7 ms·
novice programmers should not be starting a CS degree
by walshemj 9y ago
novice programmers should not be starting a CS degree
- akulbe 9y agoWhat makes you say that? Where would you have them start instead? Bumble through learning to program without the theory behind any of it? That seems like a cart-before-the-horse scenario.
- joshontheweb 9y agoNot necessarily a bad idea. This will give you a better appreciation for why you would want to use the established paradigms taught in CS courses.
- jdietrich 9y agoGiven the gender skew amongst high-school programmers, this is almost equivalent to saying "women should not be starting a CS degree". It also further entrenches the advantages of people who come from affluent backgrounds. Given the success of some short coding bootcamps, it isn't inconceivable that novices could be brought up to speed within the first semester. We don't expect law students to have been amateur lawyers in high school; it's a bonus if they have been in the debate society or have taken a personal interest in the subject, but it's not necessary. I don't see why CS should be a special case, aside from a misplaced attitude of exclusionary elitism.
- brandonmenc 9y ago> It also further entrenches the advantages of people who come from affluent backgrounds. If you can afford a video game console, you can afford a raspberry pi (or equivalent.) > We don't expect law students to have been amateur lawyers in high school No, but we expect math majors to have done some math before they get to college. I don't disagree with you that most people can be brought up to speed in less than a year, but it's also not unreasonable to expect first year CS students to have had some programming experience. Computers don't cost thousands of dollars anymore.
- Hydraulix989 9y ago> If you can afford a video game console, you can afford a raspberry pi (or equivalent.) Right. This type of democratization is EXACTLY what allowed me to climb the social ladder out of the rural midwest into a Top 15 university and then Silicon Valley. As a teenager, all I needed to teach myself coding and advanced math was free time and an Internet connection.
- Spikeyduy 9y agoHonestly I think the only prerequisite for a CS major is to have interest in it. I never had any programming classes in high school and I switch my major 3 times until landing on CS. I had never programmed before in my life, but it was interesting to me and I found out I had an affinity towards it. I'm just saying this statement that you need to have some background to it is not necessary.
- watwut 9y agoMath majors are expected to know high school math. You can literally know exactly that and succeed. If you wish to get ahead of competition, you know exactly what to do and exactly what is measured. CS does not have such clarity of expectations. I knew basics, because of journals my father bought. Since I knew basics, the teacher shown me some competitions - from then on I just went with the flow. Had my father not bought those journals or had my teacher not shown me competitions, I would not study cs or had much harder time. If you are a boy, video game console is something that is bought for you often times whether you really want it or not. Raspberry pi is likely not and you don't know it exists. And even if you know it exists, you need computer to upload code to it and then you could have just use that computer to code. I know that it is easy to code when you know where to look, but the biggest hurdle is that many kids dont know where to look. Instead, they are told there is something magical and hard about it. I remember being told that it is hard or that I cant compete because I am (presumably) just learning and other kids "already know a lot". It was bs, but that is where it is for many kids. Seriously, I knew straight A students who were more hardworking then me and had good grades in math (meaning no dummies memorizing stuff) were under impression I have some special brain because I can program. All the myths around cs tend reinforce such nonsense.
- xor1 9y ago>Given the gender skew amongst high-school programmers, this is almost equivalent to saying "women should not be starting a CS degree" What makes you bring up gender over race or class ? There are more middle-class Asian and White women in the field than lower-income African-American and Hispanic men.
- jdietrich 9y agoThe following sentence was about household income. I'm not entirely sure that race is a meaningful factor after correcting for socioeconomic status. Gender is demonstrably the biggest skew in CS majors.
- erikbye 9y ago> We don't expect law students to have been amateur lawyers in high school; it's a bonus if they have been in the debate society or have taken a personal interest in the subject, but it's not necessary. I don't see why CS should be a special case... Agreed, and when it comes to CS, programming is the easiest part. People who fail to see this are probably the ones who only know programming and no CS.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf you've applied for a CS degree and not done any programming though why (outside of financial incentive) would a Uni want you, surely it shows you've no interest in the field - that has to correlate strongly with failure. From nothing to doing bubble-sorts with something like python shouldn't be more than a couple of weekends for someone of the caliber to study CS at Uni. Say you apply to study marine biology but have never been to the seaside then sure, you might do fine, but really I'd be wondering why you weren't taking a gap year and doing some self-directed study at a beach (hey, that sounds fun!).
