11 ms·
Iron Nitride Permanent Magnets – An Alternative to Rare Earth Magnets (2014)
- oldandtired 10y agoGoes to show that stupidity isn't dead. I wonder what kind of "licensing fees" will they require? I also wonder how much of this research was paid for by public money? Instead of making this available to everyone so that these kinds of magnets can get out there, they want to scrooge first. If I recall correctly, universities that have gone down this path have simply stalled the progress of mankind instead of pushing it forward.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Sylphine 10y agoYou can bitch about it when we will all have basic income until then they are doing what any other inventors are doing.
- oldandtired 10y agoWho's complaining. I am making an observation about how universities have gone down the wrong path. Anything I invent (especially on the back of others work), I share - no strings. The main reason is that anything I have designed or thought up has been expanded by others and I get to increase my knowledge by that very process. As long as the USA (as in the people) choose the current way they have as the "best" way to run their society, then it'll never have "basic income" or even "basic health care". I live in a country that has the most innovative/inventive people on earth bar none. But we are entrepreneurial morons as a nation and we doubt our own ability and inventiveness. If we actually got past those specific cultural biases that we have, no other country would be able to catch up to us. There are three nations, which, if they were able to get past their individual biases, would together change the world so fast that your head would be spinning to keep up. Things like a space elevator or flying car or even individual flying machines would be passe. So when a university does this kind of activity then we can be assured that progress will be slowed to a snails pace.
- ageofwant 10y agoDamn right. And just one sentence above they go on about the environmental harm rare earth extraction causes. Surely if this was a real concern just 'licence' the tech for free. I would expect universities of all organisation to understand that baking a bigger cake means more cake for everyone. Fighting like jackals over scraps is what I expect 'business' to do. But uni's have become big, inefficient fascist diploma factories, and you can tell.
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoIf public money went into development - the public is definitely entitled to a cut.
- smaddox 9y agoThe US government typically gets non-exclusive license rights to any patents developed under US grants.
- lovemenot 10y agoThe University of Minnesota licensed Gopher in the early '90s. Until Gopher had its lunch eaten by a public domain WWW.
- jwr 10y agoThis is important, much more than most people think. You don't realize how many things around you need strong magnets. > This technology for producing iron nitride permanent magnets has been exclusively licensed. Interesting — I wonder to whom.
- VMG 10y agoI could come up with electrical motors and generators. Before that I saw them for controlling the arm of spinning hard drives, and those aren't used that much anymore. What else is there?
- falsedan 10y ago> spinning hard drives, and those aren't used that much anymore Hey! Are you basing this statement on your own experience of your personal/business hardware? Because spinning rust has never been more heavily used, for bulk on/near-line storage. Judging by the list of alumni from Prof. Wang's group, HDD manufacturers have a strong demand for advanced applications of magnets, plus a tiny fraction from biomedical techs. [0]: http://www.nanospin.umn.edu/people-0 http://www.nanospin.umn.edu/people-0
- VMG 10y agoYou were right, I did not consider bulk storage outside my personal use. Thanks.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoHard drives are one of those big technologies that are more widely used and more important after they are obsolete[0]. [0] for some definition of obsolete.
- lloydjatkinson 10y ago> spinning hard drives, and those aren't used that much anymore. Not sure if serious or not. Just because SSD's are popular, does not mean HDD's are unused.
- 10y ago
- batushka 10y agoI love how US beats foreign cartels or shortages by true technology (fracking, magnets).
- acchow 10y agoThis isn't just an American thing.
- jessaustin 10y agoPerhaps, but we don't love it when others do this.
- logfromblammo 10y agoSure we do. They just become naturalized Americans if we can get our hooks into them, and honorary Americans if we can't. America loves being the sewer for everyone else's brain drains. Just look at great Americans like Nikola Tesla, Albert Einstein, Werner von Braun, Leo Szilard, Alexander Graham Bell, William J. Kroll, Alexey Pajitnov, Igor Sikorsky, etc.
