32 ms·
A Physicist Who Denies Dark Matter
- shakna 10y agoThe title is irritating. This is an interview with Milgrom, covering the man more than MOND. But, dark matter isn't something to be denied. Because it isn't understood yet, to the point where we can doubt its existence. We don't have all the answers yet, where denial rejects something as patently false. But, "The man who has an alternative to Dark Matter", is a far less attractive title for those clicks.
- laumars 10y agoIronically I'm now more interested to read it after hearing your alternative title.
- Lordarminius 10y ago> ...But, dark matter isn't something to be denied. Because it isn't understood yet, to the point where we can doubt its existence.... There is something not quite right with your logic and I am struggling to identify what it is :/
- shakna 10y agoMaybe I can expand. I can deny the Earth is flat, because there is an abundance of evidence that it is round. I can't deny that there are 650 elements, because as far as I know, other elements may be discovered. But I can certainly doubt it, and supply alternative theories. I can deny allegations of wrong doing, because they either happened, or didn't. But Dark Matter isn't assured yet. Denying it means it either exists or doesn't. But the truth may be a mix of MOND and something different but similar to Dark Matter. It isn't "fixed" into a yes/no situation.
- badosu 10y agoDark Matter is not just 'something we don't understand yet'. It has predictable effects on observations and adheres to some properties, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster .
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tynpeddler 9y agoThat's evidence, not proof. We still don't have enough evidence to say conclusively that Dark matter is as we currently imagine it. And of course the same can be said about MOND. Here's Milgrom's interpretation of the bullet cluster: http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ssm/mond/moti_bullet.html http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ssm/mond/moti_bullet.html
- badosu 9y agoI am not saying Dark Matter is something that actually exists that cannot be ruled out by other explanations (a revision of GR would be ideal IMO), just that this phenomenon makes the approach much trickier.
- kobeya 10y agoHe expressed it badly. The point I think he is trying to say is that dark matter can be neither proven nor disproven at this time with the information available. An intellectually honest person should remain open to both possibilities. You can say "I am not convinced of the dark matter hypothesis." But unless you have information the rest of us do not, you can't really say "I deny the dark matter hypothesis could be real."
- kradem 10y agoI [too] don't think it's about bad wording, yet pure bad logic. The article is positioned on the principle that was imagined based on wrong assumtions of other theory and which acceptance will dissmiss the other theory. I'm not even being close to think of being positioned on a side there, but afaic one could easily take one in this subthread. TL; DR yep, dark matter could be denied no matter of the state of its understanding - just bring the better explanation of those irregularities its existence explains!
- boomboomsubban 10y agoAcceptance doesn't dismiss theories, evidence does. A physicist shouldn't truly deny anything, just look at the evidence and say it is not the best theory. Even with a better explanation, we can't be sure more information won't see the return of dark matter. Milgrom should understand this well, he's suggesting the return of the cosmological constant.
- kradem 10y agoForget dark matter, use the analogy from the article: afaik nobody has ever proven ether is not existing. I know nothing about dark matter, but I could play a zero-sum game based on this article content - just the way anybody else could play - and outcome of that game is according to this article proven theory of this guy denies dark matter and dark energy theory. And that's all, we could prove bad logic here without waiting for the third season of Dark Matter to be broadcasted.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 10y agoIt appears to be a very common trend. Modern mass culture creates more interest in people's personalities than in anything else. I feel it every day myself, when I can't help noticing how easy it is for any serious discussion to quickly decay into talking about someone's personal traits, habits or preferences.
- JoBrad 10y agoHumans have evolved for thousands of years to be social creatures, and to judge the merits of things that they may not understand by the characteristics of the person championing them. That's not modern mass culture, it's the way humans operate. I personally think it's also why many scientists fail to convince people versus (comparatively) charismatic novices.
- gaius 10y agoThe use of the word "deny" is deliberate, it's used to invoke the phrase "holocaust denier" to smear the person you're accusing of it. An underhanded tactic from the author of this hit-piece.
