7 ms·
Struggling to cover terrorism in the media age
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoMedia may like it for ratings. Sick, I know.
- matt4077 9y agoI like how you're disgusted at actual people for a hypothetical that you came up with not empirically, but because it appears to make sense to you. But to ease your pain: "media" isn't a person, and therefore doesn't like or dislike or fancy or abhor anything. As to journalists: From nytimes.com getting 10% more visitors on some day because of some terror attack to anyone's actual pay check or job security takes so many steps it's basically meaningless as a conditioning signal.
- barrkel 9y agoAnd companies are just people. Yes, indeed. "If it bleeds, it leads" - the people who choose headlines or what gets airtime select for urgency and impact within what they perceive to be their demographic. They amp up things that they know hook into trigger-points in their audience, because that's what gets the audience emotionally engaged, because engagement means revenue. Terror attacks can be played in a number of different ways, depending on the audience and what they're afraid of; whether it's immigrants, other religions, or social freedoms and militarization of the public sphere, there's plenty of fear all around to write about and get the audience riled up on. And if you don't think there's a profit motive in a media source engaging with its audience, there's not much hope for you.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoMedia isn't a person. It's a machine. A series of feedback loops within our economy that occupy a market niche in which optimizing for maximum fear and outrage is optimizing for profit. As you say, there are so many steps between getting visitors and someone's paycheck that you can't really blame a particular person within the system. That doesn't change the overall system behaviour, though. Everyone there, in aggregate, optimize for maximum fear and outrage.
- Corristowolf 9y ago(((Buzzfeed)))
- Eerie 9y ago(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((YourMom))))))))))))))))) )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) )))))))))))))))))))))
- dang 9y agoYou've repeatedly posted uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments to HN. Doing that will get your account banned, so please stop doing that.
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the site guidelines. If you don't want to be banned on HN, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe you'll follow the rules in the future.
- Eerie 9y agoDisrupt terrorism, or disrupt the media? I'd like BuzzFeed to lead the fight with a good example - by shutting itself down.
- cholantesh 9y agoWhat would that accomplish, exactly?
- Eerie 9y agoLess crap on the Internet.
- cholantesh 9y agoThat's pretty vague. What defines 'crap', and how does less of it lead to less (effective) terrorism?
- rovek 9y ago24 hour news has found its dream source. Conventional media reporting is much easier to improve than social media. * Focus on the victims not the witch hunt * Don't immediately switch into full crisis mode, dropping the program schedule * Don't speculate on whether it's "terror" (in fact, drop that terminology altogether - it's all crime) This is not new thinking. Social media is a much more challenging issue though, with professional irritants like Katie Hopkins in the UK. Edit: formatting
- moofight 9y agoDisrupt their appeal and outreach by: - no longer showing the faces / names / manifestos of the suicide bombers on media - showing the people who stand up, who demonstrate, who fight for our values rather than showing the panic, chaos, people running for their lives would that help?
- pfortuny 9y agoIn my opinion, much more useful than a terrible caption, a standard "keep calm and carry on" would be much more hurtful to the terrorist's aims than spreading the news and the "terror" (which is what they want...).
- chmod775 9y agoWhat would help is stop making such a giant fuzz about it every time something happens. The media just "likes" these kinds of events because they make emotions run high. In reality terrorism accounts for less than 0.01% of premature deaths, yet nations spend magnitudes more surveilling their own citizens and fighting stupid wars (to no apparent avail) than they spend on fighting various other things that kill more than a thousand times (> 1000x) more people. Here's a nice chart visualizing the disproportional response: https://i1.wp.com/thinkbynumbers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/death-and-dollars.jpg https://i1.wp.com/thinkbynumbers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008...
