6 ms·
Shakespeare’s Genius Is Nonsense (2014)
- mcguire 9y agoGood article. Booth's Precious Nonsense: The Gettysburg Address, Ben Jonson's Epitaphs on His Children, and Twelfth Night sounds intriguing, too. "Why do we value literature so? Many would say for the experience it brings us. But what is it about that experience that makes us treasure certain writings above others? Stephen Booth suggests that the greatest appeal of our most valued works may be that they are, in one way or another, nonsensical. He uses three disparate textsthe Gettysburg Address, Ben Jonson's epitaphs on his children, and Shakespeare's Twelfth Nightto demonstrate how poetics triumphs over logic in the invigorating mental activity that enriches our experience of reading. Booth presents his case in a book that is crisply playful while at the same time thoroughly analytical. He demonstrates the lapses in logic and the irrational connections in examples of very different types of literature, showing how they come close to incoherence yet maintain for the reader a reliable order and purpose. Ultimately, Booth argues, literature gives us the capacity to cope effortlessly with, and even to transcend, the complicated and demanding mental experiences it generates for us. "This book is in part a witty critique of the trendsold and newof literary criticism, written by an accomplished and gifted scholar. But it is also a testimony to the power of the process of reading itself. Precious Nonsense is certain to bring pleasure to anyone interested in language and its beguiling possibilities."
- foxhedgehog 9y agoBooth was my thesis advisor and Seth is a friend. Precious Nonsense is great, would highly recommend and am happy to discuss further in a thread here.
- finolex1 9y agoLooks like even science magazines have fallen prey to clickbait titles a la buzzfeed. Which is quite sad considering that it's actually a quality article.
- franzen 9y agoAgreed that the title is clickbait, but it's also quite clever.
- tspike 9y agoAnd completely consistent with its subject matter.
- booleandilemma 9y agoI gotta say Nautilus headlines get me every time. I'll see an eye-catching headline on HN and sure enough it's Nautilus.
- tnecniv 9y agoThey bother me because sometimes their articles are very good and others they are...subpar.
- matt4077 9y agoSurly an essay about the beauty of puns and ambiguity in poetry can still be allowed a modicum of cleverness in its title? "Clickbait", especially "a la buzzfeed" also usually refers to the original definition: "10 great jokes that Shakespear hid in poetry–No 12 will blow your mind". And considering they have A/B tested their headlines and you consider the article worth reading, isn't the outcome arguably good, anyway?
- Aron 9y agoI'd still prefer to know what I am in for, rather than be mislead to get there. And don't call me surly.
- 9y ago
- paulsutter 9y agoGeorge Orwell was a great fan of Shakespeare, and he wrote an essay[1] in response to Tolstoy's strong dislike of Shakespeare[2]. These quotes are from Orwell, the fan: - "Tolstoy is right in saying that Lear is not a very good play, as a play. It is too drawn-out and has too many characters and sub-plots." - "Shakespeare has a habit of thrusting uncalled-for general reflections into the mouths of his characters. This is a serious fault in a dramatist" - "Of course, it is not because of the quality of his thought that Shakespeare has survived, and he might not even be remembered as a dramatist if he had not also been a poet." Tolstoy: - "I remember the astonishment I felt when I first read Shakespeare. I expected to receive a powerful esthetic pleasure, but having read, one after the other, works regarded as his best: "King Lear," "Romeo and Juliet," "Hamlet" and "Macbeth," not only did I feel no delight, but I felt an irresistible repulsion and tedium" [1] http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/lear/english/e_ltf http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/lear/english/e_ltf ("Lear, Tolstoy, and the Fool, by George Orwell) [2] http://www.gutenberg.org/files/27726/27726-h/27726-h.htm http://www.gutenberg.org/files/27726/27726-h/27726-h.htm ("Tolstoy on Shakespeare", by Leo Tolstoy)
- foxhedgehog 9y agoThis is one of my favorite essays, it also has a great aside about how the appetite for power is more dangerous than the capacity for violence, which has always stuck with me as a particularly astute observation. The essay is also particularly good because it recognizes that Shakespeare pre-identified faults in Tolstoy's philosophy, in King Lear. I've also long thought that a lot of the subtlety of language touched on in this essay would have likely escaped Tolstoy in translation.