- fpoling 10y agoWhat is puzzling about MOND and to lesser extent about Dark Matter is that both uses violation of Newton mechanics to justify themselves when we know that Newtonian mechanics is wrong. The problem is that we cannot yet model behavior of galaxies using just General Relativity. Typically models assumes Newtonian physics with minimal accounting for relativity. However there is no sound proof that it is a valid approximation. The General Relativity is extremely non-linear and even small contribution may lead to very big consequences. We cannot yet rule out that there are no problems with dynamic of galaxies. It can be that we model them using wrong approximations.
- Maken 10y agoThere is something that always puzzles me and I would like if something could illuminate me. How are those kind of massive scale astrophysical calculations made? Do they take into account every visible mass aggregate in the galaxy and simulate them, or just apply cinematic at scale assuming the galaxy centre is a point of certain mass? I have played a little with N body simulations and I can't but be amazed about how numerically unstable physical simulations are, and how much the result can change depending on trivial simplifications.
- danielbarla 10y agoI'm not much of an expert on the topic, but have also played with writing N-body simulations. At some point, obviously N^2 is unfeasible, so most simulations seem to use some approximation, such as the Barnes-Hut approach [1]. That approach divides the simulation space into an octtree. One can then use said octtree to approximate the force of distant quadrants by simply using the center of mass of an entire region. Due to the rate at which gravity drops off over large distances, it's "accurate enough", and fortunately the majority of "N" is "distant". A good (but pretty shallow) overview exists on Wikipedia about other approaches [2] (under "Calculation optimizations"). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnes%E2%80%93Hut_simulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnes%E2%80%93Hut_simulation [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_simulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_simulation EDIT: It's occurred to me that you were referring more to stability of the simulation, rather than what optimisations are used. I have less information to offer on that part, and I agree that it would be a huge problem, if complete accuracy was desired. I suspect, however, that in the kinds of simulations we're talking about, it's more about a general result such as "the whole galaxy should be divergent", not whether a single star went left or right when interacting with a black hole.
- solotronics 10y agothe non light emitting mass could be Dyson spheres of space based computers
- JoBrad 10y agoWe're compelled to choose the option which requires the fewest assumptions. Dyson spheres involve a level of assumptions far beyond dark matter and dark energy. There would have to be Dyson spheres everywhere, that do not radiate heat, and that support some civilization that leaves very few traces.
- matt123 10y agoClouds of gas and dust don't emit light, yet we know they exist and can estimate their mass. Couldn't we apply the same methods to Dyson spheres if this was the case?
- wayn3 10y agoEverything that has temperature emits electromagnetic radiation. Including clouds of dust.
- hwillis 10y agoDark matter isn't just dark, it doesn't interact with normal matter. When galaxies collide when can verify via gravitational lensing that the normal matter smashes together while the dark matter continues unimpeded in straight lines through each other.
- marcosdumay 9y agoStars also don't interact with other stars that way. AFAIK, the bullet cluster is not evidence for WIMPs.
- hwillis 9y agoyou're correct, but it is very strong evidence for dark matter in general.
- douche 10y agoDark matter appears, to a layman with some historical knowledge, as nothing more than modern day epicycles. When we can't explain something with the models we have, and have to invent magic terms to balance the equations, that indicates that we really don't know what the fuck is going on.
- douche 10y agoWhoo, boy, the astrophysics fanboys that come out of the woodwork to suppress the notion that the emperor has no clothes
- jcranmer 9y agoEven as someone who would rather MOND be true than dark matter, I have to admit that dark matter is internally consistent in ways that MOND is not. By comparison to the theories of planetary movement (since you seem to love comparing dark matter to them so much), MOND is rather like the Copernican model and dark matter rather like Kepler's model. It's well-known that the traditional equations are off. MOND provides a fix that starts off looking better, but the more precise you do the measurements, the more you need to add the fudge factors in to make the numbers come out right, and it ends up being just as bad as the original--which is a reasonable description of the evolution of the Copernican model. By contrast, both Kepler's model and dark matter provide a much more accurate picture with a somewhat more complex addendum to the original non-fudged equations. But they also both lack mechanistic explanations for their origin: Kepler's model ruined the traditional explanation of how planets moved and inherited the stellar parallax death-knell from Copernicus's theory. In the case of planetary motion, it took the development of Newton's Law of Gravitation and the derivation of Kepler's laws of planetary motion from said theory to provide a sound mechanistic basis. We lack that mechanistic basis for dark matter, but that doesn't really mean that dark matter is inherently wrong.