- DefundTerrorism 9y ago>In reality terrorism accounts for less than 0.01% of premature deaths, Sure death by terrorism is only a blip. But the amount of money spent on spreading terrorist idealology is insane. The problem is, our ally, Saudi Arabia, is spending Billions on Wahhabist Terrorism Propaganda aka Petro-Islam. In fact, money trails show KSA funded 90% of Wahhabist Terrorism Propoganda (Petro-Islam) around the world through mosques and literature. From Wikipedia: >Wahhabism has been accused of being "a source of global terrorism", inspiring the ideology of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL), and for causing disunity in Muslim communities by labelling Muslims who disagreed with the Wahhabi definition of monotheism as apostates (takfir) and justifying their killing. It has also been criticized for the destruction of historic mazaars, mausoleums, and other Muslim and non-Muslim buildings and artifacts. >Saudi Arabia is called the "cradle of Wahhabist Terrorism". In fact, Saudi Arabia funded an estimated "90% of the expenses of the entire faith [wahhabism]", throughout the Muslim World, according to journalist Dawood al-Shirian. >It extended to young and old, from children's madrasas to high-level scholarship. This spending has done much to overwhelm less strict local interpretations of Islam, according to observers like Dawood al-Shirian and Lee Kuan Yew, and has caused the Saudi interpretation (sometimes called "petro-Islam") to be perceived as the correct interpretation – or the "gold standard" of Islam – in many Muslims' minds. >The Salafi movement is often described as being synonymous with Wahhabism.
- Upvoter33 9y agoAgree with the article (generally). The comments section below it, however, shows that many don't seem to understand the problem -- that the media is a tool being exploited by terrorists.
- panzer_wyrm 9y agoNo they are symbiotes. The same as with Trump. The media needs terrorists and love the current administration. They were not exploited... they are willing partners. Every left leaning journalist has perfect job security - something that this profession has nit seen in a decade. And highly improved social status among the crowds.
- l33tbro 9y ago>Every left leaning journalist has perfect job security You've crossed over to hyperbole now. While the current administration has been colorul, there's a click fatigue induced when outrage becomes normative. Or have you come across some data about the decline of syndicated coverage and the resurgence of investigative reporting?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- spookyuser 9y agoGreat article. Although I think it missed out on offering the obvious solution of just not watching 24H news. Large networks themselves are not going to stop making this kind of content until it's no longer profitable.
- jelly 9y agoThis seems like a reframing of Charlie Brooker's criticism of news coverage regarding mass shootings[0]. Then, as now, many institutions seemed focussed on providing dramatic and emotional coverage rather than more objective and disconnected reporting. I think the BBC has somewhat changed its tone in respect to events like this; it's usually slow or last to report casualty numbers and attacker names, but being last doesn't effect social change if lots of competitors are doing it anyway. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2o1V4lX_g4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2o1V4lX_g4
- rrggrr 9y agoIts inspiring that widespread violence and terrorism didn't erupt in South Africa in response to the end of apartheid. It certainly did as Rhodesia became Zimbabwe. The key to the relative peace, I believe, was the widely endorsed notion of reconciliation, or acceptance promulgated throughout all aspects of South African society, particularly by religious and tribal leaders. I don't think its realistic to expect the media to change how it covers terrorism. I do think much more could be done to celebrate, reward and publicize those preaching against violence and for peace.
- PKop 9y agoWell... there is this though, which sounds pretty horrible http://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/world-economy/bury-them-alive-white-south-africans-fear-for-their-future-as-horrific-farm-attacks-escalate/news-story/3a63389a1b0066b6b0b77522c06d6476 http://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/world-economy/bury-th...
- vka 9y agohttps://news.vice.com/story/us-airstrikes-have-killed-more-and-more-civilians-in-iraq-and-syria-since-trump-took-office https://news.vice.com/story/us-airstrikes-have-killed-more-a... The coalition's terrorist media strategy is a bit more subdued.
- mmjaa 9y ago> 1,472 Civilians killed by the US/UK and their allies this month. The statistics are mind-boggling. We are at war, people, FFS. Stop being so surprised when that war arrives within our borders.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nippples 9y agoWhat is needed is for nations in Europe to take less unaccompanied adults and have an education system more focused on assimilating the young ones into the local culture, not opening the local culture to the same cultures those people are supposedly escaping from.
- mmjaa 9y agoWhat is needed is for Europeans to confront the facts of their own murderous campaigns. We cry about terrorism, but never about the bombs being dropped, every twenty minutes, on far more civilians - in our name.
- ManlyBread 9y agoYou're saying this as if the people who died yesterday have anything to do with the war games that politicians play.
