14 ms·
As Computer Coding Classes Swell, So Does Cheating
- zootam 9y agocheating at harvard?? impossible!
- jboogie77 9y agoThis should be obvious to any person who tutors people online. If you check out sites like https://schoolsolver.com https://schoolsolver.com or https://chegg.com https://chegg.com they have become havens for programming questions. One could make the argument that it's partly the teachers fault for reusing old programming assignments. On the other hand, especially on something like school solver, there are plenty of programmers, living in 3rd world countries, willing to do original complex programming assignments for a paltry amount of money.
- rhodysurf 9y agoThey were havens for traditional engineering questions when I was in college too (Dynamics, Statics, Fluids, etc). Every homework question we had seemed to be available online somewhere and it let to kids simply copying answers instead of simply learning the same material they were copying. It got so bad the whole MechEng dept at my school got rid of homework in favor of problem sets that were solved in a given classroom, at a given time, with a TA supervising. I can only imagine it is much worse now.
- colechristensen 9y agoMy favorite class which I think I learned the best in, homework was given with answers and partial solutions. It was still graded, but more for "did you do stuff" and "this is what/where you did wrong". It made homework not a test of how clever you were or how resourceful you were ... "collaborating" with your peers. It made it about solving problems with instant feedback. Waiting two weeks between doing a problem is a lot less helpful.
- rhodysurf 9y agoI agree. Thats how all of my upper level classes were taught once everything got a bit more specific and trustworthy.
- bigger_cheese 9y agoWhen I was studying eng problem sets like this were the norm for courses like statics, fluid dynamics, thermo etc. They were considered optional and you usually collaborated on them in groups - university even encouraged it by helping to advertise/organize study groups. Mostly you'd sit in group everyone would work on problems independently then "What did you get for problem 3?" "100 kPa" "Yeah that's what I got." No different from looking up answer in back of textbook. Our assignments in these classes (i.e what counted towards your grade) was usually based off of lab reports i.e. I remember for thermo we had to play around with heat exchangers in various configurations and then compute their efficiency based on measurements we took.
- rhodysurf 9y agoThat is what they changed the weekly problem sets to be... except not optional and graded before you left the session. It was a much better system, at least for me.
- Apocryphon 9y ago> It got so bad the whole MechEng dept at my school got rid of homework in favor of problem sets that were solved in a given classroom, at a given time, with a TA supervising. Sounds like the Khan Academy format. Which is probably a better way for everyone to learn, to be honest. Why spend hours going down the wrong rabbit hole only to get the wrong answer anyway? Might as well have a TA around to help guide your approach.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoWhat's with the obsession with student assessment over student learning? At the end of the day the student has to perform, and there are plenty of opportunities to build up a network of people that will assert you know your stuff. Why is it that grades are still a thing at this level?
- johnfn 9y agoSaves time. It's a lot easier to determine if you are capable from "my GPA is x" rather than having someone sit down and write code for a few hours and doing a code review.
- taurath 9y agoEveryone does code review or whiteboards now in industry at least - it's not as if you're offered a residency or job after you get a degree unless it's a pretty good degree with some actual interviewing.
- srdeveng 9y agoMy engineering courses were filled with cheaters. Fortunately, these become apparent in the workplace and filter out in the first few years. Any major with promise of wealth will have those who will resort to ill means to get ahead in the system. Again, fortunately, many are weeded out in later stages.
- adamnemecek 9y agoYou are assuming the system is perfect. > Again, fortunately, many are weeded out in later stages. Why do you care?
- Jill_the_Pill 9y agoI care if engineers fake the learning required for their degrees because I don't want to cross bridges that collapse, take airplanes that crash, live next to leaky or explosive industrial facilities, or rely on faulty medical equipment. Engineering carries a lot of responsibility.
- srdeveng 9y ago> You are assuming the system is perfect. chose to use the word "many" to imply the current process is imperfect. > Why do you care? I'm a recipient of freshly graduating (and interning) engineers who got past the hiring committee. The project roadmap puts a burden on the other team members when one member is underperforming and/or not forthcoming with their abilities.
- xor1 9y ago>Fortunately, these become apparent in the workplace and filter out in the first few years. "Filter out" aka get promoted to management and earn more than they ever did as developers.
- thegayngler 9y agoWhich is why I think developers should be paid the same as managers. People actually building/creating/maintaining the product/service are at least as useful as people managers.
- parennoob 9y agoEDIT: My comment completely missed that there were 100 lines of identical code noticed as well. Leaving below for context. ------- Does anyone else find the example cited in the article rather flimsy? Out of 450, two students incorrectly used the inverse of a Boolean for a conditional – an error I have seen tens, if not hundreds of times. Perhaps they used better ways of detecting cheating (some are covered later in the article) for uncovering the collusion in this specific case. If not, this “veteran computer science professor” is going on unnecessary witch hunts.
- minimaxir 9y agoThe article implies that the cited instance of text is verbatim identical, which is unusual.
- rubatuga 9y agoYeah but the students confessed, and it turns out the professor/administration was right. What do you have to say about that?
- danso 9y agoThe two students also shared "nearly 100 identical lines of code". The `!done` was the icing on the cake.
- parennoob 9y agoGood point! I missed that and focused on the emphasized Boolean test, which is the first time I have seen any code in the NYTimes.
