18 ms·
What I Learned When Facebook Disabled My Account (2012)
- pqwEfkvjs 9y agoPretty weird, I have been operating a number of fake accounts for spamming, trolling and information retrieval purposes for years and never got a single account blocked. I've only got challenges to identify people in pictures if too many people deny your friend request in some time window. But this is easy to solve as you can see the faces by searching their name in second window.
- johnchristopher 9y agoThe article is from 2012. Not that I have seen Facebook changing its ways, anyway.
- basicplus2 9y agoAm I reading it correctly that this guy never actually found out why his Facebook account was disabled?
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 9y agoSort of. Facebook never told him. But he guessed that it was because of either real name policy or more likely because one of his clients ran a single semi spamy marketing campaign.
- covercash 9y agoThat site is struggling under the HN load. Maybe they should have optimized prior to today?
- onurozkan 9y agoI hope he learned new things after this load.
- jauer 9y agoFrom 2012. This part is quite dated: "Facebook can disable your account if your display name is different than that on your birth certificate".
- GoToRO 9y agoRight. Now they make you upload a photo with your full face showing. No need for certificate. Just create a new account, now.
- helloindia 9y agoFrom my experience, it's nearly impossible to get help from Facebook/Instagram if what you need is not listed in their help page. I used to have two Insta accounts and two FB accounts(personal & professional). When Instagram released a new version to add multiple insta accounts, I did the mistake of adding my work account. But Insta was so buggy that it merged my imported FB friend list of both my Insta accounts. This incident made me never trust Insta/FB/Whatsapp again.
- tajen 9y agoSlack has a flawless multi-account implementation, which surprised me in this era where corporates try to aggressively create links between our accounts (import/suggest users, merge, or share the advertising ID). But, for example, if you do politically controversial activity on one Twitter account [1], I wouldn't add it in the multi-profile iPhone app: I would be too afraid of being banned from one and losing all accounts together, or the identity of all accounts be shared with law enforcement. I wonder what Chrome shares between multi-accounts profiles, but I have low trust in it for isolating data. [1] I criticize my city's law enforcement, by filming where crime happens, where the police really is and the faults they do. I don't think it's illegal but I still wouldn't want my identity shared to them.
- krylon 9y agoOn the one hand, I cannot help but feel for this person - Facebook, without an explanation, did significant damage to this person's career. At least that's the way he paints it (though he mentions a rule in his mailbox that deleted mail from facebook automatically, so there might have been a warning and all that - we'll never know). On the other hand, well, that is precisely what some people warned us of - give a single company that much power, and it will inevitably be abused, be it by malice or incompetence. But it is not easy to give any useful advice, because there is basically no alternative to facebook - you can go with the flow or stay away from it. But there is not "something like Facebook without all the problems that come with it being a single large profit-driven corporation". The only solution I can think of is for lots and lots of people to pool their money and start a non-profit Facebook. And even then, I am not overly optimistic, because by now the network effect is far too strong.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoYou can slightly mitigate this particular problem mentioned in the article (the author used it to manage FB pages): I always use at least 2 personal accounts for managing a FB page. One is actively used whereas the other one is just a backup in case something happens to the first one. Redundancy is always important, also in social media.
- tajen 9y agoHow did you create 2 fb accounts? Don't they ask for phone number confirmation?
- rwmj 9y agoI don't think so. I have 3 accounts (I never use any of them, or FB at all, these days, but they are all still active). None of them are in my real name, but all have plausible-sounding names.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoI have several private FB accounts. I created them when text message verification wasn't required. But if I had to do it now, I'd have bought a couple of cheap SIM cards and still set it up the same way. I feel it's important to split your account into several ones instead of using groups of friends as recommended by FB. It's harder to profile and track you, you have more freedom and privacy in expressing yourself, you mitigate several risks etc. Only one of these accounts has my real name - I log in every couple of weeks and just accept invitations (if I care to). The other ones use common names to protect my privacy. For example, I have a separate account for reviews. Reviews are important tool for consumers to influence the quality of service/product. While I don't want to hide behind a fake name when writing a review, and if asked I can reveal my identity to the organisation in charge of the product/service, I definitely don't want everyone to see what products/services I'm using. That's just one example - if you have to use social media, do it in such a way you have at least some control in this unequal battle.