- klez 9y agoI think he's saying that governments should be partly blamed by those who blame these attacks on immigration. If those governments didn't bring war to those places, maybe less people would be prone to follow the message "attack those who attacked us first", lowering the feasibility of mass murders.
- mmjaa 9y agoCitizens are responsible for their politicians, who derive their power from the society they govern. If we weren't so ignorant about their actions, politicians wouldn't be getting away with murder every single day. This disconnect between citizen responsibility and political culpability is the problem. We cannot butter our bread on both sides: either we live in a society where our armed forces are governed by our democracies, or we don't.
- ManlyBread 9y agoI'd say it's not that citizens are ignorant, it's that they're powerless. The only way an average citizen can shape the political reality around himself is by voting. What else can one do? Protest on the streets? Organize a riot? Good luck with that.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoI don't understand how media outlets that report on terrorism (by which I mean the 24hr coverage cycle) aren't charged with being accomplices or accessories to these terrorist acts. We know what terrorism is, mass murder + widespread knowledge of aforementioned murder + political motive. Look I'm not saying we just trash the 1st amendment but there has to be some reasonable compromise that can be made in cases where violent crime is used in order to grab headlines for some political cause. I'm not saying don't do any reporting on terror either but there's gotta be some hard line of what's definitly being irresponsible.
- mmjaa 9y agoThe most reasonable compromise that could be made is to force western media to report on the casualties of the war being waged by western military forces. We'd all be far less inclined to knee-jerk react to a 'terrorist attack' if we were more aware, daily, of just how many civilians WE have killed recently. Alas, nobody wants to hear that news.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoWe could also put minimums on the rate at which new information appears on screen.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- carapat_virulat 9y agoI have to say, I am impressed at how journalists are able to find new ingenious ways to write whole articles about the attacks without mentioning Islam or why it was perpetrated even once. On a more serious note, we westerners are probably not the target audience of these attacks, so I'm not sure hiding them from our population will do anything to prevent the news from reaching their target audience. I seriously doubt ISIS potential recruits get their news from Buzzfeed.
- jansho 9y agoBecause to do so would be rather unfair on the vast majority of followers who do not share the values of these terrorists. Ever wonder why the world hasn't burnt down? Because there isn't a "sleeper switch" in every Muslim you pass in the streets. There are discussions of Islam and ISIS - the Atlantic's most popular article covers just that (so thorough that it's praised by ISIS even.) And then there's the likes of the Daily Mail, which rather than heal serves to deepen divisions and hatred - that is the aim of terrorists.
- Neliquat 9y agoSuppressing when attackers are muslim does not equal equating all muslims with terrorists. Wtf. Lets not censor our news for any reason, nor sensationalize it.
- skrowl 9y agoAnyone else find it ironic that Buzzfeed is talking about how we should curb propaganda?
- KaiserPro 9y agoThe problem is this: It is profitable to report on such things. Outrage sells. The UK (and I assume others) suffer horribly because of the death throws of print media. The dailymail would lead with every big ISIS video, simply because people would visit their site. Until the link between peddling/stirring outrage and profits is severed, we will continue to have problems like this.
- flurdy 9y agoThe media, especially in the UK, also hound victims' families for profit. In the past with the infamous phone-hacking scandal, and this week chasing families of the missing (in this sad case later confirmed fatality). I can avoid reading such journalism but the vast population is attracted to car crashes and will look. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacking_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacki... [2]https://twitter.com/danhett/status/866960257150529536 https://twitter.com/danhett/status/866960257150529536
- nailer 9y agoAn excellent point, the media are indeed part of the problem, on both the left and the right: - Buzzfeed (a couple of years ago) published an exclusive that ISIS wants it's followers to find employees of company X and slit their throats. - The Times (last week) published that ISIS wants it's followers to (attack pubic in specific manner). Anyone, worldwide, who sympathises with ISIS would simply read those instructions and follow them.
- Theodores 9y agoCould the real ISIS stand up please? Anything and everything is blamed on ISIS yet nobody has ever met a genuine ISIS person. It is a contrivance of the military industrial media congressional complex, the moral panic of our age. Because ISIS get instantly blamed a legitimate struggle against a Washington ally can be blamed on ISIS and not whatever nationalist movement was behind the incident. Things can only be done by people assumed to be ISIS sympathisers, not by anyone else.
