8 ms·
Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release
- ianai 9y agoIf I just read wiki correctly, they set out with the goal of removing systemd and then kept systemd?
- merlincorey 9y agoStatement from the OP: > Devuan is about choice. We think people should be able to choose whether to use a GNU+Linux system with or without systemd. > Devuan decided to fork not only the base distribution, but also its governance, because Debian has made it difficult to avoid systemd as init, entangling the system with unnecessary dependencies and did so despite widespread community concern. We encourage potential Devuan users who wish to install systemd to use Debian’s installer, Debian’s packages and Debian’s mailing lists, all available directly from Debian’s mirrors.
- jhkaghjkga 9y agoSo they now officially recommend Debian to people who value true init freedom?
- i336_ 9y agoNo, > We encourage ... users who wish to install systemd to use Debian.
- flevo 9y agoGreat to see they are making headway. Wonder about the long term sustainability though, as more and more software such as GNOME3 DE lists it as a dependency
- aerique 9y agoThere's also Linux life without Gnome. I hope this means more people will try out alternative window managers.
- bkor 9y agoThis doesn't address the point raised. He mentioned that more and more software relies on systemd giving just one example. IMO not much has changed in the last 2 years. Not too much additional software really relies on systemd. Nor that systemd integrated any other software like it did in the beginning (e.g. merging udev into it). There haven't been too many feature additions as well. What did happen is that way more software ships a systemd conf file, but that's about it.
- belorn 9y agoCould always use the Window manager that is included in the X-Server source code package: TWM. It's dependencies is basically the X-server.
- herewulf 9y agoIf you have ever used TWM, then you would know that the 'T' stands for Terrible. Fortunately, there are lots of lightweight WMs that are far better. Personally, I use tiling WMs (namely XMonad at the moment), so I could really care less what GNOME, KDE, et al are up to. However, I realize most people are accustomed to stacking WMs and expect something similar to what is provided by proprietary OSes with a similar amount of eye candy as well.
- teddyh 9y agoHey now, no need to resort to name-calling. In fact, the “T” originally stood for “Tom”, but the name was later changed so the “T” stood for “Tab” (referring to its then-default look of window titles as little tabs on top of windows). Furthermore, it is not terrible. I’ve used TWM for more than 20 years. It worked perfectly fine for me when I started to use it, and it still does so today, so I have not seen a need to switch.
- bkor 9y agoUnder Debian you can run GNOME under other init systems thanks to Debian+Canonical creating systemd-shim (alternative to logind). Under Devuan you cannot use GNOME (they don't offer it). This as Devuan claims that it is impossible (despite being possible within Debian) (!)
- bigbugbag 9y agoThis task package is used to install the Devuan desktop, featuring the GNOME desktop environment, and with other packages that Devuan users expect to have available on the desktop. https://devuan.org/os/packages/task-gnome-desktop https://devuan.org/os/packages/task-gnome-desktop
- digi_owl 9y agoFor as long as said shim and logind are compatible, and logind is a moving target.
- bigbugbag 9y agoSimply do not use gnome 3 and problem solved. It's a mystery to me that people still associate linux desktop with gnome. The gnome project has a long history of not caring about users or developers and prioritizing their view and their brand.
- digi_owl 9y agoBecause Icaza managed to make Qt, and thus KDE, look bad over a licensing shit storm. It is sadly really how much of Linux DE decisions have been made on political grounds.
- the_why_of_y 9y agoAre you advocating that software such as Qt version 1 as of 1998 that is neither available under a license that meets the FSF's Free Software criteria nor the OSI's Open Source criteria nor Debian's DFSG should be a core part of the GNU/Linux desktop?
- tannhaeuser 9y agoCongrats for following through on Devuan. I'm guessing it took a lot of resolve to make this happen. Should we be worried about the fact that it took over two years to untangle systemd from Debian with respect to Linux in general? In case someone from the Devuan project is around, what alternate init system should maintainers be targetting now for Devuan? OpenRC, classic SysV init, or something else?
- fmoralesc 9y agoFrom https://devuan.org/os/ https://devuan.org/os/ it seems they use sysvinit by default, but they 'offer' runit, openrc and sinit. Dunno what the latter means for maintainers...