- sliken 10y ago"Theoretical limit of its magnetic properties are more than twice the maximum reported magnetic energy product for a rare earth magnet" Call me a pessimist, but if the theoretical is more than twice the actual for rare earths that means the new magnet might well be weaker than the old ... in reality. It's doubly suspicious that they don't mention the theoretical vs reality for the rare earths.
- wbhart 10y agoThe theoretical maximum for a neodymium magnet is grade N64, i.e. 64 Mega-Gauss Oersted.
- emj 10y agoHmmm, from the summary: "The theoretical magnetic energy product for this iron nitride (Fe16N2) magnet is 130 mega gauss oersteds"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- superkuh 10y agoI don't think the theoretical maximum is wrong. It's just that the ion implantation can't be scaled up, doesn't work for bulk materials, and results in only ~40% of the material in the desired Iron Nitride form which has that theoretical limit.
- dkastner 10y agoBut even if these magnets were only as powerful as rare earth magnets, the benefits to the environment are huge.
- kazinator 10y agoYou're spot on. Compare theoretical with theoretical, actual with actual, damn it.
- novalis78 10y agoFirst thought 'no way!' - neodymium magnets had a huge impact on electronics and mechanical systems... and then twice the strength? Incredible!
- ptero 10y agoAs another poster said, iron's theoretical max is twice the currently available rare earth strength. It's apples and oranges.
- iamgopal 10y agoTwice then theoritical max of rare earth ?
- rplst8 10y agoIt looks like the theoretical max for rare earth is not that straight forward. See the BH(max) column here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_magnet#Magnetic_properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_magnet#Magnetic_pro...
- tremon 10y agoMaybe apples and oranges when purely considering the material properties, but I think the point being made is that FeN could replace Nd in all currently applicable technologies.
- Sean1708 10y agoFrom a quick google search it does indeed look like the theoretical BHmax of rare-earth magnets is about 60 MGOe, so I think that might just be poor wording from the article. That said, I would agree that we should be waiting to sing their praises until they can beat rare-earth magnets in practice.
- MertsA 10y agoCan we get a [2012] on the title?
- creeble 10y agoTitle has apparently been changed to 2014. Has anything come of this revolutionary creation since? I.e., any actual magnets in production?
- nickcw 10y agoHere is an article with a bit more info about Iron Nitride (it has quotes from Professor Jian-Ping Wang who is cited in the original link). https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/research-news/rare-earth-free-magnet-made-from-cheap-materials-2016-05/ https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/research-news/rare-ea... Looks like there is a way to go before commercialization, but then that article was written in May 2016 so maybe they've improved the process since then. > It is only a tiny sample, a film 500nm thick, but it is the real thing.
- glenneroo 10y agoAccording to the patent application[0] it's from 2012. [0]https://www.google.com/patents/US20140299810 https://www.google.com/patents/US20140299810
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoAs a bonus - this is as environmentally friendly and cheap as they come. We have a lot of both fe an ni.
- gruturo 10y ago> We have a lot of both fe an ni. Nitpick - "Ni" stands for Nickel. The magnets described in the article are Iron Nitride - that means Iron and Nitrogen (Fe16N2), not Iron and Nickel. Your point stands - Nitrogen is extremely abundant.
- logfromblammo 10y agoBoth of those are actually common enough that if a biological ecosystem ever discovered a competitive advantage for very powerful magnetic crystals, it might have come up with Fe16N2 instead of just the magnetite (Fe3O4) and greigite (Fe3S4) that currently form the basis of biological magnetism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetosome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetosome
- raverbashing 10y agoScience beats scarce natural resources. Again
- sangnoir 10y agoCall me when science transmogrifies base metals into gold for less than it costs to dig the stuff up from the ground: humanity has been trying since before science/ when science was alchemy.
- raverbashing 10y agoRight, that's still hard, but it can provide substitutes for (some) cases where gold would be used Of course some substitutions are harder than others
- Robotbeat 10y agoGold sucks compared to aluminum and other metals for most uses. Aluminum used to be way more expensive than gold. And when science was "alchemy" aluminum metal wasn't even known. It wasn't produced until the 19th Century, and at first absurdly expensive. And we can, of course, transmute lead into gold using science. It's expensive and pointless, of course. And gold itself is mostly valued for its rarity and shininess. But we can transmute carbon into diamond for less than the market price for diamonds. Diamonds are more expensive than gold.
