28 ms·
Scientists Tie 52 Genes to Human Intelligence
- throwaway91111 9y ago> Their combined influence is minuscule, the researchers said, suggesting that thousands more are likely to be involved and still await discovery. I don't follow. How does that suggest anything? Perhaps intelligence is largely environmental. In fact, all this suggests is that the genetic influence is likely non-zero.
- flukus 9y ago> In fact, all this suggest is that the genetic influence is likely non-zero. It's been widely thought to be non-zero for a while. Now that they are identifying individual genes responsible we can start to better quantify exactly how non-zero it is.
- douche 9y agoIt strikes me as bizarre that we are so reluctant to apply the same principles of genetics and heredity to humans that we have applied to canines, bovines, equines, and even vegetables, for centuries.
- flukus 9y agoIt's not bizarre, we did exactly that (to varying degrees of scientific quality) until the events of the mid 20th century. As humans we still suck at knowing what to do with the data, we look at headline figures and not distribution graphs. If we found out tomorrow that Icelanders on average had an IQ 10 points lower than most humans we would likely see a lot of discrimination against Icelanders, even the ones on the upper end of the distribution graph that are more intelligent than the average human.
- babesh 9y agoWe have been applying this especially the British. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-american-rich-kids-bought-their-way-into-the-british-elite-4252/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-american-rich-kids... I am not sure I remember the term but it was something along the lines of keeping the blood fresh. Supposedly the British did this between the gentry who had titles and self made men. A marriage of title and ability so that they two wouldn't fight. Kings did this between themselves as well.
- air7 9y agoI agree and think that is the main point here. Within our social norms, any type of generalized genetic comparison between groups of humans is very much frowned upon. I think that's because it bring back past traumas such as Slavery, the Jewish Holocaust and female oppression. This is so strong that almost any grouping statement is quickly labeled as racism, sexism, profiling etc. Imagine the popular reaction if it's discovered that these "intelligence genes" not only exist but are more prevalent in one of our go-to easily labeled human subgroups such as women, men, whites, blacks, rich, poor, brown-eyed. It'll be proof that that group is objectively genetically more intelligent. What would be the ramifications such a discovery? What should be the ramifications of such a discovery? I think it's quite tricky to research these things objectively without it being explosive. That's why even suggesting that "the genetic influence on intelligence is likely non-zero" is a big thing.
- cLeEOGPw 9y agoThis time will go in history as "the dark ages of human genetics" because of this reason. Some groups of humans are smarter than other groups of humans, some are more athletic, there are many physical and behavioral differences caused by genes in different easily identifiable groups of people. I know it, you know it, everyone knows it, but because of the toxic political environment, everyone must pretend these differences either don't exist, or they exist because of some magical politically correct reason like socioeconomic status. Even ignoring that the status itself has genetic influence and thus members of one easily identifiable group of people are predisposed to higher/lower status than other. We are doing nothing but fooling ourselves by pretending we are all equal.
- jansho 9y agoI think that most of us find it unpleasant that humans can be "breeded" to become better. Though we fight all the time about our differences, the sheer diversity around you is a wonder to behold. That it happened naturally and you too, though imperfect for sure, are unique and can become better as you grow. We talk about advancing our human race but the reality is, most of us are only capable of seeing things from our personal viewpoint, and just a bit of the future. We care most about ourselves and our experiences, as well as those closest to us like family and friends - we don't actively do things in order to get better as a species. Only 'large entities' like governments and corps afford to see this bigger picture - and I think this is extremely cynical and one-dimensional.
- Magnusmaster 9y agoThe problem is that if you breed people like animals, you will end up treating people like animals, especially those that don't have the traits people want. With embryo selection people can decide which individuals deserve life and which don't. Hitler was a monster, but since embryos don't suffer it's OK to kill them (never mind the fact that you are deciding whether another person deserves to live or not), and everyone likes abortion nowadays. CRISPR won't change the fact that a person born with low IQ is doomed, which means that anyone living today will be obsolete as soon as people start to breed people.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abakker 9y agoThat was my thought as well. Judging from the article, the model they have has statistical significance, but small predictive power. "But in the past couple of years, larger studies relying on new statistical methods finally have produced compelling evidence that particular genes really are involved in shaping human intelligence." and "But all of these genes together account for just a small percentage of the variation in intelligence test scores, the researchers found; each variant raises or lowers I.Q. by only a small fraction of a point." That doesn't sound like a compelling result, or an enormous success to me. I've taken a few IQ tests in my life and my own variation between tests is more than a dozen points. If they were showing genetics accounting for a meaningful amount of change in the IQ score, then yes, but in low predictive power models, I'd be more likely to look to a confounding variable with those genes that wasn't Intelligence. (e.g. certain genes express more when people eat a nutritious diet growing up - the study mentions that these genes in question are tied to regulating brain cell development).
