10 ms·
The problem is we're moving extremely fast to a chrome only world. If it wasn't for corporate sites and the success of the iPhone chrome would probably be domin
by MBCook 9y ago
The problem is we're moving extremely fast to a chrome only world. If it wasn't for corporate sites and the success of the iPhone chrome would probably be dominating the way IE used to.
I definitely run into sites that only work on chrome and not in any other browser.
In my opinion chrome isn't doing a good job either. It's a massive energy hog and waste more CPU than it needs to. Unlike IE and FireFox and Safari it comes from a company that is notorious for wanting to know everything about you.
The time to celebrate victory was a few years ago. Now it's starting to look like the new boss is the same as the old, maybe worse.
- zacmps 9y agoChrome is improving on the resource usage front. It's far from perfect but it's getting better. As for privacy you could use the open source chromium, there's a fork somewhere which has all the Google removed.
- wolco 9y agoOn windows firefox does everything in one thread while chrome opens many. Depending on the usage both can be fast or slow. Firefox handles multiple tabs better. Chrome handles multiple tabs of videos better
- krzyk 9y agoChrome handles few tabs better, Firefox handles hundreds of tabs better.
- imron 9y agoAnd that's one of the reasons why, with my hundreds of tabs open, I don't use Chrome.
- dEnigma 9y agoThis ultimately was what made me switch back to Firefox after I had used Chrome for a couple of years. I regularly have several hundred tabs opened in my browser, and Chrome was completely unusable in that situation, at least back then.
- PatentTroll 9y agoHonest question: why do you use hundreds of tabs at the same time? Why not bookmarks and leave a couple of the most important ones open? I have never understood the use case for "hundreds" of browser tabs
- 659087 9y agoIf you want to be 10x, you need at least 10 stackoverflow tabs open to copy and paste from. I've always assumed people talking about having hundreds of tabs open just don't understand how to properly use a browser. My grandmother, for example, usually has 100 or so open by the time I get a call about her having computer problems. There's no logical reason I can come up with for doing this instead of using bookmarks.
- nirvdrum 9y agoI have a lot of tabs open. Not multiples of hundreds at the moment, but probably around 100. I use the same computer for work and personal, so I have different contexts I switch through at least once a day. Increasingly, things are becoming web apps, so I have a dozen just to do basic tasks these days: email, multiple chat clients, music player, code repository, issue tracker, Twitter, online office suite, etc. Sure, I could bookmark and close and re-open every time, but that's a waste of time when I want to quickly switch back to something. And not every app has sensible bookmarking semantics. Then throughout the course of the day I end up looking up API docs, get linked to blog posts, news articles, and YouTube videos, and read articles which themselves have relevant links to follow. Most of these I just open in a background tab to check out later in the day. These accumulate until I have time to go through and quickly review them. Those that I want to read and don't have the time currently go to Pocket. The rest get read or summarily closed out. I find bookmarks to be a terrible way to triage tabs. This workflow works for me (and evidently others). It's faster than bookmarking. It's less prone to failure, in my experience (I've suffered bookmark corruption more than once). And a modern computer ought to handle many background tabs just fine. Moreover, if browsers aren't expected to be used in this fashion, they really should set an upper-limit on the number of tabs that can be opened. Hopefully this gives you some perspective on alternative use cases. It sounds like your workflow works out well for you. I've tried it and couldn't get it to stick. If that means I don't know how to use a browser, so be it. At this point, there's enough of us (your grandmother included) that maybe the browser vendors should just find a way to cope with it better.
- sp332 9y agoThis hasn't been true since last August when it hit release. Multi-process (which I'm assuming you meant instead of multi-thread) has been enabled by default since January, except in specific cases where it's likely to cause compatibility issues. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis#Schedule https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis#Schedule
- zokula 9y agoSigh ntsa. Firefox on my Windows 10 machine right now is using 81 threads. Firefox has used many threads for over 10 years at least.
- petre 9y agoOne of the privacy enhanced Cromium clones is called Iridium Browser. https://iridiumbrowser.de/ https://iridiumbrowser.de/
- MBCook 9y agoI find it shameful they ever let it become such an incredible energy hog in the first place. It's been well known for years among mini Mac people that you can get drastically better battery life by using Safari. I mean it wasn't like it was a 10 or 15% problem, it's orders of magnitude. It's nice there working on it, but why didn't they ever care before?
- themihai 9y agoSafari sucks under heavy usage
- campuscodi 9y ago"getting better" ?!?! Chrome using less resources than Firefox and IE was their sales pitch. Now they've become what they made fun of, while Firefox is smooth as a baby's butt.
- ekianjo 9y agoNo firefox actually uses more and more memory after each.build. check the stats available, the trend is very clear even in Firefox.