- nilson 9y agoWhy do physicists believe that formulas should be elegant, beautiful etc.? Maybe that is not how universe works.
- RockyMcNuts 10y agoHow do you explaining gravitational lensing with no visible mass, without dark matter? In other words situations where we see twin images of a very distant galaxy because light curves around intervening mass, without sufficient mass observable to explain the deflection? I was under the impression that we could map dark matter localized to a precision that tended to rule out measurement error or a general divergence from Einstein's laws, unless it had a peculiar non-uniform distribution. Edit: maybe somebody can explain these maps - http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/03/scientists-unveil-most-detailed-map-dark-matter-date http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/03/scientists-unveil-mos...
- dinglebert1234 10y agoBecause our calculations are made with poor assumptions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vivekd 10y ago>How do you explaining gravitational lensing with no visible mass, without dark matter? Black holes? The physicist says: >What struck me was some regularity in the anomaly. The rotational velocities were not just larger than expected, they became constant with radius. Why? Sure, if there was dark matter, the speed of stars would be greater, but the rotation curves, meaning the rotational speed drawn as a function of the radius, could still go up and down depending on its distribution. But they didn’t. That seems pretty damning for any theory that relies on dark matter.
- _ph_ 10y ago>>How do you explaining gravitational lensing with no visible mass, without dark matter? >Black holes? Well, black holes are not really black, you can see their accretion disk. Also, a centralized huge mass would create a different velocity profile from what we are seeing. So black holes are pretty much out.
- 10y ago
- agentgt 10y agoThis almost an exact duplicate: http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/144/the-physicist-who-denies-that-dark-matter-exists http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/144/the-physicist-who-denies-t... and original HN comments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13743439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13743439 Do people not search Agolia before posting? Is it acceptable to repost things? (I'm not HN expert).
- douche 10y agoMeta, but whatever. You really ought to check the search funtion for a url before you post it. But the dupe detector/merger ought to be smarter, in a world where medium and feedburner, to take two examples, tack all manner of querystring garbage onto a url.
- jcroll 10y agoActually what's disturbing (and I am a paid subscriber to nautil.us) is that nautil.us is duplicating content. They took that old interview and passed it off as new content in their latest edition. Not really fair to us paying readers!
- platz 10y agothe domains are different. is "cosmos" a separate thing?
- jcroll 10y agoIt's actually my favorite part of nautil.us but has not been updated lately so maybe I am the only one :( It is a subsection (as it is a subdomain) but it's linked to directly from their main page. Consider it a magazine within the main publication.
- s_dev 9y agoDo you pay anything more than attention to nautil.us? I think that site gets far too much coverage on HackerNews along with atlas obscura -- I see multiple articles everyday. Honestly I find their content here too frequently -- there is some manipulation going on.
- jessriedel 10y agoAlmost ever sentence in this comment is wrong.
- BoiledCabbage 10y agoAnd the second word of the only sentence in your comment is wrong. Please provide a constructive, substantive critique or don't comment at all.
- jessriedel 9y agoThe fact that someone with more expertise is warning that a discussion is going off the rails is a useful, constructive fact. Demanding that that person explain in detail why in order to contribute is a good way to make sure they don't bother.