- Jaruzel 9y agoI know the article is old, but the author showed a severe lack of common sense. Facebook is NOT a backup. If you only keep stuff in your Facebook account, then it is as 'at risk' as if you only kept on the hard-drive of your ageing laptop that you bought on discount in Walmart/ASDA ten years ago. This oft quoted adage also applies: 'If you are not paying for the product, then you are the product'. The author seemed to think that Facebook owe him for some reason, and that he is fully justified/entitled in begging for his account back. Facebook is a private company who most of the time let the general public mingle in the lobby of its HQ[1]. As their lobby is still their property, they can refuse entry whenever they like. Something needs to be done about Facebook's near dominance of the Social Media space. If we let this run unchecked for much longer, there won't be an 'internet' - just millions of stale, abandoned websites all simply redirecting you to their respective Facebook Pages instead. It also wouldn't surprise me if at some point, new phones will be released where the browser app is no longer installed by default, but the Facebook app is. Even if this happened today, most non-technical users wouldn't even notice. --- [1] Because the lobby is full of adverts from Facebook's business partners and Facebook gets a nice cut if you buy something being advertised.
- kolinko 9y agoIn theory that's where consumer protection and antitrust laws should kick in.
- gizmo686 9y agoThere is another option. Consider sites like Facebook to be public accommodations, and create new laws regulating acceptable behavior of digital public accommodations. Facebook is a significant part of our society. It is not clear why it should be free democratic oversight.
- bduerst 9y agoThey'll just title themselves as a "private club", like other organizations that wanted to continue discriminating after public accommodations were enacted. And in all fairness, FB originally started that way when you needed a university email address to join.
- Joeri 9y agoIf this happened, then under the EU data directive facebook would be obligated to still provide all data they have on someone even after they disable their account. So, the data would not be gone as long as it was not deleted.
- Jaruzel 9y agoSite down. Cached copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20170525042302/http://www.optimizationtoday.com/social-media/what-i-learned-when-facebook-disabled-my-account/ https://web.archive.org/web/20170525042302/http://www.optimi...
- mnm1 9y agoThis applies to almost any online service including Amazon, Google, etc. Basically, these services are so unreliable and risky that using them for anything critical is dangerous. Even if you pay for them. They can and will shut down accounts for no reason. That is a risk people should be more aware of. Since the services are not dependable, it's a mistake to depend on them.
- tajen 9y agoI run my whole company on a Digital Ocean account. I'm frightened at the idea of the account being suddenly shut, for example if I miss a payment and the process had a bug.
- ggm 9y agoThe meta-lesson from this, is that hosted domains, services have to meet the AUP of the host, and your SLA with the host has to cover off on dispute or you are in a high risk situation. I have a personal domain hosted at google. I stand at risk of having them close the google account but retention of the domain is outside of that situation, I would need to be rejected by both google, and the dns registrar to lose all control of that personal domain (not impossible. not unlikely if google WAS my dns registrar). I might lose the data, but I can at least have continuity of service at my own risk levels if I do some basic minimum of holding copies off the domain or managing the state of the domain outside of google. In facebook, this is just a lot harder. There is no outside. The tools to upload and manage content as a small enterprise are much less clear to me. What I've seen suggests most people treat it as the repo, and write into it as the repo, and operate in it. They don't upload to it from an external state or use an API. But it would be true in AWS, in any hosted solution, in any space which you think is your space, but is actually a brand like myspace: if you don't own it, you run it under their terms and conditions. Its a contract. you might not like it, but that 30 page ream of randomly mutating text T&C matters. I've talked to people who got shut out. It sure hurts. I do not like to think what I would lose, should I fall into breach of my T&C or be detected as being in breach, and blackhole the notices. My colleagues who do, or did work in google say that whilst it looks arbitrary, if you respect their mails of warning and commitment, if you reply in sequence through the hoops, you can survive being called out. If you dis-respect their sequence, or try to avoid hoops, you will suffer. My experience with FB is similar, helping persians who suffered abuse of yahoo emails by opponents of their world view, marked as recovery accounts for facebook pages. If you do the right sequence (mutating) of things with FB, you can recover. But its not well documented at any specific point in time what that sequence is and you cannot easily get third parties to help you.
- ghaff 9y agoThe reality is that you are always subject to T&Cs and decisions of a wide range of third-party service providers. Even in the most independent case, you're probably still dependent on domain registrars and one or more ISPs--as well as being affected by the actions of organizations like Spamhaus. What you can (and often should) do for critical services is to use providers that don't create huge dependencies on a particular provider. It's probably a lot easier to switch from sites hosted on Digital Ocean to AWS than it is from Facebook to X. Furthermore, if you're hosting sites on a site that actually exists for that purpose, I have a lot more confidence I'll be able to work through issues than one hosting sites more or less incidentally (as in the case of Facebook).
- suhastech 9y agoBig companies don't owe you anything by hosting the files for you, because you are the product. Something similar happened to me in 2012 but with a Gmail account[1]. So, I built an app to backup my emails. The whole ordeal, in hindsight, was the best thing that could happen to me, it taught me a good lesson on data sovereignty in the internet world and opened up a small passive income stream. [1] https://thehorcrux.com/why-i-built-horcrux-app/ https://thehorcrux.com/why-i-built-horcrux-app/
- JetSpiegel 9y agoYeah, I too was a victim of a random Gmail ban without warning or recourse, so I stopped using webmail ask together and keep all my mail local.
