19 ms·
NSA secretly conducted illegal searches on Americans for years
- foobarbazetc 9y agoPleass stop posting circa trash.
- PKop 9y agoShoot the messenger, huh. If you don't realize there is a problem with "702" authorizations, whether it involves your preferred candidate Obama or not, then maybe you aren't paying attention? Do you want Trump or any president, or more accurately, unelected intel agencies abusing power like this with no recourse and no oversight?[0] Doesn't this concern you? Well.. it's up for reauthorization later in the year, and now there is extensive evidence it lacks oversight and has been abused. Politicians of both parties have turned a blind eye to the problems, and if you follow some of the proceedings in Congress lately, they are loathe to criticize or even bring up the issue in depth. They all want this to continue. Does anyone care? [0] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170514/10071637362/inspector-generals-report-shows-section-702-isnt-only-thing-being-abused-nsa.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170514/10071637362/inspe...
- gavinpc 9y agoAgree completely. And I can't imagine that the self-disclosures at the end of the current term will be worse than this.
- rl3 9y ago>Shoot the messenger, huh. In this case: absolutely! NSA stories are too important to be dragged down by some news aggregation platform trying to feign original, investigative journalism on a site that's borderline unusable on the desktop. Circa literally numbers every passage—interspersing ads every few—while providing a cringe-worthy video of their reporter reading a script in a tone too grave to possibly be genuine. >Do you want Trump or any president, or more accurately, unelected intel agencies abusing power like this with no recourse and no oversight? That doesn't change the fact that clickbait trash is still clickbait trash, and should be discarded because it detracts from the quality of the overall discussion.
- mirimir 9y agoWith reader view in Firefox, it's fine.
- mlindner 9y agoAgreed. Impossible to read, horrible broken UI (pagination, really?). Fonts too large. Too much white space.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- talmand 9y agoSo, since the experience is bad it invalidates the information provided? Most information from the government comes to us in the form of simple documents, I guess we ignore that information as well?
- trumpcoder 9y agoHow is this a surprise? The US government is pure evil. It has always been. You don't have to believe me, just read the documents written by the founding fathers, particularly Federalist Paper #10. Few people appreciate that the main reason the US constitution is so protective of individual liberties is that the founding fathers hated each other profoundly, but they hated the British even more. So they created a system of government that would protect the new country from the British while at the same time protecting the founding fathers from each other. The US constitution and the US government are two different things. The former is probably the greatest document ever written in the history of political science. The latter was born evil, and continues to be evil to this day.
- Chronic42 9y agoAmerican here. I don't really care if the government spies on me. There are fewer terrorist attacks in the US than Europe and Asia. Seems like the NSA/CIA are successfully doing their job of protecting American citizens. What's not to like?
- seanwasere 9y agodata theft
- endymi0n 9y agoI think the most dangerous thing is that what Snowden predicted actually happened by now. After all the revelations, nobody is interested anymore. There's this general fatigue and powerlessness that leads to a feeling of "well, yeah, everbody knows by now... what's the news here?" - even for me as a security expert and privacy proponent. The real danger is nobody cares anymore, as this enables all further constitution violations and hollowing of citizen protection worldwide.
- dovdovdov 9y agoWhen I saw the movie Idiocracy, I said this is a bit exaggerated. Well, we are heading there in acceleration. It's astounding how little people care about the many walks of life.
- mtgx 9y agoThey'll start caring again about privacy when people start being dragged out of their homes in the middle of the night for participating in protests, not just against the government, but against large corporations, too. And many people will lose their lives in the process, or will be imprisoned for years until things change again, and so on. I guess we'll have to do real fighting for our human rights once again (unfortunately).
- coldtea 9y ago>They'll start caring again about privacy when people start being dragged out of their homes in the middle of the night for participating in protests, not just against the government, but against large corporations, too. They still will not, since it will be others, and a small minority, that does that and gets dragged, etc. The problem is that a society that stifles those small minorities (from labor activists in early 20th century to MLK, Snowden, and so on) ends up worse for everybody.