- gus_massa 9y agoAs the official self appointed Em-Drive denier here, my recommendation is to provide more information in the comments. Sometimes it's difficult. Most commenters here are not experts in the particular field, but are curious. Sometimes it's better to center in the worst part of the comment if it has too many errors. Sadly, I don't know enough cosmology and general relativity, so I use this approach to this problem https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/ I think that general relativity give minimal corrections in the scale of a galaxy, only some local corrections that are important near black holes and some spots. So it's enough [citation needed] to use Newtonian physics, perhaps with some correction near the galaxy center and perhaps a small effective field with the average distribution of matter. To track an individual star during many galaxy revolutions it may be necessary to be more careful, specially if the stars pass near another star. But to have a good estimation of the rotation speed it is possible to almost ignore general relativity. Question time: Do the current simulations in the area use special/general relativity corrections? Do you have a link to a recent paper? A link to a simulation program? [bonus point if the link points to the option page to enable/disable relativity or select the approximation method] Is there a Wikipedia page about this? [Most of the times the Wikipedia page is easier to understand than the paper.]
- Animats 10y agoDark matter is at best a hypothesis. We can't find any. We can't make any. It's a hack to fix theory.
- thewarrior 10y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/6488wb/i_dont_want_to_be_anti_science_but_i_am_doubtful/dg05wx4/ https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/6488wb/i_dont_want_t...
- hwillis 9y agoIt is not. Dark matter is not some smooth distribution that could be explained by adjusting the formula for gravity. There are places where it is, and places where it isn't. Not only that, but it has its own mass and inertia. Not only that but dark matter is missing in a host of other ways that can't be explained by the laws of gravity being more complex. Microwave background radiation is 30x more powerful than can be explained by visible matter, but matches exactly if you add in dark matter and dark energy. The ratio of hydrogen to deuterium is inconsistent with visible matter, but matches perfectly if you add dark matter. Galaxy clusters collide and we can literally see dark matter pass through the collision since it doesn't interact. Dark matter is as well proven as the atom was when we made the bombs. We just don't know what it's made of yet. You simply don't know enough about it.
- chmike 10y agoA.Meessen suggest a simpler explanation. Dark matter is made of electrically neutral elementary particles subject to scattering and a pressure. These particles may combine and dissociate which accounts for drak energy and the cosmological constant. The properties of all elementary particles (except mass) are predicted by his space time quantization (STQ) theory. It provides a blue print of all elementary particles. It predicts the neutral elementary particles that may constitute dark matter. There is no need to call back in question Newton's theory. [1] "From Space-Time Quantization to Dark Matter" https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=73362 https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=... [2] "Accelerated Expansion of Space, Dark Matter, Dark Energy and Big Bang Processes" https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=74430 https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=... [3] "Astrophysics and Dark Matter Theory" https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=74434 https://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=...
- hwillis 9y agoYeah, he also thinks that UFOs exist. He's a nutjob
- chmike 9y agoA.Meessen does pure science and studies whatever he consider of interest. Regarding UFOs he did inductive research. A priori we don't know if the reported phenomenon is real or not. To test the reality of the phenomenon you have to pose the hypothesis that they exist and see if this leads us to a logical contradiction. Even then, all we could say is we don't know if it's real or not. As a physicist he studied their propulsion system. There was two main reason to do so. First, we know the physics law and their constrains well. Second, the witness reported the side effects of a totally unknown propulsion system. If witness were making up the data, logical contradictions would be found quickly because most witnesses are not physicists. For instance, a witness reported seeing a UFO moving at very low altitude above trees. The strange thing was that the top of the trees were attracted by the UFO. Any conventional propulsion system would result in pushing the tree top away. If the UFO was real, how could we explain this observation ? What underlying physic mecanism could produce such effect ? That is how he started studying the UFO phenomenon. As a physicist he focussed in trying to identify a possible propulsion mechanism that could produce the reported effects. The only hypothesis he used was that UFO are real and that they may use the known physics law in a way yet unknnown to us, an original way. You have to initially suppose the UFO data valid to do this reserach. It can't work by supposing UFO don't exist. This research led him to two significant results. First the PEMP, a pulsed EM propulsion system [1]. Second, a new