in that price range, fares favorably in terms of comfort and feature. So yeah, a $15k 2003 Camry used exclusively for long haul trips in sequence isn't approachable by EVs yet. But if you compared it to a Fiat 500e that's been used and refurbed (selling in my county for about $13k) and you're NOT constantly doing 280mi trips... you'll find something competitive.
- eltoozero 9y agoIt's not even a range question, it's basic economics of utility vs cost. In this case miles to the dollar. Not to mention the rich aftermarket for dinosaur fueled vehicles, I wouldn't want to break DRM on my car and lose my warranty or worse.
- KirinDave 9y agoA used Fiat 500e was selling for $12000 pre-tax last year when I was shopping. That's pretty damn competitive to other cars in the age range. Yes, a 2004 Camry exists but I'm happy to pay slightly more to radically drop my carbon output.
- jaclaz 9y agoI would like to introduce another factor. When you buy a Tesla you pay upfront the whole price (yes I know you can have some financing and re-pay it monthly) no matter how many miles you put on it, with the gas you pay as you go, i.e. the costs are directly connected to the use you make of it. It is the same thing (I use to have this argument often) with "green" (energy saving) houses, once you strip from the equation "moral" or "ethical" considerations (lowering the carbon footprint, etc.) the fact is that you have to pay upfront a large sum of money that may (if the house is actually used) be repaid/compensated by the savings over the next 10/15/20 years, in the meantime you will have to pay (anyway) the utilities fixed fees (and rest assured that those will continue to raise).
- megablast 9y agoI guess you just don't care about all the pollution you are pouring into the atmosphere.
- jepler 9y ago.. in part due to assuming that the price of the internal combustion engine is "going to go up as a result of more stringent regulations especially regarding to particulate regulations", but also assuming that the battery (A) accounts for 50% of the sticker price today and (B) will drop by 77% by 2025. I wouldn't bet on these being the case (particularly on there being effective regulation in the US)
- pixl97 9y ago> but also assuming that the battery (A) accounts for 50% of the sticker price today and (B) will drop by 77% by 2025. With the number of battery factories being built around the world I wouldn't discount it. Tesla, Daimler, and Panasonic, I wouldn't be surprised if there were other too.
- epistasis 9y agoAll the evidence points to batteries dropping a huge amount in the coming decade. What are you willing to bet? Edit: somewhat minor, but you seem to be misquoting, they actually say: >their prices will fall by about 77% between 2016 and 2030, the London-based researcher said. Wich is a 14 year time span, instead of the 8 year time span from now until 2025
- Hasz 9y agoEven with mass production, the chemistry does not change. Limited Co supplies and a decreasing, but still present need for rare earths will only prop up prices. Add to that new and exotic electrolytes and improved anode coatings, and it'll be a wonder if prices come down at all.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe existing battery packs have (vaguely) reasonable performance characteristics, I wouldn't think that manufacturers would adopt things that increase costs more than they increase performance. (In fact I would expect them to mostly adopt things that cut costs without sacrificing performance)
- olivermarks 9y ago...'will be cheaper to buy in the U.S. and Europe as soon as 2025'...is the sub head. The article makes a number of assumptions to reach this conclusion
- epistasis 9y agoHow would one prognosticate about the future without making assumptions?
- gravypod 9y agoThe parent is saying that these assumptions will be incorrect in other parts of the world. If you limit the statement in the title to US/EU then it becomes a more reasonable claim.
- jasonlotito 9y agoThat's literally what the article is claiming though. If you limit the statement to just the title here, it's not an article, it's just a headline, and headlines are not there to tell you the entire story.
- gravypod 9y agoThe title implies that the cars are actually getting cheaper, not that social costs are being externalized into this market. The suggestion to change the title is valid. It's not the cars that are getting cheaper, it's the laws that are getting more expensive. That has nothing to do with the efficiency of the production or operation of EVs. It has everything to do with social policy surrounding the use of fossil fuels.
- epistasis 9y ago>It's not the cars that are getting cheaper, it's the laws that are getting more expensive Not quite, it is the case that electric cars are getting cheaper, and that analysts expect them to continue getting cheaper. From the article: >“One is EV technology cost reductions because there are more breakthroughs in the cost of technology and more volume, so the cost of EVs will go down. ICE going to go up as a result of more stringent regulations especially regarding to particulate regulations.”