- suhastech 9y agoAgreed. I always tell people I know to atleast use an email address with their own domain, if they can't set up their own server. https://thehorcrux.com/about/#advise https://thehorcrux.com/about/#advise
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoIn one line, you said Google disabled your account. In another line, you say have your own domain and let FastMail or google apps manage your mail. I don't understand ./?
- leni536 9y ago1. You can still backup your email if you want to. 2. You get to keep your email address if you ever get banned. I do not think there any benefit in operating your own mail server.
- MikeVanBike 9y agoI learn to quit facebook very early days. I don't like the privacy violations or that big brother spying you feeling. Also account deletions are happening to everyone who talk against facebook. Crooked as google. Both really disappointing services all the way. People, please use alternatives
- smeroth 9y agoAlternatives to Facebook that's not made by Google?
- jaitaiwan 9y agoMastodon somewhat I guess
- dredmorbius 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_social https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_social https://gnu.io/social/ https://gnu.io/social/
- mxuribe 9y agoGNU social AND/OR mastodon...They're compatible with each other (though not 100%, the basics work across each other), because they use the same underlying protocol!
- marenkay 9y agoConsider not using Facebook at all. It has zero value for the user, it only has value for Facebook.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoFacebook has enormous value for the user. They didn't get this popular by accident. They provide a wonderful service, and they chain it to acceptance of their awful terms. Imagining that your use case is the only use case is the great bane of geeks and developers. If you want to help build a world without awful tech companies, you need to stop doing that.
- turc1656 9y agoI have to agree with Marenkay. I left Facebook a long time ago and haven't missed it on bit. There was some minimal value, I suppose, in being able to have anyone contact me if they didn't have my email. And possibly organize invites for events. All of this is, of course, possible without Facebook, they just made it easier. However, the real issue is the secret cost of Facebook far outweighs any benefit the user derives. Also, the reason Facebook is popular is not because it adds extraordinary value for the user, it's because it caters to things like curiosity, narcissism, and ego that reside in all of us. It's feeding those things that keep the user hooked and coming back. Not "value". The extraordinary value you speak of is what the shareholders have.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoAgain, your use case is not the only use case. Facebook doesn't provide value for you, and that's perfectly reasonable. But at this point you're basically a guy who doesn't care for falafel standing outside a packed falafel restaurant trying to figure out what character flaw drives people to eat there, since obviously they can't just like falafel. I don't use Facebook much, in part because of how awful its policies are, but when I do use it, it remains a fantastic tool for keeping in touch with friends. At this point someone always declares that it's actually just narcissism, because email and IM exist and nobody actually needs Facebook, which is a lot like someone 20 years ago declaring that this email thing is just a fad because we already have phones and mail.
- snakeanus 9y agoAnd this is why we should move away from services with a centralised point of failure.
- antihero 9y agoI think the worst thing that they do is disable your ability to send messages. This weekend a friend committed suicide, and I had just started a seven day ban due to idiotically posting the wrong photo (a nude) to a meme group. Whereas most of my closest friends have me on WhatsApp, so I could reassure them I was ok, it was really fucking horrible getting a bunch of Messenger messages asking if I was ok and being completely unable to respond to them. Poor timing I know, but if they expect people to use and depend upon Messenger, it's actually really irresponsible to take away the ability for people to communicate with each other, plus I see no benefit in doing that. Most of my friends I eventually managed to get in contact with in other ways, but others I couldn't. Sure it's technically my fault for posting smut whilst drunk, but hindsight is 20/20 and we all make mistakes. Furthermore, there appears to be absolutely no form of appeals process or a way to say, get the ban suspended due to it being some messed up times. With great power comes great responsibility.
- King-Aaron 9y agoI know it's not directly on-topic, but I find it amazing that people end up copping a seven-day ban for a bit of titty, but then nothing is done for those videos of people killing puppies and shit.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThere are plenty of racist extremist kooks on FB, and their posts are rarely - if ever - banned. Apparently a stray nipple is more of a threat to society.
- InitialLastName 9y agoA stray nipple is a cheaper binary test than "above some threshold of ideological hatefulness"
- jjnoakes 9y ago"cheaper binary test" shouldn't be the way to decide though.
- faragon 9y agoTL;DR: don't use Facebook for messaging, nor as disk backup for photos.
- zamalek 9y ago> So what did I learn from my experience with Facebook? Back up your account! You never know if/when they’ll decide to delete you. Just delete your account. Find a way to share your photos without any of this nonsense: Google Drive, OneDrive, Dropbox, Flickr. Not only do you run the risk of Facebook deleting your stuff, but [when I still had an account] it was was a dreadful UX for exploring photos. Use products built for photos if you want to get the most out of your photos.
