13 ms·
One Step Closer to a Closed Internet
- AndyMcConachie 10y ago"this decision leads to an internet that benefits Internet Service Providers" I would correct this to: "this decision leads to an American internet that benefits Internet Service Providers" The FCC can really only screw up the Internet for Americans. If you're an Internet user not in North America there's very little reason for you to care about the decision the FCC made today.
- TJ-14 10y agoAmerican decisions can set precedents which other countries follow, and are often pushed by their trade policies. They also affect American IT companies, which are used by people all over the world. There's good reason for non-Americans to care about the American Internet.
- pasbesoin 10y agoI'm going to take this a step further. Years ago -- a decade or more -- I was saying that "China is the prototype." Early days of The Great Firewall. Initially built, by the way, with U.S. and "Western" technology and consulting. As for the Net. It was a frontier. Now, it's settled. And those who've taken up residence are busy turning it and sealing it up, for their own purposes. As for open, free as in speech communication. Start looking for the next, next-generation physical layer. One that is not in the hands of established and self-serving interests. Yet. Rinse and repeat...
- chpmrc 10y agoWell not in the EU https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/open-internet-net-neutrality https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/open-internet-... .
- tangent128 10y agoThat law can be repealed if Europeans aren't vigilant; nothing makes the EU naturally immune to right-wing, pro-corporate swings.
- xpaqui 10y agoYes but no. One of the reasons the UK left EU because it was not allowed to have different laws for EU immigrants and locals - for benefits for example. Europe choose values over money. They - Merkel - may not be the best people in the world but some moves are very commendable.
- a2decrow 10y agoIf this forces non-US Americans to use US IT company services less, there are less angles the US government can use to spy on the rest of the world. Plus, data protection laws in other countries (especially European ones) are far more restrictive. I don't think there's any reason for us non-US-Americans to care at all about the US internet. Just like we don't care about pretty much anything else that's happening in the US.
- falcolas 10y agoWell, at least at currently, the "US Internet" includes IANA, Google, Amazon, Netflix, Facebook, Verisign and a majority of the root DNS servers... Changes made to the "US Internet" are going to absolutely affect the wider world right now.
- a2decrow 10y agoI fail to see how this affects IANA or root DNS servers in any way (not to mention that IANA can be replaced by a non-US entity if it really comes down to that). As for those companies, they'll work the same way as before outside the US internet. Regrettably, because the world would be a better place without them.
- falcolas 10y agoThis was a direct response to the commennt "I don't think there's any reason for us non-US-Americans to care at all about the US internet." This change doesn't directly affect IANA, etc, but it will likely have knock-on effects which hurt everyone. "IANA can be replaced by a non-US entity" - This would, IMO, signal the end of the internet. "Look up www.google.com" "which one?"
- a2decrow 10y ago> This would, IMO, signal the end of the internet. "Look up www.google.com" "which one?" I'm not entirely sure if you know how DNS works.
- 10y ago
- awalton 10y agoYeah, it sure would be a shame if all of those American companies everyone else in the world depends on were suddenly out of business because they couldn't afford the extortion fees charged by whichever ISP wants to clone their service.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"If you're an Internet user not in North America there's very little reason for you to care about the decision the FCC made today." From the post: "The result: ISPs would be able to once again prioritize, block and throttle with impunity. This means fewer opportunities for startups and entrepreneurs, and a chilling effect on innovation, free expression and choice online" Do you not believe that the global internet has benefitted from North American tech companies that were able to innovate in part because they did't have to contend with gatekeepers and paid prioritization of traffic? Would Youtube have been possible under such a regime? Don't people from all over the globe consume Youtube content? Additionally Ajat Pai is an ex Verizon lawyer. Verizon being half of the broadband duopoly in the US. Most countries have some similar former PTT(post telephone telgraph) monopoly/duopoly. This action sets a precedent for any other countries where the monopoly/duopoly is seeking to enact a similar gatekeeper/pay to play regime where there now stands an open internet.
- bigbugbag 10y ago> Would Youtube have been possible under such a regime? Assuming youtube is something desirable, let's not forget that it has been created for the sole purpose of selling to a giant company too big to be able to innovate and too slow to conquer users while youtube purposely used pirated content for its growth. Nowadays years after youtube has been bought to be the frontend UI of googlevideo.com youtube is considered to be an example of internet centralization, users tracking and spying, automated censorship, geolocalized blocking, among others criticisms. Maybe consider a better suited example next time you want to take a stance for net neutrality, maybe peer-to-peer.