- pythonaut_16 9y agoChrome being faster and less bloated was their sales pitch. Keep in mind that Chrome came out as a counterpoint to IE and Firefox in what was then still a very desktop centered market. No one was talking about battery life back then. The solution to battery life on laptops was to create better power profiles, lower powered hardware, and shove in bigger batteries. Chrome is still a huge improvement compared to the browsers it was competing against. Chrome changed the market and now the other browsers are competing in the world Chrome created. So while Chrome might fall behind in some areas now, it's naive to say that it's become what they made fun of.
- josefx 9y agoThe sad thing is you can't trust chromium since it takes effort to keep the Google out. We already had one black box DRM module sneak its way in via background download because the commits aren't checked for sneaky code.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago"The problem is we're moving extremely fast to a chrome only world. If it wasn't for corporate sites and the success of the iPhone chrome would probably be dominating the way IE used to." "Always after a defeat and a respite, the Shadow takes another shape and grows again." -- Gandalf
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 9y agoGreat Tolkien quote.
- nojvek 9y agoWell its not the same boss again. Sure Chrome has a massive market share. But even Today's MS Edge is not open. I used to work for the Edge team and the directors never really gave Open Source a serious thought. It was too tied to windows. I am glad Edge doesn't have the market share that Chrome has. Chrome works on every platform. It hogs memory but its fast. Chromium & v8 are open. This is the kind of things that gave us Electron, nodejs and everything that is built on top of it. I appreciate Google for working on it. Regarding privacy, I totally agree. Would be nice if the most popular web browser wasn't developed by the world's biggest ad company. I still think they do a descent job of isolating the two orgs. I can technically install extensions that stop much of the ad invasions.
- btschaegg 9y ago> Well its not the same boss again. So you're saying that Chrome is but a Sauron to IE's Morgoth? ;-)
- bzbarsky 9y ago> Chrome works on every platform. Except anything MIPS-based. Or Power. Or in fact anything that isn't x86 or ARM. And it's not just a matter of compiling it for those platforms. There's a bunch of architecture-specific porting that would have to be done (e.g. you _have_ to implement a V8 backend; there is no platform-independent way to run V8 just with a C++ compiler).
- leephillips 9y agoI use Firefox and haven't run into this problem. I guess I've been lucky. Why Firefox rather than Chrome? On my Google Chromebook (original Pixel), Chrome (the last versions I tried) are almost completely unusable - it hogs all the CPU until it crawls to a stop and needs to be killed. Even if they fix that, I'm not going back, however, because Firefox's handling of text is so immensely superior. It was bad years ago¹ and it's still terrible. One contemporary example: hyphenation support. ¹https://lee-phillips.org/google-chromeBadKerning/ https://lee-phillips.org/google-chromeBadKerning/
- oxide 9y agoThe most specific example I can think of is the sears credit card site, I couldn't pay the bill with Firefox, so I keep a Chrome installation handy for the occasion a site doesn't work.
- dblohm7 9y agoYou can report issues like this to webcompat.com
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoBofA has some flash-based services which I have to switch from FF to Chrome in order to use, sigh.
- SomeCallMeTim 9y agoGoogle products, which I can't get away from, are starting to fail completely on Firefox. I've run into several other complex sites that fail on Firefox. It's sad, because I've used it for years. I'm using it right now. But my default just switched to Chrome because I started having too many Firefox issues.
- khedoros1 9y agoHmm. I use Pale Moon and rarely have problems. Maybe I'm just not creative enough about the websites I visit.
- Arizhel 9y ago>Unlike IE and FireFox and Safari it comes from a company that is notorious for wanting to know everything about you. That's not true. Microsoft has now gotten into the spying business, and is infamous for the Windows 10 telemetry. They're basically copying Google. Firefox and Safari are the only ones that come from companies that aren't notorious for wanting to know everything about you. And Firefox doesn't try to get you to spend scads of money on massively overpriced but mediocre hardware that locks you into their ecosystem. Firefox has its warts, but it's the only choice that really makes sense if you care about privacy and freedom and avoiding vendor lock-in.
- MBCook 9y agoI see telemetry as fundamentally different from the kind of data that you want to use to push advertising to people.
- imron 9y agoSo you think the telemetry is not going to help with things like this? https://www.extremetech.com/computing/245553-microsoft-now-puts-ads-windows-file-explorer https://www.extremetech.com/computing/245553-microsoft-now-p...
- _jal 9y agoThere is no clear line to be drawn between the two, and it really depends on the use to which the data is put, something that's opaque to end users. Sure, error reporting feeding in to a QA database is one thing. But is there the capability to target Win10 OS ads to, say, folks with old video cards? I'd be very surprised if someone in Redmond didn't think of that.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> The problem is we're moving extremely fast to a chrome only world. If it wasn't for corporate sites and the success of the iPhone chrome would probably be dominating the way IE used to. I definitely run into sites that only work on chrome and not in any other browser. This hasn't happened to me in a while, except for occasionally government or bank sites which require "IE or Chrome". In many cases, spoofing the user agent works just fine for those. I agree it's bad, though. The one exception I've noticed is Yubikey (U2F) support for Google services. Firefox has an add-on that provides Yubikey support, but last I checked, Google blocked access to those (I believe even if you spoof the user-agent).
