3 ms·
> The same applies with NVidia. You can't start a GPU company because they are the GPU Mafia Comically, be sure to let ARM know that that's how things work. Fo
by adventured 9y ago
> The same applies with NVidia. You can't start a GPU company because they are the GPU Mafia
Comically, be sure to let ARM know that that's how things work. Founded in 1990, they shouldn't exist today if what you're claiming is true, Intel should have wiped them out of existence 20 years ago.
And be sure to let nVidia know that's how it works, 3DFX (given their early lead) or ATI should have wiped them out of existence early on. Or perhaps any number of a dozen other early big corporate leaders in graphics technology.
And be sure to let AltaVista, Lycos, Yahoo, Microsoft, AOL, Excite, et al. know that's how it works, as they should have wiped out Google.
And be sure to let Walmart, Target, Sears, JC Penney's, B&N, Waldenbooks, Borders and a hundred formerly major / soon to be bankrupt retailers know that's how it works, they all should have wiped out Amazon if your premise were true.
And be sure to let Microsoft know that's how it works, as they should have wiped out Redhat in ~1999.
And be sure to let MySpace & Friendster etc. know that's how it works, as given their extreme scale vs Facebook in 2004, they should have wiped them out.
And be sure to let Atari know that's how it works, as they should have wiped out Nintendo.
And be sure to go back in time and let Steve Jobs & Co know that's how it works, as given Apple's early size they should have wiped out Dell, Gateway, and dozens of other IBM compatible clone makers before they took over the PC market. Since that's how things work and all.
And be sure to let Netflix know that's how it works, so two dozen other massive global media & tech companies - from Comcast to Disney - know they should have wiped them out.
And be sure to let Oracle know that's how it works, they should have already wiped out Salesforce.com (and Workday, and and and and).
This list doesn't stop going.
- dman 9y agoARM is not a great example since they do not manufacture their own chips.
- adventured 9y agoThey're the perfect example, because Intel was a thousand times larger than them during the 1990s and they're competitors. If the op premise were correct, Intel should have (must have in fact, if we're going by the deterministic concept put forth) been able to use any number of levers to crush them, easily. The op premise is trivially easy to prove wrong: it requires infallibility / perfect judgment on the part of competitors. That one thing alone is enough to end the argument put forth - and there are numerous other issues with it.
- dman 9y agoHow could they crush arm when arm would not be infringing intels manufacturing patents. Why do you think intel was unable to make dents into the gpu space? Why did they fail at the soc business ? Why are they having a hard time in the modem business? Why did they have to acquire altera to get in the fpga business? Most hardware companies operate as oligopolies in their fields where the players have a mexican standoff going on with patents. The threat of mutually assured destruction keeps the balance going. Any new entrant faces huge challenges since they dont have the patents to hold others to ransom.
- unsigner 9y ago"Intel unable to make dents in the GPU business" must come from a parallel universe. Meanwhile in ours Intel has gobbled up virtually the entire low end GPU market, and is proceeding to take over the middle ground. It's the No 1 or No 2 supplier of GPUs for PCs, depending on who you ask. It's virtually impossible to buy a laptop without an Intel GPU in it. It is widely suspected in my circle (game development) that the only thing stopping Intel from shipping a competitive discrete GPU based on their Gen design (the one that goes into CPUs) is that they get much better margins selling that production capacity as CPUs. Intel sucking out the air of the GPU market is a large part of what's driving NVIDIA into "AI" and "machine learning", and AMD into custom designs (consoles).
- robotresearcher 9y ago> This list doesn't stop going. Survivor bias, and the blindness to survivor bias, does keep going.
- adventured 9y agoThat's exactly the point: the survivors prove the op's premise wrong. If the op premise were correct, the survivors would not exist, as that's what the op is claiming (that Intel exists means ARM can't exist; that Microsoft exists, means Redhat can't exist; that Walmart exists, means Amazon can't exist; that Sears existed (ha) means that Walmart could not have existed; and on it goes). Back in reality, that's not how things work. Instead of crushing Apple, Microsoft chose to help them survive. That's one example and it demolishes the op premise completely (ie competitors don't always seek absolute dominion for numerous reasons, such as political concerns; and sometimes competitors are just plain stupid or lazy or blind).
- robotresearcher 9y agoOf course, a single counter example disproves the claim that it's impossible to compete with an established business. But more realistically, we can list some successful outliers in a sea of tens of thousands of failed newcomers. It's very difficult indeed, but not impossible. How many chip companies have seriously threatened Intel in 35 years? Not enough that it makes sense to invest in any of them but Intel. Picking ARM would have been pretty darn lucky.
- adventured 9y agoIn an economy the size of the US (much less the globe), as an example, very difficult means a lot of positive outcomes. nVidia is a positive outcome vs Intel. So is Apple (after all, they sell a couple hundred million units per year of compute devices with their own customized processors, which directly threatens Intel's prosperity, of course thanks again to ARM). Or see: McDonalds vs the hundred new burger companies (Five Guys, Shake Shack et al) that have cropped up in the last 10-15 years. Or: Anheuser Busch AmBev vs the thousands of independent brewers that have cropped up and taken an increasingly large slice of a formerly stagnant market (thanks to government regulations) with finite physical shelf space. Talk about a perfect example of how wrong the op premise is. Tell GM & Ford not to worry about Tesla and the electric car revolution, because they can just kill off Tesla at any time (and yes, some things like that did occur, such as Tucker - thanks to government abuse in the market).
- coredog64 9y ago> And be sure to let AltaVista, Lycos, Yahoo, Microsoft, AOL, Excite, et al. know that's how it works, as they should have wiped out Google. AltaVista was a marketing stunt by Digital Equipment Corporation to show off how awesome the 64 bit Alpha processor was.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoI'll call BS on that. AltaVista was a great (I'd argue the best) search engine up until Google. More importantly, it wasn't a marketing stunt, it was the product of a research project and some really great, bright engineers. AltaVista was created by researchers at Digital Equipment Corporation's Network Systems Laboratory and Western Research Laboratory who were trying to provide services to make finding files on the public network easier.[3] Paul Flaherty came up with the original idea,[4][5] along with Louis Monier and Michael Burrows, who wrote the Web crawler and indexer, respectively. The name "AltaVista" was chosen in relation to the surroundings of their company at Palo Alto, California. AltaVista publicly launched as an Internet search engine on December 15, 1995 at altavista.digital.com.[6][7] At launch, the service had two innovations that put it ahead of other search engines available at the time: it used a fast, multi-threaded crawler (Scooter) that could cover many more webpages than were believed to exist at the time, and it had an efficient back-end search, running on advanced hardware. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AltaVista https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AltaVista
- skybrian 9y agoI agree, it was quite good for the time. I can justify considering it "marketing" though. They didn't consider it a way of making money, so from a business point of view it was basically a way of showing how good their research was and how powerful their hardware was. (Compare to, say, Deep Blue, or AlphaGo today.) And to be fair, Google didn't start out knowing how they would make money either.
- aswanson 9y agoInfoseek delivered far superior results to altavista in that era.
- largote 9y agoExcept most of your examples don't make "the same thing" as the companies you're comparing to. For the ones that do, like nVidia or Google. The technologies are orders of magnitude more complex now than when they took over their competitors.