7 ms·
If you had done this the Right Way from the beginning you would have had a vesting agreement that specified what would happen in a case like this. A typical ve
by lisper 10y ago
If you had done this the Right Way from the beginning you would have had a vesting agreement that specified what would happen in a case like this. A typical vesting agreement would have vested your stock over a 48-month period, so after 18 months you would have vested 33% x 18/48 = 12.375%. So 10% is not unreasonable.
However: having 10% of the company owned by a non-particiapting founder is a big red flag for many investors, and would be a significant obstacle to the company's success. So you might want to consider settling for significantly less than 10% simply because you may end up making more money in the long run. 10% of zero is still zero. If I were setting up a company today I would have a back-loaded vesting schedule: 10% the first year, 20% the second, 30% the third year and 40% the fourth year. On this schedule, your share at 18 months would have been 4.95%. If I were you, I would offer to take that.
If you're raising $500k for 25% of the company, that means you think that the company is worth $1.5M now (because the company now plus the $500k would be worth $2M). So your share on a flat vesting schedule is about $180k, on the back-loaded schedule it would be about $74k. If you want to cash out you should offer to sell for significantly less than those numbers because you want everyone to think they've gotten a good deal. You never know when you'll want to do business with someone again in the future. A reputation for being reasonable is worth a lot more than $180k.
You need to decide what you're doing before you approach investors because you need to achieve clarity on what you're selling them: is this a company with three founders, or a company with two founders and one ex-founder (and is the ex-founder willing to sell and if so for how much)?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nealbozeman 10y agoInvestors will not see his 10% ownership as a red flag any more than they will see a non participating investor owning 25% of the business as a red flag. In this case, he/she delivered 18 months of value that led to a 1.5mm pre money val. The most fair option is already mentioned - to maintain your 33% that makes all three of the founders equal as of today, and then allocate a new share allotment to dilute you out over a new specified vesting period. If you want to show future investors good will, ask to maintain a seat on the board.
- anovikov 10y agoIf i was an investor, i'd see it as a red flag indeed. I'd think: 'so this guy left the boat being a founder, giving up most of his share, so probably he knows that the company is going to tank and don't want to waste his time anymore, and he definitely knows a lot more about it than i could potentially know being an outside guy'.
- angersock 10y agoGood thing you're not an investor then, yeah?
- empath75 10y agoOr you might think that he got in over his head and decided to step aside and let the other guys manage the business.
- greglindahl 10y agoStill a huge red flag.
- SkyMarshal 10y agoThat rarely happens. In that case the incentive is actually to stay on, let your co-founders drive the value, and pocket the equity/$ for it. Easy money. Takes a rare breed to self-sacrifice for the good of the company. It's more likely what annovikov said, the one leaving has serious doubts about the strategy but got out-voted.
- derefr 10y agoWhat is the self-sacrifice in this case? You're trading "working to build a business to earn an equity-stake" for "free-riding on others' work to build said business to make your equity-stake more valuable." Think of it as two separate companies: Startup A, which you co-founded, and which ended up dissolving, you seeing nothing for your efforts (other than whatever salary you managed to scrape out); and then, Startup B, which you bought a huge number of shares of for the amazing price of $0/share, and now get to smile as those shares appreciate, like any investor. It just so happens that Startup A and Startup B are the same company at different points in their life, but that shouldn't change your views toward the two situations.
- sage76 10y agoWhat's the point of a vesting schedule and having an orderly way to exit if it would still not be acceptable? I think it's odd that people would have a problem with him owning a stake. Should he not be compensated for the work he has put in? He was awarded shares for his work presumably. I would say he should stick to 12%. It's derived from an industry standard. VCs who have a problem with this are, pardon my french, greedy assholes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- GnarfGnarf 10y agoactually it's "trous de cul gloutons".
- omginternets 10y agoactually, it's "trous du cul gloutons" ;)
- beat 10y agoIt doesn't matter whether or not they're greedy assholes (it's probably safe to assume they are). It only matters whether they're willing to invest. So a red flag is a red flag. There are plenty of places for handwaving and hope in startups already. The ownership status of a departed founder should not be one of them. That should be crystal clear.
- sage76 10y agoWell, what you are essentially saying is that if you need money, VCs can and will make you dance to their tunes. That much has been confirmed by Parker Conrad himself, so I agree. It's not really a red flag since he could have a number of reasons for leaving that are not related to the business. But I guess a VC would use anything as an excuse to control and manipulate things. This really puts a giant question mark on why anyone would bother with a non-CEO founding role. Startups are hard enough as it is, adding to it the potential of losing all your equity because you had a falling out with the CEO makes it almost not worth the trouble. Engineers getting into partnerships with domineering business types should definitely watch out for this and evaluate their options. At least when you work for Microsoft and leave after 2 years, they cannot claw back what you earned over that period of time.
- javajosh 10y agoInterestingly, those numbers are the same order of magnitude cost of a coder for 18 months. That feels right to me, that you'd get ~$100k, and perhaps retain .5%, basically demoting yourself to a (fully vested) second gen hire, and moving on with your life. No investor would see that as "dead weight".
- firloop 10y agoThis is a big reason why YC requires founders to have vesting shares with a cliff (even as a solo founder!). Better to have some agreement than not, especially when cofounder disputes ruin many early startups.
- inputcoffee 10y agoThere is an alternative: The investors buy up 99.99% of the company for $500k at a $1 premoney, and then give out 75% of the company to current management in order to incentivize them to stay. I am using extreme numbers here to make the point, but current management almost always gets a carve out.
- neltnerb 10y agoIf the red flag is related to the founder leaving over a disagreement related to strategy, it sounds like it should be a red flag and be considered by an investor. Even ignoring the cap table issues making it harder to incentivize future employees. Assuming that they're taking the high road and that the potential investor is well aware that a founder is leaving over a disagreement regarding strategy, which I sure hope they are, the investor is walking in with eyes open and is making a bet that the person leaving is incorrect. That seems to me to be perfectly reasonable. If you want to be generous (as the person leaving) you can certainly offer to let the investor or co-founders buy you out at the same valuation the investor is getting. If you want to be extremely generous and a little creative, you can ask for an amount of money that would make you feel you hadn't been cheated in exchange for all of your equity stake. After all, you disagree with their strategy, so perhaps you are skeptical that the equity is worth anything and would rather just get decent back-wages for the work you've done and wash your hands of it. In that case, perhaps you can just ask for something like $200k for all of it and call it a day. If I disagreed enough with the company direction to leave, I might call that a huge win relative to putting in years more effort and eventually getting nothing at all out of it!
- nslindtner 10y agoSpeaking from experience. You guys Need to find an agreement now. Do not keep any part of the company. It will not work in the long term. Things will get messy, and they will slowly build up a truth about you not giving (and never did) anything to the company. You have to settle on some kind of amount. And then you can be flexible about the payment of the amount - it could be over 36 month or someting. My experience was it took 3 years with layers, lost friendships - and in the end we enden exactly the same place - same amount and everything. I sold 50% of my stake right away, and should have keep the rest. Big mistake. My recommendation would be to find an amount - yep - it's hard. But it will only get worse from now.