4 ms·
Exactly. One of my eternal questions about shiny new technologies is, "Great, but who's getting value from it on a daily basis?" I keep asking this about Bitco
by wpietri 10y ago
Exactly. One of my eternal questions about shiny new technologies is, "Great, but who's getting value from it on a daily basis?"
I keep asking this about Bitcoin, et al. For 6 years I've been getting, "Oh, it's just about to take off! You'll see soon!"
The Internet was definitely delivering value daily by 1990. It wasn't just a technological curiosity. Email, Usenet, mailing lists, file transfer, remote computing: all providing the sort of benefits that let researchers and academics justify paying to connect up.
I think cryptocurrencies and blockchains are technologically neat, and I appreciate them on that level. But neat technology doesn't always end up being useful.
- hdhzy 10y ago> all providing the sort of benefits that let researchers and academics justify paying to connect up. Well you could say the same about Bitcoin as it's current price comes from people willing to buy Bitcoin using their USDs.
- canoebuilder 10y agoHow many people paid an ISP in the hope that someone would pay them more for their account at a later date? If you're buying bitcoin because of some utility it offers you beyond speculation, the price doesn't really matter. You just exchange one monetary denomination for another and do whatever you plan to do with it. When you buy something like an internet connection or any other good or service you perform a cost benefit analysis. For example, if internet connections were 100x their current price, many fewer people would have one.(And interestingly for a network like the internet, the higher the cost to access, the less users, and thus less useful because of the network effect.)
- TylerE 10y agoThe answer is simple. They created an artificial gold rush so they could sell shovels.
- jcfrei 10y agoThe raison d'être of Bitcoin is that it makes the entire banking infrastructure (ie. the equivalent of the huge settlement industry currently in place to keep global finance running) accessible to everyone with a smartphone and internet access. Or think of it like this: Before the internet the knowledge you had access to depended mainly on the people and libraries around you. With the internet you gained access to all the knowledge in the world. Blockchains are doing the same with regards to the accessibility of financial resources and services.
- evgen 10y agoExcept for the unfortunate fact that the only parts of the banking infrastructure that people actual care about in daily life are already accessible via smartphone and internet. Once again, this reduces to a solution in search of a problem.
- jcfrei 10y agoThe full suite of banking services that are accessible to you (sending money to any person in any country, buying shares, investing in funds, mortgages, insurance, etc.) are accessible to fewer people than you might think. Most people from Africa, Asia and South America don't have access to such services. Access to a deposit account provided by their local phone company is just starting to become widespread (eg. MPesa).
- evgen 10y agoPeople in Africa and Asia actually have access to better and more ubiquitous direct payment mechanisms that I do here in western Europe. Those systems happen to run through telcos and the phone networks, but they work well and are available to billions of people. These technologies get the job done and show that there is no need for blockchain tech in this arena. Please try again.
- jcfrei 10y agoDeposit accounts just cover a fraction of the financial services we regularly use in the developed world. They still lack retirement schemes, insurance and investment funds, etc. Blockchains (due to working in a trustless environment) could make these services possible in countries lacking the required settlement infrastructure and legal frameworks. The services provided by their telcos are also usually limited to a deposit account in the local currency. They don't provide access to international financial markets, ie. they can't invest in a retirement fund in London or buy Euros. And just like the internet allowed hackers to access information that their government censored, blockchains give people access to financial assets which their government could previously restrict.
- finid 10y agoThe Internet was definitely delivering value daily by 1990 Yes, the Internet was delivering daily value in 1990, but only to a very, very small group of users. I was in grad school then, but the Internet was not a factor in my environment. Networking was carrying floppies from here to there. Same thing with cryptocurrencies. It's delivering value to a small group of users, though that group is much more than the small group served by the Internet in 1990. Mining and trading in cryptocurrencies have millions for some, so it's serving them well.
- wpietri 10y agoMining and trading do not create value. Like speculation in other commodities, it's basically gambling. Except that the markets for, say, oil futures let people buy insurance to mitigate risks in the underlying commodity that they don't want to take. But since Bitcoin doesn't have a similar underlying value yet, the speculation can't be justified as possibly creating value. The one group I have to admit is getting value from Bitcoin is criminals. E.g., it's the technology of choice for ransomware. But that just doesn't strike me as a use case that will help Bitcoin cross the chasm.
- api 10y agoBitcoin is most useful as an alternative to awful systems like Western Union. The rest of these systems seem to be research projects at this stage. Not saying they won't mature, but they're not like the Internet in 95. More like the Internet in 75.
- wpietri 10y agoOk. Who's using it as an alternative to Western Union today on a regular basis? I live in a city, SF, that has plenty of signs up to attract people sending money back to their family back home. But I've never seen a single sign getting people to use Bitcoin for that. It's certainly possible that Bitcoin is like the Internet was in 1975. But at that point, they hadn't even invented TCP/IP, which came in '82. At that point, ARPANET was just one of many approaches to networking, including BITNET, Merit Network, Tymnet, and Telenet. Not to mention the circuit-switched networks that were probably dominant in revenue terms. It seems totally plausible to me that Bitcoin and/or blockchains could end up as a similar "people used it for a little while but it's hard to remember why" thing. Or, worse, it could end up like the OSI protocol stack: a collection of exciting ideas that nobody ever really got working to deliver much value in the real world.