- danso 9y agoTrivia point: One of the co-authors of the piece, Jeremy Merrill, is a programmer-journalist at the Times (and previously at ProPublica); I imagine he helped with the code: https://www.propublica.org/nerds/item/upton-a-web-scraping-framework https://www.propublica.org/nerds/item/upton-a-web-scraping-f... http://jeremybmerrill.com/blog/2016/01/flyover.html http://jeremybmerrill.com/blog/2016/01/flyover.html http://jeremybmerrill.com/clips/2013/05/updating-dollars-for-docs/ http://jeremybmerrill.com/clips/2013/05/updating-dollars-for...
- robotic 9y agoThis reminds me of My last year at university. At our final senior project we each had to give a group presentation. I remember this one group that showed off this VB6 program (which was considered outdated language even then). They didn't know how to run the program without opening visual studio and clicking run. They didn't even have basic understanding of compilation/run phases. They couldn't answer basic questions about the code. Obvious to everyone they copied the code. Yet they still passed the class.
- paulcole 9y agoWith tuition what it is these days, kids aren't paying to be failed.
- flukus 9y agoI've worked with a tonne of people in the industry like this, particularly in MS land where something is "impossible" if Visual Studio can't do it. Often you'll end up with a million projects for namespacing because they don't know what a folder is. It's only going to get worse as we have a generation of kids that have only used tablets and don't know what an "exe" is, or even a file.
- UK-AL 9y agoI find that multiple projects are heavily used in Visual studio, because a lot tooling works better by splitting into projects instead. NCrunch is the example here. It's easier to enforce dependency rules. A domain model should not have any dependencies on a specific technology, the easiest to way to enforce that is a separate project, with no references.
- keerthiko 9y agoWhat they call "cheating" is how I do my job as a developer of a 3-person (dev) software company. We make software. People like it and use it. We make money. Who cares whether the code came from our head or from something publicly available on the internet, or from someone willing to help us? As long as it wasn't an actual violation of the law. There's no good reason to create a separate set of laws for the classroom than the real world. Can we just accept that this is how software is meant to be developed? Beyond the very intro level, the real assignments and challenges given to students should be about how to utilize, extend, integrate and optimize easily available existing code, not how to reinvent (regurgitate, rather) the wheel. This tests and improves understanding just as well as, if not better than making them implement from scratch. Evaluate the student's understanding and the quality of his output, not how independently they wrote the code.
- wyager 9y agoIf the structure of the class incorporates using real-world code, then fine. Most upper-division classes allow you to use any libraries you want anyway. But some classes, especially lower-division, are explicitly built around learning a concept from scratch. If you copy the code, you can't learn the concepts. I agree that teachers should strive to allow "open internet" assignments and tests as much as possible, but it's not always viable. All the best classes I've had were this way, but it's usually quite labor-intensive for the instructors.
- chrisper 9y ago>As long as it wasn't an actual violation of the law But it is a violation of Academic Integrity, which is sort of a law you agreed to when signing up for a class. At least at my school it was like that.
- stale2002 9y agoHe is saying that we should get rid of the law of Academic Integrity, and make classes more like the real world. It is an interesting idea, the problem being that in the real world, while you can kinda look up the answer, it is rare to find someone who is doing the exact same thing as what you need to do, for thousands of lines of code. Maybe college would better simulate the real world if you gave students personalized, large problems, that nobody has ever done before(instead of small, toy problems)?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- c0rruptbytes 9y agoanyone who relies on cheating never seems to do well during the harder major courses at my school (Texas). A lot of the professors have really rigorous cheating detections, and will make you explain every line of code in person if they suspect something. (At least in honor classes) Also, I don't know what these people expect when they have to do a technical interview?
- flukus 9y ago> Also, I don't know what these people expect when they have to do a technical interview? They probably don't know they exist, they're fairly unique to our industry. They probably expect interviews to be just like everywhere else, all smiles and dressing well, with generic "when have you been challenged in life" questions. A lot of them will get hired by big corporates that don't do code tests too, that's why even people with 10 years of experience have to do FizzBuzz.
- kurtisc 9y agoEvery form of engineering will have technical interviews. I imagine a lot of them use their degree as a ticket to a non-technical job.
- flukus 9y agoTechnical interviews or tests? A lot of Devs can talk the talk and still not handle FizzBuzz. Engineers have official tests to get their licence. As for those in college, it's entirely possible they don't realise the testing requirements either.
- glangdale 9y agoThis is hugely important as a lot of people see programming as a ticket into higher-end jobs and will spend as little time as individual contributors as they can. The idea that "oh, they'll get caught in the workforce" is not correct - quite often the plan in the mind of these folks is that they will try to fake their way through and be moved up into project management, technical marketing, etc. and never have their lack of these specific skills exposed again. In my experience these people are very dangerous, as their motivation to avoid being forced to try to do the thing they were actually hired to do is very strong. So they will have a mindbogglingly strong motivation towards office politics, manipulation of grievance mechanisms, etc. relative to someone who is 'distracted' by the prospect of, I dunno, doing the work that they are meant to do. I worked at a tutor at the University of Sydney in 1993, where a group of 7 students hired a professional programmer to sit the 'gatekeeper' practical exam. These exams could be retaken but you could not enter 2nd year CS without passing them regardless of your marks. They were caught (via handwriting analysis on the worksheets where you were required to show your notes, among other things!) and in some cases fought the university in court for years over this.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> The idea that "oh, they'll get caught in the workforce" is not correct - quite often the plan in the mind of these folks is that they will try to fake their way through and be moved up into project management, technical marketing, etc. and never have their lack of these specific skills exposed again. Even if they don't follow the Dilbert Principle path, it's not like there's a universal catalog of how skilled any given employee is; someone who can bullshit their way into a job and can last there for six months is still employable after they're let go when it's discovered that they don't know what a for loop is. Not everyone checks references.