- r00fus 9y agoWhile this seems drastically unrealistic from the viewpoint of someone in the US, from a European point of view, I can totally see that electrics become very viable - take a look at the new cars from Citroen, Renault and Hyundai in terms of decent to serious range (200-300km+) and Europe seems more likely to push regulations than a Trump-administration US.
- gsnedders 9y agoHow many people drive more than 300km regularly? Even in the US, I doubt it's actually that many.
- r00fus 9y agoWell, the calculation I made is to put 150% of my highest most recent daily usage - i.e., commute + pickup kids + store + random errand. Combined with wear/tear range reduction, I add a buffer of 50% so reduce advertise range by 1/3 for "usable range". So 200km*1/3 is somewhere around my comfortable range. That might be higher for other folks...
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoA car that gets 250 km on the European NEDC test cycl will only get 150 km when driving at leisurely highway speeds with AC loaded (for example Nissan admits to this on their very own website for the Leaf); and even less than that at actual motorway speeds. But it's all right. I mean, just for road safety you should take a 30 min break after every hour on motorway unless you're some sort of superhuman. Who could argue it's not a perfectly decent range for travelling? (edited for clarity) And you can spend that time just thinking where to invest all the money you save from oil changes.
- greglindahl 9y agoI don't think you'll see anyone saying that a car with 150km of actual highway range is good for long-distance trips. Which is why a bunch of carmakers are building or planning cars with much longer ranges, similar to Teslas, which are fine for road-tripping.
- olivermarks 9y ago'electric cars aren’t going to take over' there seem to be endless articles on line pro and con electric vehicles http://www.businessinsider.com/why-morgan-stanley-wrong-about-electric-cars-2017-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/why-morgan-stanley-wrong-abou...
- mandude 9y agoFor now. In 5-10 years the debate will be "why do we have gas cars at all now that electric cars are all faster, drive farther, don't pollute, and are solar powered." In my opinion, not having to deal with oil spills and carbon emissions will certainly win out in the long run.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoEven if electric car range passes gas powered in 10 years, it is really the refuel vs recharge time that needs work. Range is already good enough for a majority of use cases.
- greglindahl 9y agoMost EV owners recharge overnight for day-to-day driving, so refueling time is zero. Were you referring to long-distance travel?
- sideshowb 9y agoPrivate cars only account for a small slice of oil demand, so I'm afraid oil spills will still be a thing. The co2 savings are worthwhile though.
- linkregister 9y agoGasoline (petrol) is the primary portion of oil use (about 40%) in the U.S. [1] I don't know what portion of that is passenger cars, but it's probably substantial. 1. https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/index.cfm?page=oil_use https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/index.cfm?page=oil_use
- guscost 9y ago⃰Unfortunately, still only after factoring in regulations.
- KirinDave 9y agoThe dual of this for gas cars is, "Unfortunately, still holding gas prices at their current lows and ignoring any supply issues."
- guscost 9y agoAt first I was just upset seeing another piece of speculative PR, I guess, so I had to make a salty comment. Of course your example is true too.
- theprop 9y ago1. Gigantic longevity. Electric Vehicles will likely run 1 million miles or more without requiring any significant repairs except a net battery pack. Internal combustion engines develop all kinds of problems related to burning petroleum for energy. 2. No gas charges. For the $35k Tesla, if you get an invite from a current Tesla owner, you can get $1k off and a free lifetime supercharger usage. Supposing you always use a super-charger and had no gas charges, on 200k miles you just saved $25k in gas charges...so your Tesla's net cost came in under $10k!! And it's probably still got a long life ahead of it so would have far more resale value than an internal combustion vehicle with similar mileage. So it makes a lot of sense for everyone really to buy a Tesla :-D! That said if electric vehicles do last far longer than traditional vehicles you could reduce car sales by as much as 75%+...if you add in another trend of transportation-as-a-service via on-demand vehicles (e.g. Uber), that could reduce car sales by a similar amount. Both combined could decimate the current car industry as we know it which has a lot of impacts on inputs e.g. mining for metals, etc. which go into car manufacturing. It does make the world a lot more efficient. If you look around the US, all you see are parking lots and cars everywhere sitting around (for like 97% of their life).