type of oscillator using a supraconducting surface that can generate very intense EM fields required for the propulsion [2]. It may not be a coincidence that a supraconducting shell would also protect occupants from the very intense oscillating EM field. Since humans can't produce supraconductive materials at room temperature, there isn't much room left to suppose a human origin of UFOs. The logical and scientific consistency, as well as the sound theory does also point to the reality of the UFO phenomenon. A.Meessen has data that you and scientists don't have to make their opinion, although it is published and in open access. The idea that UFOs are not real is just a belief supported by a few bogus cases and, I guess, by the fear of ET with far supperior technical skills than us. The idea that UFOs are real is now supported by scientific results. It's just theories that are waiting experimental validation. But at this stage we don't need to make an hypothesis about the reality or not of UFOs. These theories can be tested today in a lab with our technology. This is pure science, not crack potery. Sorry for your beliefs. Beside, the validity (or invalidity) of his STQ theory can't be inferred from his work on ufology because they are totally independent. If his theory on STQ is bogus, then say in what it is bogus. Otherwise, you are in the gossip domain, not science domain. [1] "Pulsed EM Propulsion of Unconvnetional Flying Objects" http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/#Propulsion http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/#Propulsion [2] "Production of EM Surface Waves by Superconducting Spheres: A New Type of Harmonic Oscillators" http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/#Production http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/#Production
- amai 9y agoMOND might explain rotation curves of galaxies. But it doesn't explain all the other places in astrophysics, where one needs dark matter. Especially MOND (and any modification to gravity) cannot explain the Bullet Cluster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster#Significance_to_dark_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster#Significance_to... The Bullet Cluster is especially significant, because it shows gravitational lensing by dark matter spatially separated from visible matter. No modification to gravity can explain that without giving up the idea that gravity is a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_force .
- knodi123 9y ago> Especially MOND (and any modification to gravity) cannot explain the Bullet Cluster The creator of MOND addressed that: http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ssm/mond/moti_bullet.html http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ssm/mond/moti_bullet.html
- Eyght 9y agoYour link made me very grateful for Firefox's Reader View.
- H4CK3RM4N 9y agoIs that part of the Pocket acquisition? I was comparing Safari and Firefox a while ago and Safari's reader view was one of the deciding factors in my choice.
- bumblebeard 9y agoIt might be; looks like they were both added in 38.0.5: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/38.0.5/releasenotes/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/38.0.5/releasenotes/
- scythe 9y agoIt seems like the takeaway is not that galactic cluster anomalies support or break MOND, but that MOND is a way to reduce the general astroöbject mass anomaly problem to a modified gravity plus the cluster mass anomaly problem. This makes sense if the cluster anomaly is tractable (?) and there are no other problems created by MOND (the real question IMO). The problem then is that we want to have enough examples where MOND "works" that we don't think we'll run into another cluster anomaly. However, there aren't too many types of objects in the sky. So we either need very good numerical evidence for MOND in all other systems (unlikely) or a solution to the cluster anomaly which might not be too hard, unless MOND is actually wrong of course, and that's a risk you often face as a scientist.
- rileymat2 9y agoThis is really great. It has always bothered me (as a non-physicist) for precisely this point: "Sure, if there was dark matter, the speed of stars would be greater, but the rotation curves, meaning the rotational speed drawn as a function of the radius, could still go up and down depending on its distribution. But they didn’t. "
- powera 9y agoBetween dark matter and the problems with inflation theory (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cosmic-inflation-theory-faces-challenges/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cosmic-inflation-...) I think there's enough evidence to show that the Big Bang model of the universe is flawed. As soon as somebody invents/discovers a better model, most of current research will prove itself completely useless.
- JoBrad 9y agoWhether or not inflation theory holds long-term, I highly doubt that "most of current research will prove itself completely useless." Even if Dark Energy process to be done yet-undiscovered property of ordinary matter, the research on its effects and properties will still be very valuable. We didn't throw out Galileo's research when Kepler discovered new principles, or Newton's when Planck and Einstein performed their research.
- doener 9y agoThe story was already published in February: http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/144/the-physicist-who-denies-that-dark-matter-exists http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/144/the-physicist-who-denies-t...