- yulaow 9y agoPeople have no idea how many times in a interview (especially with big corps) I end up talking with a PM and he tells me "Yeah, I started here already as Project Architect after my cs degree. I really don't like coding or anything related so I never do it, I focus on architecture and guide the others". And then I mentally run away.
- NickGerleman 9y agoI've been a TA for a couple CS classes at Iowa State University. Cheating here at least is pretty rampant. I would guess 1/3 or more of the students cheat in some capacity. Some of it is really easy to detect too. For a first semester freshman class, I tried using MinHash to cluster student submissions together. Maybe 10% of the assignment have near duplicate pieces of code. More comprehensive methods like MOSS (Measure of Software Similarity) find much more. It's hard for professors to take time to deal with it. A professor more or less told me that the process to report it to the dean of students would take months of his time, and that he already spent 55 hours a week for his classes. He explained that the time it would take to go after the cheaters would detract from time to make good assignments, labs, and lectures for the students. It's hard to see a professor for a large class (500 people) having the time to deal with handling cheaters so the problem continues. I'm curious how common this is as a problem at other schools.
- wayn3 9y agoIn germany, what you call cheating isnt even considered cheating. On homework, we openly collaborated and handed in near duplicates without trying to hide it. Some students would just copy the work of others. None of this mattered. Nobody "went after" it. It just gets graded, you get your points and you move on. Most people accept the fact that grades don't matter, but you need them for your resume. For some reason, universities have moved on from being institutions of knowledge-production to being diploma mills, and grades are their way of succumbing to societies need to make shit measurable. The way we cope with this is to just hand out grades that are utterly meaningless, but keep the system alive. In the meantime, people carry on with their lives. Some people in university want to learn things, some are just enrolled because its a cheap livestyle choice. In the end, nobody cares about grades. Whether I actually know my stuff is my problem. Not my professors. No company hires you based on your grades, but a lot of HR personnel will reject you based on them. So you need good grades. But good grades alone wont get you shit. We live in this weird limbo of grades being a necessity but beyond that, dont mean shit. They are the shittiest heuristic known to man. If grades were a scientific theory, those who came up with them would be ostracized crackpots. Neither meaningful nor in any way falsifiable. A written exam on quantum field theory can only test so many things. Since its written, you have to ask for things that can be produced in a given timeframe. That leaves you with memoizable calculations. Any professor will tell you that such an exam will tell you nothing about whether the student actually understands the subject matter. A 2 minute discussion of the topic in very high level terms is probably more useful to assess actual aptitude. Professors KNOW that they cant possibly measure the ability of individuals in classes of more than 15 students. Why would they care about cheating? They are part of a system that doesnt make sense just as much as everyone else.
- KKKKkkkk1 9y agoWhy do those students even need to cheat? Harvard has a 97% graduation rate and Stanford 93%.
- zepto 9y agoHow do you think they got that?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- objclxt 9y agoI used to Head TA CS at Harvard (or "TF", to use their verbiage), so can answer this: the graduation rate is very high, but honors are capped (mainly because the honors rate was at one time out of control). Personally I never really cared for honors, but for many people it can be extremely important. Because honors are capped at a fixed percentage of the class relative to GPA this means it's vital to maximize your grades, hence the cheating. No joke - I used to get many e-mails from students after grades were released begging for us to bump them up.
- nebabyte 9y agoWhy not turn that to your advantage? Institute a policy wherein they are bumped down if they send an email and their reason for doing so does not fall within pregiven requirements (e.g. clerical error in recording a grade). An excellent prof at the non-Ivy I went to did this, and it was quite effective. Some small percent of your grade (significant enough to bump you if needed) was guaranteed unless you chose to try and create noise to get moved up.
- UK-AL 9y agoI think this creates a massive disincentive in order to ask why they didn't get the mark they want. For fear of being marked as a complainer. At the end of the day you are there provide guidance to get their skills and knowledge to place they want to be. Not to simply filter wheat from chaff.
- adamnemecek 9y agoNo one talks about the fact that current CS curricula are fundamentally flawed. Too much time is spent in class, and on homework and one is left with little time to do "real" work.
- minimaxir 9y agoDefine "real" work. There's a lot on HN about the dichotomy between "boot camps are enough for a software engineer job" and "you need to know computer science fundamentals to be a software engineer," but both teeter on the No True Scotsman fallacy. Granted, I do think that CS curricula should include actually implementing things in production.
- adamnemecek 9y agoThat should be left up to the student to define this.
- xor1 9y ago>Define "real" work. Things that generate profit. In 2017, that mostly means CRUD backends and mobile apps. Before you get upset with my definition, don't take it up with me, take it up with capitalism.
- apersona 9y agoWhat's "real" work?
- adamnemecek 9y agoWhatever you want it to be.
