10 ms·
Google and Paint.NET need to stop misleading users (2013)
- tehwebguy 10y agoWow, those ads convert well enough to be worth the clicks? Must be even shadier on the other side of the click.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThis is one of the examples of why I consider Google a malware distributor. This sort of stuff just continues undealt with. Companies should be held responsible for the ads they distribute, it's the only way to make them care enough to vet the ads they push.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jug 10y agoI find that article hilarious with this context: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/02/google-now-blocking-websites-that-show-fake-download-buttons/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/02/googl...
- oceanswave 10y agoYeah, everyone got so riled up they forgot to see that this article is from 2013
- anon1385 10y agoNothing has changed though. You still get these kinds of ads pretty much every time you visit the site. It doesn't matter that the article is from 2013 when the problem it describes still exists. That it has existed this long, despite people pointing it out, just makes it even worse.
- jug 10y agoThat's my point though. Four years ought to be time enough for them to sort this out after implementing that new view on ads. What's worse, that initiative was about blocking sites altogether if they had this crap on them, despite still allowing their own partners to use these practices.
- kuschku 10y agoYet, nothing of that sort has happened. Screenshot taken 2 minutes ago: http://i.imgur.com/FOcB46m.png http://i.imgur.com/FOcB46m.png
- pasbesoin 10y agoAnd yet, yesterday, people were downvoting me because of my skepticism regarding the latest "we're going to keep Android installations updated -- no, really!" initiative. Technically, this latest initiative actually makes sense. But, manufacturers still want to sell new devices, and carriers want to move them, with mark-up. And there's no dis-incentive to this "abandon and re-sell" incentive. And mostly, Google doesn't stick with things, any more. Color me skeptical. Time to go and "Download" me a new phone... ---- P.S. I don't begrudge the Paint.NET developers recompense for their work. Although, as I recall, it originally came out of the University of Washington, presumably with some funding behind it (many years ago, and perhaps no more). I've used it, upon occasion, and it's a very good substitute for everyday "photo-shopping", as it were. But the ads, as described/demonstrated, sure seem to be at odds with the old "do no evil" or whatever it was. Loading grandma up ('Download! HERE!') with 5 "toolbars" and nag-ware? Bad Google.
- ascom 10y agoHere is a small sample of ads I have blocked from my sites: https://imgur.com/a/5SD9b https://imgur.com/a/5SD9b
- wernsey 10y agoThanks for the link. I wondered what happened to that policy
- Kenji 10y agoThis is trivially solved with an ad blocker. Frankly, I do not see the problem. Why should you rely on Google/Paint.NET/state legislation when the solution is literally a few button clicks away on both chrome and firefox? All browsers should come with ad blockers by default. Hell, the OS should come with blocking hosts.txt. That would make the digital world a whole lot safer. And before you say the internet will die, I'd be more than willing to pay a subscription fee for stuff like youtube and twitch.tv. Or there could still be ads like here on hackernews, relevant and embedded in the site.
- GordonS 10y agoAs much as I agree that the problem is solved for those who know about ad blockers, many people (e.g. non-hacker news types!) do not know about them. In any case, whether users can solve this by installing an ad blocker is beside the point - this is really shitty behaviour that I wouldn't have expected Google to allow, or for Paint.NET to allow on their site.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI think a lot of the reason Google has been allowed to get away with this is because of ad blockers... the people in a position to most loudly condemn the practice and push for change... aren't using the same Internet as the rest of us, they don't see the problem.
- Dolores12 10y agoI don't see any problem too. Now they download something that is not paint.net , next they download and run malware. In this case the cost of mistake is cheap. Let them learn from their mistakes. What we need is to educate people how to download and run what they really need, not blindly clicking the biggest banner on the page.
- SmellyGeekBoy 10y ago> In this case the cost of mistake is cheap. Let them learn from their mistakes. All well and good until they unwittingly become part of a botnet and start attacking the rest of us...
