10 ms·
Curious to see this here, given that I've been trying to set up some of these "decentralized services" at my home servers and figuring out if it is really possi
by rglullis 9y ago
Curious to see this here, given that I've been trying to set up some of these "decentralized services" at my home servers and figuring out if it is really possible to replace the common mainstream services.
So far, I installed my own Matrix server (synapse), my own XMPP (ejabberd), yesterday I got semi-happy with my mastodon setup, and now I was just finishing some tests with ownCloud to see if I could replace Dropbox.
MediaGoblin is on my list of services to setup. I ran a basic deployment and checked some other instances of it before, but I didn't put it higher on my priority list because to me it looks like it focus too much on being a "community-driven website" instead of providing a solid service as a media-hosting/publishing/catalog system.
To me it looks like they are shooting for the wrong level of "decentralization granularity". Each instance of these services are aiming for a "community", and think that the people use the mainstream tools because they don't want to/won't manage the server.
The point they seem to miss is that this only creates another type of top-down organization. It would be MUCH easier for them to focus on a "single-user" system, and start from the point that the communication will work when the applications talk with each other.
To me this is why Diaspora failed, and Wordpress is still such a big part of the internet.
Another thing I noticed: the projects that really focused on separating client from server produced much better results in terms of UI/UX. With Matrix, I just had to setup the server, and then I could have the riot app just point to my instance. If by any chance a better client comes around, my instance would be untouched.
- anderspitman 9y agoI dabbled with ownCloud, Seafile, etc and came away disappointed. At the time I was trying to run them on a raspberry pi and ownCloud at least was too heavy. Eventually I found Syncthing and that's been the ticket for me. It's great for synchronization but not so much for general sharing.
- simplehuman 9y agoDid you try nextcloud?
- mikenew 9y agoIf all you want is file syncing then Syncthing is really fantastic. I have a NextCloud installation on a Raspberry Pi 3, and getting it to work well took some suffering. If you use a MySQL database and php 7 it can actually perform pretty well though, at least for a small number of clients. A big issue with the Pi is that it shares the Ethernet and USB on the same bus, so there's a hard limit to your file access speeds. But for syncing between my own machines plus the occasional file share I am extremely happy with the setup.
- lebrad 9y agoI second syncthing. It's been gloriously reliable on Linux, macOS, and Windows, even while pumping terabytes through it.
- agnivade 9y agoWe evaluated syncthing. There is a glaring problem which the developer has chose to deliberately ignore. Couldn't move forward due to it - - https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/issues/107#issuecomment-81217307 https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/issues/107#issuecomme... - https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/pull/3527 https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/pull/3527 tl;dr- Syncthing doesn't do a rolling hash implementation. Therefore, lets say you have a 1GB file. And you add a 1 line header at the top of the file, syncthing will download the entire file.
- bronson 9y agoYou saw that 3527 was merged in December? Is there still an issue?
- jancsika 9y agomerge link: https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/commit/05828368200d519e3ddc18f22ebf05c4a6c5e836 https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/commit/05828368200d51... discussion link: https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/pull/3527 https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/pull/3527
- 9y ago
- ekianjo 9y agoSyncthing is fantastic. It completely replaces Dropbox for folder duplication and syncing. Extremely reliable.
- j88439h84 9y agoNextcloud VM https://github.com/nextcloud/vm https://github.com/nextcloud/vm sets it up automatically. Very easy to use.
- thomasDE 9y agoWhat exactly was the problem with Seafile? I was looking for a Dropbox alternative. Tried Owncloud and was fairly disappointed. But Seafile is working great for me (using it for ~1.5 years now).
- doomrobo 9y agoWould you consider writing a blog post on all the tech stacks you tried and how it panned out? I'm kind of in the same place as you and there is just an overwhelming number of underwhelming options.
- corobo 9y ago> an overwhelming number of underwhelming options I love this phrase, it really seems to catch the problem with all these decentralised projects. Sure I could try to set up whatever matrix/status/appnet/tent decentralised service of the month happens to be on the front page of HN but also I could just not do that and use Twitter. The other thing is they all want to take over the entire domain you use them on. Either you have to use a subdomain (which means you can't use your cool name@example.com address) or you forfeit your domain to whatever advert the software brings with it. Honestly I've just given up with them. I use Twitter, I use Facebook, I use Dropbox and I do things other than trying to run my own versions of those in my free time
- cyphar 9y ago> The other thing is they all want to take over the entire domain you use them on That's not true. Many such projects use /.well-known/ to provide the ability to redirect from the root example.com identity to where you should actually go to send things.
- corobo 9y agoCould you source that? I'm not saying it's incorrect I've just not come across it in these things yet. That'd be the key to getting me on the decentralised bandwagon
- Arathorn 9y agoMatrix doesn't take over the whole domain; right now you use an SRV record to point to the right place and we're planning to switch to .well-known URLs. source: i work on Matrix.