- Aissen 9y ago> Should we be worried about the fact that it took over two years to untangle systemd from Debian with respect to Linux in general? The time it took says nothing about the difficulty of the task. It could be very hard with the best hackers working on it full time. It could be the time it takes committees to reach a consensus. Even if it was that hard, is it because systemd is so entangled with the system? Or because it makes maintaining a distro so much easier ?
- notalaser 9y ago> Or because it makes maintaining a distro so much easier ? In my experience, such a general statement is not true of any init system. I had to maintain a systemd-based system (albeit not a general-purpose one) and I was moderately happy. The profiling tools are great and units are easy to write even by people with no Linux development experience (hint: easy to outsource to cheap consultancy firms). On the other hand, it's extremely complex; if you get into trouble with systemd itself, you've got a lot of code reading to do. systemd upstream itself is a pretty volatile target, so you regularly end up with things that used to work three versions ago but now bork. Maybe for a general-purpose distribution like Debian, or for a special-purpose, but server-/cloud-oriented distribution, it makes life easier, but at the other end of the spectrum I wouldn't say it made my life any easier than other init system (albeit not much harder, either).
- doener 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14419189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14419189
- piokoch 9y agoI am not Linux admin, but I've been using Linux managed by others on servers for many, many years and I have a question: Is that 'systemd' thing is so crucial and important to devote so much effort to create brand new Linux distribution. I have only vague picture what systemd is doing, I can imagine that there could be something better (as always in IT), but is this really that important?
- mhd 9y agoFor most users, it wouldn't matter anyway, and I'd argue that that's true even for a lot of the sysadmins. But the argument had a few layers more. Quite a few people agreed that the current init system wasn't exactly the bee's knees, but disagreed on what to use to replace it (systemd, upstart, heck, even Apple's launchd). There was a rather vocal group that didn't actually care that much about the specific implementation either, but but wanted something in the "Unix spirit", i.e. consisting of a more modular base of small components. Systemd pretty much fails that test as much as humanly possible without being J2EE. And it all ended with a bad debate on the Debian mailing list. Can't remember all the details, but the Grand Poobahs were accused of acting a bit too grand. So it wasn't just about the technical merits themselves, but also about philosophy and policy.
- rbanffy 9y agoAs a dev/sysadmin, systemd is barely noticeable when you think if it as an init system. When you look at the cool tricks it can do, it's more like its part of the OS than something living on top of it, providing services you'd expect a kernel to provide (albeit not a very Unix-like one, which is what makes people so mad about it). It's a large and complex beast, doing a lot of different things that make sense in a modern server environment.
- petre 9y agoAsk my users if Apache failing to start on openSuSE because of systemd and lack of ServerName resolution is "barely noticeable".
- ckastner 9y agoI never understood why the Devuan developers could not just contribute their work to Debian directly. Yes, systemd had become the default init system, but the idea that other developers would oppose contributions that would do nothing but improve interoperability is just absurd. To me, this whole "we're forking Debian" thing just feels like a strongly emotional opposition to systemd, not rational solution to the init system problem.
- hd4 9y agoYes it would have made better sense to create some kind of process to switch mainline Debian from systemd to runit, openrc etc.
- bkor 9y agoDebian can already run various init systems. E.g. you can run GNOME under sysvinit. Within Devuan they just removed GNOME. If you want init system choice, run Debian (or e.g. Gentoo). Devuan seems more about hating systemd than any actual choice.
- nottorp 9y agoAs far as i know, systemd is creeping in as a dependency of a lot of unrelated packages - even UI packages. So you can have a Debian that doesn't run systemd, perhaps, but not a Debian that doesn't depend on bits of pieces of the systemd OS any more.
- bkor 9y agoYou have a tiny systemd library which does little more than checking if systemd is running. It's a helper library for doing that check. Within Devuan they didn't want this dependency, but that's unrelated from being able to use software under another init system. There's a huge difference between not accepting any dependency with systemd in the name vs being able to use another init system. That some software has a dependency does NOT mean that the software is restricted to only run under systemd.
- softwarelimits 9y agoDoes anybody know how many people are working on this and how many people are working on the security team?