- dangrossman 9y ago1. Lots of things on cars wear out over the years other than the engine/emission system. Some of the most expensive common car repairs are water pumps, AC compressors, brake lines, suspension parts, wheel bearings and brake parts, etc. EVs have all of those things, and they suffer no less wear-and-tear than ICEs. Even a full transmission or engine costs far less than replacing the battery in an EV, too. 2. The referral program is only for the Model S and Model X, which start at $70K. There is no discount and no free charging with the $35K Model 3.
- linkregister 9y agoDo EVs have water pumps?
- dangrossman 9y agoYes. EVs have liquid cooled chargers/inverters, motors, and usually batteries (the Nissan Leaf being the main exception to that). That means they have coolant tanks and water pumps to move the coolant just like an ICE.
- Angostura 9y agoI'd love one. Unfortunately, I - and quite a few like me in large cities in the UK only have on-street parking, so no way to charge at home. Once some of the large supermarkets start offering charging in a large proportion of their parking spaces, it'll get more interesting.
- pi-rat 9y agoWe're slowly but surely getting there in Norway. Most supermarkets offer free charging, and fast chargers are being put up all over the mayor cities ( ex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k73-rYe82lI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k73-rYe82lI ). Some parking spaces have 100s of chargers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktNKWLwjQJM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktNKWLwjQJM It's totally feasible to own an EV without home charging in Norway now, especially if you get one of the longer range ones like Opel Ampera-e (/ Bolt).
- appleiigs 9y ago> “On an upfront basis, these things will start to get cheaper and people will start to adopt them more as price parity gets closer,” said Colin McKerracher, analyst at the London-based researcher. “After that it gets even more compelling.” "Research" needs to include repairs for accidents (even though I've never been in an accident in my own cars). Because I'm OK with the upfront basis, but definitely not OK with the after. I've seen many articles regarding rare parts and long repair times with Tesla. I've put in $5K of repairs in past 2 years for my aging gas car... about 10% of what I plan to spend on my next car, so repairs are a big deal and even more so when (not if) I get into an accident.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoThe premise turns on the batteries: They are still expensive and need replacing every 7-10 years. If you're modeling the cost of ownership, you should be factoring in a new battery pack after 10 years. (Message to ye who covet 1,000,000 miles) Therefore, the rate of adoption will be somewhat modulated by the ecosystem of lithium ion materials and production. It's obvious Tesla sees this as a crux since they are investing billions in battery production. Li ion Battery cost per KWh has already been falling at about -14% annualized over the last 10 years [0]. However, mass adoption of EV autos changes the demand side considerably and we therefore cannot assume the same rate of decline as we have seen recently. Perhaps we will, given the ramping production, but if they don't move more or less in step, prices could be somewhat stubborn. [0] https://cleantechnica.com/2015/03/26/ev-battery-costs-already-probably-cheaper-than-2020-projections/ https://cleantechnica.com/2015/03/26/ev-battery-costs-alread...
- epistasis 9y agoIt could go either way, honestly. Solar has shown that as production is vastly overbuilt, prices plummet and a lot of people go out of business because they were assuming higher prices than they were able to charge. It seems likely that lithium ion battery production is going to face a similar fate. Tons of people interested in the space, enticed by a market that's set to explode in size.
- greglindahl 9y agoNote that solar production, or dram production, or flash memory production generally doesn't go down during the shakeouts. It does cause fluctuations in dram and flash memory prices.
- hwillis 9y agoTeslas have been showing around ~8% degradation at 100k miles. Battery degradation drops fastest at the beginning, so it would be unsurprising for the batteries to still have 80%+ capacity at 250,000 miles. That's quite good. https://electrek.co/2016/06/06/tesla-model-s-battery-pack-data-degradation/ https://electrek.co/2016/06/06/tesla-model-s-battery-pack-da...
- clock_tower 9y agoThis wouldn't surprise me, although manufacturing lithium batteries is still a bit complex. The railroads already use all-electric drivetrains; short-range locomotives carry batteries only, while long-haul ones use diesel to generate electricity and power the drivetrain. The big advantage of an electric drivetrain is regenerative braking, which is just as useful in cars (think of the Prius and its remarkable mileage) as in trains. Over the medium term, I'd expect to see a car market that looks a bit like the train market: all-electric cars for city driving, plus hybrids for traveling in the country or in underdeveloped areas. Fossil fuels will probably never go away entirely (certainly the military will always need them), but oil is good for things other than fuel; 100 years from now, I expect electric cars will be the usual option while gasoline-burning hybrids are an expensive curiosity. (Or we might move to a mix of electricity and hydrogen fuel cells; Toyota's betting on this, since natural-gas refining releases waste hydrogen. Safe containment of hydrogen is harder than safe containment of gasoline, though...)