- bogomipz 10y agoThat's a total straw man. It does't matter whether or not you think its ethical in its current incarnation. Youtube was a startup that became one of the most popular sites on the internet[1] and were acquired by Google. If they had to pay a gatekeeper to deliver those bits it might not have been a viable idea. The examples are not the point but rather the environment that those were produced in - i.e an environment of an open internet. >"Maybe consider a better suited example next time you want to take a stance for net neutrality, maybe peer-to-peer." Maybe consider not createing straw man fallacies the next time you want to be critical of other people's comments. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_YouTube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_YouTube
- Kholo 10y agoTrue. Good to remember the American Internet is not the Internet. It's fascinating how this debate plays out in other countries with a certain class of citizenry that don't have the capacity to think for themselves. Even if the ISP landscape is hyper competitive people who spend their time on American tech sites, actually believe they are under threat. They express it via the media, social media etc. The Americans anti net neutrality activists totally ignorant of local conditions show up in full support. It's like watching cascading exploding ignorance in real time.
- nickthemagicman 10y agoIt will affect you almost immediately when they stop allowing traffic that competes with their voice arms. Facetime, Messenger, Skype, all going to get brutalized.
- tangent128 10y agoIf it succeeds in America, ISPs in other countries will try to replicate the policy.
- orthecreedence 10y agoI want to say this first: I love net neutrality and I support it 100%. That said, I think this battle will go on forever until either - We have a decentralized network anybody can plug into without ISPs (mesh net) or - Cities build their own fiber infrastructure (or 4G towers for rural areas) and rent it out to companies. Cable/DSL become a thing of the past, and you connect via radio/public wifi/direct fiber. This battle is starting to get ridiculous. The "let the market decide" shills don't seem to understand there's no market. So let's give them one, on public infrastructure. Either that, or make the internet some kind of mesh-connected network that routes around blocks/slowdowns. Until then, let's all just agree the net neutrality is a common-good consumer protection, and there's absolutely no reason, at all, to get rid of it until we either have a viable marketplace or we don't need ISPs..
- Jtsummers 10y agoA third option: Standard net, but everything end-to-end encrypted including what protocol is being used. If this information can't be discerned (easily), then priority cannot be given or taken away for any given data, only for certain data sources/destinations. If two computers (could be mobile devices, PC, server, doesn't matter) have an encrypted channel connecting them then anything could be transmitted across that channel without anyone but the endpoints knowing what it is. Now, all this traffic could be slowed. But if it becomes near ubiquitous, then only source/destination would be useful for determining throttling/accelerating data.
- orthecreedence 10y agoIf the destination is encrypted, how does the ISP know where to send the packets? You could use some form of garlic/onion routing (Tor/i2p/etc) but that's really slow generally, and there's a decent chance the ISP at the end of the chain will be in the US anyway (and can still throttle).
- woah 10y agoNet neutrality advocates are worried precisely about isps being able to discriminate by source or destination. Additionally, most traffic is already e2e encrypted. You just used the system you were proposing to post that comment.
- Shivetya 10y agoI would hope people understand that the only true fix will come out of Congress so having the FCC who is staffed by people who don't report to voters vote this way puts the issue back into our hands. get on your Congressman's ass and ride them hard
- ianai 10y agoMake no mistake, regulations like this can lead to bubble bursts. This could very well be a first step toward the end of the current technology boom. Silicon Valley should be nothing but up in arms. Or, SV should be working on technological ways to circumvent throttles based on content.
- tsunamifury 10y agoSV is moving into a the "stasis" stage of a mature industry where the incumbents are more interested in freezing the market in its current self-optimized configuration than allowing for new players and risk loss.
- lithos 10y agoGetting rid of 35-50 megabyte "text" pages would be a good start.
- ianai 10y agoI think you just made me a proponent of ending net neutrality! /s
- kirykl 10y agoWhen startups are de-regulated out of existence by barrier to entry costs, big companies can look forward to both real and perceived lower innovation costs. The bubble may burst but a few tech companies will be more profitable than ever
- unityByFreedom 10y agoI agree. I think this is a money grab, from which we'll see no added benefit. Content providers, and ourselves, will be hurt, while ISPs play god with who gets access to what.
- amcca029 10y agoWe need to take a ground up approach to solving this, get open infrastructure into the community and build local isps. Over time replace our broken network with a new generation.