- imcoconut 9y agoI remembr a discussion here recently regarding "p-hacking". With so many thousands of genes, aren't a fair number going to be correlated or predictive with statistical significance by sheer probability?
- pjscott 9y agoThe more genetic variants they test, the more they correct for multiple comparisons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study#Methods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study#...
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y ago>Perhaps intelligence is largely environmental How does this correlate with identical twin studies which show that over time their IQ converges, even in the case of separate upbringings, adoption, etc?
- openasocket 9y agoSource? Last I checked the literature identical twin studies showed a variance of as much as 20-30 points.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoI was going by the Minnesota Twin study. Is this research still valid?
- mikekchar 9y agoWould you mind giving a source as well? I've been doing some googling and every paper that references this seems to describe correlations to IQ scores rather than variance of IQ scores. For example Bouchard & McGue (1981) reported a correlation of twin's IQ of 0.86 if living together and 0.71 if living apart. That particular paper doesn't fill me with confidence (it seems to have a sample size of 111 and it's a meta-study), but it appears to be the most cited paper I've seen. I haven't seen anything that discusses a variance of IQ score, nor do I really understand what that means (what's the standard deviation of correlated multivariate distributions?) It would be interesting to see the analysis.
- throwaway91111 9y agoSorry, why are you asking me? It's the nytimes that didn't explain their mental leap from "insignificant effect" to "probably many more genes involved".
- kafkaesq 9y agoTheir combined influence is minuscule My eyes grabbed on that fragment, also, and I pretty much stopped reading there. And yet, even though their influence is "minuscule", researchers want to use them to "determine which interventions would be most effective for children struggling to learn". What? Sounds potentially scary, actually. It may be a compelling result, or maybe not. But from the way the NYT piece is articulated, you just can't tell.
- BurningFrog 9y agoIntelligence is at least 50% genetic. Possibly up to 80%. This is thoroughly studied, and easily googled.
- kafkaesq 9y agoThis is thoroughly studied, and easily googled. The keywords (and ultimately, links to the published studies themselves) are "easily googled". But understanding the true import of the studies -- and in particular, the various sampling and other statistical caveats in the foreground of them -- far less so.
- tptacek 9y agoGoogling this is going to lead you into a morass. You probably want to be more careful than that. A better starting point would be a paper by a reputable scholar (this is a field where there are disreputable scholars, so be careful, but you can find people doing good work on pretty much all parts of the spectrum of hypotheses here --- stick to universities you've heard of) and then walking their references.
- pjscott 9y agoThey're looking through a huge number of genetic variants for genes that each have a small effect on expected intelligence scores. Two obvious problems that they run into: 1. When you test that many genetic variants, some correlations will appear purely by chance. To correct for this, they require very strong evidence for each variant that they declare significant. This means they end up having a lot of false negatives, and it's only through having an enormous sample size that they manage to get results this good. 2. There are a lot of genetic variants that they're not even looking at. (They try to pick a decent subset to measure.) So they end up with some set of extensively-vetted genetic variants that, combined, predict a fairly small percent of variation. This is what you'd expect to see if there were a lot more that they weren't able to detect, which would be consistent with the much larger heritability numbers from things like twin studies.
- throwaway91111 9y agoThis makes sense. Thanks!
- cperciva 9y agoThe genetic variants that raise intelligence also tend to pop up more frequently in people who have never smoked. Some of them also are found more often in people who take up smoking but quit successfully. The more we look, the more we're likely to find confounding genes like this. Sure, it might be that those genes directly raise intelligence... but it might also be that those genes make the parents less likely to smoke, and the measured difference in intellect is entirely due to exposure to parental smoking. If there's a gene for "less likely to drop babies on their heads", it will probably show up as being correlated with higher intellect -- even if it has no direct effect on intellect and instead acts solely though yielding improved parenting.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIf this study has captured anything beyond systematically correlated measurement errors (a problem which plagues high-throughput sequencing assays), it is almost certainly ancillary population substructure which correlates with socio-economic status.
- gwern 9y agoAlex, why do you say these hurtful things? You know perfectly well that they use principal components to successfully control away population structure, that the genetic correlations between cohorts are high, the hits replicate across populations, the enrichment sets and tissue expression are predominantly in the nervous system as expected, the polygenic scores are predictive of success even looking at just kids in poor families, and the within-family polygenic scores perform fine. No, it's not some measurement error on the several different SNP chips they used in the ~12 different cohorts or the entirely separate GWASes whose results they replicated, and it's definitely not 'residual population structure'. It was silly 4 years ago to write off GWAS results with that sort of logic, and it has only gotten sillier.
