4 ms·
You can sum up this whole article with this quote: ...which is more likely? That Asian manufacturing powerhouses will learn to market their own products, or th
by stickfigure 10y ago
You can sum up this whole article with this quote:
...which is more likely? That Asian manufacturing powerhouses will learn to market their own products, or that Western P.R. spivs and window-treatment consultants and professional espresso-tasters will learn to rebuild an industrial base from scratch?
A lot of emotional invective around a fundamentally faulty premise. Which is harder, building a successful brand or building a clothing factory? The brand, unquestionably.
EDIT: /s/easier/harder. Somehow my fingers typed the exact opposite of what my brain instructed. Sorry!
- rndmize 10y agoI think you do the article a disservice to try and summarize it in such limited fashion. It considers questions such as why does trade today/globalization no longer seem to have the benefits economists consistently claim it does, or did in the past? How does this tie to labor in the US? I'm not even sure why you consider the part your quoted based on a faulty premise, when it sounds like you agree with it.
- ThrustVectoring 10y ago>Which is easier, building a successful brand or building a clothing factory? The brand, unquestionably. I'd question that. To me, convincing tens of millions of people that your products have certain qualities seems much more difficult than physically manipulating some cloth.
- api 10y agoYou are largely correct. Brands are very hard, especially in established markets. But brands don't employ people.
- mayukh 10y agoAnd why does brand building have to be the domain of the western world ?
- ng12 10y agoThat's only true for a very small class of luxury goods. If you had said the same thing about car brands in the 80's you'd be out a lot of money right now.
- rrggrr 10y agoManufacturing employs people, not brand value. How many ad agencies do you think Nike needs? You are tragically ill informed.
- dbmikus 10y agoYeah, I also took issue with the author's point that branding and marketing was so easily swappable. I'd say it's much easier for a global brand to swap where their factories are or who is running logistics than it is to just "create a new brand". Still, as another child comment of your post mentioned, branding doesn't employ the same number of people as manufacturing, so the US is shifting the share of job quantity to other countries. A lot of those middle-skill jobs get picked up by the still-growing service industry (which we can never outsource), but I'm pretty sure we're still exporting more lower/middle-class jobs than we're importing. Ultimately, tons of non-service jobs will get automated anyways, so in the long term I don't think it's enough to say, "Just keep the jobs here!" That just means robots do them instead of cheap foreign workers. I'm a big proponent of investing more in adult re-education to help retrain people for new jobs as their old ones disappear. But even then, who knows if that's enough. It's a very complicated issue.