- openasocket 9y agoCare to expand? This isn't exactly a helpful answer
- 9y ago
- andy-wu 9y agoAt my university, most of the profs that teach our entry level programming courses use MOSS. One prof I had said that it's really good at detecting plagiarism and he automatically refers any infractions to SJA. I always work alone so I've never been caught, but looking at the grade sheets, it seemed like almost 25% of the students were referred every assignment. I can understand the desire to catch cheaters because as I've progressed into my more advanced classes there's always a few students that really shouldn't be there because they didn't learn anything in the prereq classes.
- conanbatt 9y ago> He also said that since students could use the regret clause, instructors felt more comfortable going to the honor council when students had passed up that chance. This is very interesting: the clause that apparently gives a way out to the student is never/seldom used, but it gives the teachers more confidence and easiness to report their students. Its a measure that literally just makes it harder on the students, even if it appears the opposite. Economics is truly magic.
- userbinator 9y agoI taught computing for a short time, and some of what went on between instructors and students was quite astonishing. In fact I'll go as far as saying that some instructors were complicit in the cheating, either by tacitly encouraging it or deliberately making the material easier or shorter/lowering grading standards to keep "student approval", and grades, high. I didn't --- I was pretty much the exact opposite --- but for every one who didn't, there was probably at least 2-3 others who did (and perhaps not so surprisingly, those were the student favourites.) Then it's no wonder that, on the other side, we see things like https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/
- ilaksh 9y agoIs cheating also a problem at coding bootcamps?
- Buge 9y agoI was an IA for a computer security class. We discovered a number of students cheating by copying answers from a public github repo from the previous semester. We noticed because many students were submitting the same bizarrely wrong answer. Some students had even copied all the typos. Even crazier, a number of the students had even forked the github repo with their github accounts. That is some terrible opsec. Definitely losing points for that.
- bragh 9y agoI have noticed that these things matter only when someone has been burnt by it once already. So before your class, nobody in their life had even bothered to check for plagiarism. Had to fail the projects of 1/3 of the class in a community college because of plagiarism. Although to their credit, they at least put in some effort by shifting sentences around and re-drew other students' diagrams. They did keep the same node names and relationships between nodes, though.
- sdiq 9y agoIn this case, I believe, the prevalence of cheating among CS students isn't higher than cheating among students of other courses in the same universities, or elsewhere. Even in public health, occasionally, the prevalence of a certain disease goes up courtesy of technological advancement. The prevalence of that disease in a population that was initially low or unknown suddenly shoots up because the means with which to detect the disease has now become widely available, and not always because the incidence of that disease in that population has only started going up. Now, if other courses offered at these named universities had means of detecting students cheating in such courses, the prevalence of cheating in these other courses would probably be as high as in CS. Universities would thus need to either come up with systems that detect cheaters that has both a high true positives rate and a low false negatives rate, or, come up with a better way of assessing students that does not involve exercises that can easily be "borrowed" from the Internet.
- miranda_rights 9y agoThis is exactly it, in my opinion. It's much easier to catch cheating by running homework code through something like MOSS than relying on a human TA to catch that 2 handwritten math assignments are exactly alike. I TAed both CS and Math classes at a large state school and once caught ~20% of a 50 person math class on a homework assignment because they had all copied a mis-labeled problem from the solutions manual. It's probable that they had all been cheating up to that point but I couldn't tell. It turns out, the Math department as a policy doesn't try to do anything about cheating and just encourages lecturers to base the majority of the final grade on exams. I can't say this works much better because I've sat next to a student 2 separate times during exams who obviously had their phone out and was reading from it. The rate of cheating is probably lower in exams but lecturers should be more proactive about it.
- TheSmiddy 9y agoAt my uni you had to have all electronic devices in your bag under your desk and have all supporting materials displayed on your desk before the exam. There were floor walkers who would go up and down the aisles constantly throughout the exam looking for signs of cheating. If you were caught you were expelled. A neighbouring uni even gave students lockers and didn't permit bringing anything into their exams. Exam cheating seems like an incredibly easy problem to solve.
- not_a_cheater 9y agoI may or may not have cheated my way through classes. If I was to cheat, I would use the following methods: 1. Break up (or merge) functions 2. Switch ordering of declaration of variables and the ordering of methods/functions 3. Change names of variables/functions 4. Create useless variables to hold state (or condense/remove useless variables). 5. Switch ordering of math operations As long as you take the time to understand the code you are copying, you won't make an obvious mistake like that while(!true) fail in the article. The general guideline is to use cheating as a shortcut to the answer, not as a zero effort copy paste. If I had hypothetically cheated using the above method on ~ 15 major code projects, I wouldn't have gotten caught.
- humanrebar 9y agoAt some point it would incrementally more effort to just write the stuff yourself. Most of the time in undergrad, you're just implementing the (provided in pseudocode) data structures and algorithms from the textbook anyway.
- darioush 9y agoif you know enough coding to break up and merge functions, you can also write fizzbuzz and therefore are not the type of person this article and comments are picking on.
- logfromblammo 9y agoSo... the easiest way to cheat on programming assignments and not get caught is to google an existing answer and know how refactoring works? It occurs to me that I may have been "cheating" at the majority of my paid job for years.