- theWatcher37 9y agoMan, that burn was orbital. Comments like these are why I come to HN
- hprotagonist 9y agoThe phrase that determines the total pain of basically all systems biology is "combinatorial explosion".
- Brendinooo 9y agoLast week I read an [article][0] critiquing Charles Murray's work, largely in response to a [podcast][1] he did with Sam Harris. One of the assertions in the article was: > There are no “genes for” IQ in any but the very weakest sense. I'm not super knowledgeable about this stuff. I'm not trying to kick a hornet's nest; just trying to point out how I found this news to be particularly relevant in light of what I'd been reading recently. I'd be interested in seeing the Vox article's authors would fit this news into their thesis. [0]: https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/5/18/15655638/charles-murray-race-iq-sam-harris-science-free-speech https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/5/18/15655638/charles-... [1]: https://www.samharris.org/podcast/item/forbidden-knowledge https://www.samharris.org/podcast/item/forbidden-knowledge
- defen 9y agoThat Vox article is profoundly dishonest. The sentence immediately preceding the one you quoted is "Virtually none of the complex human qualities that have been shown to be heritable are associated with a single determinative gene!" That is the most ridiculous straw-man in the history of straw-men. No one thinks IQ is determined by a single gene. In reality it's probably caused by a large number of small-effect genes, leading to the characteristic "bell-curve" distribution. To oversimplify - within a population let's say there are a thousand genes or SNPs that each affect IQ by a small amount. If you have 500 "plus" (good) and 500 "minus" you end up with an IQ of 100 (average). If you have 450 "plus" and 550 "minus" you have 90 IQ. If you have 550 "plus" you end up with 110 IQ. If you have 800 you are Newton or von Neumann. The numbers are obviously simplified and made-up, but that's the general idea. Of course this is assuming the nutrition and environment to allow that IQ to develop. Since the individual effect sizes are tiny, you need a large number of people in a study to find them. But as big data gets better, we're going to find them, and the anti-science left will have to figure out a way to deal with it.
- snowwrestler 9y agoThis is nonsense. Genes don't work by some sort of "total weight" principle like pebbles on a balance. And intelligence has noting to do with "right" vs "left". That sort of political framing language is an excellent smell test for bad scientific information.
- crusso 9y agoTheir combined influence is minuscule, the researchers said ... Keep in mind that all they were likely doing was correlating the presence of certain genes with intelligence. They couldn't begin to start determining combinations of those genes 50. It will certainly be the case that the combination of the genes matters. What if gene A gives you a little boost by itself and gene B gives you a little boost by itself, but genes A & B together actually lower your IQ? With just 50 genes (assuming no mutual exclusions), you'd have 1.1258999e+15 different combinations of them. Then as the article mentions, they think that there may be many more intelligence genes to find.
- rjeli 9y ago> What if gene A gives you a little boost by itself and gene B gives you a little boost by itself, but genes A & B together actually lower your IQ? Seems like a good application for NNs?
- nwah1 9y agoUnless you could produce identical clones that only differed in terms of the relevant genes in question, and raised them in very similar environments, then neural nets will have extreme difficulty factoring out all the confounding variables. Even with large sample sets, given all rarity of the genetic combinations etc. Given the vast complexity of all this, really the only low hanging fruit could come from determining modal genes, and eliminating all the many mutants since the overwhelming majority will be deleterious. If you could run such a spellcheck on a person's entire genome, the results could be very impressive. Although, I admit that if done at large scales you'd essentially be creating a monoculture species. Of course, people are unlikely to all voluntarily opt for having the same genes, so under a voluntary gene therapy system this is an unlikely outcome... stratification is more likely. http://squid314.livejournal.com/345414.html http://squid314.livejournal.com/345414.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rlanday 9y agoThere's reason to believe that the combined effect from all these different gene variants is approximately linear. Effects caused by multiple variants interacting are difficult for natural selection to operate on because of the way sexual reproduction works. See section 3.1 of this paper, "On the genetic architecture of intelligence and other quantitative traits": https://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421 https://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421
- skybrian 9y agoThis is about what you'd expect based on how behavioral geneticists are thinking these days: "A typical human behavioral trait is associated with very many genetic variants, each of which accounts for a very small percentage of the behavioral variability." http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0963721415580430 http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/096372141558043...
- newtem0 9y agoIve known people who were related to certain very famous physicists and their intelligence was obviously much higher than most people. As in very conspicuous. There is no doubt thay intelligence is purely genetic. The difference between an ape, me amd my friend is genetic. Yes, environment counts but if you give everyone their own personal most ideal environment, they will all taper off at an intelligence level that is determined by their genetics. There is a popular myth that genetics arent everything when it comes to intelligence because it makes people uncomfortable. They dont want to believe that their own intelligence is deterministic. I think it has to do with the tendency of americans to never tell amyone how much money they make or anything else directly tied to their sense of self-worth. What a massive waste of time.