- zeta0134 10y agoI'm curious why these ads are even allowed to get through the network in the first place. Is there just NO content reviewing taking place? That's seems negligent on Google's part. There is no reason for an ad like that to exist on any webpage, period. It should have been blocked at the source. Where is the 3-strikes policy in the ad space? Google is so eager to punish its Youtube streamers for running questionably offensive content, and yet it continues to let advertising scum like this run rampant across its ecosystem.
- ben_jones 10y agoI wonder if they ran an A/B test on customer spending depending on the time it takes from "uploading" an ad to the network and the ad showing positive metrics. My guess is the result of such a finding would impact the duration and thoroughness of the review process. And my guess is youtubers make up such a small slice of revenue that the threat of lawsuits outweighs the convenience of the customer.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI highly doubt it has to do with the time it takes to have someone review the submission. Google does not like hiring people to do things it thinks algorithms can do adequately, because people cost a lot more than servers.
- jfim 10y agoAt least on adwords, you get a "quality score" for ads, which is essentially a clickthrough rate, which lowers your cost per impression. In this case, I assume those ads get a high clickthrough rate due to being terribly misleading, which leads the algorithm to believe these ads are the most appropriate for this ad slot (they are if the only metric you care about is money going into Google's pockets).
- threeseed 10y agoWhat is amazing is that this is the easiest type of content check to automate.
- coding123 10y agoI think this was the exact same downfall as SourceForge. It's great we don't live in the SoftPedia/SourceForge days anymore (or maybe it's just me, I'm on a Mac now).
- giancarlostoro 10y agoMy question is why is it so easy to have advertisements that directly link to downloadable software? If I'm clicking on an advertisement I want to know more about a product, not be forced to run a binary of which I have no certainty of it's true purpose. Or am I thinking wrong? If you disallow download based advertising including linking to pages that only offer you a download, this could be a little more useful against malvertisements. More reason to run an adblocker.
- GeneralMayhem 10y agoThe problem is enforcement. Telling malware distributors "that's not allowed" obviously isn't going to do anything, and it's easy to have the ad go to one place when Google is investigating and another when a user clicks the ad in the wild.
- ethbro 10y agoI can't believe Google couldn't categoricatically add context to these type of ads if they really cared. Google knows the ad link. Google can crawl the target page / file. If it's an installer, Google can run it in a VM and note what ends up being installed. If you can't pull a clear "this is crapware" signal out of that, then their ML is a lot less advanced than it seems. And if they can, then just automatically put a stronger visual border around it with something like "This is an advertisement" in bold. Then let advertisers sort it out. Google penalizes SEO they disagree with all the time, and people stop doing it because they don't want to take the hit. And I'm pretty sure it is (image recognition) and they don't... so... advertising buys trump "don't be evil."
- sundvor 10y agoThey would care if thousands of organisations pulled their advertising over it.
- giancarlostoro 10y agoI really wish this were the case. It would be nice if more organizations were more action oriented against malvertisement. I seem to recall there was one blog / news site that got rid of Google Adsense from their website here on HN not over a year ago, and I'm sure others have. It's really sad that Google doesn't put any effort (that we know, though we would see less of this) against these advertisements.
- tysonstewart 10y agoI don't think 2013 article is still relevant today.
- LongTermBond007 10y agoUnfortunately, I got similar advertisements on the Paint.NET site today. https://www.getpaint.net/download.html https://www.getpaint.net/download.html
- anon1385 10y agoIt's still relevant. I took this screenshot a few seconds ago: https://i.imgur.com/6LoQ3TW.png https://i.imgur.com/6LoQ3TW.png
- tysonstewart 10y agoToday I visited the site again and now it started to show me the same download ads. So it is still relevant. But how these ads are able to pass through AdWords review.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- angry-hacker 10y agoAnd nothing has changed in 2017 from both sides, the ads are still there and show spyware download links. I guess Google is too busy dealing with "fake news" and paint.net can't give up that sweet ad money.