- booleandilemma 9y agoThis is how this happens: https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/
- xor1 9y agoAnecdote time: My friend is currently doing a Computer Science MS at a university that I'm sure most people on HN have heard of. She got accepted with an unrelated undergrad degree (though still STEM) and two Intro to Programming community college courses she took after graduating (which she cheated her way through by paying her roommate at the time to do all of her homework). She hits me up for help with her homework/projects all the time. I'll help her a bit and then tell her how to look up everything else she needs to know on her own, but she always ends up falling back on another friend, who just completes the assignments for her. Homework + group projects count enough where she can bomb her tests and still pass. She's about a year into programming coursework now, and still struggles with just about anything outside of for loops and print statements. She is extremely good at math, though, (tbh she's just really smart overall), so those courses and the theory itself aren't giving her any trouble. I initially told her that spending 3 years getting the MS would be a waste of time for her, and she'd be better off learning on her own or maybe even doing a bootcamp, but now I realize that she doesn't actually care about becoming proficient or even competent when it comes to software development. She's going to get her MS, and someone will undoubtedly hire her based on a CS MS that she obtained through cheating, and a resume that goes past embellishment and has outright lies. At worst she ends up at a defense contractor that bills $200/hr (and pays her 1/3 of that) for her to just sit around and read Reddit on her phone all day. I really feel like a huge sucker sometimes for always having been completely honest, both in terms of school and work. I've never cheated and I've never lied or exaggerated about anything related to work, in regards to both job applications and employment. When I think about it, it's cost me a lot.
- stale2002 9y agoWell, it depends. People like this are why companies ask programming questions that are slightly harder than fizzbuzz. You might be able to get a middling, junior dev position, using her method, but good luck doing anything else with your life. I certainly slacked off a bunch during school, as I only minored in CS. I was able to get a job, but I've had to work really hard after that to improve my skills, and go beyond the junior dev role (along with having to job hop a bit more than I am comfortable with). And I also don't have any specialized knowledge, so I don't feel like I can do anything more than web dev. The thing is, there is much more to a career in tech, than just being a mid level engineer. And it is difficult to go beyond that unless you can really bring useful skills and value to the table.
- theprop 9y agoI wonder if the most effective cheaters in school end up being more or less successful both as coders and professionally in general. "Hacking" is in a sense related to cheating (finding easier solutions to problems...).
- tsm 9y agoI TAed every semester of college except my first, and went to a small liberal arts school where cheating was legitimately uncommon. However, I'll never forget the following exchange: Student: Why did you give me a 9/10 on the sorting lab? tsm: Your shell sort didn't work for n > 7 S: But Professor Smith looked over my shoulder during the lab and said it looked fine. tsm: And in fact it breaks for n > 7; I don't care if Alan Turing looked over your shoulder and said it was fine, if it breaks it breaks. S: proceeds to pout at me for literally the rest of the semester, failing to understand how the professor-anointed code could have problems in it
- ec109685 9y ago9/10 was a very generous grade for that. I was saddened when I TA'd an operating systems class and not only caught two groups cheating, but numerous groups with race conditions in their Nachos code (you could fuzz the seed to change the system's execution order between threads and students clearly didn't test that). The professor wasn't harsh enough on either sets of groups, in my opinion.
- eutropia 9y ago7/10 would have been more appropriate. ;)
- bdcravens 9y agoThese days, at least half of the requests I see come through my CodeMentor profile are blatantly obvious homework assignments.
- dba7dba 9y agoI went to one of the better University of California campuses like 20 years ago. And my friend majoring in CS told me a CS professor caught about a third of his class cheating in their take-home programming assignments. This was in a lower level CS class. He ran an analysis through turned in assignments and discovered almost a third had patterns that signaled it had been copied from someone else's work. This is before github so the suspicion was that some were copying code from other classmates. We will always have cheaters.
- askvictor 9y agoI teach at a (somewhat academic) high school, and we've noticed a massive shift in how students think about copying in the past few years - about half of our students think it's OK to share answers for an assessment where it will assist another student (i.e. classical notion of cheating). I'm very curious if this is a mind-shift in younger people that are just a lot happier to share things, and this is just a consequence. The other thing to consider with this is that the assessment system probably needs to be overhauled entirely - which would be a good thing as there are plenty of other reasons why it's broken.
- stale2002 9y agoHere is one big reason why "cheating" happens. It isnt directly related to the high school level, and more applicable to the college, though. The problem is that different classes/subjects/majors have wildly different expectations with regards to how much you are allowed to collaborate with other students. For example, in my business and economics classes I took, collaboration is encouraged by the professors so much that everyone just works together on everything, without even asking if it is cheating, because of course it isn't. And people who take these classes then go on to take a class in a different subject, where you are not in a situation where literally every single assignment is a group project, and they forget to ask if what they are doing is allowed.
- sbov 9y agoA few anecdotes from college (15 years ago now) regarding cheating/"cheating": I transferred from community college, where we used C++. The new school used Java, but the C++ classes still counted as credit at the new school, so I was in upper division classes. I asked a teacher about it, they said "theres no way you can survive this class if you don't already know Java." I used one weekend to learn Java, and saw it wasn't much different. However, throughout the semester that teacher would continually say "I know there are cheaters in this class because I know some of you don't even know Java." Uhuh. My first actual cheating encounter was also that same semester, after I turned in my first project for a class, a classmate asked to see how I did something. Ignorant me sent them my project so they could. However, we had a final project built on the first. After the class ended they admitted they never finished the first, and used my first project as a base for their final project. Lesson learned. Someone offered me $200 to do a group project with them. Not really cheating, but their intentions were obvious. No thanks. Of course, plenty of dead weight on other group projects. But nothing as overt as the above two incidents.