- gragas 9y ago>There is no doubt thay intelligence is purely genetic. Largely genetic, perhaps. Purely genetic, no. Blunt force trauma can cause brain damage. Blunt force trauma is not genetic.
- sattoshi 9y agoAlright then, your maximum intelligence is purely genetic. Everything else, or lack of certain things, lowers it.
- gragas 9y agoI agree. People who shoot down science because it's racist/sexist/etc. are shooting down the truth. People who make overreaching claims are just as detrimental. I think intelligence is very largely genetic. Claiming its "purely genetic" only gives more fodder for the "that's racist"-types to shoot it down.
- pjscott 9y agoI'm confused; what would it mean for that statement to be false? It sounds equivalent to "If everything non-genetic that can raise intelligence is present and everything non-genetic that can lower intelligence is absent, then the part that's left, the non-non-genetic component, is 100% genetic."
- jjawssd 9y agoAre the people with higher concentrations of these genes equally distributed geographically or do they tend to be more concentrated in some areas?
- defen 9y agoYou're not even allowed to ask that question, let alone attempt to answer it, if you want to get the funding to perform these studies.
- sattoshi 9y agoBecause it justifies scientific racism which people decided is a bad thing.. mostly after the second world war.
- jjawssd 9y agoWhy is this a taboo topic?
- defen 9y agoBecause people are afraid of what they might find. Because people are afraid it will be used to justify scientific racism. Because people are afraid of being cast out of polite society. Basically everything that Charles Murray predicted 20 years ago has come true or is coming true, but he literally gets physically assaulted if he tries to speak on college campuses.
- douche 9y agoGood question... unfortunately it tends to conflict with various socio-religious-philosophic categories.
- brobinson 9y agoIt would completely upend the belief that "all men are created equal"
- 9y ago
- MawNicker 9y agoHow do they control for environmental influence and correlations between environments and particular genes? Can someone elaborate on the "new statistical methods" briefly mentioned in the article.
- mattmcknight 9y ago"All association studies were performed on individuals of European descent; standard quality control procedures included correcting for population stratification and filtering on minor allele frequency"
- sbierwagen 9y agoFor the curious, this is known as a Genome-wide association study. There's been something of an explosion of these studies done, as cheap genotyping has given us datasets big enough to detect small effects. Wikipedia has an (excruciatingly technical) (edit: not really) overview here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study Wikipedia has a fun list of effect sizes here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_complex_trait_analysis#Traits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_complex_trait_anal... Unsurprisingly, height is 0.40-0.60 heritable, but did you know that "nostril area" is 0.657 heritable, while cilantro tasting is only 0.087? The NYT article seems to imply this is the first study of its kind to be done, which is absolutely not the case. The GCTA article linked above cites 18 GWASes on general intelligence, starting in 2011. The abstract on the Nature article focuses on the 15 new SNPs found that affect intelligence, in addition to the 336 already known. It's an incremental advance, not a stunning breakthrough. HN user gwern has covered this field extensively. Shouldn't be surprised to see him show up in this thread and gently correct some of the confused thinking in the light gray comments.
- logicallee 9y agoFWIW, I only read the first couple of sections of your first Wikipedia link (the overview). I didn't find it excruciatingly technical, and have no training in biology other than high school. Anyone who knows words like allele and phenotype from high school can feel free to click. It's interesting.
- sbierwagen 9y agoAh, somebody's tamed the article considerably since I last read it, a couple years ago. The article for linkage disequilibrium has some of the math I remember being in the GWAS article. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linkage_disequilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linkage_disequilibrium
- ganonm 9y agoI would highly recommend reading 'A brief history of everyone who ever lived' by Adam Rutherford. IIRC it contains a whole chapter on GWASs (pronounced jee-wazzes). There are some phenotypes (characteristics) which clearly can be associated with a small number of genes (e.g. autosomal recessive disorders) , however for many phenotypes such as intelligence, it takes a lot more effort to correlate them with underlying genotypes. The fact that intelligence is approximately normally distributed is an indicator that there are many individual effects at play.
- Chathamization 9y ago> But all of these genes together account for just a small percentage of the variation in intelligence test scores, the researchers found; each variant raises or lowers I.Q. by only a small fraction of a point. OK. Even if you believe there's an objective measure of intelligence and that IQ tests do a good job at measuring this (both very questionable premises), it's worth keeping in mind that slight monetary motivation can boost IQ scores by 10 points[1], and the general population's scores go up about 3 points every 10 years[2]. Much more of an impact than the genes here that correlate with "only a small fraction of a point" difference. [1] https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/motivation-may-influence-iq-scores https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/motivat... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4152423/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4152423/
- MagnumOpus 9y agoYou are 40 years out of date. The Flynn effect disappeared in the 1970s once everyone had compulsory secondary education and access to decent nutrition. Scores have been flat since then.[1] To your other point: just like money, a lot of other variables can influence test scores. As long as everyone in the study group gets the same monetary motivation or lack thereof, results will be robust. [1] https://image.slidesharecdn.com/intelligence-150210083926-conversion-gate01/95/intelligence-47-638.jpg?cb=1423579241 https://image.slidesharecdn.com/intelligence-150210083926-co...