- EddieSpeaks 10y agoThis is exactly why People need to use the store only as much as possible, and Paint.NET needs to get on the Windows Store as well
- mkup 10y agoInteresting, I've visited this website multiple times before and didn't know about this problem until today. Ad blocker browser add-on seems to be doing its job really well.
- wcummings 10y agoSounds like a personal problem to me... This is a little shady, but all the units are clearly labeled as ads. I have a hard time getting as worked up over this as the author does. Paint.NET is a free product, what do you expect?
- threeseed 10y agoYou could've at least visited the website. They are NOT clearly labeled as ads. https://www.getpaint.net/index.html https://www.getpaint.net/index.html
- webmaven 10y agowcummings might mean the tiny grey-and-blue icons in the top right of each unit. If so, I disagree. Those icons are not visible enough, and are hard for many users to click without accidentally clicking the ad instead.
- wcummings 10y agoThere's screenshots in the article I don't see why that would be necessary. Anyway, all Google ads have a tracking opt out link. When I go to the site the ads aren't even "download" style ones like those in the screenshots, just normal banner ads.
- ajmarsh 10y agohttps://ninite.com/ https://ninite.com/ Accept no substitutes when installing on Windows.
- dizzy3gg 10y agothanks.
- FlorianRappl 10y agoLooks nice, but I would always prefer Chocolatey (https://chocolatey.org/packages https://chocolatey.org/packages). Reason: More (and easier to customize) packages / applications to get.
- nandhp 10y agoNinite has the advantage of being self-contained in a single executable, though. Chocolatey looks like something you have to install, which makes it poorly suited for quickly installing something on a machine that's not yours.
- hackbinary 10y agoChocolatey is like apt for Windows. It is worth the install.
- monochromatic 10y agoThat's really interesting. I'll try it out next time I have to wipe my Windows machine.
- yuriks 10y agoYou can report these bad ads by clicking the small X in the corner. Please do that if you ever see any of those, and they'll be replaced by other kinds of ads (and hopefully over time they'll get enough reports to be removed.)
- mynewtb 10y agoThe better solution is installing a capable adblocker.
- mherdeg 10y agoHmm I tried this and I see 4 reasons: (1) Seen this ad multiple times (2) Already bought this (3) Not interested in this ad (4) Ad covered content There doesn't seem to be an option for "this ad is a huge DOWNLOAD link directly above the actual download link on a page that offers to help me download software." I did try filling out the form at https://support.google.com/adsense/troubleshooter/1190500 https://support.google.com/adsense/troubleshooter/1190500 with this info, though. There was no way to indicate with a screenshot in that form exactly what the bad ad was.
- yuriks 10y agoInteresting, for me the options were 1) Not interested in this ad 2) Seen this ad multiple times 3) Ad is inappropriate 4) Ad covered content I chose 3 for all of them, but I'd argue that 4 would also fit somewhat.
- scarface74 10y agoAnd as unpopular as the idea is with geeks, I think this illustrates the need for a "walled gardened" for the majority of users where each app is sandboxxed. Something like this couldn't happen on iOS, ChromeOS or Windows 10s. Most non developers would be served perfectly fine with a locked down OS.
- FatalBaboon 10y agoSo you want to limit creativity and empower big companies even more by pushing forward walled gardens, because there are too many ads on the download page of one paint app out of a myriad? It's like adding regexp to have one more problem.
- scarface74 10y agoHow does it "empower" big companies? With app stores, distribution is easier and people are more likely to download an app knowing that it won't install malware, they have fine grained control over what the app can do (at least on iOS) and they can pay just buy putting their thumb on the fingerprint sensor. Compare that to distributing apps on the internet where you have to trust each software provider with your credit card credentials and even if you do trust the vendor, there is a certain amount of friction just entering your payment information all over the internet. I much prefer handling all of my subscriptions through iTunes even for services that use other places like Hulu, Netflix, and PluralSight. Did you ever try to distribute a mobile J2ME app on mobile before the Apple and Google app stores? I know indie PC developers love Steam. I'm very hestitant to download random software on Windows because of crapware/malware. I'll download iOS apps with abandon from the shadiest developers because I know they can't really do that much harm.
