8 ms·
I had a terrible "Billy" moment a few years ago. I was travelling and a friend said I could use her house, because it was empty. This was perfect for me, since
by lordnacho 10y ago
I had a terrible "Billy" moment a few years ago.
I was travelling and a friend said I could use her house, because it was empty. This was perfect for me, since I had a wife and kid.
It turns out there was a housekeeper. She did everything for us, made us feel very comfortable, cooked, served, helped with the kid, etc.
Then one day I found out she didn't have her own room, despite the place being a multi storey mansion. In fact, she slept on a mat in the kitchen. And not only that, there would be a phone call each morning to wake her up, from the master of the house. He didn't want her to get too comfy while the family was out.
It was all a bit shocking. I still haven't chatted to my friend about this, because what on earth do you say? And otherwise ordinary western educated person -in fact a feminist, globalist, left-leaning idealist- who has a slave? What if I've misunderstood something? Maybe my friend didn't approve of it? Maybe he did? I'd never be able to talk to my friend again.
I got the housekeeper a present when we left, as she'd been so good at taking care of us. But naturally I didn't enquire any further into her relationship with the family.
-------
My main thought is there's a sort of Stockholm syndrome going on. Lola still had thoughts for her family back home, but she was so integrated in the new family it became part of her life, too. I guess it's a coping mechanism. Even slaves need meaning in their lives, and taking care of kids is meaning.
-------
Ok, enough of moralizing. Actually I find it comforting that there is at least some sympathy for my predicament. At least one or two of you think it is possible that they would behave similarly. Or at least acknowledge the awkward situation.
I will talk to this friend in person next time I'm in that part of the world, which should be soon, about this incident, and get the full story of how their housekeeper lives.
- bflesch 10y agoSo you're trying to tell us that your feeling of uncomfortness is the only thing stopping you from growing a spine and standing up for such an inhumane treatment, that apart from you nobody else can witness? Have some decency and confront your so-called friend. How can people be rich and not have the decency to give the person feeding you and your family a freaking room. And I really had to constrain myself from using expletives in this reply.
- MrLeap 10y agoSeems like he's so hypnotized by being rich adjacent he couldn't ask some questions about something that weird. HN is the closest thing I have to a portal into the private lives of people with nigh infinite money, and eeeevery so often I read something like the gp that makes me want to gulag the rich and seize the means of production. Now I know there's evil people at every income level, but infinite money really increases the ability of a person to project evil. My intuition tells me this story isn't even that exceptional. I bet the evil rich hedonism spectrum has some real nightmare fuel.
- 5thaccount 10y ago> makes me want to gulag the rich and seize the means of production. I feel the opposite way. This sort of thing rarely happens in the west, but quite openly happens in other places, and that fact makes me want to help fix the inequities in OTHER countries that cause this, not tear down my own country. Specifically (and proselytizing to a degree) it makes me more determined to give a significant portion of my income to https://www.givedirectly.org/basic-income https://www.givedirectly.org/basic-income so that at least some of the poorest people on the planet can be empowered to make their own choices.
- fjdlwlv 9y agoWhy not both?
- cdelsolar 10y agoYes, my goodness, do something about this!
- lordnacho 10y ago> Have some decency and confront your so-called friend. Sounds like you haven't been in this situation. You know, there's often a gap between how good we think we are, and how good we are. I feel terrible about it, and the subject comes up now and again of whether we should say something, and my wife and I feel bad. It's easy to tell people what they should do, I do it all the time as well, even to myself.
- qntty 10y agoThis sounds like a question you would be asked to think about in an ethics class. The kind I would probably dismiss as so unrealistic that it's not worth taking seriously, so I'd give some canned answer that I think is supposed to be the correct one. I don't know what I would do in that situation either to be honest.
- devopsproject 10y ago> because what on earth do you say? For starters: Why is a woman sleeping on a mat in your kitchen? you need new friends
- deft 10y agoHave you considered he has the friends he has because they fit? He didn't speak up because it wasn't a big enough deal for him.
- devopsproject 10y agoHe is at least aware that what is happening was not quite right. It is concerning that he cared more about rich friends feelings than the woman sleeping in dirt but there isn't really enough here to label him a sociopath :)
- wavefunction 10y agoI guess I would have taken her to the authorities and helped her get whatever help she needs as soon as I determined her situation. And your friend is no feminist or idealist.
- kostyk 10y agoI see a lot of ads in the highway rest areas against slavery translated in multiple languages. There is hotline phone number on them. Its so easy to report to authorities they even encourage you. Every time i saw them i thought slavery in our day and age??? Now i know better.
- wyager 10y ago> And your friend is no feminist or idealist. No Scotsman either!
