12 ms·
P: A programming language for asynchrony, fault-tolerance and uncertainty
- sverige 10y agoAt last, the long awaited successor to C, at least in the naming convention that assumes P comes after C because of BCPL. (Apologies to Walter Bright: No inference should be drawn that D was not also a good name for that sequence.)
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt's a language for expressing protocols. So, P for protocols most likely. It also focuses on safety and ease of analysis. Can't possibly be connected to the C lineage...
- girvo 10y agoI believe it does compile to C, interestingly, so not really connected, but a little bit nonetheless
- mattnewton 10y agoL must be lisp, brought here from the future by the space aliens.
- Razengan 10y agoOr Logo.
- contingencies 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_notation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_notation
- panic 10y agoIt's worth noting that this isn't just a research language -- it's used in practice for writing drivers: P got its start in Microsoft software development when it was used to ship the USB 3.0 drivers in Windows 8.1 and Windows Phone. These drivers handle one of the most important peripherals in the Windows ecosystem and run on hundreds of millions of devices today. P enabled the detection and debugging of hundreds of race conditions and Heisenbugs early on in the design of the drivers, and is now extensively used for driver development in Windows.
- blorgle 10y agoThis looks SO cool! Kind of like Erlang but at a different level, so you can model both inter-node systems (like Erlang) but also intra-node systems (like USB3 drivers)! As someone who has been thinking a lot recently about SPARK/Ada and "free" formal verification, can anyone tell me how this language compares on that front? If I write a P program, do I get the ability to "prove" its correctness?
- mmalone 10y agoThe docs are sparse... but it looks like the answer is that it depends on what you mean by "correct." It doesn't look like it's a general purpose theorem prover, but it does appear to be model/spec-driven and the linked article says that the system can prove safety and liveness. I'm guessing they mean "type safety" but they may be using the term in the broader distributed system sense. In any case, it does look like it gives you certain "proofs for free" if your definition of correct is "eventually converges on a consistent state." I don't think you can prove arbitrary properties like you can with Coq or with a dependent type system. Still, very cool.
- ulber 10y ago"Safety" in a verification context generally refers to safety properties, i.e., properties that can be shown to not hold with a finite counter example (a test that hits a bug). Liveness properties in comparison are those that need an infinite counter example, i.e., a way to make the bad thing happen infinitely often.
- rubyn00bie 10y agoIf anyone is interested in syntax and more tangible bits, here is the manual from the GitHub page linked to in the article: https://github.com/p-org/P/blob/master/Doc/Manual/pmanual.pdf https://github.com/p-org/P/blob/master/Doc/Manual/pmanual.pd...
- tyingq 10y agoThat would have been really helpful for things like telnet and option negotiation. Or more recently, perhaps something like QUIC.
- tekacs 10y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12673739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12673739
- rambodroneprog 10y agoP is also being used to build safe robotics systems. https://drona-org.github.io/Drona/ https://drona-org.github.io/Drona/
- rambodroneprog 10y agoThe high-level syntax of the language looks amazing for writing and specifying complex protocols.
- staticassertion 10y agoP is a really cool language, and I've been keeping an eye on it. Unfortunately, the documentation has been pretty perpetually out of date, and the language is still a moving target. So you can't just "get started" in P, the example code won't compile. I don't know what their plans are or if they ever intend for it to be consumed outside of MS. If they do, some focus on docs would be nice. Pony is a similar language - but better documented. If you're interested in P, I suggest checking out Pony.
- rurban 9y agoPony generates also much tighter, better, faster code. Code which I would use in a driver. Not managed C#. I know no other language which generates faster code. I mean faster than C++ with OpenMP, while being memory and concurrency safe. P has fantastic proof and test generating libraries and IDE's though. In pony you'll have to write perfect code to pass the type checker. P does much better handholding to get there.
- robertkrahn01 10y agoHere is a demo for using P to program a drone, shows a little more of the language itself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8ztpfMPs5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8ztpfMPs5c
- StreamBright 10y agoThanks for sharing, this is really insightful.
- eggy 10y agoThe graph visualization towards the end of the video in MS VS is amazing. I can see this being really useful for my robotics projects. I'll have to figure out how to get started. I was learning Erlang, and looked briefly at Pony, but the syntax and the demo appeals to me.
- cgb223 10y agoI'm still holding out for NP It'll be wayyy more complex
- moomin 10y ago(Citation needed)
- tobyhinloopen 10y agoCan we stop naming programming languages with letters and symbols and give it proper names that, when googled (or binged), makes the programming language appear on top?
- neokrish 10y agoSecond this. It might seem irrelevant for us folks, we aware of different places to seek help e.g. Stackoverflow but when introducing someone new and they encounter a million questions about programming in a language, searching just becomes a nightmare with these single letter naming.
- LeoNatan25 10y agoSearching for "<Letter> Programming Language" works wonders. Give it a try sometime.
- progx 10y agoPlang
- mrslave 9y agoSomeone uses Bing? And enough people to justify a new verb? binged is already taken and I don't think Microsoft wants to associate itself with such indulgence.
- paulddraper 9y agoSo no B, C, or D? What about common words like Java, Ruby, Python, Go? I suppose this makes Scala and Perl the easiest languages to find documentation for.
- faragon 10y agoMicrosoft's "Node.js" equivalent for asynchronous stuff?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mempko 9y agoLove it. What if all computing are communicating state machines