5 ms·
Doesn't the US Bill of Rights talk in several places about "any person": Fifth Amendment to USA Constitution: >nor shall any person [...] be deprived of life,
by pbhjpbhj 10y ago
Doesn't the US Bill of Rights talk in several places about "any person":
Fifth Amendment to USA Constitution:
>nor shall any person [...] be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law;
Sounds like quite a strong right.
FWIW this contrasts with the pages referring to "the people" which are limited and not universal, "any person" means any person.
- toyg 10y agoI'm not a US legal scholar but I wouldn't be surprised to know the US Supreme Court might have ruled that such rights do not apply to non-US citizens.
- ekianjo 10y agoyeah otherwise it would be hard to justify the invasion of Iraq among other things.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoDeclaration of war comes under "due process of law" surely.
- ekianjo 10y ago> such laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. No declaration of war was made on Iraq.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> No declaration of war was made on Iraq. Yes, it was; no special language is needed in a declaration of war; the "Authorization for the Use of Military Force" was plainly and unmistakeably a conditional declaration of war, the conditions for which were fulfilled.
- toyg 10y agoIf you declare war, you have to follow Geneva rules, so you can't do Guantanamo detentions; if you do Guantanamo detentions, you're not legally at war. Pick one.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If you declare war, you have to follow Geneva rules, The applicability of the Geneva Conventions is affected by the fact of war, but independent of whether there is a declaration. And even if it wasn't, violations of the Conventions would not reach back in time and change whether a declaration had occurred.
- wayn3 10y agosuch laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. an officer can order hundreds of soldiers to charge into certain death without repercussions - as long as the military goal he's trying to achieve is justifiable.
- ekianjo 10y ago> such laws generally don't apply to war. they don't even apply to soldiers. There was never a formal declaration of war on Iraq. Just saying.
- zeckalpha 10y agoYes, but Guantanamo is outside the US and so the Constitution doesn't apply.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoIt doesn't say "any person in the USA" nor "any US citizen", when it wants to specify that then the amendment uses "the people". Would be interested in the actual caselaw for this?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Yes, but Guantanamo is outside the US and so the Constitution doesn't apply. Nowhere in the Constitution is there any support for the idea that the Constitution only limits the actions of the US government that happen to be within the US rather than on territory leased from another country and subject to full control by the US government.
- Sir_Substance 10y agoSome quick Googling tells me that the fifth amendment was ratified in 1791, 74 years before slavery was abolished. So apparently the US didn't really take that one seriously from the start. More recently, I recall the case of David Hicks, an Australian citizen. He was declared an "enemy combatant", detained without charge and tortured in Guantanamo bay until he signed a confession to a law which did not exist at the time he was detained. You should read more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hicks#Guantanamo_Bay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hicks#Guantanamo_Bay Regardless of the stupidity and provocativeness of Hicks' actions, he is a citizen of a nation that is supposedly a US ally, and one would think a person under the US constitution, but he received no protection. The US abused him while the AU government did nothing. The US government ignores it's own constitution whenever it finds it inconvenient, and any objections are arm-waved away as being legal by the findings of a secret court no US citizen is allowed to know the inner workings of. It doesn't matter what's written on some crusty paper in a museum somewhere if no one actually abides by it. The US constitution is dead, and I would certainly not trust my liberty to the tender mercies of those who have nailed it's corpse to their standard.