- bkor 9y agoThe major contributors are listed here: https://devuan.org/os/team/ https://devuan.org/os/team/. Either they don't mention packagers specifically or they don't have a lot of them. They didn't fork too many packages, so security handling should be fairly easy. They plan to offer support for a longer period than Debian. I don't think they'll be able to based on my experience contributing to a slightly bigger distribution (e.g. maybe 30-40 packagers) whom are lagging behind on security updates.
- partycoder 9y agoSome things that need work: - The logo. Logos are very affordable. I would consider revisiting this logo, buying a new one or organizing a contest. Believe it or not, many people use t-shirts with the Debian logo and I assume that's some source of revenue stream. I do not see myself wearing a Devuan t-shirt with this logo. Right not it looks like a logo for a UFO cult or some cheap Internet cafe. - The information on the landing page should be organized to emphasize what is important for each type of experience. e.g: dividing it into info for users, info for prospect contributors, info for existing contributors, and donation (what and how to donate, and what is done with donations). Try to interleave these roles less and summarize more. Then, I would like to understand what the key differences are with Debian, also what specifically does "control over your system" mean?
- kk_cz 9y agoI agree, this logo looks terrible.
- walterbell 9y agoAny recommendation on logo designers?
- partycoder 9y agoA friend commissioned a logo through a website where you get proposals from multiple artists. He had the chance to buy a fantastic logo for a very affordable price. I don't know the name of this website but my HN family here surely knows. Someone?
- sethammons 9y agoThe website needs some work. I could gather they were a fork of Debian, but I couldn't find the benefits. I had to come to the HN comments to learn about the systemd controversy. Less important, the mobile experience was not good on Android Chrome. When scrolling, the logo visibility toggles and the page content jumps.
- appleflaxen 9y agoat the very bottom of the page it addresses it: > Devuan is about choice. We think people should be able > to choose whether to use a GNU+Linux system with or > without systemd. > Devuan decided to fork not only the base distribution, > but also its governance, because Debian has made it > difficult to avoid systemd as init, entangling the system > with unnecessary dependencies and did so despite... but you're right that it makes sense to put it in a more obvious location, given that it seems to be the reason the project exists.
- sethammons 9y agothanks; I missed that
- johnnycarcin 9y agoIt's likely that I missed it, but I can't find anywhere that talks about how many packages deviate from Debian. I love what they are offering but I also want to make sure that the ease of use I get with Debian continues with Devuan. Can we assume that any packages that are not Gnome related from the Debian repos are in the Devuan repos?
- herewulf 9y agoThis video[0] (dated Nov 29, 2016) says 381 forked packages. That's not nearly as bad as it sounds because many individual software projects are divided up into multiple packages. For example, libvirt[1] produces 9 packages consisting of: libvirt-bin, libvirt-clients, libvirt-daemon, libvirt-daemon-system, libvirt0, libvirt0-dbg, libvirt-doc, libvirt-dev, libvirt-sanlock. The video is rather interesting for learning about how the project came about and how it works in general. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMvyOGawNwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMvyOGawNwo [1]: https://git.devuan.org/devuan-packages/libvirt/blob/master/debian/control https://git.devuan.org/devuan-packages/libvirt/blob/master/d...
- arca_vorago 9y agoNobody wants to hear this, but I have strong suspicions NSA worked with Red Hat to make systemd their backdoor of choice for Linux systems, and I highly praise efforts to offer diversity in in it land regardless if I'm right or not.
- throw2016 9y agoIt's great that they have released and it's important there are options so users are not locked-in to a single init. We need to do more to ensure projects do not create lock-ins especially gratuitous ones from single companies that make it difficult for people to use for instance Gnome without systemd. This kind of lock-in can only lead to bad outcomes and make developing future alternatives and improvements more difficult. Also its time Systemd defines a scope and decouple and brand any additional functionality beyond an init differently so it makes it easier to inter-operate and pick and choose both for users or distributions. Or you have distributions like Debian for instance voting for an init system but getting all the externalities that were not voted for ending up becoming defacto choices.
- keithpeter 9y agoDevuan Jessie with Wicd on a Thinkpad X220. All just works. Enables the non-free repository (iwlwifi drivers installed out of box) if that matters to you.