- Chathamization 9y ago> You are 40 years out of date. The Flynn effect disappeared in the 1970s once everyone had compulsory secondary education and access to decent nutrition. Scores have been flat since then That's addressed in my second link (published 2014): The mean effect size for 53 comparisons (N = 3,951) (excluding three atypical studies that inflate the estimates) involving modern (since 1972) Stanford-Binet and Wechsler IQ tests (2.93, 95% CI [2.3, 3.5], IQ points per decade) was comparable to previous estimates of about 3 points per decade, but not consistent with the hypothesis that the Flynn effect is diminishing. As for your other point, the results of that study suggest that at least a large part of what's being tested is motivation. If people have motivations besides money (as most people do), or if monetary motivations aren't uniform across the population, this is going to influence the test. This is also a relatively recent study. It's likely that there are many other factors that have a large influence on the test that haven't been studied yet. At the very least, being able to significantly alter the test scores by giving someone a small monetary incentive shows that the scores aren't simply capturing innate ability.
- logicallee 9y agoImagine if you could choose exactly how smart you want your son or daughter to be - but only via a set of genes that also directly correspond to laziness. This sounds silly, doesn't it? But you can't deny that this article is a firm step in that direction. It's not crazy to think that parents may make gene choices in the future. This would be not just a new stage, but a new kind of evolution. (Not too scary in the form we're reading about, and close to everyday sexual selection of mates anyway.)
- neom 9y agoI suspect you're simply lucky if your brain is wired in a manner that is particularly relevant to the period of societal time. In that, I mean "IQ" is related/tied to a period of time. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSy685vNqYk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSy685vNqYk
- calebm 9y agoAnyone know if the SNP list is publicly available? I'd love check my numbers against my raw 23andMe data to see if I'm smart :)
- gwern 9y agoThe summary statistics are in fact available on the CTG website, but I'm not sure why you would want to bother. The performance of the polygenic score is about the same as the SSGAC polygenic score for Okbay/Selzam et al 2016, so Sniekers et al 2017 isn't all that helpful in that regard. (And in any case SSGAC is expected to come out with a paper this year with n=1m (!) http://programme.exordo.com/bga17/delegates/presentation/214/ http://programme.exordo.com/bga17/delegates/presentation/214... which is expected to at least double the polygenic score performance, so it'll be obsolete soon. And I hear there may be a second group with as large a sample size...)
- ralfd 9y agoCould you explain this like I'm fifteen?
- StavrosK 9y agoThere's this dude whose results are already about as good as this new dude's plus this other dude is gonna come out with a totally rad new set of results so you should just wait for those bro.
- sbierwagen 9y agoIf your GWAS has more people, the results are more accurate, and you can detect smaller effects, finding more SNPs that do something. The CTG study had 78,308 people in it, the SSGAC study will have 1,000,000.
- KKKKkkkk1 9y agoIs human intelligence really a thing? Sure, we can all tell the difference between a mathematics savant and a mentally challenged person. But is there really a reason to think that a single number can capture with any degree of accuracy some property of the connection structure of 10^11 brain neurons?
- pjscott 9y agoIt's an approximation, of course, but a surprisingly good one: loads of predictive value, very strong correlations with things people care about, and so on. For some quality pondering on the epistemology here, see http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/11/does-the-glasgow-coma-scale-exist-do-comas/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/11/does-the-glasgow-coma-s...
- jessriedel 9y agoThe best analogy is with general athletic ability. Yes of course, athletic ability is a multi-faceted thing; yes you can be good in different ways; yes, being the very best as baseball does not make the you very best at football; etc. Nonetheless, athletic-ness is a robust, real concept, which is very heritable, predictive of athletic success. Importantly, it encodes the empirical fact that if you are good at X compared to the general population, you are more likely to be good at Y, where X and Y can be almost any athletic activity.
- therealdrag0 9y agoTo tie your analogy back in: There is correlation in intellectual capacity between categories of intelligence (linguistic, mathematic, spacial, etc.). Individuals capabilities vary, but on average individuals high in one area are rarely below average in other area. (Anecdote: I found it no problem to get degrees in both Computer Science AND English with minors in French and Philosophy. Some people find it strange that someone could do both types of things, but I just like learning everything!)
- rimliu 9y agoMy friend, a math teacher, had this saying: only 5% are good at math, but those 5% are good at anything.