- mb_72 9y agoI didn't cheat once through a CS degree gained in the early 90's (as my sometimes shabby, sometimes ok results would show), but I was made hard to think about whether a certain incident was cheating or not. One of my final year subjects involved a group project; we had to develop a PDA-type collection of applications, so it fitted well with a group project. The 'calculator' guy never turned up to any programming sessions or meetings aside from the initial one - someone else ended up hacking together his app in the last day - and then 60 minutes prior to the submission deadline. Back then we had to put together a paper project outline and notes, and there were strict requirements for it's submission format; laid out like so, printed like so, index like this, bound like that. If this paper submission was a minute late, we'd be docked 50% (!) of our overall marks. Four of us were panicking, with < 1hr left to submit, our project unprinted and unbound, and us with no idea how to operate the required machinery. The fifth member, our 'calculator' guy, actually shows up, and then proceeded to, unassisted, blitz through the printing, collation and binding of the project. We eventually submitted a minute or two prior to cutoff, and got a good mark; without the 'calculator' guy, who did no programming whatsoever, we would have been in big trouble. I've always wondered if he went on to be the 'binder guy' or 'fixer' IRL after graduating.
- ender89 9y ago... The kicker to me is that as a developer if I am having trouble doing something, I ask the internet to see if someone else has already solved it. If I find the solution on stack exchange, I'm not going to rework the solution just so I can claim that I did the work. I'm probably not going to change a thing other than tweaking things to fit whatever the rest of my code looks like. I will re-write anything I find on something like stack exchange because it helps you remember what you did and you think about how what you're typing out works, but its essentially copied and pasted from someone else's work. I don't know if this counts as "cheating" or something in the classroom - though I certainly wouldn't have an entire application with reworked answers from stack exchange - but its a skill worth teaching to cs students. Heck, people sell books with code snippets intended to ease development for pete's sake, I can't see why using a java cookbook should be penalized in the classroom.
- OrthoMetaPara 9y agoit's all dotheads and chinks
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and promise to follow the rules in the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- internalfx 9y agoProgramming requires constant learning. If you need someone to teach you, it will be hard to keep up. If you can teach yourself, you don't need college. I Never went to a university. I have no degree. I have the best career I can imagine.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoI tried to learn to code on my own growing up and failed, eventually losing interest. It wasn't until I had proper instruction in my intro-level college course that I was able to learn the basics. I haven't had trouble keeping up since then. I have three degrees. I have the best career I can imagine.
- kutkloon7 9y ago"Troves of code online, on sites like GitHub, may have answers to the very assignment the student is wrestling with, posted by someone who previously took the course." If the assignments are not changed from year to year, the institution is partially to blame. A good student, researcher or scientist is expected to do research. When you stumble upon the solution (either by accident or intentional) to your problem, it will become very hard to come up with a different solution. Your solution is very likely to be viewed as plagiarism. Of course, the student should cite the source of their inspiration, but since the instructor may reduce the grade when he learns that the student looked at someone else's solution, this is a devil's dilemma.
- Eridrus 9y agoThis is getting downvoted, but I once had an advanced-level course where the the assignment was to write a peer review for a research paper. We were given 24 hours and allowed to use the internet, so I Googled the paper, found a scathing blog my professor had written and deleted, looked it up on archive.org and found myself with a dilemma about whether to cite it or not. I decided it was better to cite it than risk getting caught, and it worked out fine for me. In hindsight I shouldn't have put myself in that position, but temptation is a cruel mistress.
- nathan_f77 9y agoI understand that it's plagiarism when you're supposed to be learning and writing your own code, but perhaps this is the wrong way to teach programming. It shouldn't be such a big deal if you find an open source library or code snippet on StackOverflow that solves your homework assignment. Maybe the problem lies with the assignments. They could be rotated, rewritten each year, or even randomized for every student, so that you really have to understand the code you're writing (or copying). If you find some code that solves 90% of your problem, and you know how to tweak it to solve the remaining 10%, then that's a far more valuable and practical skill than writing everything from scratch. It's also a great way to learn from other programmers and see what they are doing. I'm probably completely off-base, since I'm a self-taught developer, so my learning style is very different. But I spend the vast majority of my time reading other people's code, studying documentation, and using open source libraries. "Plagiarism" is a very, very important part of this industry. It would be interesting to work on randomized coding assignment generators. I've worked on similar things in the past, where my company used it as a filter for software engineering applications. I wonder if any universities would be interested in that. It would completely solve the plagiarism problem, because every student would have to write unique code to solve the problem they were given.
- b0rsuk 9y agoWhat I don't understand is why anti-plagiarism software they mention seems to compare test solutions in isolation. Only 2 out of 450 made this particular mistake, but where did they sit on the exam ? If they made the same mistake and they sit within 5m of each other, that would be much stronger accusation. The bottom line: software should take into account not just how similar two solutions are, but how far from each other both students were.
- ncke 9y ago> Though coding is a foreign language to most people, the principles of plagiarism are the same as with papers written in English. English is a foreign language to most people too. You expect more from the NYT.
