11 ms·
Does any government in the world have a sensible plan for what happens when (probably) 1 in 10 of the workforce become unemployable when self-driving cars/truck
by rwmj 10y ago
Does any government in the world have a sensible plan for what happens when (probably) 1 in 10 of the workforce become unemployable when self-driving cars/trucks take over their jobs?
- throwaway2048 10y agoI'm sure the mighty invisible hand will save us all in its bosom. What we need is faith.. err confidence in the market. All praises be to the one true god money.
- gooseus 10y agoI haven't heard of one, the conspiracy-theorist in me is reminded of all the ammunition that various federal agencies have been purchasing over the last decade and the militarization of local law enforcement. I'm not sure if that's an indication of any actual plan (certainly not a sensible one) or simply a hedge against the fact that nobody has one, or nothing at all. In any case, ignoring even just the truckers is a bad idea (let alone ups, fedex, usps, etc), they know the highways and the trucks and if they form a new Luddite group then any self-driving trucking company is going to be in for some surprise expenses when their trucks start disappearing and/or breaking down randomly in the middle of nowhere.
- snerbles 10y agoThose agencies tend to pre-purchase ammo years in advance, and the "militarization" of police is mostly from agencies receiving surplus equipment from the DoD for pennies on the dollar. Lord knows civilian cops don't have the same level of discipline - if I pulled one-tenth of that sort of abuse while I was an enlisted MP, I'd be rotting in a cell in Fort Leavenworth instead of writing this post. All that being said, I wouldn't be surprised if certain elites have noticed that public sentiment is resembling France in the 1790s. This whole surveillance apparatus is here to intercept the next Robespierre, national security be damned.
- scrumper 10y agoI haven't heard a single proposal yet. I could imagine a government passing a succession of laws which first required all autonomous trucks to have a supervising human on board (with a relaxation of existing maximum hour rules), operating under a new Trucking Supervisor License (which any current CDL holder is automatically granted); then slowly ratcheting up restrictions on actual CDLs (reduced hours, reduced permissible routes, reduced maximum weight) to make them less attractive; then ultimately ceasing issuance of new CDLs for heavy trucks once the final generation of drivers-cum-supervisors has retired.
- jtuente 10y agoThe second part of your proposal doesn't make any sense in the scheme of transitioning humans out of that sector of the workforce. Increasing restrictions on CDL issuance doesn't make it any easier to transition drivers out, it kicks them out. I find it comparable to increasing the minimum wage of fast food workers as the food prep process is increasingly automated. It simply makes it more and more favorable to choose the automated option.
- scrumper 10y agoIt stops more coming in; existing holders keep driving (base case) or move to those supervisory roles. Ending the supervisory license and mandate is the end game, done once most of that last generation of CDL holders has hung up their hats. This is really about long distance, semi truck freight only. Local delivery (as someone mentioned above) is likely to need humans for a very long time.
- atonse 10y agoApart from people putting out feelers about a Universal Basic Income, the next best thing I've heard is an informal proposal by Bill Gates about taxing automation [1] so we can better control the speed in which this stuff will upend everything, and buy more time for a more controlled transition. I say that as a developer who is one of the classes that will benefit more from automation (until we are also replaced). [1]: https://qz.com/911968/bill-gates-the-robot-that-takes-your-job-should-pay-taxes/ https://qz.com/911968/bill-gates-the-robot-that-takes-your-j...
- malandrew 10y agoThat sounds like a recipe for crippling the competitiveness of the US relative to other countries. It's not like China is going to slow down on the inevitable march towards automation. The absolute best scenario is for a country to automate as much as possible as quickly as possible to capture the productivity gains available on the global scale and then figure out how to tax gains (from automation or otherwise) domestically after the fact to support those in its population that have been displaced. If you think instability from unemployment is bad, it's certainly worse if you also have the problem of not having the resources to even try and address it.
- TheAdamAndChe 10y ago"Competitiveness" means nothing when only a fraction of the population prosper from those gains. On paper, America is significantly richer than it was in the 80's, yet incomes for the majority have been flat, social mobility has decreased, worker leverage has nearly disappeared, and quality of life for those outside of the coastal regions has gone down. There's no reason to push for exponential growth any further until we can correct income and wealth inequality a bit.
- malandrew 10y agoIt's better that a fraction of the population prosper that the can act philanthropically or that rest of the country can tax. The alternative is a fraction of the population of another country prosper over which we have no power to tax and whose philanthropy likely won't benefit Americans. The former gives you options, the latter affords you none.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoNot to mention entire small town economies, particularly in the West, are entirely economically dependent on truckers to stop by, rest, fuel up, visit prostitutes etc. Those people are gonna have a much harder time. Any owners of property will see the values of their assets plummet just as their jobs disappear.
