5 ms·
I'm very curious about this: is there a reason the reductionists seem to win in communities like this? Wikipedia has a similar culture. Are there systemic force
by sanderjd 10y ago
I'm very curious about this: is there a reason the reductionists seem to win in communities like this? Wikipedia has a similar culture. Are there systemic forces that point this direction, or is it just an accident of the history of the specific people involved?
- cft 10y agoThere may be so much spam that they practice a shotgun banning approach without comprehension or real content evaluation. Somehow the best "spam banners" get elevated perhaps?
- chadcmulligan 10y agoin all these things the pedants win, because every one else says whatever...and goes outside in the sun
- reitanqild 10y agoOne thing HN does well is having reasonable mods.
- mrout 10y agoThere should be a niwdoG's law: the longer an argument goes on, on the internet, the greater the likelihood that someone will accuse someone else of being a nerd that spends all their time indoors, while arguing on the internet themselves.
- umanwizard 10y agoIt's worth noting that SE and Wikipedia are two of the most valuable reference resources human civilization has produced, ever in history. Maybe the reductionism contributes to their high level of signal.
- reitanqild 10y agoMy problem is that it feels like they could have been much more useful. Annoyingly often it is also the most useful questions that are closed while things I consider trivia style/karma-farming operations like: "what is the reason for x" seems to be totally OK. I too find those trivia questions and their answers interesting but IMO they are a distraction.
- sitkack 10y ago> SE and Wikipedia are two of the most valuable reference resources human civilization has produced Again, this a pull quote that couldn't even be asked to be written. Pure gold! Wikipedia is entertaining, valuable ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CRC_Handbook_of_Chemistry_and_Physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CRC_Handbook_of_Chemistry_and_...
- adamsea 10y agoMore valuable than Charms of Defence and Deterrence by Catullus Spangle?
- mfukar 10y agoAs a member of both, no, they're really not. The information on SE is very useful but highly transient (and redundant, but at least we constantly try to rectify that). It'd be extremely more valuable if it could be condensed into a guide or textbook or what have you to teach idioms to beginners. As for Wikipedia, I'm almost convinced most information on it is erroneous, unverifiable, or useless in the forms it is presented. I've stopped making contributions and try not to ever reference it at all.
- setr 10y agoprobably because both have the goals of being encyclopedic sources of knowledge, and successfully complete this goal following reductionist policies, and its a hell of a lot easier to follow a strict philosophy than a lenient one (because the latter invites heavy legal discussion by armchair lawyers, while the former minimizes it). In short, likely because its efficient and apparently sufficient
- sanderjd 10y agoI don't really agree with this, but I upvoted it because it's the best charitable explanation I've seen, even if I'm frustrated by what I perceive to be a missed opportunity.
- setr 10y agoWhich part do you disagree with? That its easier to enforce, or that its sufficiently effective? The former is intuitively true; finding good rules to enforce strictly is difficult, but enforcing is simple (is the act explicitly allowed/banned or not?). Find broad rules is trivial, but then you spend all the enforcement time arguing edge cases (see: US gov) The latter is defended by the assumption that wikipedia/overflow do indeed follow such a policy, and its difficult to argue that they are not successful. There might be something better out there, but at least currently the market seems to have converged on this policy; ala "democracy is the worst form of government, except for the all other forms we've tried.
- sanderjd 10y agoI disagree with the part about it achieving the goal of being an encyclopedic source of knowledge. Except it largely comes down to how you define "encyclopedic". I would like it to mean "broad and inclusive", but it often means "highly curated", which tends to translates to "conservative". I don't think the convergence of the market on this sort of policy provides any indication one way or the other, because of network effects. Both of those sites won their space before the culture we're discussing here became entrenched, and because of network effects, it is not realistic to unseat them.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"Are there systemic forces that point this direction," When you can "contribute" to the community simply by clicking a delete button, rather than actually adding new and useful information, you're bound to get this sort of situation. StackOverflow mods are appointed to police content. The more content they remove, the more it looks like they're doing their jobs. It's the same with Wikipedia. Deleting someone else's hard work counts as a "contribution". It shows up in your profile just like writing a new multi-page article would. When the same credit is awarded for for destroying as for creating, the destroyers are always going to win.
- eastWestMath 10y agoI recognized a few of the names who deleted the post to be fine mathematicians who have contributed quite a bit to mathoverflow, so I don't think that applies. Mathoverflow is a Q&A site for professional mathematicians, you may have it confused with math.se.
- icantdrive55 10y agoNow I get it. StackOverflow just need to lighten up. There's been times where it looks like the Moderator isn't even reading the responses, or shut it down because he/she personally didn't find it interesting? I sometimes wonder if some the Moderators have a complete grasp of the English language? And the rewrites at Wikipedia, sometimes it seem like there's a financial motive to the rewrite. Years ago I bought a Domain name. It was the all to familiar neologism. Someone tried to buy it. I said no. The very next day the singular of a made up word was registered and his website was online. And Wikipedia was rewritten to "see the singular." that day too.
- mrout 10y agoMathOverflow is not StackOverflow. For that matter, StackExchange mods in general are not 'appointed'. A very few are employees of the StackExchange company, but the vast majority are just normal people that have contributed a lot. MathOverflow is intended for professional mathematicians. It isn't a general purpose discussion forum for mathematics. That such a thing doesn't really exist in a satisfactory form can't really be helped.
- 10y ago