- FatalBaboon 10y agoWhat I'm reading is that you like a process to be enforced to guarantee some level of quality, which is indeed something I like as well. However I believe good package formats and OS-level checks can get us there without compromising my private informations to a third party in the process.
- deprave 10y agoPeople must remember that Google is first and foremost an advertising company. 90% of its revenue comes directly from advertising. Anyone who thinks they will prioritize anything over ad revenue is either very naive or very stupid. Google's CEO declared it's "AI first" and they developed TensorFlow. If they wanted to, they could have easily prevented those ads from entering their network.
- theDoug 10y agoPlease explain how, since it’s easy.
- webmaven 10y agoI'll take a crack at an explanation: Google has machine learning technology that automatically reads street address numbers on houses, regardless of angle, color, size, focus, or typeface. Using the same type of algorithm to answer "does this ad have anything that looks like a button in it?" is relatively simple by at least two orders of magnitude. So rather than it being "easy" in some absolute sense, what's meant here is that it is easy compared to similar tasks that we already know Google does routinely and has largely automated.
- yuriks 10y agoLots of things have button and aren't maliciously masquerading as download links. Furthermore, if they start doing that then ad producers will start changing their ad images to evade the algorithm. It's much harder to use ML for a problem when you have a malicious opponent actively working against it.
- rvnx 10y agoThere is a human behind every single creative shown on Google AdSense. There are even rules around these creatives (need to have distinct border and need to say the name of the advertised product).
- 10y ago
- jameshart 10y agoThe terrible experience of pulling down an installer for Paint.net was one of the final straws that pushed me to move over to using chocolatey for windows workstation setup. > choco install paint.net Unfortunately, while that allows me to never see fake download-button ads when pulling down software for my machine, one place it's still a nightmare in is the world of getting minecraft mods installed on a kid's computer. Picking out the real download link from among all the fake ads is sometimes a real challenge.
- Nexxxeh 10y agoHave you got uBlock Origin installed?
- julianz 10y agoYep, the only time I've ever managed to install malware was trying to put a very ordinary Minecraft mod on for my kid. How to feel stupid in one easy move.
- aerique 10y agoDon't feel too hard on yourself. While I do not think I've installed malware because of that, I've mostly been lucky I guess (or just haven't noticed the malware yet). The stars are aligned against you on this: 1) impatient kid who wants his mod working, 2) unfamiliar territory for you, 3) the timing for these things is ALWAYS wrong, you've probably got pressing household matters to attend to or another kid wanting your attention, 4) a couple of more points I forgot.
- ThomW 10y agoI was going to say - obviously the author of this post hasn't looked for Minecraft mods, because there the problem is far worse.
- phit_ 10y agois it? 99% of the mods nowadays can be downloaded from Curse [1] without any ads and for easy mod management you can even install their launcher those that can't, can be usually found on this site with their official download site linked [2] [1] https://minecraft.curseforge.com/ https://minecraft.curseforge.com/ [2] https://bot.notenoughmods.com/ https://bot.notenoughmods.com/
- johnnyb9 10y agoEveryone seems to give Google the benefit of the doubt here. Is it possible they aren't doing anything because they are making lots of money from this ethical grey area? The incentives seem perfectly aligned... the advertiser doubtlessly doesn't care about whether it's a scrupulous ad or not. Paint.NET authors make money, and Google makes money.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThis is entirely it. It's not nearly offensive enough to get the "you're putting racist ads on my page" level of public uproar for them to do anything about it. And distributing malware is incredibly profitable. They simply have no incentive to stop. And trying to moderate it would cost them money, both in terms of effort to review ad submissions, and lost revenue from the ads themselves. Heck, Google likes to brag about how Chromebooks don't get viruses. Distributing viruses for Windows PCs only helps their bottom line. (You'll also notice that Windows support-related search queries have malicious ads, and no ads display at all for Chromebook or Google support-related search queries.)
- Camillo 10y agoIf the toolbars, as is typical, end up hijacking the search engine, or injecting their own ads on pages, then Google loses money.