- wavefunction 10y agoFeminism is the idea that women have the natural right to make decisions for their own lives and pursue those decisions to the best of their abilities. Taking part in the detention and mistreatment of a woman is orthogonal to being a feminist. Idealism, well I'm assuming she's not an adherent of the philosophical kind and aspires to some sort of 'ideal' which I would have a hard time reconciling with slavery. So in conclusion, I reject your charges of No True Scotsman. Some things are cut-and-dried.
- dismantlethesun 10y agoWould you say it is misandrist to harm any man, anywhere? But I agree like most people they are likely a realist not an idealist.
- zem 10y agoif his friend was indian, the authorities would have been mightily puzzled. this is standard treatment for live-in servants, right down to the sheer meanness of making sure she "didn't get too comfortable" by way of an unnecessary phone call each morning.
- urbanj 10y agoYou need to take a look at yourself in the mirror. It's still not too late to talk to your friend and express your utter disgust at how that lady is being treated. Why haven't you done that?
- lordnacho 10y agoOne reason is I almost never hear from this friend since his relocation to another part of the world. Another is they have enough issues going on, personal issues requiring a lot of work, and being told they are a slave owner would not help. Perhaps most importantly my friend is not the direct slave owner, if that is indeed the relationship. It's my friend's dad, a guy I've barely even met. Perhaps if he was around, and caning her as I walked into the kitchen, I would have said something, who knows? But I was receiving his hospitality through a third party, and I am a foreigner to their country and customs. Did you ever read the article and wonder why Billy or his family didn't do anything? They probably felt it was so alien they didn't know what to do. You also gotta ask yourself, if you owned a slave, why you would allow that slave to be the only attendant when a western family comes through town?
- novembermike 10y agoWhat about the slave?
- dismantlethesun 10y agoI think there might be some conflation between this story and the article posted. We and the OP don't actually know if the person was enslaved by forced labour. All they know is that they slept on a matt in the kitchen. If they were being paid adequately, I would not call it slavery. Poor labour practice, certainly, and distasteful in the extreme but not the same thing as forced labour and bondage.
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago> I think there might be some conflation between this story and the article posted. Yeah. My sense is people are angry at what the OP described, and their anger has clouded their judgment. They're twisting ambiguous stories like lordnacho's into a version of the OP's, so they can play-act their sense of righteous superiority.
- hobs 10y agoI usually refrain from telling people who they are instead of what they do, but your friend is not a feminist or a left-leaning idealist if they have a slave, full stop.
- MockObject 10y agoWell, men have owned slaves for ages, so it's only fair for women to catch up in this measure.
- Danihan 10y ago> there's a sort of Stockholm syndrome going on Imprinting basically.
- Mz 10y agoMy main thought is there's a sort of Stockholm syndrome going on. Lola still had thoughts for her family back home, but she was so integrated in the new family it became part of her life, too. I guess it's a coping mechanism. Even slaves need meaning in their lives, and taking care of kids is meaning. OH, puhleez. This is so much worse than theories of "codependency," as if a woman with young kids being financially dependent on her alcoholic husband isn't an actual serious problem, it's just some sort of emotional disorder. If you are married and financially dependent on the guy, you wake him up and help him get to work and you cover up his alcoholism because you and your kids are dependent upon his money, not because you need therapy or something. Geez. Lola had no papers. She had no means to job hunt. She had no social connections outside the family. They uprooted her and moved her repeatedly. They never gave her the allowance they promised. This was her only means of survival. And she had agreed to it to get out of being married off to some asshole twice her age. So, she could do domestic labor or she could be de facto a sex slave. That would have probably involved all of the same abuses this involved, only add into it routine rape as part of the deal. She came from a place with no prospects. Then, having taken this deal, she was incredibly trapped. It is abhorrent to westerners, but indentured servitude used to be pretty common and was often done somewhat willingly/by choice as a means to pay a debt with labor at a time when money per se was hard to come by. Historically, it was not uncommon for people to pay for passage to the U.S. by agreeing to 7 years of indentured servitude following their trip here. That is still reality in a lot of places in the world. We don't want to hear it, but there is some truth to the idea that you need a middle class income to afford middle class morality. There are parts of the world where large numbers of people have no hope of anything resembling a middle class American lifestyle.
- infinite8s 10y ago> That is still reality in a lot of places in the world. We don't want to hear it, but there is some truth to the idea that you need a middle class income to afford middle class morality. There are parts of the world where large numbers of people have no hope of anything resembling a middle class American lifestyle. Not only that, they likely don't even have hope of anything resembling a poor American lifestyle.
- abalashov 10y ago
- petters 10y ago> I still haven't chatted to my friend about this, because what on earth do you say? > But naturally I didn't enquire any further into her relationship with the family. I just hope I would do the opposite. This is so wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- afthonos 10y agoYes, please, do something about this. Talk to your friend. Call the cops. Leave an anonymous tip and try to follow up. Something. Custom, law, and your own sense of right say so. Billy isn't the villain—but is he the role model you aspire to? If your kid learns your online identity some day and they stumble across this, is this the end of the story you want them to hear?