- Retric 10y agoGold is a proxy not a goal. If you want a TV you don't care what it's made of just that it works. Consider it's only rather pointless blocks of actual gold that are expensive, you can make items that look and act like gold without actually using much gold.
- GoToRO 10y agoAt that time gold would become just like plastic. Gold has value because it is rare and because it can not be forged.
- zeristor 10y agoThis looks to be up an update from several months ago, with graphs and data. However the text is very domain specific, I can't follow it myself: http://www.nanospin.umn.edu/new-magnetic-materials http://www.nanospin.umn.edu/new-magnetic-materials
- castratikron 10y agoThey use the term "giant saturation magnetization" to describe an iron nitride magnet that they made. The saturation magnetization is the point where the magnetization in a material cannot increase any further. Think of it like a maximum strength of a magnet. Neodymium magnets have their saturation magnetization around 1 Tesla, and they reported that their iron nitride magnet has a saturation point at 2.68 Tesla, so it's greater. (The magnetics community likes putting words such as "giant", "colossal", and "extraordinary" in front of terms to emphasize how big something is. Especially when it comes to magnetoresistance) BH max is a characteristic of a magnetic material. You can think of it as a kind of magnetic energy density rating, so more is better. What you linked to showed that the iron nitride magnet they made had a BH max similar to a neodymium magnet. Also, I love the name "Minnealloy". Very Minnesotan.
- usmeteora 10y agoThis is interesting. I am an Electrical Power Engineer, and at my tech school, our Senior Thesis projects are essentially real Engineering firms coming to the school and assigning a group of engineers to work on a project they are actually working on in real life. The company I worked under makes electric motors for navy ships and other government contracts. There are enormous machines in side of these things, but rare earth metals are economically volatile, on a scale unlike most other industries. China and Malaysia have most of the rare earth metal mines (we had a bastanite mine in CA where you can mine for rare most of the rare earth metals, but the liberals did not want the pollution in California, so as a result, they closed down the mine (before it reopened for a bit and then went into Chapter 11 bankruptcy last year) and made America dependent on rare earth metals from Asia, where for a long time, and probably still now, they have zero emissions policies so we are effectively polluting the planet more (but not in my backyard so it feels good to feel clean and drive a prius as long as all the rare earth metals and pollution caused mining it are done by people working 1/26th the pay in China breathing in that air in not me, it makes me feel green), until Elon Musk has recently come and been working with mining companies in the U.S. for his operations. At the time in 2011 when I was a senior working on this project and the explicit motivation for investing in research for this, China had overnight banned global trade on rare earth metals with 24hrs notice for 6months, to focus on their internal development, skyrocketing the price of 90% of the worlds rare earth metal production by over 9000% At that time, my engineering group was contracted to come up do motor design and look for utilizing either less rare earth metals while meeting the same specifications for output or looking up for alternative metals. We ended with a form of a Halbach array, which arranges rotor and stator magnets in a permutation of an orientation where the magnetic field is increased on one side and cancelled on the other, reducing the amount of loss not going into the relationship between the stator and the rotor and increasing the magnetic field where it did. There is still a lot of need for this kind of design and optimization, and I ended up in a different niche of Electrical Power but, people were and are dishing out alot of money around this kind of work for good reason. I looked up patents a few years after I graduated around this kind of thing and they have spiked up significantly in the passed few years, particularly with halbach arrays. And you are right, most people don't realize rare earth metals are required in electric motors, wind turbines, inverters for solar panels and most movements we associate with sustainable energy, despite the fundamental components being extremely rare economically volatile, and relatively no innovation going on in the space of addressing these issues.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- markvdb 10y agohttp://www.designworldonline.com/coming-revolution-high-strength-magnets http://www.designworldonline.com/coming-revolution-high-stre... (December 2014) seems to give a wider overview of non-rare earth magnet development: FeN, MnBi, Ce and exchange spring magnets.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stillhere 10y agoIt's a miracle. How do they work?