- mikestew 10y agoI see the rare few towns along, say, the Dalton Highway on the way to Deadhorse, Alaska as being the first to go. Ignoring the weather for just a moment, that 400 miles of packed gravel would have to be an appealing target for autonomous vehicle engineers. Mostly straight, mostly flat (albeit with one non-trivial mountain pass), little traffic other than other trucks. And poof, there goes Coldfoot and Yukon River when humans don't stop anymore (except for a smattering of tourists). Or maybe the tank range is enough that trucks don't stop between Fairbanks and Deadhorse the way it is now, and I'm talking out my ass. All I know is that the traffic I saw last time I was up there consisted of a lot of trucks, a minivan, one camper at the Arctic Circle that said they were going to Deadhorse, and the remainder of tourist traffic consisting of a bunch of dumbasses like me on motorcycles.
- niftich 10y agoI'd guess that a road like Dalton where weather-related and road condition-related hazards can suddenly appear, would make an exceedingly poor fit for self-driving non-guideway vehicles. Far better would be vehicles -- self-driving or otherwise -- on some sort of fixed guideway; given that most of the current usage of the road is for traffic solely between the two points-of-interest on either end. Special vehicles could still be used to access the pipeline running alongside at arbitrary points. A railway, potentially with extra equipment to assist with maintaining traction and negotiating grades, would accomplish this nicely, but is avoided due to its large up-front cost. While self-driving vehicles don't come with such large non-distributed up-front cost, they would be unreliable on such a road without permanent in-vehicle supervision, at which point they're not really making any of the intervening towns that provide driver services superfluous.
- cmiles74 10y agoIn my experience, the US federal government tends to see this as an issue for those who are being unemployed to figure out for themselves. Not to be cynical, but I wouldn't be surprised if their solution boiled down to granting lots of money to private companies to try to tempt them into providing retraining.
- golemotron 10y agoAdd the implosion of brick and mortar retail and we're in for some hard times. Automating away jobs increases inequality.
- mullen 10y agoClinton did. She had a jobs retraining program that would have addressed people in industries that were in decline or going away. Ironically, the very people who would benefit from this program mostly vote for Trump and he is not going to do anything for them. Automation is coming for these people's jobs and there is nothing that can be done about that. Retraining is the only hope for these people but they have to stop acting entitled and start voting for people who will help them get retrained.
- wavefunction 10y agoI think rural America needs more than retraining programs, though you're correct that Donald Trump has made no mention of what he's actually going to do for coal workers. They need new and dynamic industries that treat the employees with respect and agency. Something entire communities can benefit from.
- krapp 10y ago> Donald Trump has made no mention of what he's actually going to do for coal workers. He apparently plans to revive the coal industry by repealing environmental regulations and to put them back to work mining coal[0,1]. [0]https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/29/business/coal-jobs-trump-appalachia.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/29/business/coal-jobs-trump-... [1]https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2017-03-27/trump-s-order-won-t-resurrect-jobs-of-miners-key-to-his-campaign https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2017-03-27/trump...
- wavefunction 10y agoForgive me for saying so, but I don't believe that's much of a realistic plan. Which to me is no plan at all.
- krapp 10y agoIt's not even remotely realistic, it's a populist fantasy. Nevertheless, that is the plan, to somehow force the world to turn the clock back on globalism to a time when American coal, steel and auto workers were relevant, and to beat back the tide of modernity until the world makes sense again.
- jackhack 10y agoThe same thing that, at the turn of the century when one in ten people were employed in agriculture. (today it's closer to 1/100) they go find other work. Same goes for a farrier or a blacksmith or milkman, or ice delivery, or newpaper boy shouting "extra, extra - read all about it" from the street corner. In some cases, the job is simply gone. In others, the work still exists, but is nowhere as common.
- wonderwonder 10y agoI agree to a point but I think it is a different scenario today as you have unprecedented concentration of wealth in the top 1 % as well as the means of production. I have a hard time seeing how 5% of the nations workforce suddenly transitions to jobs that did not exist before. You also have an increase in the cost of living where most households require two incomes compounding the issue. With agriculture new jobs were created as people moved to cities and new communities were created. those cities already exist. Short of a sudden civilization focused effort to colonize mars, I just don't see it.
- malandrew 10y agoI honestly don't think we pay enough attention to the rising cost of living. Cost of living should go down year over year due to productivity gains, but we see at least three line items becoming more expensive over time: (1) housing, (2) healthcare, and (3) higher education. https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost-disease/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost... https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/17/highlights-from-the-comments-on-cost-disease/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/17/highlights-from-the-co... https://howmuch.net/articles/american-spending-past-75-years https://howmuch.net/articles/american-spending-past-75-years
- cousin_it 10y agoAmusingly, these exact three things were free in the USSR. I benefited from that a lot. Though most other consumer goods were less affordable and lower quality in the USSR than in the US, and the economy was in worse shape overall. I wonder if there's a way to combine the two systems without people screaming blue murder.