- technion 9y agospoofing the user agent works fine I'm continually upset by this. If you know you rely on, for example, the fetch() api, test for the fetch api[0]. Whitelisting browser user agents just means chasing your tail for forever. By all means, politely warn a user that "your browser is not tested". It's getting to feel like a marketing driven decision, where pages just about say "our site is so powerful, we only work with the greatest browser ever, Chrome, so come back when you have it". A local airbnb competitor currently does this. [0] https://philipwalton.com/articles/loading-polyfills-only-when-needed/ https://philipwalton.com/articles/loading-polyfills-only-whe...
- chx 9y agoTry http://www.linksys.com/us/special-deals-and-refurbished/c/Refurbished/ http://www.linksys.com/us/special-deals-and-refurbished/c/Re... buying a refurbished router from Linksys with anything but IE. When you click Guest Checkout your cart will be empty. Dead end.
- bdcravens 9y agoWasn't my experience. (latest Chrome on latest MacOS)
- fnord123 9y agoI've had this on sites that switch domain for the checkout process while I had cookie killer installed. Leaving the first domain dumped the cookies and hence the basket.
- dEnigma 9y agoWorks fine for me in Firefox Nightly
- nialv7 9y agoTo be honest, all browsers currently on market are energy hogs and use massive amount of memory. God I miss the old Opera....
- vanderZwan 9y agoI do wonder how much of that is the browser's fault, and how much is because of website developers not understanding that we have a website obesity problem[0], nor the concept of "optimizing for fan noise"[1]. I'm fairly conscientious about this myself since I'm working on plotting data, and the dumb client-side number crunching involved is actually pretty good at eating CPU cycles. Most plotting libraries want to show off how smooth and incredible their animations are. What I really want to know however is: does your library keep updating the canvas at 60FPS, or does it only refresh when the data does and idle otherwise? [0] http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm [1] http://prog21.dadgum.com/61.html http://prog21.dadgum.com/61.html
- wordupmaking 9y agoBoth, since browser these days don't even show the number of connections and download speed for a loading page, much less an indicator for high CPU usage. I'm not saying displaying this stuff would be enough by itself, but hiding what is going on just so we can have a slightly bigger viewport into unicolor surfaces with huge padding and line spacing certainly doesn't help. I know there are all sorts of flags etc, but consider old Opera, where switching the status bar between none, simple and advanced was right there in one of the main menus. That was a good start, that stuff would be compact and super useful by now if we'd just keep going.
- WorldMaker 9y agoF12 has becomes something of the universal key for Dev Tools in the browsers. It's not compact, but it is super useful and does have all the information and more. Most browsers even offer Profilers to get detailed stats on CPU and Memory usage. Sure, it doesn't explain to average users why the webpages they view might be slow, but average users don't care.
- microcolonel 9y ago> Unlike IE and FireFox and Safari it comes from a company that is notorious for wanting to know everything about you. Are you suggesting that Chrome gathers data about you? Because unless you tick that box (which they show pretty prominently) it doesn't. It doesn't by default in most linux distribution packages. > Unlike IE I don't know if you've been following, but Microsoft is now the king of knowing everything about you. They record things about their customers' computer activity which should horrify anyone. Sometimes they don't respect user selections either, even all the way up to Enterprise editions (where it is often mission-critical not to send competitive information to Microsoft by accident in a core dump), which is infuriating. > In my opinion chrome isn't doing a good job either. It's a massive energy hog and waste more CPU than it needs to. My impression is that at this point, most unique performance problems in Chrome are either an inherent cost of multi-process, a mediocre implementation choice in that model, or a performance tradeoff toward better application latency at the cost of heavy initialization. Chrome could display many pages more quickly if they ignored the GPU, but they use it across the board so that they don't have to restart into "GPU mode" when they realize there is a lot of compositing on the page. Chrome has converged toward other browsers recently, they'll now run multiple tabs on the same process as long as they share a FQDN (sites that host together, crash together), I suspect they do this to save memory. If we're talking about runtime speed of real web apps and sites, Chrome has everyone matched or beat. > The time to celebrate victory was a few years ago. Now it's starting to look like the new boss is the same as the old, maybe worse. The problem with IE6 was not Microsoft, or IE6 itself. Microsoft did not win by literally forcing people to use IE6. The problem was, and probably always will be, greedy unscrupulous web developers (and their managers) who want all the cool new toys at any cost. Microsoft was doing the cool, "html5, bro!" type browser innovation that google is doing now, and developers (and their managers) lapped it up. People forget that Microsoft made box-model: border-box, XMLHttpRequest, favicons, <ruby>, and bi-directional text on the web. They did this all in IE5, this put IE6 ahead, and people loved it too. Microsoft did the right thing and didn't break compat for honest customers who just wanted their webpage to work, so IE5 quirks are the way of the web. The problem is not that nobody likes the boss, the problem is that everyone likes the boss.