- noja 10y agoStop thinking about thinking about it, and do something about it for god's sake "Lord" Nacho.
- anigbrowl 10y agoMaybe my friend didn't approve of it? Maybe he did? I'd never be able to talk to my friend again. I've got to say that slavery as a moral ill outweighs social awkwardness, and rationalizing the situation by saying that maybe it gives slaves' life meaning is an abdication of moral responsibility. I mean, yeah, you could find meaning in that. I'm pretty stoic, I can find meaning in things like dying of cancer or whatever. But that doesn't make it acceptable to put someone in that position, since there's an implicit assertion that their life would lack meaning without this structure. I think you should swallow your anxiety about this and discuss the matter with your friend, who essentially coopted you into participating in an abusive relationship by not informing you of this in advance.
- jlarocco 10y agoIt's tough, but you really need to say something. It won't hurt to ask who she was. Maybe it's legit and there's a sensible explanation. But if it's not, think if it were you or one of your family or friends in the housekeeper's position.
- naiveattack 10y agoTake a homeless person and let them sleep in your kitchen in exchange for mowing your lawn -> moral hero. Build a mansion around this kitchen -> morally reprehensible It seems contrast in an unrelated area has confused the morally righteous over here. Do you own a nice car? Have a room in your house that is currently empty? There are people out there who could use some of that wealth for food. How would you feel if this wasn't a mansion but instead a small shack with only a kitchen and an adjacent room? It seems we're ok with: Low contrast at any distance, High contrast at large distances. But not high contrast at short distances It's good the woman in the story has shelter and a place to sleep.
- Cyph0n 10y agoSorry man, but that's dangerous thinking. I might understand if all rooms in the mansion were occupied by family members, or if the house was small such that the housemaid didn't have a room to stay in. But having her sleep in the kitchen of a huge mansion is inexcusable.
- naiveattack 10y agoI made no comment on whether it was or was not inexcusable. This isn't about what I believe is correct. Merely on the paradoxes and hypocrisy in this rather large stream of replies. What exactly makes it inexcusable to you though? The fact that the owner of the house could but did not, and the proximity of the rooms? That's what I'm talking about.
- Cyph0n 10y agoIt's inexcusable because it's expected that the housemaid gets his/her own private area. Remember, they are employees, and their job is to maintain the household. They are not "homeless" people skulking around the house. I've lived in a country where live-in housemaids are quite widespread and this kind of behavior would definitely be out of the ordinary, especially among more affluent families. Yes, worse things can happen to housemaids, but I'm talking about the general case.
- imesh 10y agoYeah, a lot of people would act like you, a lot of people also wouldn't. Just because others are pussies doesn't mean I have sympathy for you being a pussy.
- sctb 10y agoThis comment is not OK on Hacker News no matter what you're replying to. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- logfromblammo 10y agoThis is why US government employees and employees of contractors get mandatory training in how to recognize human trafficking. In this situation, at the very minimum, you need to ask "Do you feel your employer treats you fairly? I will keep your answer confidential." If the answer is "yes", then your moral obligation is satisfied. If the answer is "no", you may have to dig down through "uncomfortable situation," potentially to "friendship-ending argument about unethical behavior."
- mgkimsal 10y agoIf you discuss the answer with anyone... you've not kept the answer confidential.
- dismantlethesun 10y agoWell obviously, if there is an ongoing crime being committed they will speak. Even lawyers, priests, and doctors will speak if there's an ongoing crime being committed by someone who they'd otherwise hold confidence to.
- logfromblammo 10y agoYou can discuss your own observations without ever referring to your conversation with the housekeeper, or even admitting that a conversation happened.
- abraae 10y agoWas she a slave? When travelling in Vietnam (and probably plenty of other places) its pretty common to find the staff at little hotels all sleeping on mats on the floor in the kitchen. Its not a big deal - to get to the fridge you might need to step over and around them. None of these people are slaves, though they are certainly lowly paid workers. Is it unusual to have this arrangement in a private home? I don't know. The opprobrium from other commenters seems a little steeped in our own western views as to what's right and wrong, and I think your plan of digging more into the situation sounds an appropriate one.
- vzjrz 10y agoAll that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing
- bestopesto 10y agoJust send your friend the article with a vague message like, "Wow, this article was so powerful!"
- poweribo 10y agoat least share this article to your friend and ask her innocently what she thinks. and then pounce on her for being a hypocritical evil b1tch. good luck. im just kidding but pls do it. lol.
- kwaldman 10y agofull writeup here https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/06/lolas-story/524490/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/06/lolas-s.... no idea if this is related or not but "slavename" is the same