- nailer 9y agoThere is no 'real ISIS'. There's only people closer and further from the center who share the same ideals. That's the point: the media connects them. > Things can only be done by people assumed to be ISIS sympathisers No, certain things are done by people who identify themselves as ISIS symathisers > not by anyone else. Huh? I think we all know far right and far left groups who are responsible for violence and nobody pretends they're ISIS.
- daemin 9y agoWhenever I read a meta article like this I think that part of the reason it is written is so the author can appear or feel superior to the people reading and the other people writing about the same event. Much in the same way I am (in some small part) writing this comment to feel superior to the author of the article. This then feeds into an endless meta-loop from which only few escape.
- zamalek 9y agoThere's another side to this that I contemplated today. If the goal of terrorism is to spread terror, have they accomplished their goal? So far as the families of the victims and people in surrounding areas go, likely. However, when you look at the planet as a whole you have this sort of response[1]: widespread and global compassion. This defiance must be incredibly demoralizing for murderous scum. Removing awareness of these events, which media provides, takes our defiance (compassion, solidarity, and fearlessness) away. Limiting the media would only work if we limited all media in this way. The media needs to cover our peaceful defiance and we need to give the media more of that defiance to cover. [1]: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/05/23/world-monuments-illuminated-british-flag-tribute-manchester/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/05/23/world-monuments-i...
- whack 9y agoI'm reminded of the Vietnam era slogan: "Suppose they gave a war and nobody came" One could just as easily adapt it to our modern day. "Suppose they gave a bomb and nobody talked about it" I can only imagine how frustrated those narcissistic sociopaths would feel if after all that meticulous planning, people simply talked about the weather the next day.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoWould that not lead them to try larger attacks?
- yodon 9y agoIn 1972 there were over 1,900 acts of domestic terrorism bombing, and more than 2,500 such bombings in the US in an 18 month period in the early 1970's[0][1]. The bombings were so common that reporters didn't even bother to cover all of them, and yet the bombings continued until very gradually the number of people who felt setting off a bomb in a building was a productive way to end racism gradually declined towards zero (the 1970's are remembered as the anti-war era but that wasn't actually the cause that drove most of the bombers, as recounted into the linked histories). [0]https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/42038209-days-of-rage https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/42038209-days-of-rage [1]https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/opinions/remember-weather-underground-bloody-terrorism-at-home-in-1970s/2015/04/01/c68f8b8c-d17f-11e4-8fce-3941fc548f1c_story.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/...
- finid 9y agoMissing in media reports about these things is the connection between action (our foreign military mis-adventures) and reaction (terrorist attacks). About a month ago we celebrated the mother of all bombs that flattened what amounted to a small village in Afghanistan. We were told that it killed ONLY 90 terrorists, assuming the vast area it affected was inhabited only by the killed terrorists. Not a single civilian was killed, we were told. The pilot and his crew are our heroes. Somewhere there's an Afghan from that flattened area. Even if he doesn't subscribe to ISIS/Taliban ideology, he can't be too happy. Most people in his position would feel that they have a score to settle. And when he has the opportunity, we don't make the connection. He's a terrorist, but we have our heroes. Sometimes I feel like crying, not for the dead (that won't help them), but for the rest of us still alive.
- lostmsu 9y ago> Missing in media reports about these things is the connection between action (our foreign military mis-adventures) and reaction (terrorist attacks). Ha! That is probably because there's comparatively less correlation between terrorist attacks and foreign politics, than there's between terrorist attacks and attacker's religion. In case you are not aware, various islamic groups perform terrorist attacks in Philippines (look up recent news), India and Russia, the former two being 100% internal affairs.
- finid 9y agoAnd in virtually all those cases, there's a link to the target's actions against something the terrorists hold dear. Terrorist activity in India? Look to Kashmir. In Russia? The Russians fought their own war on terrorism before we went into Afghanistan. In some ways going into Afghanistan diverted fighters streaming into Chechnya to fight the Russian army to Afghanistan. We gave them a target they hated more than they hated the Russians. From reports, many of the best fighters on the side of ISIS are Chechens. The Russians, by the way, are still fighting terrorists. And whether these wars are "internal affairs" or not is immaterial.
- lostmsu 9y ago