- e0m 9y ago"…they had identified 52 genes linked to intelligence in nearly 80,000 people. These genes do not determine intelligence, however."
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIntelligence is like TNT. It's not a virtue... it can just destroy things very quickly, for good or for ill.
- steanne 9y agoI make mistakes like the next man. In fact, being -- forgive me -- rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger. --Albus Dumbledore
- arethuza 9y agoI have to say that the really truly awful mistakes I've seen people make in my career in computing were actually extremely bright people acting with sheer hubris.
- flukus 9y ago-- Typed on a machine only possible because a lot of very smart people came before me. I wish you luck in your future hunter-gatherer career.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoDid you miss the part where I said "good or ill"?
- nocoder 9y agoI am curious, what is the definition of human intelligence? Blanket statements like A being more intelligent than B don't mean much outside of specific context. It is likely that certain kind of genes influence certain specific ability like math or soccer more than others. The idea of blanket intelligence does not provide much room for us to optimise for specific areas of intelligence.
- kyberias 9y agoMainly it's the G. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)
- madiathomas 9y agoThat's why I prefer using the context of that intelligence as a prefix. Like Messi is a "soccer" genius. Messi will probably score less than average in general intelligence tests.
- arethuza 9y agoHe certainly failed in basic understanding of tax law!
- madiathomas 9y agoIn his defence -> His father was responsible for his taxes. Wait a minute, am I admitting that his predecessor is dumb? He is probably dumb. Sidenote: I am a Messi fanboy.
- arethuza 9y agoWasn't his defence basically "I sign what my father tells me to sign without reading it"? NB I don't follow football but I've just finishing reading a book on the Panama Papers that features a section on him.
- kilotaras 9y ago
- tokenadult 9y ago"But all of these genes together account for just a small percentage of the variation in intelligence test scores, the researchers found; each variant raises or lowers I.Q. by only a small fraction of a point. 'It means there’s a long way to go, and there are going to be a lot of other genes that are going to be important,' Dr. Posthuma said." Indeed. This result is fully predictable from the several previous GWAS studies on IQ that have been done. Any gene that influences IQ in the general population has at most a small effect, and the variance among human individuals in IQ is the result of interaction of hundreds of genes and the environment the individual lives in. Here's a link to a lot of good writings by one of the leading researchers on human behavior genetics, for more details. I especially like one particular article I'll link just below the link to his collected writings. http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/vita1_turkheimer.htm http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/vita1_turkheimer.htm Turkheimer, E. (2000). Three laws of behavior genetics and what they mean. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9, 160-164. http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20Online%20CV/(45)%20Turkheimer%20(2000).pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20O...
- tptacek 9y agoMore of Turkheimer's writing here, recently, in Vox: https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/5/18/15655638/charles-murray-race-iq-sam-harris-science-free-speech https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/5/18/15655638/charles-... I assume the authors (all three of them professors of some renown) did not write this headline, because the piece is far better, more careful, and more comprehensive than the title would suggest (I'm no fan of Murray but this is not a typical Vox hot-take).
- maroonblazer 9y agoAs a response to the podcast the Vox piece is slipshod. One reads the article wondering if they even bothered to listen to the podcast. Here's a good takedown of the Vox article: https://medium.com/@houstoneuler/the-cherry-picked-science-in-voxs-charles-murray-article-bd534a9c4476 https://medium.com/@houstoneuler/the-cherry-picked-science-i...
- theprop 9y agoThe most impactful technology that will ever exist is "engineering human beings". This becomes possible as we identify genes for things like intelligence and with CRISPR. Intelligence is of course huge. Trustworthiness is huge. Probably 20% of GDP is related to trust whether it's paying for security, police, the military, $100s of billions of excess health care spending from over-billing and over-testing. I think engineered human super-intelligence will have inestimably more impact than AI...but it enables AI because in a world of a few billion Leonardos, everyone will have figured out ways to solve repetitive work.
- cLeEOGPw 9y agoSo far intelligence don't seem to be as one-sidedly positive trait as it seems for most here. With increased intelligence comes increased risk factors of many diseases like depression, anxiety, bipolar, and many others. That means that less intelligent people have actually more reliable brain health than more intelligent. So unless this problem is solved, simply adding the genes that, among other things, increase IQ, can backfire in unforeseen ways. Another thing is more intelligent people are predisposed to be less reproductive. In this way lesser intelligence is a balancing force for mental health and survival of species.
- Joeri 9y agoWe don't need smarter people, we need better ethics. Many of the monsters from history were highly intelligent. Many of the world's problems have ready solutions which are not applied because people are being clever. Think of intelligence as a force multiplier, if you apply it to a bad person they become a terrible person. It would be disastrous to start genetic engineering for intelligence prior to tackling the ethics problem. The biggest issue with better ethics is that we can't define them, so we couldn't optimize for them. Nobody agrees on what a good person is because nobody agrees on the meaning of good. But meanwhile the real world outcomes are decidedly not good.