- toyg 9y ago> People forget that Microsoft made box-model No, I didn't forget. But you forgot to say that MS did all that with draft specifications or even no spec at all (XMLHttpRequest), just to beat everyone to market, then refused to correct their implementation once the standard was revised and agreed by others. And they sprinkled ActiveX on top, for good measure. > developers (and their managers) lapped it up Disagree. Developers were the ones that pushed Mozilla and then Firefox (and then Chrome) as soon as they could. > Microsoft did the right thing and didn't break compat Microsoft did the right thing for their own bank account: they smashed the competition with bundling then left IE to flounder, even obliterating their dedicated team, because they had reached their objective, which was to dominate the web so that they could sell what they really cared about: ActiveX and other Windows-only technologies. > the problem is that everyone likes the boss. No, the problem is that people are lazy. IE won with OEM bundling on Windows. Chrome is winning with OEM bundling on Android. As long as the default is good enough, people won't switch, especially 15 years ago when downloads took a degree of effort (waiting several minutes, restarting after failure etc etc) and now on mobile where it is awkward and/or completely forbidden to switch browser. This is basically what the article says as well: they couldn't push a browser, they had to push an OS with a browser bundled. If people don't switch, developers can't build for alternative browsers, because their managers won't allow the additional time and effort.
- ryandrake 9y agoI think a "Chrome only" world like the IE-only world we had years ago is a long way away. I don't know how long Chrome has been out, but in that time I have literally never used it. I've never needed to. I could not have made that statement about IE during its heyday. It was nearly impossible to use PCs in any way without using Microsoft. If you never got to experience the Internet in the late nineties, early 2000s, you have no idea how dominant Microsoft was.
- johnsmith21006 9y ago> I think a "Chrome only" world like the IE-only world we had years ago is a long way away. "Microsoft has lost over 300 million browser users in 2016, mostly to Chrome, tracking site shows" Not going to take very long at this rate. Appears to be accelerating. Personally just use Chrome as for me extremely stable and when tried Edge it was not stable. I do a lot of surfing and often times have a lot of tabs open and can not remember the last time a tab crashed.
- user5994461 9y ago"I definitely run into sites that only work on chrome and not in any other browser." You spend too much time working lurking around HN sites and young web developers.
- senorjazz 9y agoI run into it occasionally, but it is usually caused by plugins. If I just cannot be bothered to try to figure out which of the 100+ JS files needs to be allowed or what ublock green / red / + / - bit I have to click (I admit I have no idea what they refer to) sometimes I just quickly open the page in chrome.
- tedmielczarek 9y agoOr using Google web properties: https://www.ghacks.net/2017/04/18/google-makes-the-new-google-earth-chrome-exclusive/ https://www.ghacks.net/2017/04/18/google-makes-the-new-googl... https://support.google.com/hangouts/answer/7334146?hl=en https://support.google.com/hangouts/answer/7334146?hl=en https://www.theverge.com/2015/2/19/8068697/google-inbox-email-app-available-ipads-safari-firefox https://www.theverge.com/2015/2/19/8068697/google-inbox-emai... (4 months after launch)
- AmIFirstToThink 9y ago>The problem is we're moving extremely fast to a chrome only world. May be. I see this as truly the case of making the pie bigger. All devices include 2 Billion Android devices. That's a bigger pie that Chrome owns now, but FireFox can target in future.
- true_tuna 9y agoI switched to Opera recently. Got sick of finding Chrome hogging insane amounts of resources. I'm quite happy with it (built in VPN and Adblock!) I don't feel like anyone is trying to force me back to Chrome. Choice and competition are key. Chrome and Firefox did great things, but never forget that competition is the real hero.
- kuntau 9y agoI don't know if you're serious or not. But current Opera engine is the same as Chrome; Blink.
- kkruglov 9y agoyes, but it works better in terms of start-up speed, battery life, looks more native (at least on windows 10).
- beerbaron23 9y agoSame engine but it is tweaked heavily to run lighter and they have a nice power saving mode as well. Watch out for Opera's add block, it works through a proxy to compress data, thus they know your every move online too...
- true_tuna 9y agoI switched to Opera recently. Got sick of finding Chrome hogging insane amounts of resources. I'm quite happy with it (built in VPN and Adblock!) I don't feel like anyone is trying to force me back to Chrome. Choice and competition are key. Chrome and Firefox did great things, but never forget that competition is the real hero.