6 ms·
Pilots get up to use the lavatory, and are brought food. The code is an authenticated knock, and replaces the speakeasy-style "secret" knocking patterns that we
by closeparen 10y ago
Pilots get up to use the lavatory, and are brought food. The code is an authenticated knock, and replaces the speakeasy-style "secret" knocking patterns that were used before 9/11. Someone in the cockpit views the person who entered the code on a CCTV monitor and decides whether or not to buzz the door open. This is a control against someone who knows the code but is under duress. If the pilot inside doesn't explicitly deny the request to enter after some number of seconds, it's automatically granted (useful if the pilot is unconscious, say).
This all came up in the Germanwings pilot suicide. The suicidal pilot waited till the other pilot was outside the cockpit, then repeatedly denied acccess to the cockpit when he entered the code to get back in.
- GuB-42 10y agoI don't remember even seeing doors that were more than a privacy shield before 9/11. Sometimes it was just a curtain, and sometimes, it stayed opened during flight.
- Ntrails 10y agoIt makes me really sad that young children will never get the experience I had when flying, of going into the cockpit during a flight and looking at all the buttons and talking to the pilot. :(
- DamonHD 10y agoWell, not just as a kid for me. One pilot showed me just how much work the autopilot did by turning it off and turning our glassy-smooth commuter jet ride into a bumpy and alarming one. I hope the other 150 people in the cabin didn't get as worried as I did!
- glbrew 10y agoA child in the cockpit once accidentally disengaged some controls which eventually resulted in a crash that killed all 75 people on board. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot_Flight_593 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot_Flight_593
- mseebach 10y ago> One of the children had unknowingly disengaged the A310 autopilot's control over the aircraft's ailerons while seated at the controls. [...] With the autopilot active, Kudrinsky, against regulations, let the children sit at the controls I remember visiting the cockpit pre-9/11 and it did not include being invited to sit at the controls. Or, in other words, children visiting the cockpit was probably more the proximate cause than the root cause.
- GuB-42 10y agoThere is a difference between letting a child in the cockpit and having him sit in the pilot seat, as it was the case in the Aeroflot Flight 593 crash.
- AlphaWeaver 10y agoThe child sitting at the controls was the pilots child, that's the reason for the increased (but certainly unacceptable) access.
- ApolloFortyNine 10y agoThis is actually an odd case, as it was mainly the result of improper training and different configurations between two planes. In a Boeing plane, autopilot will never disengage without specifically being disengaged. In an Airbus plane, giving a 'harsh' enough input will disengage the autopilot. The pilot here mainly had experience on Boeing, so was not aware of this minor but very important difference. The Air France flight that crashed into the Ocean by Brazil was also partly the fault of different designs by the two major aircraft manufacturers. In Boeing planes, the input is synced between the pilot and copilot (if one pulls up, the other physically moves as well). In Airbus planes however, the input is merged together instead. If one pilot pulls up, and one is pushing down, nothing really happens. This ended up partly leading to the crash, as one pilot heard the stall warning and pulled up (causing more speed loss), while the other pilot correctly pushed down. If the inputs were synced, the other pilot likely would have noticed his copilot was making the wrong input.
- StavrosK 10y ago
- ehnto 10y agoOne of my fondest childhood memories was nearly crashing a three story ferry into the side of a canal after the captain let us hold the wheel. He very quickly took over and I doubt we were ever in danger, but I can definitely understand a reluctance to let kids even stand close to the cockpit controls. It's all wholesome until an engine shuts down!
- Bluestrike2 10y agoIt's nowhere near the same, but I remember being a little kid back in '96 (maybe '97, I'd have to call up my mom and ask) and getting to ride up front with the monorail pilot at Disney World. Anyhow, kids aren't the only danger in the cockpit. Around the same time, I rode in a Bell helicopter with family members during a local festival. An older cousin in his 60s at the time sat up front with the pilot. Trying to "get comfortable," he'd slammed his foot against one of the pedals and managed to bump the cyclic in his surprise. Needless to say, the pilot wasn't very happy once we landed.
- fivestar 10y agoShouldn't the pilot have instructed him to keep his feet off the pedals before takeoff? Seriously, a minute going over safety procedures with a neophyte and nothing would have happened.