- hx87 9y agoMaybe because in the USA, you don't "apply for a degree" at the undergraduate level? You apply to be at the university full stop, or at most an honors program.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSo, you do modules or somesuch; presumably they have pre-requisites that work in largely the same way? Like for non high-school subjects "read chapters 1-4 of 'intro to $subject' and have a grade C or above on $exam"? How do you manage expectations for courses/modules/whatever from both sides (teacher:student) without such things.
- hx87 9y agoYou simply declare a major/concentration and register for classes in the appropriate departments. If you get acceptable grades in those classes you are allowed to continue.
- lostboys67 9y agoYou do in countries that specialise earlier you wont get into a STEM course at a UK Uni without the relevant GCSE / A Levels. In the UK you start to specialise at 13/14 I and I bet having a GCSE and A level in Law would help for wanabe lawyers
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>Given the gender skew amongst high-school programmers, this is almost equivalent to saying "women should not be starting a CS degree". Somewhat related to your point, letting novice programmers get CS degrees doesn't fix the problem because there is still a performance gap which results in a hiring gap. If there is problem with demographics having unequal experiences, while colleges can be tweaked to keep the inequality from growing, it is far better to fix it where it comes from. It's far simpler to say than do, but our society needs to find why the gender skew in high school programmers happens and stop it.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoGod forbid someone goes to college to learn something. Of course, in my experience coming in to a CS degree as a techie didn't actually teach me how to make a living writing code. Most of the useful stuff I had to learn on my own time. The connections I made at school helped, but the value of the actual classes was low. So perhaps a CS degree isn't intended to teach anything to anyone.
- ghaff 9y agoTo the degree that colleges have their curricula setup that you need to have experience programming to enroll in the CS degree, that's on them. It's not true of essentially any other STEM major--or indeed for most degrees. (There are a few exceptions. Lack of fluency+ in English would make it had to make it through many top humanities degrees. And many music, etc. degrees would be tough/impossible without prior exposure.) However, in general, the idea that you need to already be a programmer per-college to major in CS is somewhere between wrong-headed and toxic.
- scaryspooky 9y agoI think the founders of what now is CS would be lumped in with the very, very bright but still novice programmers. Most of the field has nothing to do with actual hardware anyway.
- alistairSH 9y agoPoppycock. I studied CS at UVA in the late-90s and had no previous programming experience. I was an experienced computer user, which wasn't a given in the 90s, but I hadn't done any programming. There wasn't anything in the curriculum that required previous experience. Linux wasn't required for entry-level courses. At the time, they were taught using C++ and a Borland IDE on Windows. Similarly, source control wasn't introduced immediately. I'm pretty sure CS101 assignments were turned on paper, in addition to email. And the department offered many options for lab time, office hours, and tutoring. I worked as an undergraduate TA for 2.5 years, which basically meant holding lab hours 3-4 times/week for 2-3 hours at a time, in addition to grading assignments and exams.
- Yhippa 9y agoI was there the same time you were and while I thought I came in knowing a lot but I was dead wrong. I had to learn a ton of things from the ground-up like everyone else.
- henrikschroder 9y ago+1 I also started a CS program in '95, with practically no previous programming experience. (10 PRINT "HENRIK IS THE BEST", 20 GOTO 10 doesn't count) One thing our university did though was that the introduction course was in Scheme, which evened the playing field immensely, because most of the kids who could program were self-taught in Pascal or C, and where pretty stumped when confronted with a functional programming language. But my university's approach didn't help the abysmal graduation numbers either, there were so many classmates that dropped out during the first year. A bunch dropped out because the programme was an engineering programme, and they failed the math parts, but did good on the CS parts. Most of those switched to other programmes that were more pure CS and were successful. But there were a lot of students who just lacked that elusive thing that makes a person a good programmer. There's been a lot of studies, and lot of previous discussions on HN of those studies, but the jury is still out, we have no idea how to effectively screen people for programming ability. The only thing we can do is toss them into an education and see if it sticks. The original article asks: > Isn’t it reasonable to expect that people with an aptitude for math, physics, and engineering will also have an aptitude for CS? And the answer is a resounding no. Funnily enough, this whole thing ties into the problems of recruiting good programmers, another HN staple topic. We can't tell if someone will be a good programmer before an education, and we can't even quickly tell if someone is a good programmer after an education, or even after years of working in the industry! If there was a quick way of identifying good programmers, we wouldn't be in this mess.
- meej 9y agoin my day/at my alma mater non-novice programmers had a reputation for dropping out because they were bored by the introductory material in the first year of the program.
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoI did my BS in CS with no prior programming experience.