- marksomnian 9y agoFirst they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
- mirimir 9y agoWell, this isn't exactly news. What's interesting, however, is how interagency sharing doesn't get mentioned often in this debate. Such as SOD, where DEA, DHS, FBI, IRS, etc can access the data.[0,1,2,3] And use it secretly in criminal investigations, through parallel construction. Which, by the way, involves criminal conspiracy to suborn perjury. 0) http://www.reuters.com/article/us-dea-sod-idUSBRE97409R20130805 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-dea-sod-idUSBRE97409R20130... 1) https://www.deamuseum.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/042215-DEAMuseum-LectureSeries-MLS-SOD-transcript.pdf https://www.deamuseum.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/042215-... 2) https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/mar/08/fbi-changes-privacy-rules-accessing-nsa-prism-data https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/mar/08/fbi-changes-... 3) https://www.wired.com/2017/01/just-time-trump-nsa-loosens-privacy-rules/ https://www.wired.com/2017/01/just-time-trump-nsa-loosens-pr...
- nl 9y agoOne unanticipated consequence of the Snowden revelations is that other agencies now know what to ask for.
- mirimir 9y agoMaybe so. But SOD started in the 70s. Its focus was drug cartels. I'm guessing that NSA staff reached out to the FBI.
- nl 9y agoYeah, but SOD isn't data sharing exactly (or wasn't?). To quote the Reuters's article: You'd be told only, ‘Be at a certain truck stop at a certain time and look for a certain vehicle This isn't a defense of the program or of parallel construction of course. But it is indicative that raw data wasn't shared, and other agencies didn't know the source or get any idea of how it was obtained.
- indolering 9y agoWikipedia states that circa.com is a recently acquired property of the Sinclair Broadcast Group, who is known for mandating stations to carry canned editorials as news [0]. Google also shows this report as surfacing ~month ago [1]. I agree that what the government did is insane, but this is a pretty poor source. [0]: http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/05/08/527462015/sinclair-broadcast-group-has-deal-to-buy-tribune-medias-tv-stations http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/05/08/527462015/... [1]: https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=%22I+think+what+this+emphasizes+is+the+shocking+lack+of+oversight+of+these+programs%2C%22&hl=en&source=lnt&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A1%2F1%2F2012%2Ccd_max%3A5%2F1%2F2017&tbm= https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=%22I+think+what+this+e...
- ttctciyf 9y agoemptywheel.net is generally a good source for lawyerly concerns about surveillance. I don't have time to track down if she has anything on circa's issues specifically, but: https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/03/17/ron-wydens-complaints-about-section-702/ https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/03/17/ron-wydens-complaints-... https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/05/03/i-con-the-record-transparency-bingo-4-how-151-million-call-events-can-look-reasonable-but-is-besides-the-point/ https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/05/03/i-con-the-record-trans... https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/05/02/i-con-the-record-transparency-bingo-3-cia-continues-to-hide-its-us-person-network-analysis/ https://www.emptywheel.net/2017/05/02/i-con-the-record-trans... ... etc.
- roywiggins 9y agoI think the article is wrong on the definition of "about data." The definition I read was, "about data" is information that mentions a foreign intelligence target, even if it's sent between two Americans domestically. This was, apparently, perfectly legal to query as long as you were querying a foreign target. The NSA overstepped pretty egregiously and had to shut those queries down. The article say it's data "about" Americans, which is true but confusing.
- mtgx 9y agoSo who's going to prison over these "illegal searches"? Oh, let me guess - nobody, because intelligence agencies seem to always be above the law?
- type0 9y agoIntelligence agencies often have judge Dredd mentality- "I never broke the law, I am the Law!"
- Bakary 9y agoThe law has power only because it can be (potentially) enforced.
- josteink 9y agoWhy should the people in power go to prison for doing illegal stuff just because they got caught? If they don't imprison themsleves, who's going to force them? What do they have to lose by not doing so themselves? These are the simple questions (with relatively simple answers) you need to ask. If they have nothing to lose, then why do you expect them to follow the law? Until you give them something to lose, why should you expect them to change their behaviour?
- ff10 9y agoYou're exactly describing the reason why there is checks and balances. "People in power" is supposed to be a heterogenous group with different interests and formal functions. Your post suggests that it doesn't work properly in your country anymore. I wonder where exactly one could pinpoint the weak spots and systemic issues.
