4 ms·
I'm not a US legal scholar but I wouldn't be surprised to know the US Supreme Court might have ruled that such rights do not apply to non-US citizens.
by toyg 10y ago
I'm not a US legal scholar but I wouldn't be surprised to know the US Supreme Court might have ruled that such rights do not apply to non-US citizens.
- ekianjo 10y agoyeah otherwise it would be hard to justify the invasion of Iraq among other things.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoDeclaration of war comes under "due process of law" surely.
- ekianjo 10y ago> such laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. No declaration of war was made on Iraq.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> No declaration of war was made on Iraq. Yes, it was; no special language is needed in a declaration of war; the "Authorization for the Use of Military Force" was plainly and unmistakeably a conditional declaration of war, the conditions for which were fulfilled.
- toyg 10y agoIf you declare war, you have to follow Geneva rules, so you can't do Guantanamo detentions; if you do Guantanamo detentions, you're not legally at war. Pick one.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If you declare war, you have to follow Geneva rules, The applicability of the Geneva Conventions is affected by the fact of war, but independent of whether there is a declaration. And even if it wasn't, violations of the Conventions would not reach back in time and change whether a declaration had occurred.
- wayn3 10y agosuch laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. an officer can order hundreds of soldiers to charge into certain death without repercussions - as long as the military goal he's trying to achieve is justifiable.
- ekianjo 10y ago> such laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. There was never a formal declaration of war on Iraq. Just saying.