- petra 10y agoI can see an alternate scenario happening: Let's say, for the sake of argument, self-driving cars and truck, fully deployed, are 10 years away. In that time we might see a move to many more drivers on the road, not less: A lot of growth in food delivery, e-commerce and in particular shuttles offering a fast,affordable, shared transport mode, as an attractive replacement for private cars in many places. Maybe, with all of that, instead of 1/10 we'll have 2/10 of the workforce as drivers. Consider the effect their salaries have on the families, and indirect support extended families has, we could see a really strong political base against self-driving cars. And from that point, all kinds of things could happen, to better manage or prevent that change.
- chii 10y ago> political base against self-driving cars. it doesn't matter how strong the political base is, when there's profit motive, the humans will lose to machines.
- wonderwonder 10y agoIts interesting as we are seeing a similar scenario play out in the energy sector with the shift away from coal. So far the government response has essentially been to ignore it or to use it as a scape goat for relaxing environmental protections. As far as having a real plan dedicated to finding people decent paying and more importantly fulfilling jobs, i believe the answer is for the most part no. Finland beginning a limited basic income trial is the closest I have seen. It is a kick the can scenario that has the possibility of massively reducing the quality of life of tens of millions of people.
- cbanek 10y agoNo, not really. If anything, it's likely those people might have a lot higher risk of suicide. (deaths of despair) "Because at 54 years old, nobody wants me. I can’t retrain for anything else. For older people, you kind of get trapped. For every one that does well, there’s 30 that it destroys." That feeling that nobody wants you is a killer. It may be true, it may not, but that lack of hope just prevents anything good from happening. "I can't retrain for anything" - you're defeated right from the start, and it's obvious people don't even want to take the leap to try. It's hardest on people that had it good, and then lost it. Much worse than those that never had it, in that you feel like you're losing something. (endowment effect) Here's an interesting article the WaPo did about whites and a lack of hope. While there is a race component to it, I think it'd equally apply to other races where people have had a good/stable life, but lost it. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/05/15/the-worst-thing-poor-whites-are-inheriting-could-be-a-lack-of-hope/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/05/15/the-w... http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/03/23/521083335/the-forces-driving-middle-aged-white-peoples-deaths-of-despair http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/03/23/52108333...
- watwut 10y agoFrom the article it seems that whites in the same situation as blacks have the same mortality rates - "If you compare whites with a high school degree or less with blacks with a high school degree or less, their mortality rates have converged." It suggests that the group having higher status previously does not change things all that much.
- cbanek 10y agoI don't think it's about the groups having higher status or not, say whites vs blacks, but in the article they say they believe the cause is: "These deaths of despair have been accompanied by reduced labor force participation, reduced marriage rates, increases in reports of poor health and poor mental health. So we are beginning to thread a story in that it's possible that [the trend is] consistent with the labor market collapsing for people with less than a college degree. In turn, those people are being less able to form stable marriages, and in turn that has effects on the kind of economic and social supports that people need in order to thrive." Like you said, the rates are converging when they have a high school degree or less. These are the kinds of people that get hit the hardest when the labor market is collapsing. It's not that "whites had it before and now they don't", it's "I used to believe I was entitled to a job if I wanted to work hard, and that would pay enough to live, but now that doesn't seem to be true." People just don't know what to do now and are feeling hopeless.
- dboreham 10y agoPerhaps they are not drinking the koolaid you need to drink in order to believe that self-driving vehicles are likely to work well enough to be widely deployed in the next 20 years?
- galdosdi 10y agoWell, I wasn't sure either, but have you seen Waymo's current state-reported stats for mean miles driven between human takeover incidents? If not, look them up, they are very impressive. If you still disagree, please elaborate on _why_ you think this
- adrianN 10y agoTrucks travel a lot of highway miles. That is a significantly easier problem than general driving. Even if you don't believe that general driving will be solved in 20 years, you can easily imagine trucks doing their highway driving alone and only having the last couple of miles taken care of by humans.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoCurrently in the US the workforce population rate is at an all time low in almost 40 years. Basically the same number of people working as in the early 1970s. Yikes. My point is we're already in this situation, automation be damned, and until the tsunami of anti-intellectualism backs off, then smart people aren't going to have a chance to actually figure some of this out.
- ryandrake 10y agoHow about when 9 in 10 become unemployable? Human nature is not ready for this world. We are dogmatic puritanical beasts obsessed with the idea that a person's value must be inextricably tied to one's economic output. We're more likely to see a worldwide make-work program where 1/2 of the people are paid to dig holes and the other 1/2 paid to fill them in, than we are to see something like universal basic income.
- iak8god 9y agoNot sure that's strictly Human Nature, but it's certainly the prevailing paradigm in this time and place.
- skocznymroczny 10y agoWhen will that happen? Self-driving cars/trucks aren't anywhere near being deployed on real roads. Also, as soon as there's an accident and the self-driving car kills a child, they will be postponed for at least 5 years until safety assurances are strengthened.