- pawadu 10y agoAnd yet this happens. All the time. In adsense, on youtube, on Google+, on the Play store and basically in every other customer-facing Google business. I can see two reasons for that: 1. A not-my-problem mentality at Google 2. Google is trying to replace human intelligence with AI pseudo-intelligence which has turned out to be really really easy to fool I believe it's actually a combination of the two and it scares the crap out of me thinking these guys want to create self driving (and flying!) cars.
- nolok 10y agoI think you should look at point 3., slightly different from 1: everytime Google acts on something like this, they show that they can act. If the damage it causes them, both in profit and image, is not very large then it might very well not be worth it to risk setting a precedent than Google is responsible for policing their ads. It is exactly the scenario they were caught in with YouTube, and becoming the police there didn't help them at all compared to the previous status quo. Of course that's the good scenario, the bad one would be that Google, being of a size and importance that can be called a monopoly in the Internet ad space, would be violating these "fraudsters" rights since technically what they do may not be breaking any laws, which would lead to this becoming a precedent and all the others who currently try to keep themselves mostly clean in their ads would be vindicated to go evil too. I'm not saying these are the real reasons, but again if the damage and risk they represent is insignificantly small relative to the whole, why would Google risk opening that can of worms.
- Itaxpica 10y agoThis article is from 2013. Google has banned these types of ads from its network (and started blocking sites that serve them) since then, as was discussed on HN at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11032270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11032270
- johnnyb9 10y agoAnd four years later they are still there...
- kencausey 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14336972 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14336972 And I just checked myself and confirmed the continuing existence of very similar ads.
- Aaron1011 10y agoExactly the same type of ads are still present at https://www.getpaint.net/ https://www.getpaint.net/
- mrsaint 10y agoTo be fair, this is not just Paint.NET. I am a Adsense publishers and I had the chance to talk to "optimizers" from the Adsense team from time to time, and I told them how much I loath those "Download" ads... unfortunately, up to today, things haven't improved, and there is little an Adsense publisher could do, because you can ban those ads in your Adsense panel, but usually they just show up a few days later under a different account.
- brodie78382 10y agoJust curious, why single out Paint.NET exclusively? These types of ads have a long history all over the Internet, even on more popular sites than this - isn't this more of a Google issue than an individual website operator?
- emmelaich 10y agoThe Bing search engine is about as bad. A close friend used IE to get Google Chrome. They clicked the first result and luckily I was able to stop them before starting the install on some crapware. So I asked them to be careful to ensure the download site is correct and left them to it. I came back to find they had downloaded some other crapware. I checked the search results. The ENTIRE first one and a half page of results were advertisements for versions of crapware which may or may not have been Chromium or Chrome lookalikes with lots of malware.
- dgudkov 10y agoI hope the author of Paint.NET will see this submission and removes the ads. I'm a big fan Paint.NET and made a donation. But this practice is just shady and makes no honor to the author of otherwise great application.
- throwaway16801 10y agoHow about users, and especially corporate users, actually start paying for Paint.NET and other pieces of software they rely on so the developers don't have to resort to Ad Sense or e-begging to fund further development?
- wernsey 10y agoIf it is about the money for Google, can't they at least put a warning over the ad that says "Are you really sure you want to download [Some Malware]?" if you hover/click on the ad. Nevermind, the right thing to do would be to ban these kinds of ads outright, but we can't count on them to do that now, can we?
- CM30 10y agoSo why do they allow banner ads to look like download buttons anyway? I mean, there's no real reason you should be able to pass an ad off as a download link, so wouldn't the obvious answer just be to ban ads that look like that? Heck, you could probably even automate that process with Google's technology. If OCR technology can identify captchas, it can probably identify button shapes in images or text that looks like program information.
- Grue3 10y agoI always recommend against Paint.NET precisely because of its adware-ridden website. There are enough free, open-source alternatives that you don't really need it. Hell, even IrfanView can do little image edits if you need something really damn quick.