- wiz21c 9y agospot on
- 9y ago
- rdl 9y agoI hope nothing bad happens to the scientists for pursuing this line of inquiry. Charles Murray basically got excommunicated for work in the general area of intelligence and populations; this is different, but could be viewed as worse by some people too.
- Houshalter 9y agoJames Watson lost his job just for making an offhanded remark about this subject. He had to sell his nobel prize to stay afloat. And still gets a ton of shit for it whenever his name comes up. Even on this website. It's dangerous to have opinions about this.
- mr_overalls 9y agoIt will be interesting to see how many people immediately accept the genetic influences on intelligence when it becomes possible to do something about it. When safe, effective germline engineering for greater intelligence and health is possible, I predict that it will be embraced as enthusiastically by the majority of society as indoor plumbing was.
- alextheparrot 9y agoCome now, Watson, when selling his medal, said he wanted to buy a painting and donate some of the money to charity [0], saying he needed it to stay afloat is disengenuous. If you can find support for Watson's statements, which he apologized for, regarding Africa's progress being correlated largely to their lower intelligence [1], I would love to explore it more. [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/11261872/James-Watson-selling-Nobel-prize-because-no-one-wants-to-admit-I-exist.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/11261872/James-Watso... [1] http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2007/10/watson-loses-cold-spring-harbor-post http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2007/10/watson-loses-cold-spr...
- Houshalter 9y agoI read that he said he was selling it because of his severely diminished income, which is true. But I guess he had enough saved and it was just for charity.
- RichardHeart 9y agoKinetic ability vs potential ability (should reduce the fear/hatred of differences in IQ): People overestimate the value of Intelligence in comparison to motivation, delayed gratification. How many people do you living up to their potential? Is it because they don't know what to do, or because they won't do what they should? If the difference in results is traction, not horsepower, then don't worry so much about someones bigger or smaller motor. Cascading advantage: People underestimate the value of small changes in some types of intelligence. They cascade. If you learn how to learn faster, or better, it cascades across all the new learning. Imagine a bookshelf vs a stack of books. Some people develop tricks early on that are the the shelves. Hit a golf ball a little crooked and see how crooked it ends up 100 yards away. Different is better: This social programming to search for equality amongst men ignores the value of evolution, competition, meritocracy, and the resultant emergent fitness and excellence that results. Different, sometimes better, sometimes worse, is a requirement for robustness and progress. See higher resolution: Measure mental ability more like physical ability. Look at the detail measured in the nfl combine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_Scouting_Combine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_Scouting_Combine When you create an IQ test, you use specific stratagies to avoid cultural bias, and measure useful traits, like memory, speed, visualization, rotating objects in ones mind, etc. Why not just declare the results by category. The test maker knew what he was measuring. There's no reason to mush it all together.
- cousin_it 9y agoIn Vernor Vinge's "Deepness in the Sky", the villains use a kind of mind enhancement called Focus which isn't really mind enhancement at all, it just makes you obsessively focused on whatever task they give you. I've long thought that the first "mind enhancement" tech to appear would be like that, because it seems easier than hacking g.
- arethuza 9y agoIn "Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow", the sequel to Sapiens, the author describes a "focus helmet" being developed by the US armed forces that provides a degree of Vinge-like focus.
- 9y ago
- lngnmn 9y agoThe gap between genes and intelligence is the same as between individual characters and poetry, or even bits of UTF-8 encoding. But it is fun to watch these "0.40 heritable" meaningless statements. This is the same as to claim that a particular tech-process of a CPU and its particular instruction set defines what kind of porn would be watched on a laptop. While there are few statistical correlations, say, between the cost of a CPU and statistically significant preference to, say, MILFs, a direct causality is still rather difficult to establish, at least for people of some intelligence.
- madiathomas 9y agoI usually score higher when taking intelligent tests, but I dismiss all the intelligent tests I have taken. I know people who are more intelligent than me who can score higher if they are tested in their own indigenous languages and on subjects that are important to their cultural backgrounds. For someone who lives in a remote area and survives on hunting wild animals, being able to tell where game is situated, is more valuable than matching some geometrical figures or knowing capital city of a country he will never visit. Such tests that take into account language and cultural differences don't exist. Not knowing something you are not interested in, doesn't make one dumb. It is just not important to that person. I also noticed that the older I grow, the higher my IQ due to voraciously reading technical books and articles.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nyolfen 9y ago>I also noticed that the older I grow, the higher my IQ due to voraciously reading technical books and articles. I can guarantee you this is not the case. This comment is honestly so thoroughly full of misconceptions about the nature of IQ and IQ testing that it reads like a troll.
