6 ms·
At some point we have to decide whether the purpose of society is to promote the general welfare of all citizens or just to give capitalists the opportunity to
by maxxxxx 10y ago
At some point we have to decide whether the purpose of society is to promote the general welfare of all citizens or just to give capitalists the opportunity to make as much money as they can. I don't see anything wrong with worker protections. The capitalists have plenty of protections like patents and copyrights.
- WaxProlix 10y agoAll property law, basically.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoIndeed. It's no accident that the Libertarian outlook puts so much stock in property law and very little in labour law, it's an outflow of the Powell Memorandum. When you have much property to lose you seek to protect it, but when your only property is your labour then Libertarianism can't do much for you.
- anigbrowl 10y agoExcellent point. I have yet to hear a meaningful reply to the argument that 'the American free enterprise system' implicitly depends on having a whole continent's worth of resources to exploit at the outset. Libertarianism would be a lot easier to take seriously if it banned inheritance or something to prevent the accumulation of resources that could be handed to others, which is at odds with the whole notion of meritocracy. Libertarians do make some effort to speak up for open labor markets and abolition of borders, but I can't think of any libertarians leading the charge for immigration reform offhand.
- Joky 10y agoThat so much a loaded partisan view of the world... The citizens are capitalists: they are (almost) all looking to put their saving where the interest rate is the highest, they would (almost) all protect their private property and seek to increase their own capital, and is anyone seriously considering that the government should run the means of production? Workers protection need some balance: pushed to the extreme it leads to competitive loss. The "general welfare" of all citizens does not means you have to push the cursor all the way: France switched to 35h weekly legal a few years back, but why not 30h? Or 20h? That would surely improve the happiness of workers! What about PTO? Legally entitled to 5 weeks currently in France, why not double it? Etc...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Daishiman 10y agoNo, it's absolute truth. Workers in generally are simply incapable of owning means of production beyond very small businesses, and their participation of the market as stockholders is minimal and comes with near-zero ability to influence the companies for which they might be shareholders. Capital should be at the service of society, not the other way around. We know that we can have perfectly functional societies where wealth is distributed more evenly and less work is done at the lower end of the pyramid at essentially no disadvantages in quality of life for anyone involved.
- Joky 10y agoWhat is "absolute truth" here? The manichean opposition that is proposed between "promote the general welfare of all citizens" and "give capitalists the opportunity to make as much money as they can"? This is what I was addressing and I'm still considering as a very manipulating rhetoric that does not leave any place for nuance and balance.
- Daishiman 10y agoThe nuance and balance exists in the practice of states with maker-driven capitalist economies that still make an effort to capture and funnel a part of profits to the benefits of the participants of society regardless of their position in the market. On the contrary, it's a vocal minority of libertarians that want to insist that benefits to capitalists are indispensable to the welfare of the rest.
- pjc50 10y agoSavings come from income. Savings are a small fraction of income: http://www.financialsamurai.com/the-average-savings-rates-by-income-wealth-class/ http://www.financialsamurai.com/the-average-savings-rates-by... Apart from housing, many people have remarkably little savings. In the UK, there are all sorts of schemes to make people become capitalists like this with their pensions, but I'm not sure if their hearts are really in it. And I think most people are smart enough to realise that cutting their income but boosting savings rates by a tiny fraction is going to result in a smaller savings pile and a worse life in the meantime.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> I don't see anything wrong with worker protections As long as people can opt-out then it's fine. Otherwise I think there is something wrong with it: if two consenting adults want to send work emails to each other after 5pm what business is that of yours?
- obstinate 10y agoIf people can opt out, then this gives the opportunity for the business owner to make opting out a requirement to get the job. Then you may as well not have the protection at all. You can't opt out of: - minimum wages - OSHA - discrimination protection - etc. There's no special reason why you should be able to opt out of this work hour regulation. Now if the regulation is overall a bad idea, that's a separate question.
- chrisseaton 10y agoYes it's a fundamental philosophical problem isn't it. Protecting people by taking away their freedoms. A tricky balance and you can see how people come down on either side of it.
- lovich 10y agoIt's protecting the commons. As an individual it might make sense for me to opt out of those regulations because I can get a job easier or command a higher wage. This only works if most people follow the regulations. The problem is when companies make opting out a de facto part of the deal and then individuals are no longer getting a benefit from their choices but are forced into it
- chrisseaton 10y agoYes I think I'd agree in practice. I was really replying to the 'nothing wrong with it' assertion. I think there is something fundamentally wrong with it and we should acknowledge we're taking away people's freedom, but it's probably an acceptable trade-off in practice.
- wand3r 10y agoI agree. As indicated below; the way you phrased it comes off very partisan. I infer I have the opposite bias; but still agree. This law is flexible. It is for larger company's; presents the choice to the worker and seems to have reasonable adjustments for both parties. I think protecting workers is good but top down absolutism isn't. From what I can tell based on the article this seems to be a measured response to the issue taking the middle ground
- FTA 10y agoI see the issue of peoples' time being taken advantage of in the public sector, too, which I would argue is not necessarily capitalism. A good example is a teacher, or professor, or researcher--someone who is either salaried or paid for a set number of hours, but has expectations far outside a normal 40 hour work week. The larger government system dictates that person cannot be compensated more than a certain amount, yet that person could not hold their job if they only put in that set amount of time.