- YCode 10y agoISPs in the U.S. are already way out in front of this on both legislative and legal fronts. They help write and push state legislation to make this difficult/impossible and sue anyone who tries into oblivion while finding ways to deny access to the supposedly shared lines tax dollars paid to build. Not saying it could never work, but that's a hell of an uphill battle to take on. I'm convinced the disruptive change to this mess will be some kind of WiFi mesh-based network that pushes ISPs out of the loop. I'm just not sure how you'd go about porting that mesh network back into the regular Internet since local ISPs would control all the gateways.
- mabbo 10y ago> During the public comment period in 2015, nearly 4 million citizens wrote to the FCC, many of them demanding strong net neutrality protections. We all need to show the same commitment again. Do they really think that the people who made these decisions did it because they care about the best interest of the people?
- justforFranz 10y agoWell look, for the time being, it's a democracy. It could be called off due to lack of interest however. The FACT of low voter participation while politicians are bashing us in the face is at least as big a problem as being bashed in the face.
- onetrueopinion 10y agoLet's all agree that your opinion is the correct one and go from there? That's a bold rhetorical maneuver, do you find that it ever works?
- orthecreedence 10y agoI've yet to see a viable, informed argument against NN given our current market/options.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoI agree. While I would prefer a market in which we let competition decide how it goes, as it prevents the government from getting involved, there is no market for the majority of Americans. I moved from MD to PA to now CA and every place I go I have had zero alternatives to Comcast. Zero. AT&T told me they would have to run lines to my house at some insane cost (I think it was like $20k or something? It's been many years). If there is an alternative that's realistic to implement I would be very interested but I haven't heard one.
- orthecreedence 10y agoA year or two ago I would have disagreed and argued that NN is the only way, but recently I've realized that we're just going to keep ping-ponging between regulation and deregulation until the real issue is fixed: ISPs in the US have a stranglehold. So if we actually get a viable marketplace for internet in most places in the US (internet treated like a public utility rented out to private companies), I would concede NN regulation. Basically, short of nobody having any internet at all, almost anything is better than our current situation.
- jandrese 10y agoOpen access rules like the ones that exist on phone lines could do the job. The problem is that we got those rules on phone lines by having the government heavily subsidize them back in the Ma Bell days. The cable and fiber networks were much less subsidized so it's a hard argument to make. The ship has already sailed on treating broadband as a utility like it should be. Muni broadband projects can help, but they're few and far between, plus they suffer from tremendous political pushback from the well connected incumbents.
- theprop 10y agoWhile I think this is a terrible idea, there's not that much to worry about for us as ordinary internet users. There's not going to be a slow & fast lane, at least not anytime soon. ISPs want net neutrality banned so they can "extort" money from Google, Facebook, YouTube, Netflix (to some extent in place), Amazon, etc. They're going to artificially slow those big, rich sites down unless they pay up. Netflix already is paying Verizon fees to avoid being throttled (btw the throttling was easily demonstrated by using a VPN to mask the Netflix traffic, speeds went way up). This is analogous to the AdBlock extortion racket where they charge Google to allow Google's ads through AdBlock.
- jackmott 10y ago>there's not that much to worry about for us as ordinary internet users. >"extort" money from Google, Facebook, YouTube, Netflix That's going to degrade my experience or raise my bills at those sites, and make it impossible to make informed decisions when picking an ISP, as I won't know the true costs involved.
- YCode 10y ago> picking an ISP If you're even lucky enough to have a choice.
- thesuitonym 10y agoWhat I've noticed in most cities is that picking your ISP is a choice between the crappy but affordable cable connection, and the ultra-expensive but reliable fiber connection.
- tobltobs 10y ago> there's not that much to worry about for us as ordinary internet users But rising costs and reinforcing monopolies do worry me.
- jefurii 10y agoWhat about nonprofit web sites that can't afford to pay the extortion fees?
- woodymcpecks 10y agoFor whatever it's worth, there's a group of people trying to raise money to sue the FCC over the sudden policy changes like this they've imposed recently. http://www.irregulators.org http://www.irregulators.org
- guelo 10y agoGoogle and Facebook's silence on net neutrality is deafening. It makes no sense. Are they thinking they'll be able to pay for access to the customers that their competitors won't be able to afford?
- claytonjy 10y agoI'd wager that's exactly what they're thinking. This hurts consumers, it hurts potentially-but-not-yet-big tech companies, and it even hurts currently-established players in the short term, but on a not-too-long time horizon it cements the big players' near-monopolistic positions in their respective markets. What's $50mm/yr in "fast lane" payments to ISP's when it prevents others from disrupting your multi-trillion-dollar tech conglomerate?