- madiathomas 9y agoPlease enlighten me about those misconceptions you are talking about. While at it, show me an IQ test that was compiled using my first language since you are dismissing facts I put on the table.
- nyolfen 9y agoIQ is a relatively stable attribute after adolescence. it begins declining around 60. http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/education/ageing-and-skills_5k9csvw87ckh-en http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/education/ageing-and-skills_5k9... IQ is meant to measure g, or 'general intelligence'. it's roughly the ability to solve complex tasks, and tends to span across domains (ie, if you are above average in one area of problem-solving, you are likely to be above average in others): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) >While at it, show me an IQ test that was compiled using my first language since you are dismissing facts I put on the table. just for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven%27s_Progressive_Matrices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven%27s_Progressive_Matrices
- oh_sigh 9y agoLord help us if intelligent is correlated some how with neanderthal, denisovan, etc genes.
- gwern 9y agoDon't worry, they're probably not. Denisovan admixture is minimal, and the more substantial admixture with Neanderthal genes appear to be evolutionarily selected against, and the genetic correlations people have computed so far have generally been bad ones. I haven't seen a specific education-IQ/Neanderthal correlation reported yet, but no one has reported noting the education-IQ PGSes as being oddly enriched in Neanderthal variants, and the Neanderthal genetic correlation papers haven't said anything about education-IQ despite the PGSes being publicly available & on LD Hub etc, so arguing from silence, I think there's probably either no correlation or it's negative. There's an interesting debate about why this is the case: were Neanderthals sufficiently distant from humans that their genetic variants tend to be incompatible, or was it because the smaller Neanderthal population made it harder to purge bad mutations so more of their variants were simply bad in general, or something else entirely?
- ekns 9y agoI recall seeing this Google Tech Talk by Steve Hsu on how they are in the process of finding out basically all the additive genes that contribute to intelligence in China at the BGI research institute: https://youtu.be/62jZENi1ed8 https://youtu.be/62jZENi1ed8 They would take roughly a thousand people who are >=3 standard deviations smarter than average and compare their full genomes against people who are of average intelligence. This way they expect to find out all the "easy" genetic determinants of intelligence.
- z3t4 9y agoa pill that increase intelligence is a wet dream. but imagine the placebo effect - it should not be underestimated.
- phkahler 9y agoIt's nice to identify genes that have influence, but I wouldn't cal it an "Enormous Success" by any means. Given the following: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2014/celebrating-science.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2... It turns out that one genetic variant has caused two different mental illnesses and they still don't know why. The treatment for them is the same though. Of course they are not twins, so there may be other genes in play that may account for the difference in manifestation. For me the bottom line is that evolution is still hard at work changing the human brain to work the way we need it to in modern times.
- hackernewsacct 9y agoIQ test results are not completely valid in all cases. Feynman was tested at 125. He wouldn't qualify for MENSA. It is thought by some Feynman may have done exceptionally well in the areas that deal with numbers, logic, pattern matching but poorly in the verbal areas of the test, thus suppressing his overall score. How many people here have a tested IQ higher than 125 want to say they're smarter than Feynman? IQ test are also not completely accurate for those that are gifted and have a learning disability. Kids that are gifted + LD'd may not even be put in gifted programs because their IQ scores are too low, but too high to put in an LD program, so they are stuck in normal class rooms where it isn't a good fit for them. Imagine being just as intelligent, if not more so, as the students in the gifted classes but denied access. That's what IQ scores do for some of those kids. IQ test tend to work for gifted people that answer questions quickly and those without lopsided talent. If you are gifted + LD, or gifted but have really slow processing speed, then IQ test will not identify you as really that gifted, despite being so.
- mowenz 9y agoThe most amazing thing about IQ tests are that some social (really pseudo--they cant really experimentally test theory) scientists convinced the world these things matter. If you go and read the literature the idea is that thete is a concept called g, general intelligence, and that IQ tests dont test that, but produce a result which correlates with g. In this framework it is acceptable that Feynman's g is different from his IQ score--they were only ever meant to be correlated.
- pas 9y agoThings progressed a bit since then, and [IQ, but let's say SAT] test scores correlate very well with a lot of things. Even after controlling for as much socioeconomic and other confounding factors as you can. (Sure, that's still not a conclusive experiment.)
- mowenz 9y agoWe agree they do correlate, but there is actually some debate about just how well intelligence tests do correlate with success, but the general idea of them remains the same as described above afaik, unless you'd like to point what has changed? Many things correlate with successful life outcomes. Height for instance correlates with income.
- zouhair 9y agoDefine intelligence.
- jlebrech 9y agoSo we'll be able to assign jobs at birth? http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119177/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119177/