- ZenoArrow 9y ago>"Curious to see this here, given that I've been trying to set up some of these "decentralized services" at my home servers and figuring out if it is really possible to replace the common mainstream services." Just in case its not yet on your radar, you may be interested in Sandstorm: https://sandstorm.io/ https://sandstorm.io/ It bills itself as a 'self-hostable web productivity suite', but it's much broader than that, it's really a platform for self-hostable decentralised apps. Sandstorm manages security and app interoperability, so that developers and users can focus on the core functionality of the apps.
- simplehuman 9y agoI mentioned this elsewhere but sandstorm packages are simply not updated at all - https://wiki.mediagoblin.org/EasyDeployment#Sandstorm https://wiki.mediagoblin.org/EasyDeployment#Sandstorm for example. But this is true for vast majority of the packages.
- clacke2 9y agoAlso, sadly, Sandstorm is not built for federated/decentralized apps that want to connect to arbitrary other servers.
- kentonv 9y agoThat's not completely true. Sandstorm was built for federation, but also security (e.g. against malicious apps), and it took a while to get the right model in place to provide both. It's now possible for apps to request access to each other and to outside servers, but Mediagoblin hasn't been updated to use that feature.
- PudgePacket 9y agoWhat are you thoughts on own cloud vs sync thing?
- msh 9y agoIt seems like neither supports encryption of the data at rest which is a showstopper for me.
- dnel 9y agoI use both Nextcloud and Syncthing, they solve different problems. Nextcloud is great for easy access to currently important files and automatic uploads of phone pictures, synchronising contacts and calendars. The news app is also an excellent RSS reader. Syncthing synchronises the bulk of my data between systems I own, it is much faster at this and isn't exposed to the risks you get with public web servers, but I cannot access those files from systems I don't own so anything I am currently using goes in Nextcloud.
- unixhero 9y ago/r/selfhosted says hi :)
- BugsJustFindMe 9y ago> I didn't put it higher on my priority list because to me it looks like it focus too much on being a "community-driven website" instead of providing a solid service as a media-hosting/publishing/catalog system. To me it looks like they are shooting for the wrong level of "decentralization granularity". Each instance of these services are aiming for a "community", and think that the people use the mainstream tools because they don't want to/won't manage the server. The point they seem to miss is that this only creates another type of top-down organization. It would be MUCH easier for them to focus on a "single-user" system, and start from the point that the communication will work when the applications talk with each other. This 1000 times. It just kills me to think about how much potential progress has been lost to these major projects spending so much time and energy on social federation protocols instead of working on the actual primary function of the software. Mediagoblin could have already been THE software go-to for personal media organizing and display, but it seems to be getting stuck like every other potentially great project that runs out of steam when the main developers lose their focus. And now Yahoo has sold assets to Verizon, and millions of Flickr users are wondering what will happen next.
- worldsayshi 9y agoI feel like I want to strongly agree on this sentiment but what is the concrete point here? What should be the focus of projects like these??
- throwanem 9y agoNot OP. But the argument seems to be: Start by being maximally useful to one person. When you have enough people using your software that they want to use it together, that's the time to start investing a lot of effort in helping them do so.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThe Wordpress model - only better? Put together a distro with a complete solution - mail server, web server, media and social servers. Make it one-click easy to set up. Keep security tight. Maybe do some deals with cheap hosting providers. Then federate and connect.
- mike-cardwell 9y agoI just had a brief look at Mastodon, and it appears to have the same humongous flaw that Diaspora has. No events management. What the hell? That is the main feature required in a social network, after the ability to see each others comments. People want to organise their lives using the graph that their social network provides. Is anyone aware of a distributed or federated open source social network which provides event management functionality? I would love to hear about it if you have... Gallery functionality would come in handy too.
- mallaidh 9y agoI haven't heard of `events management' as a core feature of social media and Mastodon gets alone just fine without it. I'm assuming that you're referring to facebook-style timelines for life events, etc.?
- mike-cardwell 9y agoI'm talking about being able to create an event and invite people to it, and let them specify whether they are coming or not. This is the main feature my friends use in Facebook, other than posting comments.
- BeetleB 9y agoDoes Twitter have this? Honest question. If not, why are you complaining that Mastodon does not?
- mallaidh 9y agoTwitter does not have this feature, the only platform I know of that has this is Facebook.
- mallaidh 9y agoAnd Facebook is a platform oriented towards interacting with `meatspace' friends, while Mastodon is for microblogging. I feel that `event creation' would be a significant and unfortunate scope creep considering other platforms are better-equipped to handle it.
- user102938 9y agoInteresting the various stacks that people are coming up with for their home servers. I use ZNC, Bitlbee, NextCloud, Offlineimap + remote notmuch, mopidy. I'm actually very happy with this - contacts, calendars, news, files - never have to go on the cloud for these things. The uptime I've been able to manage for the last 2 years is about 95%. Most of the downtime was due to a kernel panic, a shady bios on the intel nuc, and no means of remotely restarting the thing.... had to get a "smart switch" and now my uptime could potentially hit 99%. DR is next... got to drop my RAID disk + server combo with some friends and family. Probably slap on gluster, or just use lsyncd to synchronize changes. We should make a freenode channel for this!