- Bluestrike2 10y agoI'd assume he did, because it's kind of an obvious thing in hindsight. But I was pretty young at the time, so I don't really have a clue beyond what stuck in my memories.
- Symbiote 10y agoA couple of times in the 1990s I 'drove' a steam locomotive [1], with coaches, on the tourist railway not too far from where we lived. I was about 9 or 10, and was only just strong enough to push or pull the regulator (controls how much steam is allowed into the piston). The driver explained the important gauges, like the boiler water level and pressure, and showed the tiny view ahead which he had to use to look at signals. And the shelf above the firebox, which could be used to keep tea warm. [1] One of these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SR_V_Schools_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SR_V_Schools_class
- akhilcacharya 10y agoEh, it's not that bad, just do it before or after the flight. Source: Did it as a child twice
- tyingq 10y ago> The code is an authenticated knock Many aircraft have actual keypads on the cockpit door. That's what was leaked in this case. Edit: Yes...I was thrown off by the context of knock. Thanks for the clarification.
- robjan 10y agoEntering the key on the keypad is the "knock". The pilot is only alerted that there is someone outside if you enter the correct code. They then verify using either CCTV or the peephole. If you just physically knock on the door then the pilot will be suspicious.
- joncrocks 10y agoSo the confusion here is about the term 'knock.' In this context I believe it's being used to indicate the nature of the mechanism of entry. It's a 'knock' because the entry of the code is used to indicate to the people in the cockpit that someone outside wishes to enter. It is the people inside who can then decide if the person is allowed entry or not, even if the code is entered correctly. So in that way it's similar to knocking on a door, just one that is authenticated with a code.
- SimbaOnSteroids 10y agoWait how would this stop a pilot doing what he did in the case of the Germanwings pilot suicide? Are you saying it came up during the investigation/coverage or were you saying that it as fixed as a result of this.
- piquadrat 10y agoThe "fix" for the issues that the Germanwings tragedy laid bare was a "2-person policy": if one of the pilots has to leave the cockpit, another member of the crew will take their place. But this introduced new problems, e.g. the time that the cockpit door needed to be open increased considerably, creating new opportunities for forcibly entering the cockpit. Many airlines are in the process of rolling back this policy. http://onemileatatime.boardingarea.com/2017/04/30/two-person-cockpit-rule-abolished/ http://onemileatatime.boardingarea.com/2017/04/30/two-person...
- FabHK 10y agoBy way of background, US airlines apparently always had the 2-person policy (after 9/11). But the reason was, from what I understand, that one person had to get up to the door to look through a peephole to authenticate the pilot requesting access back in. European airlines, by contrast, had a monitor in view of the pilots, so they could authenticate visually from their seat. In the wake of the GermanWings tragedy, they were chastised for not having the 2-person policy, introduced it (partially under the pressure of media and the public, in my opinion, and because "you've gotta do someting!!!1!!"), and now, as this has faded from public attention, they revert to their original (entirely sensible) policy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coredog64 10y agoIn US carriers, if a pilot leaves the flight deck, someone else in the crew needs to enter the cockpit.
- 10y ago
- fivestar 10y agoIt's troubling that airlines require reliability redundancies in order to maintain safety. The reinforced cockpit doors were good solution, and then...Germanwings happened. Wow. I just don't know if I even want to fly commercial anymore.
- anarazel 10y agoHow are you going to travel otherwise? It's not like private or commercial non-line aviation is any safer, nor are other forms of transport. Realistically the risks here are so low, that you're really unlikely to be affected. There's a lot of risks you're frequently exposed to, that are higher.
- dsp1234 10y agoHow are you going to travel otherwise? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QTq-HEEnn4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QTq-HEEnn4 "The Obvious Solution To the Airline Problem (United Airlines)"
- throwaway2048 10y agoLets talk about your drive to the airport...
- komali2 10y agoThat seems like an excessive response to arguably the least dangerous mode of transportation humans have come up with. Safer than driving, bicycling, walking on the street. I wouldn't be surprised if it as safer than pushing your computer chair from one side of the office to the other.