- ryanlol 9y ago>Your post suggests that it doesn't work properly in your country anymore Your post seems to suggest that the default is it working, is that really true? Does it actually work anywhere?
- 9y ago
- imron 9y ago> and that the improper searches constituted a “very serious Fourth Amendment issue,” I for one hope the people involved get a very stern talking to.
- talmand 9y agoAt least a sternly worded letter that'll go in their folder at the minimum.
- fischersully 9y agoIt's not OK that this doesn't shock me!
- awqrre 9y agoI think that the privacy issue will get worst quicker under Trump, which is why I voted for him. I think that it is required, for it to get better, because people don't care enough yet.
- mowenz 9y agoIt wont happen that way. How many times has America been through this kind exercise? Truman gave us a dire warnong and not enough cared. Look at Iraq, Vietnam, Hiroshima and Nagasaki--they were all unjustified atrocties, and that is the truth--which you will come to if you research them--but it's too easy to make up believable bullshit that the people gobble up. Most of us are conditioned to follow leaders, and "great men are almost always bad men." Who has time to think or worry about this? Our jobs, lives, bills and healthcare are overwhelmingly stressful and if that wasn't enough we are conditioned by our culture to religiously value money over everything else, which keeps us in line and productive. "If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever." - George Orwell Something big needs to happen to prevent this.
- roywiggins 9y agoWhen has accelerationism ever worked before?
- xadhominemx 9y agoI think for a lot of relatively wealthy, straight, white people there's not a lot of downside to 4 or 8 years of Trump, which led to some pretty awful accelerationism risk calculus.
- braveo 9y agoPlease get out of here with that crap, the loudest majority of anti-trumpers tend to be young, white people who think they speak for every other race and religion.
- braveo 9y agoI think the idea is to get people to "right the ship" by forcing it to lean too far to the other side, causing them to quickly pull it back to center.
- MikeVanBike 9y agoOh my, Is people so naive that they really believe what NSA is telling them? Some people huh, really ?
- bipr0 9y agoPrivacy is of course important. We should take it seriously. And i think its our duty to encourage other people to do so, and i know there are many people does not care.
- gcatalfamo 9y agoThis is an old story. And, even if it wasn't, I don't want to sound cynic or excessively sarcastic, but it would be the biggest case for "no shit, sherlock". edit: grammar
- GrumpyNl 9y agoThats not the problem, the problem is that no one seems to care anymore. Thats very, very disturbing.
- yostrovs 9y agoThe word "Obama" is mentioned only once within the 81 comments so far posted...
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoWhy is this worth noting? The surveillance state is far bigger than any one person and has been operating clandestinely for decades.
- talmand 9y agoMaybe because the title and bulk of the article directly attributes the problems discussed to Obama and his administration? That the ability to abuse such things was made easier during his term? The problem may be bigger than any one person, but that doesn't mean we don't discuss their possible role in that problem.
- hammock 9y agoWho's to say that NSA did not blackmail Obama into expanding its powers or relaxing oversight?
- strictnein 9y agoWho's to say serpent people aren't running the UN?
- talmand 9y agoWould not a discussion over Obama's possible involvement in the problem possibly bring such a thing to light? Is "he might have been blackmailed" a reason for everybody else to not discuss something?
- yostrovs 9y agoThe "one person" is the President of the United States, the very person able to single handedly stop this and the one who takes responsibility for managing these things. If politics is to have any impact on governance, actions of all the political players have to be judged equally.
- Allower 9y agoIs anyone surprised? fuck you
- freeflight 9y agoThis is pretty much the very same problem the German BND has right now, I'd guess pretty much any intelligence service which conducts mass surveillance has this problem of "surveil everything, except stuff from your domestic population". How to find out if your target belongs to the domestic population without looking into any content of that target? German BND supposedly does some of the filtering by country domain extension i.e. users with a "@xyz.de" mail address are supposedly exempted from BND scrutiny. Which is of course yet another flawed approach because not every German has a .de mail address. Case in point, I have an account with German mail provider GMX that ends on .net. That method would also make it stupidly easy to evade any scrutiny by the BND. Imho this is a problem that doesn't have a good solution or any solution at all, for this to actually work in reality security services would need to be clairvoyant.