- monk_e_boy 9y agoWe still have the occasional steam powered traction engine go past our house. We live on a very steep hill, so there is a lot of stoking to get up pressure before they attempt it. I'd say we see them 2 or 3 times a year. Really cool beasts.
- NegativeLatency 9y agoI'd love to see a video of that
- monk_e_boy 9y agoI never thought to video them. There are rallies every year in our local town where 20 or so get together and drive around. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gbs5BfpbAH4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gbs5BfpbAH4 My father-in-law is a conductor on a local steam engine. My SO got to drive it -- the lucky lady :)
- 9y ago
- rjdagost 9y agoThis projection that electric cars will soon become cheaper than gas cars assumes an exponential decay in cost. All exponential trends ultimately cease due to some physical limiting factor. We're seeing Moore's law sputter to a halt because it is getting more expensive (and not less) to make smaller features on microprocessors- semiconductor manufacturing processes are just not scaling the way they have for decades. Nevertheless Moore's law was a truly exceptional exponential ramp unrivaled in the history of technology. Does battery manufacturing have the same advantages that will allow for a tremendous long-term exponential ramp analogous to Moore's law? I am wondering how long it will take for battery technology to "hit the wall". Hopefully batteries will become significantly cheaper, safer, and faster to charge but I am skeptical that we will be able to ride this exponential curve for anywhere near as long as we've benefited from Moore's law. I hope I am wrong.
- madengr 9y agoThough I don't think it needs to drop exponentially. Take any of the new EV (Leaf, Bolt, Model 3) that are $35k and drop the price by 2/3, keep the 200 mile range, and ICE car sales will die fast. ICE car prices are not dropping. EV only need to drop below ICE, not a continuous Moore's law. I bought a used 2015 Leaf recently for $8500. Yes, it's only 80 mile range, but that gets me to work for two days without charging. It's nearly free to drive; $0.02/mile energy costs, or nothing if I charge for free at local charge stations.
- WorldMaker 9y agoThere's the flipside to consider too: ICE car prices are as low as they are today because of huge efficiencies of scale in existing engine supply chains and also a large inventory of used cars. Used car inventory is something that will market align over time. Engine supply chain disruptions are hard to predict, but can snowball quickly.
- grandalf 9y agoI've made this point before and people are always skeptical. Consider how many fewer moving parts an electric car has. It's like the difference between solid state electronics and vacuum tube electronics.
- MarkMc 9y agoOr difference between VHS casette player and DVD player.
- gens 9y agoTangents: Vacuum tubes can work a very long time without breaking, if they are never turned off. Wankel engines have less moving parts then piston engines and can last longer because of it. Problem with Wankel engines is that they need heat and a good seal to be efficient. Stirling engines could, in theory, be superior to bout piston and Wankel engines, in efficiency and lifespan. [0] Fuel cells used to power electrical engines is yet another alternative that combines the high energy density of liquid fuel with robustness of very few moving parts. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H_Vnxapd5fs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H_Vnxapd5fs
- pfooti 9y agoOne thing I'm surprised about is the way Gogoro scooters are being rolled out and sold. The model 2 has a retail price of below $2,000 and is pretty much ideal as a city commute scooter. But they're not selling them for individual use, only in cities where they have their battery exchange charger stations set up. So I have to wonder: what kind of loss-leader is the cheap gogoro 2 scooter? Because I guarantee I would buy one (and a charging station that let me trickle-charge one set of batteries while I ride around on the other) if they were for sale. I have a 10 year old vespa that I love, but is starting to get long enough in the tooth that I'm considering a replacement. But they're not going to be sold in san francisco (or pretty much anywhere else in the US unless you're really optimistic), because they want to have a citywide network of single-use battery exchange stations. By single-use, I mean: only good for this one product. With gasoline, you can fuel anything, but they are basically angling for a whole-city distribution of a single thing: battery packs just for a scooter. This strikes me as a pretty bad model, which circles me back to the start. I wonder how much the scooter actually costs, if they're willing to leave this much market on the table for individual bike / charger sales. I suppose it could also be NTSB certification holding them up too. https://www.gogoro.com/ https://www.gogoro.com/