- hitekker 9y agoVery astute indeed, this is my first time hearing about it. Copy pasted below: > The distinction that really matters is not between violence and non-violence, but between having and not having the appetite for power. There are people who are convinced of the wickedness both of armies and of police forces, but who are nevertheless much more intolerant and inquisitorial in outlook than the normal person who believes that it is necessary to use violence in certain circumstances. They will not say to somebody else, ‘Do this, that and the other or you will go to prison’, but they will, if they can, get inside his brain and dictate his thoughts for him in the minutest particulars. Creeds like pacifism and anarchism, which seem on the surface to imply a complete renunciation of power, rather encourage this habit of mind. For if you have embraced a creed which appears to be free from the ordinary dirtiness of politics — a creed from which you yourself cannot expect to draw any material advantage — surely that proves that you are in the right? And the more you are in the right, the more natural that everyone else should be bullied into thinking likewise. My two cents is that the vast majority of people likely have the similar capacities for violence, their expression only changes in different contexts and for different reasons. Orwelles articulates that in the political context, the most likely reason for violence is to attain power, so those who care less for power have less reason and therefore less-seeming capacity for violence. I quite like how he establishes that the reason for violence comes before the capacity of violence when considering if someone will be violent/express violence. That man had a window into the political soul.
- dang 9y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8431653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8431653.
- mowenz 9y agoWhether Orwell or Tolstoy is right about Shakespeare's genius, it's impossible to reliably quantify, or even qualify, genius outside of contributions to the hard sciences. Orwell himself actually talked about this in Politics and the English Language. He discussed the debate about that lasted unnecessarily long about the nautical screw, showing how even a relatively easily provable concept can be difficult to prove.
- theprop 9y agoI'm not convinced that Shakespeare's genius is nonsense. The nonsense poets like Ionesco while really good are not comparable to Shakespeare precisely because there is sense in Shakespeare, even in Shakespeare's "nonsense".
- vivekd 9y agoI always thought Shakespehre was over-rated both as a dramatist and as a poet. I happily read this article thinking someone else was finally going to make the case for Shakespeare's mediocrity. But alas, I had been tricked, it was about something much less interesting. The article presents some speculative research by scientist Stephen Booth about Shakespeare's effect on the bran under brain scans. It makes strange claims about brain scans showing that the brain focuses and pays attention when listening to Shakespeare. It then reaches the dubious conclusion that this is because of some patterns that Shakespeare, in his genius, put in the verses. Of course, these patterns are semantic rather than syntactical and thus not easily quantifiable and measurable in an objective fashion. Naturally Booth doesn't even consider the possibility that the brain activity may be attributable to other factors. Like the fact that it could just be the brain reacting to archaic styles of English and realizing that it has to focus and pay closer attention to discern the meaning. . . Or that it may be the verses trigger memories of studying it in high school English classes where focus and close attention was required . . . No it can't be any of these things, obviously it's because Shakespeare is a genius and put some "genius patterns" in his verses. After all everyone thinks it's true so it must be true. Speaking of which, why is jealousy a green eyed monster anyways? What do green eyed monsters or even green eyes have to do with jealously anyways? what a terrible analogy! Also, who says "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day, thou art more lovely and more temperate." Summers days aren't temperate, they're hot!! What is wrong with this guy? Why does everyone think this nonsense is so great, don't they realize that there are other poets and playwrights who wrote in iambic pentameter? In conclusion, Stephen Booth's research is nonsense, much like Shakespeare.
- puranjay 9y agoI remember when I first had Othello and Marlowe's Doctor Faustus in the same semester. While I liked Othello a lot, I felt that Faustus was a much superior piece of literature, both in the lyrical beauty of its prose and the actual plot. I was also fortunate enough to have a professor who was a huge Marlowe fan. So while most professors obsess too much over Shakespeare, my professor spent a good couple of months on Faustus. Highlight of my academic life.
- gfysfm 9y ago
- zwischenzug 9y agoI was hoping to read about his supposed genius vocabulary, which I did a study of here: https://zwischenzugs.wordpress.com/2011/03/06/shakespeare_unexceptional_vocabulary/ https://zwischenzugs.wordpress.com/2011/03/06/shakespeare_un... my first ever blog post :) I also resent the clickbaity title of the article here.
- olavk 9y agoIt is not clickbaity, it is a clever play on words.
- js8 9y agoIt's an interesting article, although I don't know much about Shakespeare. But it kinda confirms my theory that a good art is like a good puzzle - it requires some (decent) mental effort on the part of the audience to "interpret". And humans have rewards for interpreting data, that's why we like art. Like in a good puzzle, it cannot be too open-ended, because then too many interpretations are possible and there is not enough motivation on the part of casual audience to make something out. On the other hand, it cannot be too straightforward, because then there is only one, obvious interpretation, and that makes the reward for the audience very small. Good puzzles have a balance between those things to maximize the reward/effort ratio involved in solving them. The same is true for art, there has to be enough ambiguity for audience to fill in themselves (leading to satisfaction), but also enough stuff to keep the audience interested.
