6 ms·
>Buying an apartment in New York City is a marker of success for some residents It's also a sign of folly for some. Many people hate-read the Sunday Real Estat
by jseliger 10y ago
>Buying an apartment in New York City is a marker of success for some residents
It's also a sign of folly for some. Many people hate-read the Sunday Real Estate section. There are often one-bedrooms listed for $700k – $1 million, with $1K+ per month maintenance fees. Add on to that $200 – 1K per month in taxes, and suddenly you will have to wait a VERY long time to make anything like the return you'd get from investing in a Vanguard Total Market Fund and renting for $3K per month.
Everyone in the real estate industry loves purchases because of the fees associated with purchase. But buying is often not a good idea (though it depends on when). If we get another real estate crash and prices drop by 10 – 20%, buying may start to make sense again. In 2011 buying was a great idea.
This same basic dynamic plays out in many cities. The NYT has a decent rent-vs-buy calculator: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calculator.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-cal... that can help answer some questions. Notice the investment return expected, which is a vital part of these calculations.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBuying is almost always a good idea except in the hottest of real estate markets. If done properly (buy, then rent out when you move, managed by prop management company), you'll come out far ahead versus just renting. You should of corse still be investing in equities for diversification.
- Domenic_S 10y agoIt's an even better idea in hot markets. That is, unless you get in at the end of a cycle and need liquidity now.
- user5994461 10y agoDepends if it is going to be your primary home. You need a roof on your head. You might as well pay the rent 10-30 years and own the place, rather than have nothing.
- arielweisberg 10y agoIs renting out really that low risk even with a property management company? You are also now exposed to the vagaries of rental pricing and demand.
- jshen 10y agoI think people misunderstand low risk. On average it easily nets out positively depending on location. The problem is the "on average" part. If due to bad luck you aren't the average, is it catastrophic for your finances, or is it just painful. I wouldn't take the risk if I were in the first category.
- klipt 10y agoReal estate has a long negative tail if e.g. the renters stop paying and trash your place when evicted.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThat's what reserves, insurance, and a real estate attorney are for.
- lotyrin 10y agoWhen my wife did the math before purchasing in our market, you'd have to have frequent or catastrophic repairs, have crazy vacancy (>50%), or be taking in well below market rate for comparable units (or some combination there-of). It seems the kind of property management it takes to sink the rent-vs-buy gap is beyond abysmal and made us really confident that we could afford to purchase despite not being sure if we're staying in the place long-term.
- sidlls 10y agoIt depends on the market segment. It's not that difficult to pick markets where the 1% rule (rent should be ~1% of the value of the home) applies and maintenance and vacancy are minimized. That's going to be primarily middle class and upper-middle-class markets in areas that don't have absurd "values" for homes.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's like anything else. Buy low, sell high. Capital is cheaper than ever and prices are insane right now. If your goal is to make money, this is pretty clearly not a time to buy in many markets. Renting always has very significant downsides. You have no control, sacrifice flexibility, and are always exposed to any market price changes in the market at lease renewal. The rent vs buy calculators focus too much on asset value vs. cash flow.
- jshen 10y ago"and renting for $3K per month" I think you make a lot of assumptions, like the one above, which don't fit my admittedly anecdotal experience. I live in one of the hot markets, I bot a place at the peak of the market before the last crash, and found myself nearly $200k in the hole on paper. That was roughly 10 years ago, and here's what happened. I lived in it for 10 years, and I just sold it for more than I paid for it. Obviously this in isolation wasn't a good investment, but I did nearly the worst thing, bought at a peak before a crash, and still came out net positive 10 years later. Second, you said "and renting for $3K per month" which is a mistake because it's assuming rent will not go up in any significant way. Where I live, rent goes up a lot. That place I bought 10 years ago, a couple years back we thought about selling and renting (to get into a different school district) and we realized that our mortgage was lower than what we would have to pay in rent to get a similar place in the same area. Again, these are just anecdotes, but my experience doesn't fit with the assumptions you are making above.