- barking 9y agoYes. Thankfully I've never felt the inclination to join Facebook and reading stories like this just makes me angry at Facebook and at people for making them so powerful.
- NuDinNou 9y agoI get the idea that you need a more serious back up for your personal stuff. But what's wrong with using FB to share photos with friends? FB takes down your account? No problem, you upload your photos from an external HDD to other sites.
- naskwo 9y ago(cough cough) www.famipix.com More info: https://www.famipix.com/privacy-promise https://www.famipix.com/privacy-promise And: free for schools, with intuitive (and well-documented) features to let schools quickly share photos with parents. And of course download a zip of your albums whenever you want. - I started this site in 2005 to share photos of my growing family, as I was living abroad. I've never shared any meaningful photos on Facebook.
- bcrack 9y agoAlthough unfortunate for the author (and a huge inconvenience), such cases display in the best possible way the problem of depending on non-federated communication tools which promote disowning your data under ridiculous privacy policies.
- uranian 9y agoYou should have learned to be very happy they disabled your account! Facebook is for idiots and for companies that milk those idiots. This event likely saved you for wasting even more of your precious life time. Be happy and do some great things with your life without feeling the need to constantly show off.
- blowski 9y agoI partly agree with you, as I quit Facebook years ago, and have never wanted to go back. That said, I don't think people who use it are idiots. In fact, I can see that they get a lot of value from it. A lot of genuinely valuable content is siloed in Facebook - you're not an idiot just because you can't get it from somewhere else.
- uranian 9y agoI didn't say all people who use it are idiots. But willingly sharing your private data for free while waiving all your rights? If you realise that facebook runs AI on that data and knows much more about you then you could ever imagine, and if you realise they are selling that data to companies you might not like so much, or what else more, that's pretty stupid imao.
- throwanem 9y agoThe man runs a business that depends in considerable part on his ability to maintain Facebook pages. This ban could've put that business under. A dicey model, to be sure, but in contracting you have to go where the clients are - I think this is a fair bit beyond "play stupid games, win stupid prizes".
- wfunction 9y agoAnybody know what those who have the "wrong" name on Facebook but who can't change their name anymore (because they already changed it once and got reported or something) are supposed to do? Obviously IDs are going to show your legal name rather than the one you go by, so if you send one in, won't you just be giving Facebook proof that you violated their ToS, and won't they just ban you instead of updating it? Or if you don't send one in, then how can you change your name to the "correct" one so you don't lose your account like this later?
- subroutine 9y agoAs others have pointed out: fb is not your primary disk, so back up your pix. If they're offering a free service, you are the product. I'm gunna add one obvious thing to that list... fb is not your product. As I was reading through that article, it was all - client this, client that. "I can't admin my client's fb pages." Admin. A fb page admin. Cuz it sort of reads like: I perform guerrilla social marketing, SEO, and branding campaigns for a myriad of clients on someone else's social network, and they banned my account for spamming their users. "Why would fb do this to me", he asks himself, but then realized something, "something very important - I hate getting bullshit spam all day from facebook, so I filtered all Facebook updates to Skip Inbox, Delete. Surely the answer to why they blocked me was there somewhere."
- turc1656 9y agoSeems like an appropriate time for this Andrew Lewis quote - "If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product"
- turc1656 9y agoHaha. I have to chuckle. I'm really curious why anyone would downvote this comment, unless of course they worked for Facebook.
- seattle_spring 9y agoEvery person I've known to have their FB account deleted also happened to be people who posted inflammatory, toxic content on a daily basis. most of them also acted that way in PMs with people, but on an even more terrible level. Harassment level conversations, and probably a much larger scope than I was directly aware of. I am not at all convinced that Facebook just deletes accounts for no reason. Sure, high-profile people get maliciously flagged sometimes, but I seriously doubt these randoms who get deleted are telling the entire story.
- rexpop 9y agoFacebook is such a mega-center of cultural life, that for it to have a black-box method of permanently banning people is dangerous, however you may feel about the "attitudes" of the people who're ostracized. Maybe I am inflating their role.
- seattle_spring 9y agoIt's not a black box method. Their Community Standards[1] are pretty cut and dry, and every person I've known to have been banned was flagrantly disregarding those standards for months prior to their accounts being deactivated. [1] https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards
- lyra_comms 9y agoWe've always felt strongly about Facebook's views on real names: they're intrusive and unfair. So we made Lyra, a better conversation service which lets you have whatever name you like (among other things). https://hellolyra.com/c/343 https://hellolyra.com/c/343 We're a nonprofit and don't take investment, so excuse the plug :)