- stevespang 10y agoThis research was funded by a government grant, so we all have the right to know the true results. As a magnet material researcher, I inquired with the researchers of this project over a year ago, never a response back. Apparently, this iron nitride was/is created in a crystalline form in tiny quantities, it is very sensitive and HIGHLY subject to oxidation, way more sensitive to oxidation than Neo magnet materials, and will likely never go beyond this stage of research. If this was a practical material the same researchers would have already taken it farther.
- ridgeguy 10y agoSome important applications properties I didn't see listed in the brief UofM blurb: Curie temperature: - at what temperature do these magnets start to lose their magnetic energy? Coercivity: - how easily are these magnets demagnetized by external energy input (vibration, inductive kickback from motor windings, transformers, etc.)?
- creeble 10y agoInteresting to note that this[0] article from Magnetics Magazine in 2016 has exactly zero mention of FeN magnets. Vapor? [0] http://www.magneticsmagazine.com/main/articles/permanent-magnets-in-a-changing-world-market/ http://www.magneticsmagazine.com/main/articles/permanent-mag...
- leggomylibro 10y agoThank christ, have you tried to source NdB magnets at quantity lately? I hope these get to be produced at scale soon, although unfortunately it sounds like the technology has been "exclusively licensed," which in my experience means a 500% markup from whatever its aiming to supplant once it finally hits production. The price of progress, I guess. But yeah, I tried to order a few hundred rare earth magnets from China (where almost all of the world's rare earth metals come from) and got told that they can't export "pill-shaped" objects...bullshit, that's the same mealy-mouthed politically-backed excuse that they gave for not shipping a few dozen CCP badges through customs. Anyways, the patent application doesn't make it sound THAT hard. Maybe it's something you could DIY for personal use: https://google.com/patents/US20140299810 https://google.com/patents/US20140299810 Maybe someone who knows more about...all of this...can correct me, but tl;dr: Take an iron wire or sheet of diameter/thickness ~10μm-1mm. Strain it by pulling it in opposite directions, e.g. using two rollers pulling in opposite directions. While the iron is strained, heat it to ~125-600C in an atmosphere of N2 or N2+inert gas at ~0.15-1.5 Pascals for 2-10 hours. You actually need atomic Nitrogen and this part of the patent is vague, but I think ~500C might be enough to break the N2 bonds? They also describe a urea infusion process, but that sounds more difficult for a garage effort. Anyways, if that all works, it sounds like you can stack 'em to make larger and more powerful magnets. Anyone up for it?
- raziel2701 10y agoThere's a lot of canceled items in the patent, I wonder if that's because it was too vague to be part of the patent? I agree with your interpretation of the manufacturing process. They expose the sheet of <001> Fe to either nitrogen gas (N2) or NH3. NH3 does break apart with high temperature but ideally you want to work with N2 instead for safety reasons. It's more efficient to break the N2 bond using a cracking source, they use a plasma arc to break the bond of N2. The usual problem is always going to be compositional control, you know, coming up with a method that preserves the rather excessive stoichiometry of Fe16N2. There's a bunch of other phases that can be achieved with simpler stoichiometries, so the long term stability of this magnetic phase is of concern to me. What are the ideal operating conditions of this magnet before interdiffusion occurs and we lose the right stoichiometry? Maybe there's a small window that could render this material inapplicable to many mechanical or thermal conditions. Oxidation of the Fe sheet before nitridization is another concerns. Fe oxidizes very easily and would become a barrier for the nitrogen. The other concern is that they characterize the magnet's performance only on the product of saturation magnetization and coercivity, and mention using ion bombardment to enhance the coercivity. This can be interpreted to mean that the Fe16N2 has a poor coercivity which means that it's a magnet that is very easy to switch with weak magnetic fields or thermal energy. Not what you want for permanent magnet applications. So I still have a lot of questions and concerns although I do think it's worth pursuing this material because it makes a lot of financial sense as Fe and N are super common and easier to process.