- reacweb 9y agoIMHO, US shall be governed by law. This is fundamental of our values. NSA misbehavior shall be severely sanctioned. If we relinquish these values, what distinguish us from the dictatorships we fight.
- dude01 9y agoPutting on my marketing hat -- protecting privacy sure has lousy marketing. Privacy is so abstract and sounds passive. Why don't people talk about how upcoming politicians can be blackmailed by having this surveillance info lying around? Or our current politicians, who vote and decide on the powers granted the NSA, are easily blackmail-able with this surveillance info?
- pvnick 9y agoThat's always been my biggest concern. It appears to have happened to Trump's team, which is very ironic because the republicans are supposedly the national security hawks that want this surveillance; but at the same time now the dems turn a blind eye because it happened to someone they despise.
- exabrial 9y agoWhat ticks me off is no one will assign blame to the commander in chief, who willingly let this go on.
- Cuuugi 9y agoHe's the first black president. In identity politics, that's all that matters.
- willstrafach 9y ago> willingly let I believe the US continues to have a president right now, at this very moment. The past tense is confusing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lafytahoe 9y agoWe voted in a new dynastic leader to handle these issues. That is what you do in a representative democracy.
- Dahoramano 9y agoRepublican Propaganda. The text tone is slanted. Where these rules broken and loosened? If so, was it an executive order or a constitutional appeal / ammendment? The line "...that the Obama administration loosened in 2011" is too vague. And let's not even get started on the download, the javascript, the huge image as the first payload. Smells like I'm being tracked!! Not very privvy to privacy-esque circles, i see. Oh and you have to have the facebook PLUGIN to pretend to talk real people through their Sock Puppets, Daniel Nyguen (the most common last name in Vietnam) and James Morrison from Ft. Worth Texas.
- tripzilch 9y agoAs a non-American, whose rights to any sort of privacy whatsoever have been deemed zero by people on this very forum from the start[0], I really just want to point my finger and say: "Ha, ha!" I guess it's my turn to finally say, "is anyone really surprised?". Okay having gotten that off my chest, I have a question too :) It's about the timing of this release, just in the last few weeks before Trump got elected. I have a little theory that sprung to mind reading the article. Is it maybe because NSA was violating the restrictions left and right, because obviously they believe it's for the Greater Good, or something. But they are probably also aware that the mere existence of all this data is dangerous by itself, you slurp it up, filter, categorize, store, etc. Now it's like nuclear waste sludge, waiting to fuck shit up when it ends up somewhere it shouldn't be. And maybe during the Obama administration, who, you may not have liked the guy but at least he is you know, SANE[1], so the NSA believed that these violations were for the Greater Good/for the better. But now there's Trump. And he's a wild card. Literally no telling what this guy will do or won't do. And then there's these rumours about Russian connections[2]. So now the NSA is suddenly like, wait a minute, all this data is still here, and we're spying on citizens, and we're collecting all this shit, and ... Trump's in power. Maybe better limit ourselves, before he (or his underlings) start using it in very, very badwrong ways. Like, the NSA trusted they could wildly overstep their boundaries in a relatively sane governmental environment, but now they're not so sure any more and kind of worried about what powers they actually gave this administration? Does that sound about right? It's just some thoughts I had about the matter. Good luck getting your privacies back, and all though. Honestly. [0] because violating my privacy is "their job" even though I am a human being with a fundamental right to privacy just like you guys, I've nothing wrong to have that taken away from me! We all live on the same planet, and no, my government's intelligence service is NOT spying on the entire Internet just the same, because they can't, they don't have the unique position and resources of the NSA. And if they would, I would not defend them for it. [1] Disclaimer: I don't have a background to actually diagnose people. But I do know a thing or two about it. So there's the blatantly obvious narcissistic personality disorder. And then there's the part where he's just simply not qualified, he doesn't know shit about 20th century world history, international relations and diplomacy, etc. Believing you can do this super important job, is also pretty insane. The spokespeople, in their eyes you can see they want to scream we don't know what the guy is saying half the time either. [2] Trump almost literally admitted he fired the FBI guy because he was investigating him about Russia. I mean he also denied it, but even though that's one of his insane shticks, to say something and claim the opposite a bit later, in this case, saying both does not in fact, add up to saying nothing. It's really crazy that. But the jury's still out, right?