- staltz 10y agoGood point, but then again, access to Facebook is probably going to be the most demanded by ISP customers, and therefore FB company has little to worry. Google, on the other, as a search engine company, may appear to depend on the open web, but they don't necessarily need to be an internet company. They are a "world information" company, and they can achieve that by moving content to Google servers (like they do with AMP), or simply providing intelligent content through their AI who is learning from content on the open web. I won't be surprised if/when Google stops being a de facto internet company and becomes an information company.
- thesuitonym 10y agoVery likely. At least in Faceboook's corner, they might be looking to make a tidy sum on this, I mean, who would want to use the ISP that doesn't have Facebook?
- bigbugbag 10y agoAren't those two mentioned in the death of transit ? Besides, facebook is a fierce opposant to net neutrality, remember their facebook basics offer as an attempt to conquer more users in emergent markets ? Pay less than a regular ISP and have an internet access limited to facebook and its partners, the exact opposite of net neutrality.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoWhen I worked in the DoD contracting space there were rules handed down that outlines what browser(s) and version(s) you MUST use due to security concerns. It was always Firefox. This may be an insanely stupid idea, but, as sort of a thought experiment: what would the fallout be if, say, Mozilla changed their license on Firefox to disallow the usage of their browser by government representatives and associated contractors unless they have a viable, open internet policy in their country? Maybe even restrict future updates to existing Firefox builds to require the same license change? Might cause some significant headaches as they can't update to the latest IE on likely most of their systems and Chrome has too much Google functionality built into it that, I believe, they'd have to use Chromium. Like I said, probably a dumb idea but I wanted to throw it out there as a thought exercise because I'm curious if something like this could be effective, much like the original internet blackout was.
- Jtsummers 10y agoNone. DoD doesn't require Firefox, Chrome, or IE. But the base install is typically IE only with the option to install Firefox or Chrome upon request. If anything, it'd hurt Firefox's market share, but would have no impact on the government beyond not being able to use it. Especially these days with sites making themselves Chrome-first like the damned IE-only sites from 20 years ago.
- BinaryIdiot 10y ago> None. DoD doesn't require Firefox, Chrome, or IE. But the base install is typically IE only with the option to install Firefox or Chrome upon request. Hmm, maybe depends on where you are in the crazy large DoD system. Our company was told the DNI office passed down requirements to use specific versions of Firefox and Firefox only for security purposes but IE was typically installed for when you were forced to use it. But it's also been 3 years now since I've been out of that space.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- kumar878 10y agoSuggestion - %s/Ajit Pai/Robert Taylor/ . Or some other DARPA person.
- jbob2000 10y agoWhere is Apple, Google, and Microsoft on this? What is the point of an app store if I can't use 90% of the apps on it? What the hell do I need a search engine for if there's only a few websites to search? Why would I use a computer at all if it just serves me the same garbage as a TV? Come on, throw your fucking weight around, jesus...
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoI think my viewpoint here is more devil's advocate because I'm not entire sure I believe it myself. But it seems like a possibility so I wanted to share: One thing to consider here is the large juggernauts in the tech industry would actually benefit to this type of legislation. Let's say Comcast adds a fee to get priority access. Google, Apple, Microsoft; pretty much all of the existing and large-enough companies would likely be able to pay for it without much issue. While this would cut into their profits to some degree it makes the bar much, much higher for competition to come into their space. If competition springs up it'll likely not grow as fast in an environment with many paying for special access so the tech companies could buy them at a likely cheaper price if they see them. Alternatively this may help kill existing competition like Spotify who has razor thin (or negative, I can't remember) margins so they wouldn't be able to compete. Aside from a, likely very small, cut into profits there isn't much down side for any of the big tech companies. Are we sure they will want to band together?
- jbob2000 10y agoAll three of those companies survive off acquisitions. They rely on small independent companies taking a risk and doing the hard work, and when they find the diamond-in-the-rough, they get snapped up and brought under the corporate umbrella. This legislation dries up the well. No small companies to buy = no progress.
- tetrep 10y ago> No small companies to buy = no progress. Which is perfectly fine for incumbents.
- 10y ago
- epx 10y agoThe dynamic IPs were the beginning of the end. Even the IPv6 connection of my ISP does not allow incoming connections. Sad :(
- BenjiWiebe 10y agoSurprisingly enough, my (tunneled) IPv6 address from CenturyLink has no ports filtered that I can tell, and is regularly higher bandwidth and lower latency than the IPv4 portion of our link.