- Retric 10y agoThat's with a small correction followed by a new bubble. Property values have dropped over 50% in various corrections around the world EX: Shanghai @ 64%. The US is easily that inflated relative to historic norms, so what we think of as a huge correction could basally be a minor blip vs what's next. Or even just a 20+ year stagnation in housing prices. Worse real estate transaction fees are are massive. PS: Same as it ever was. http://www.businessinsider.com/the-economic-crash-repeated-every-generation-1800-2012-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/the-economic-crash-repeated-e...
- larrik 10y agoI bought a condo at the peak of the market before the crash, 11 years ago. So far, it's only gone down in value, regardless of what the rest of the market does. Even after refinancing it years ago into a 15 year mortgage, it's STILL worth less than I owe on it. Hurts
- mgce 10y agoI didn't see where the parent assumed the $3k per month would stay static. Also recall that selling a place for more than you paid for it doesn't mean you've made money. As I'm sure you know, owning property also involves substantial ongoing costs (beyond the purchase price) that never get recouped: maintenance, property fees, incidental construction / renovation, insurance, mortgage taxes, real estate fees, and so on. Never mind the lost investment potential from the down payment, which is now a sunk cost vs. something that could have earned interest in the markets. I'm not trying to challenge your anecdote; just to recognize that even with stories like yours the truth is complicated and hard to assess. For my part, my experience has taught me to be especially wary of "hot markets" - the hype that comes with them IMO artificially inflates real estate prices to a point where the underlying value can easily get lost. I happen to be very lucky in having a rent situation that easily beats purchasing, even over multiple years. But I acknowledge rental arrangements can also get hyped, so a bad rental situation can also cost you.
- wyldfire 10y ago> with $1K+ per month maintenance fees. wow! How are these itemized? Or is it just referred to as a single line-item "$1,000.00 Maintenance fee" ?
- nealrs 10y agoIn NYC, most property ownership is through coops or condos. and in both, you'll pay a monthly maintenance fee - which includes things like common charges, landscaping for the complex/building, building mortgage, coop mgmt, real estate taxes, etc. I pay ~$900/month in fees for my 1 bedroom (charged based on the 113 shares i own) - and then I pay another 20-30 for electricity, which is billed on the same ticket. Then, come tax time, I get to deduct around ~35% of those maintenance fees as real estate tax. it varies from building to building and borough to borough.
- mgce 10y agoBrownstone neighborhoods stress these numbers even further (e.g. much of "hot" Brooklyn). These consist largely of 19th century buildings. And even the "modern" apartment buildings are 1920s, 1930s, etc. These are also precisely the neighborhoods that zone-limit modern construction to avoid compromising their character. So you have a bunch of old buildings that need serious maintenance, sometimes by firms with specialized and otherwise outdated skill sets (e.g. stoop rebuilding and iron fence work). Many of these neighborhoods are also in historic districts, meaning they're landmark-protected to preserve traditional architectural character. Brooklyn Heights is a prime example. Essentially the whole neighborhood is one big historic district. The housing stock is ancient. And it's a highly desirable neighborhood. Maintenance fees can easily waver between $1,000 and $2,000. There are very few modern condos (which basically avoid these problems). So their very scarcity inflates their purchase prices. All in all you get a very difficult place to live in and own property.
- itchyouch 10y agoBuildings will have an association fee, similar to an HOA. I've never looked into NY condos, but I've seen buildings in Northern NJ with fees at 500/mo. I would guess there is literally a $1k association fee to pay.
- lr4444lr 10y agoNYC was minimally affected by the real estate crash because of the ubiquity of co-ops, whose boards were not going to approve an onslaught of people with wealth that was only on paper or that were speculating on them as investments rather than using the dwellings as their primary residences. Prices dropped some, a little more so in the outer boroughs, but where did you see "10 - 20%"? The real problem with buying an apartment (as I see it) is that you don't really have most of the benefits of "ownership" aside from cost and location stability, and even that is somewhat in flux due to association/management fees, and if you have a co-op., mortgage rates. But, it's worthwhile for some, and IIRC, the return was better than the S&P 500 from 2000 through about 2013.
- mgce 10y agoAnd if that's not a wild enough ride, try land leases. I can't for the life of me figure out any way to be truly comfortable with a land lease. NYC real estate is a really weird world.