- simplegeek 9y agoA little off topic. I'm not a native English speaker and am very inclined to start reading Shakespeare soon. Any advice on how to get started? Do I just read his plays first? Any other commentary I should read? Who are the authors whose work in Shakespeare must be read by people like me?
- matt4077 9y agoTo be honest the best intro may be watching the Romeo and Juliet movie–yes, the one with Leonardo di Caprio. The text is unchanged, but the setting is contemporary gangs in Florida (or California?). The on-screen action, as well as hearing the text spoken with all the right rhythm and emotion makes it much easier to get the meaning. As for reading, I believe the Arden Edition are the best-regarded annotations. I somehow ended up playing Macbeth in College and spent hours with the text, but it takes a lot of effort to start enjoying all the nuances, and having to perform may have made it easier to stay motivated. (also non-native English speaker)
- olavk 9y agoThe movie is called Romeo+Juliet :) And agree it is a great version. I'm pretty sure it is supposed to take place in a fictionalized LA - "Verona Beach" is a clever play on "Venice beach" since it allows the characters to just say "Verona" like in the play.
- foxhedgehog 9y agoThere are many reasons why I would recommend the zeffirelli version over this one.
- triplesec 9y agoAlso Polansku's Macbeth, Coriolanus with Anthony Hopkins, and King Lear. . I think there's a Richard Briers version which was really excellent, though you may find others. And of course Olivier's famous Richard III.
- foxhedgehog 9y agoI'd start by watching the plays, maybe start with MSND or R&J.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- orf 9y agoThis article is a bit clickbaity. Shakespeare's genius is most certainly not nonsense, his corpus of work as a playwright is unparalleled in its size and quality. Sure, some of his characters may be a bit flakey and some of his stories 'too drawn out', but the man's genius lies only partly there. His ability to pluck words out of thin air to create his narrative (the man invented 1700 new words!) and give them directly to the people influenced the English language in a way that very few, or indeed any, individual people have done before. He is a wordsmith in a very literal sense. While his comedy night not translate well to other countries or cultures, and some is lost in time, a lot of it is incredibly astute and still very very funny today. He also had a huge influence on the now-classic farce, something that has moved from the stage to the screen still carrying his marks. My mother has seen every single play performed live, so I was taken to quite a few when I was younger and developed a taste for him. The man was a genius.
- phab 9y agoThe point is that the article's title is another "unexploded pun", the principle of which is a central theme to the article; it is referring to Booth's analysis of one of the sources of the Bard's greatness: Shakespeare achieves this by weaving incredibly rich networks from the same kinds of “substantive nonsense and nonimporting patterns” that pop up in slang, jokes, songs, and nursery rhymes. Those dense networks of patterns, Booth posits, are “the principal source of the greatness we find in Shakespeare’s work.” edit: formatting
- rspeer 9y agoDefinitely clickbaity, as the title is intentionally misleading. (Read it as "The literary device named 'nonsense' is something that Shakespeare was genius at".) This is definitely a case where HN should change the title. However, one nonsense claim to watch out for is the claim that Shakespeare invented 1700 new words. Shakespeare is the first recorded use of many words, but that doesn't mean he invented them, it means we care a lot about Shakespeare and preserved his writing better than others'.
- phab 9y agoThe whole point of the article is that ambiguity in interpretation is to be celebrated, which is precisely what we see in the title. The title is an accurate reflection of the content of the essay in this regard. That people are so hung up on interpretation, on meaning, is no more than habit. Better to revel in uncertainty.
- JoeAltmaier 9y ago"Shakespeare - he's that guy that just strung a bunch of cliché's together, right?" Its hard today to appreciate how much he's affected language and thought. We can hardly speak without paying tribute to his works.
- coldtea 9y agoA take a little offense with the "clickbaity" accusation thrown willy nilly. The title translates to something like "Shakespeare's Genius lies in exploiting non-sensical language and sentiment for dramatic effect". It is a kind of pun, using the same kind of structure as the professor's point out Shakespeare was prone to use to drive their point. Is it clickbait? That might have played a factor. But decades before the internet was even a thing, when you couldn't see the title of a piece unless you have already bought the magazine/newspaper, journalists still likes to use such puns and clever wording in their stories. Not just on cover stories ("Headless body in a topless bar") but in stories and regular columns buried deep deep inside the magazine/newspaper. The same also holds true for many people writing in their blogs. They like a good pun / clever title. So maybe we should leave the knee-jerk accusation of "clickbait" where it really belongs? "This guy lost 100lbs with a small trick. Doctors hate him!", "You wont believe what Kim said to Kanye!", etc.