- subterfudge4 10y agoIs there any evidence anywhere that non-neutral net actually makes money for ISPs ?
- Jtsummers 10y agoIn what way would it not? ISPs could leave everything as it is, and there'd be no change. But without net neutrality they will have the ability to extort cough, sorry, "request" that companies and (potentially) customers pay them extra for prioritizing certain content. They'll also have the ability to deprioritize content, potentially costing companies that don't pay (why I call it extortion) customers. If Comcast does this to Netflix (deprioritizes) then Comcast can drive customers to their own VOD services. If Netflix doesn't pay, Netflix loses customers, Comcast gains customers. If Netflix does pay, Netflix retains customers, Comcast gains money. Either way, Comcast is better off. The primary issue is that ISPs are not just ISPs. They have many services which compete with 3rd party providers (some big, some small) and their market position will allow them to abuse the hell out of both customers and other service providers.
- claytonjy 10y agoComcast successfully extorted payment from Netflix a few years ago by throttling their content until they paid up.
- jandrese 10y agoSure, the incident that caused the FCC to write the Net Neutrality rules. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/186576-verizon-caught-throttling-netflix-traffic-even-after-its-pays-for-more-bandwidth https://www.extremetech.com/computing/186576-verizon-caught-... Basically the ISPs held one service for ransom by slowing down the traffic enough to make it run poorly until the service paid the demands. We can probably expect to see more of this in the future. Amazon and Google should probably start setting aside a warchest for the inevitable shakedowns.
- bigbugbag 10y agoDepends on the ISP, not for the federated local non profit ISPs for example.
- pixelbill 10y agoWhere I live (United States, rural area) there is no choice in cable internet service. We have one provider (PenTeleData) who charges $60 a month for 25mbit, though you'd be lucky to ever see that full 2.5 MB/sec. Because of the lack of competition, their customer service is absolutely abysmal as well. They don't care how their customers are treated because we have no viable alternative. We've had our internet turned off (and were charged to turn it back on) because we were allegedly downloading movies. We've had our internet go out and the service tech said it would take a MONTH to come out and take a look at it (at first he said there were NO appointments, like at all, but when pressed he gave the month time frame). Our corporate world is shitty, and it's getting shittier every day.
- rocky1138 10y agoDo the people in the USA elect the leader of the FCC? If so, can't they elect someone better? If not, why not?
- orthecreedence 10y agoThe FCC is "ruled" by five people: two democrats, two republicans, and a chair. The president appoints the chair of the FCC and at any given point, there have to be at least two members of each of the two political parties on the FCC. The the position(s) in the FCC are not elected, except indirectly by who you vote for as president. (Please someone correct me if I'm wrong).
- thomastjeffery 10y ago> each of the two political parties What about all the other parties? Independents? Edit: cnnsucks explained it more clearly: > The commission may not have more than 3 members from the same political party.
- orthecreedence 10y agoThanks, that makes sense.
- bogomipz 10y agoUnfortunately no. The FCC Chairman is appointed by the President. Ajit Pai was appointed by Trump.
- sp332 10y agoThe chairman has to be approved by the Senate after being nominated by the President. But the Senate can't remove the chairman afterward, while the President can. Edit: the commissioners including the chairman have five-year terms and have to be re-approved by the Senate for each term. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Communications_Commission#Organization_and_procedures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Communications_Commiss...
- newsat13 10y agoThe optimist in me sees this as a good things. Maybe Google will bring back it's Fiber program. Maybe the heavy weights of IT industry will start a conglomerated ISP? Maybe new startups will appear that provider an unregulated internet. In the long run, the only solution that is going to work is to have proper competition to the likes of comcast.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoPeople forget sometimes that the ARPAnet was a closed Internet. And it didn't have some of the problems of todays internet like spam for that same reason. (you could be kicked off) And the thing that lived alongside of it was FIDOnet and Usenet which exploited another closed network (the switched network service known as the telephone network) to run a parallel and notionally "open" internet. Then (as now) the challenge was that for long distance communication you needed someone who was paying for that infrastructure. The way it typically worked was that a big company like Xerox which nominally had a coast to coast telephone system that was being maintained for corporate reasons but had excess capacity, was notionally "ok" with a couple of engineers creating a 'tunnel' between the west coast and the east coast. Locally people would use their 'free calling zone' to call. We have companies that have their own wide area networks, and we have things like software defined radios and ISM bands that allow for nominally low cost 'hops'. Is it time to dig up the old Usenet architecture?