- throw2016 9y agoThis happens in every profession. Some people are lazy, some are shirkers, some thrive on politics, some cheat, some steal credit. As history shows us looking for shortcuts is a perennial human issue that affects a section of any population. You are unlikely to be a doctor without going through an intensive educational curriculum and exams over a period of time. You will probably have an idea of what it entails, but laziness or other factors could motivate looking for shortcuts. It would be the same for software or any other field but the level of scrutiny and rigour would vary. The education system, the interviews, and constant oversight by managers are designed to weed out these issues. No individual employee escapes managerial oversight in the real world so this is an organization problem that gets solved at that level and should ideally not be a concern or worse an excuse for a witch hunt by other employees.
- Zenst 9y agoI started out in the very early 80's and first job was a Electrical company government job. First week was an introduction to COBOL (which I already knew) and second week was an introduction to GCOS (which I also already knew). One of the challenges in the second week was to come up with as many ways of copying a file using the GCOS8 (Honeywell Bull DPS8) shell. Now on GCOS the current workfil was called SRC, so one example was to use that, now one of the other `students` came over and accused me of copying another chaps work, I laughed and so did the chap in question who knew me very well. We thought nothing of it. Later when it was show and tell this chap who had accused me of copying somebody else's work had a glaring error in his work. He had used MTW instead of *SRC. Now this chap was called Martin and had accused me of copying from Steven, who's initials happened to be...SRC. Sadly this Martin chap ended up getting the best position, turns out he had schmoozed the head guy with BBC micro talk and as he had one, they had a good chat about that and the whole aspect that he was not that good just got overlooked. Moral being, if your a good person and honest, you do get shafted on from time to time.
- austincheney 9y agoAs a JavaScript developer none of this matters to me. Here is the reality I see: JavaScript skills are in demand almost everywhere even if it is not the primary language or skill of a given job. Almost nobody receives any kind of formal education or training in how to write in JavaScript. If you work for a web based company you WILL at some point be tasked to write in JavaScript. When developers, who have never touched JavaScript before, are tasked to write JavaScript one of a couple things happen. First, they will attempt to write Java (C# or whatever) in this language because the syntax roughly looks the same. Secondly, they will grab the easiest framework they can find and hope to fill in the blanks. Essentially, at the end of the day, almost nobody knows what they are doing. In this line of work most people are utterly afraid to write code. We would be in much better shape if our biggest problems were developers or students cheating. Some food for though: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/66hpqs/less_than_5_of_indian_engineering_students_are/dgioklc/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/66hpqs/less_th...
- oregondan 9y agoWhat?? This seems like a road that only leads to technical debt brought on by people who, as you say, know nothing about the code they're working on. Why would you feel that's acceptable to a company? Fortunately software development (often) has little direct impact on matters of life or death, but can you imagine an architect or construction worker who successfully cheated their way through school being brought on and having zero idea of how to weld, or how to predict the weak points in a structure? Also, I'd argue that using frameworks is different than 'not writing code,' though I do agree that the JS community has become framework-obsessed...
- austincheney 9y ago> This seems like a road that only leads to technical debt brought on by people who This technology is littered by technical debt by people doing everything they can to cheat. We are already there. That line in the sand was crossed years ago.
- douche 9y ago> Essentially, at the end of the day, almost nobody knows what they are doing. In this line of work most people are utterly afraid to write code. We would be in much better shape if our biggest problems were developers or students cheating. It's really the terrifying thing. What's more terrifying is somebody that thinks they do know what they are doing. Once in a great while they will be right, but far more often they are wrong, disastrously wrong.
- beckler 9y agoI had an incident like this when I was in University. There was a guy in my class who struggled with a major project, and he asked if I could help him with it. He wanted me to show him how to get started, but he would never meet with me, and wanted to see my code. So I stripped out the most critical part of my implementation, and shared it with him. After weeks of silence he asks for help again, I ask him to send me what he had... And it was the exact same code I had sent him weeks earlier with very little changes. He had been asking everyone for their code and trying to copy and paste it together. I ended up going to our professor about it... And he knew who I was talking about before I finished explaining everything. It was not his first time in the class, and he had done it before. He somehow graduated with a CS degree even though it took him a few more years.
- abronan 9y agoIn my French University, group or individual assignments had a very low coefficient compared to written exams (where it was almost impossible to cheat as this was basically like white board coding and students would be spaced by 2/3 seats between them). It was in the order of 20%(group/coding)/80%(written exam). This had the effect of eliminating 50% of all students on the first semester for the first year of CompSci (DistSys) Master's Degree. So even if a group cheated on group/coding assignments, they most likely wouldn't go through the written exam. We called it: "The Purge". From then, very few instances of cheating (topics were changed every year). One group got caught cheating on another one during the second year (iOS objectiveC class) and they got a failing grade. Almost every professor would use automated code checkers on group and individual assignments. And if you get caught, you have to go through thorough questioning by the professor, eventually getting a failing grade and having to go through the second session of written exams (which was most of the time harder than the first session). What was unavoidable though were group projects with only one person working on the project and the others doing nothing or just spending time preparing for written exams. This happened to me quite a few times. I didn't mind as I was learning a lot, but it got me exhausted for written exams where I was getting good but not outstanding grades.
