5 ms·
I've wanted a locked down computer ever since every program that I installed in 1995 wanted to put a useless icon in my tray and take over every file type assoc
by gwbas1c 10y ago
I've wanted a locked down computer ever since every program that I installed in 1995 wanted to put a useless icon in my tray and take over every file type association. General purpose computers are great when I'm writing the program, but awful when running someone else's poorly written program that wants to take control over my computer.
I like to think of a general purpose computer like a giant truck: great if you like that kind of thing, but not for everyone.
- chtfn 10y agoWhat about a thriving Free Software ecosystem where the code can be audited and modified, and where the best apps (i.e. the ones that follow what users generally accept to be a standard of "respect" to your machine and its user, as well as doing their job) bubble up to the top? Using various Ubuntu-based distros and Free Software apps over the last 8 years, I have never felt like any program was overstepping the boundaries.
- Dylan16807 10y agoYou want a curated software store/repo. The computer itself doesn't need to be locked down to get the benefits you're talking about.
- natch 10y agoSo, which curated software store/repo do you prefer? http://download.com http://download.com? Now owned by CNET, and full of sketchiness. Or maybe you like http://freeware.com http://freeware.com? Oh, snap, it's down and parked by a squatter now. Or maybe an open source site? How about https://sourceforge.net https://sourceforge.net? How'd that work out? Could start by installing Java, let's see, oracle.com, click, ah, what's this? It's installing the Yahoo! browser toolbar by default??!!! Yeah. Curated. And even if you do manage to get a curated software store without lockdown that has a business model, it's not clear to me how you solve the problem of people sharing passwords with sketchy family members and friends who then install hidden software that secretly, behind their back, stalks them without so much as an informational prompt or opt-in. No, I think there are good reasons for having devices somewhat locked down, especially when it's being done for the sake of the end user.
- Freak_NL 10y agoUbuntu, Debian, Fedora, Arch; many Linux distributions provide excellent curated software repositories that just work for general purpose software. Have done so for well over a decade. All without locking the user out of his own computer. And of course Steam, GoG, and the HumbleStore provide curated repositories for proprietary games on many platforms.
- Macha 10y agoSteam is far less curated these days than 2-3 years ago
- 3131s 10y agoYou sound like you've been living under a rock for twenty years! Choose pretty much any Linux distribution and you'll get an excellent package manager that plugs into curated lists of software, AKA repositories.
- Dylan16807 10y ago> sharing passwords with sketchy family members and friends who then install hidden software I guess that's a fair use case for locking down the OS. But when it comes to various sites giving you bad software, how is locking the device and not giving the user control supposed to help? Any security measures like sandboxing could exist on a device without taking control from the user. And while installing zero programs is pretty secure, the user could make that choice without a lockdown. > So, which curated software store/repo do you prefer? Ninite is quite good. Other comments already pointed out various linux repos that do a very good job. Also look at the iOS store for something that has pretty aggressive quality control, even if the rules aren't perfect. (While iOS is locked down, the store would work the same if it wasn't.)
- michaelmrose 10y agoLinux official distro package repositories. Free open source software has had currated software repositories for many years and since hosting is quite cheap not much of a "business" model is required. Don't want to deal with the official repository you can easily host your own and provide a package that adds your own repo and serves the latest and greatest version of your software. Want a solution that targets multiple distros and bundles deps there is no snappy. Preventing untrusted users from installing software is also a solved problem. Require the root password or simply don't let them use sudo. If you give morons and bad people physical access your machine AND permission to install software it seems to me that you have put you in a bad place where no amount of lockdown can render you safe. Rather than make the futile effort to render your situation tenable when we know it wont how about we continue to improve actually feasible use cases?
- michaelmrose 10y agoYou basically want everyone's machine to be locked down to protect people like yourself with bad taste in applications.