- apatters 10y agoI support the principle of net neutrality in some philosophical abstract, but increasingly it seems like we're being asked to choose between: A) A cabal of Comcast-centric billionaires who control key infrastructure on the Internet B) A cabal of Sam Altman type VC billionaires who control key infrastructure on the Internet What are ANY of these guys other than profiteers who seek to pervert the open protocols of the Internet for the sake of their own profits? I think they are all aspiring emperors with no clothes. I dare any of these profiteers to respond.
- thomastjeffery 10y agoI'm not sure what that has to do with net neutrality. Care to elaborate?
- doctorshady 10y agoThe FCC under Pai has become an absolute joke. Unless a piano happens to fall on his and Trump's heads in some sort of freak accident, this crap is just going to keep happening. For whatever it's worth, there's a group of people trying to raise money to sue the FCC as sort of an alternate approach: http://www.irregulators.org http://www.irregulators.org
- skrebbel 10y agoIt's probably a nitpick, but to me Mozilla has always been an organisation with a global mission. They make it seem like these decisions have a global impact, whereas in reality, if I'm not mistaken, this is about national policy for a single country. A country which is not mentioned by name at all in the entire article. I wish authors would step away from the "USA == world" idea a bit more often. I'd like to get an idea of whether this impacts the rest of the world at all. My impression is "no" but most articles on the subject are too busy screaming "fire!" to clarify much about this. The title of this article is "one step closer to a closed internet". That really does make it seem like this can have internet-wide impact though, but I don't see it. Anyone?
- ajdlinux 10y agoAs an Australian I agree that Americans have a tendency to forget that the world exists beyond US borders, but the internet and the tech industry is still dominated by US companies. A less-free US internet absolutely has flow-on effects to the rest of the world when the rest of the world is dependent on US services. Furthermore, the FCC is setting a very poor example for other regulators...
- anewday 10y agoAnd also that US law propagates through the world by trade deals and such.
- erikb 10y agoSadly this kind of battle can only be extended, not one. There will always be parties on both sides of the net-neutrality spectrum. But sadly one side needs to active millions of people for each battle and the other one can be confident with just a handful of politicians and two hands full of lawyers. Kind of obvious that you can't push people every two years to rally on the streets for the same topic, again and again.
- bigbugbag 10y agoOne Step Closer to a Closed Internet ... in the USA This probably means internet business will move outside the USA where it is way too centralized, some good could come out of such a move. On the other hand we have mozilla not putting money where its mouth is, not giving a shit about non-majority users and using skewed users tracking to justify those decisions. Have a look at how they dropped alsa support and refused to admit they made a mistake rejecting the responsibility on people disabling their spying, refused to backtrack when someone came forward to fix their code and maintain it. When mozilla's action will be in line with the air they push out of their lung, I'll pay attention and support them again. Right now and after 15+ years supporting them, I'm giving them the same support they give me, the faster mozilla fails and disappears the faster a competent body can replace them and start doing the right thing and give the right direction to firefox.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- strin 10y agoLove the vision of neutrality, but it feels disheartening that net neutrality has been broken with increasing number of platform companies. Google's algorithm decide which content show up in search results, and Facebook's ranking model determines the news you will see. Same wth app store, only apps that fit the "Apple philosophy" can get approved. Since most of our times on internet nowadays are spent on platforms, it turns out unconsciously we've already lived in a "closed internet".
- rickdg 10y agoFrom the perspective of non-tech people, the internet has actually grown by shedding its neutrality. Huge numbers came to the net because of the "e" of IE, the "s" of skype or the "f" of facebook. As we watch people spend all of their time online locked in a closed platform (or spend all their money in hardware they don't control), we can't be surprised that net neutrality doesn't resonate with them. We can't just fight the occasional battle and then wonder why we're losing the war. If there's more money to be made in crushing net neutrality than in leveraging it, it will get crushed (specially in America). A basic problem is that technological literacy is not growing fast enough. In fact, ignorance is celebrated. Both Apple and Microsoft are lowering the bar for their operating systems every year. The lack of monetization solutions has made it necessary to sell the user, and their ignorance or just lack of interest facilitates this tremendously. If you want to be able to choose freedom over convenience, you need to care for how things work. Meanwhile, modern corporations are perfectly aware of how net neutrality got them to the top, of how relinquishing it allows them to stay on top and of how suppressing it keeps other companies from doing to them what they did to the older corporations that used to rule the world.