6 ms·
> the modeling required to find arbitrage or alpha does Not really. Even if everyone is just throwing darts, half of the players will beat the market, and the
by lisper 10y ago
> the modeling required to find arbitrage or alpha does
Not really. Even if everyone is just throwing darts, half of the players will beat the market, and the more players you have the more extreme the outliers will be. Of course, the converse is also true, but no one pays attention to the losers. Both Vegas and Wall Street prosper from this same principle.
- cheez 10y agoI also think so, but... Gotta keep up the charade imo. Can't prove otherwise.
- vowelless 10y ago> half of the players will beat the market For how long? And if it is for more than one sample (year), then how do you explain the continued success of places like Renaissance Technologies? > Both Vegas and Wall Street prosper from this same principle. I think poker is probably the closest thing in Vegas that matches Wall Street. Probably why it is so popular among quants.
- moxious 10y agoThere's such a thing as real alpha and also just luck. In a market with so many players, you would also expect that random chance would predict many people winning consistently year after year. This is not to say that all such funds can be explained this way. But most of the successful ones likely yes
- dsacco 10y agoVirtu only lost money trading one day out of 1278 trading days between 2009 and 2014. In the most uncharitable analysis (1278/2; or the lost day happened in the middle), they had a 0.5^639 chance of doing that. Maybe you disagree with 0.5 per day. Let's make it 0.9! ...But that's still 5.7 x 10^-30. How many firms do we need to exist for this to emerge by chance? This and website bug bounties being sold on the black market are my two HN crusades. I have heard darts, I have heard coin flipping; I hear all manner of analogies from people who stubbornly insist or strongly imply that consistently, purposely beating the market is infeasible in principle. But no one ever does a modicum of analysis to support whatever trite analogy that's thrown out, they just wave their hands and exclaim, "statistics!". So here is something actually quantifiable. If you have something quantifiable to refute my analysis of your analogy in turn, please share it by all means.
- kasey_junk 10y ago> Virtu only lost money one day out of 1278 trading days Lost money trading. If they made $1 trading that counted though I assure you that day was a loser from a business perspective. I also have not lost money trading in 3 years, simply by not trading at all. It doesn't really detract from your broader point, which I don't have a strong opinion on but that stat is a pet peeve of mine as it's fairly meaningless.
- dsacco 10y agoFair enough, that's correct :) But as you said, it doesn't detract from the point, even if we shift the definition a bit. The likelihood is still clearly beyond what would emerge by chance.
- SEJeff 10y agoThis is massively incorrect. If Virtu only made $1 trading, they would still make massive amount of $$$ via exchange rebates, as they are a designated market maker. In fact, they aren't the only market maker that does this. A market maker guarantees they'll take trades on both sides of the book, so long as their strategies aren't grotesquely losing, they'll always come out ahead due to exchange rebates. http://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/042414/what-makertaker-fees-mean-you.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/042414/w... Source: I worked for Virtu's predecessor Madison Tyler for 4 years and for Virtu after it merged with Madison Tyler for ~8 months and have first hand experience with HFT.
- tptacek 10y agoFor whatever it's worth and on the off chance that this short-circuits a really common message board pathology, and allowing that I'm only commenting here because I read all of Kasey's comments: he's got HFT experience too. I think he's just saying that particular metric is missing context: a lot of crappy businesses could claim never to have lost a dollar trading, while still as businesses losing tens or hundreds of millions of dollars chasing, and not finding, profits. I don't think he's arguing specifically that Virtu lost money.