- b0rsuk 9y agoMost of these articles read: "They cheat because A, B, and C... it could be because of D..." I would love to read an article which is like: "I cheat because X..." "I cheat because Y..." "We cheated because Z..." In other words, an article or a study based on an anonymous survey. Straight from the horse's mouth.
- emidln 9y agoI helped people cheat because it paid better than working fast food. I never took an exam, but I did a lot of assignments. I kinda felt bad for some of the students who were taught Java for a couple semesters and then thrown into C for an operating systems class. I also figured that they'd just fail the exam if they didn't learn it eventually (which happened frequently, usually resulting in more work/money for me next semester).
- douche 9y agoI bought the solution manual for my algorithms and data structures course, because the professor, TAs, and textbook were so incredibly bad that I couldn't figure out how you were supposed to structure the proofs that you were expected to write for the problem sets - and they were incredibly anal about the way that everything needed to be formatted. I just gave up - I'd implement everything in C for fun and to know how it actually worked, and copy over the bullshit parts for the homeworks. I've never seen a class that could have been so much fun taught so badly. When you sit there and watch a tenured professor do nothing more than copy CLRS out on a blackboard, listing by listing...
- strictnein 9y agoI "cheated" in one of my junior level CompSci classes. Forget what the name of it was, but we ended up doing a fair amount with low level debugging/analysis, assembly, etc. One of the big multi-week projects had a series of increasingly difficult questions about different aspects of a compiled program that you were supposed to figure out. We were told we could use whatever tools we were comfortable with using. So I used a C decompiler and finished the entire thing in about 5 minutes.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoThat sounds like an inspired and competent solution to the problem. Given that the article focused on pre-made work shared amongst students, this hardly sounds like cheating at all.
- strictnein 9y agoAgreed. In reality, I cheated myself more than anything else. I ended up needing to teach myself some of those skills last year, 15+ years later.
- mmartinson 9y agoIt's interesting how at-odds the concept of plagiarism in a university classroom is with the industry-lauded values of open source software and reuse of well established implementations. As someone familiar with the university system but who learned software engineering entirely outside of that context, I can't help but think it seems a bit antithetical to a large component of the skillset I's like to see in a new grad I was working beside.
- josepi_ 9y agoStudent at UIC here: Pretty much everyone in the lower level classes is cheating. Some of it's just "driving five-over" and some is practically murder. I've heard Chinese students talking throughout entire exams in big lecture halls, students leaving lab and immediately finding their friends waiting outside for the next lab section and dishing all the details of the day's lab, and students giving away a little too much information when talking about their strategy for a project.
- qwer 9y agoI was a CS TA 20 years ago and it was the same. Literally everyone was doing it to some degree. Back then you would hand in printed source code. People would occasionally photocopy someone else's, scratch the name off the title page and write in their own name like I wouldn't notice something that stupid. I actually caught some phd students in some cheating that was almost as blatant. The professors generally don't care either. The whole thing burned me out pretty quickly. I realized the school was just full of a bunch of people going through the motions, and CS degrees don't really indicate any particular expertise on their own.
- throwaway2n2222 9y agoThrowaway account, obviously. I'll add to the corpus of a few commenters talking about cheating: We're in bioengineering BS/MS/PhD levels, so the issues with cheating are 'serious', in that our designs are somewhat likely going to end up in a person someday (depending on FDA approval, thank god for that). The cheating in our department is staggering and totally ignored. I've brought up these issues before to the department, per the large red warning about it in the student handbook. Nothing has happened, at all. There was a wiki on all the old homework that is re-used from year to year. The department did not care and the admins of the wiki were not expelled, nothing happened to them, last I heard it was still functioning. The tests and finals are re-used every year and you would then be very stupid to not cheat, as the classes are curved. Some classes have a large coding component in them and there are coding 'projects'. I remember a final project of the year (last of 3 total) was to model a honey dollop spreading on an incline, runge-kutte methods and all that. They never looked at the code, just the output graphs of it for the report. I know this because I put an infinite while loop in the code to hang the computer, as I was quite disgusted at the lack of effort in grading at the time, and it wasn't mentioned at all in the committee meetings later. As some test were open computer, it was quite easy to see that everyone was cheating because all the screens were in the same wiki copying the answers there. Just disgusting, really. But the department is benefiting from letting in all these people in and then taking their money, so nothing happens. I know I will never hire anyone out of here, as I know they are just garbage.
- b0rsuk 9y agoWhat I don't quite understand is why those people study CS or IT in the first place (in my country there's no distinction in naming). I get that some people are good at networking and office politics, and might even be good managers, let's give them the benefit of doubt. But are there, no doubt, studies specifically aimed at educating IT managers ? IT industry is still hot, surely there are some corresponding management courses to go with that ? That way they wouldn't have to struggle with conceptually hard topics, and employers would get a better idea of a person's skills. Why study IT if you don't like wrestling with algorithms, installing software, configuration etc ? Why pretend to be a techie ?
- technobabble 9y agoAn additional anecdote from high school three years ago (take it with a grain of salt) There was a person in my CS class where we built a virtual computer using Python. Almost weekly I saw her cheating, yet during her spare time she devoted that saved time to a side project that won her an award and some publicity. Starting from then I've learned to focus less on the grade and more on actual projects that are challenging enough that I have to learn.
- sumobob 9y agoI wonder what percentage of students ever take that regret clause