11 ms·
The Brain Can Only Take So Much Focus
- AznHisoka 10y agoI can relate as I always feel very fatigued mentally after a long drive, especially if it involves a route I am not familiar with, and there is lots of stop and go traffic.
- crawfordcomeaux 10y agoThis is when I practice PCD (I think?). I'll choose a goal (like letting go of something, feeling joy, exploring my emotions, creativity, etc), a song or album I think I can make work for said goal, and then either a specific context (eg. a conflict or project) or to with the story in the song/album. I play it on my phone through an FM transmitter with voice nav on in Google maps. While listening, I'm typically constructing a music video in my head or forcing/mapping thoughts/memories/feelings onto the lyrics. This also develops the skill of forcing analogies, which helps with keeping an open mind.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zitterbewegung 10y agoI find that I will lose and gain focus throughout the day when I have a task when I don't know what to do next. When I do have energy I will try to push past it. After awhile though I start reading HN. The amount time I will read HN depends on an ever decreasing amount of energy. After about 3-5 times of losing focus and not making progress I will spend increasingly longer on the site. From the website I am practicing mindfulness throughout the day since I have my Apple watch (through the breath app). I think mindfulness would be good for hackers. On physical tasks you could lift weights but on mental tasks your goal is probably reducing anxiety or frustration. Or preserving flow (Podmoro supposedly does this but I could never get into it). On the other hand if I get a good flow going and I am uninterrupted I will probably forget to check HN and I will continually work until I do get stuck even if that happens.
- grrowl 10y agoI found pomodoros help control the impulse to visit HN (or twitter, news, etc). If it's non-negotiable that you must chip away at your task, even if it's a case of "don't know what's next" -> do supporting tasks until it becomes clear. By the 25-minute mark I'm much more likely to continue into the next pomodoro, and if not there's no problem taking time out without guilt.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- terminalcommand 10y agoThe problem I found with sticking to using Pomodoros or longer periods (90 minutes) per work is that they work for a short while. After a couple of days or max. a few weeks I plunge back into my old self. Using self-discipline techniques help in the short term, but in the long term I find them harmful. Because after a while of dedication, I feel exhausted and kinda burnt-out. It's true that working for the time you allocated removes guilt. It's true that setting aside a fixed amount of time for working makes you more efficient. If I could only find a way to sustain this kind of movement. One thing I've seen working is listening to easy-listening music. After quieting down my brain, I have much more self-discipline and focus.
- Bakary 10y agoTo change your habits over the long term it helps to take it really slowly but consistently.
- thanatropism 10y agoI find the Pomodoro technique much too confusing and detailed. Whenever I'm in an impossible procrastinating mood (and I feel that this is what is: a mood) I put e.ggtimer.com to the minimum amount of time I really think I can put together. Usually by the timer is gone I have to reset it and keep working. If I'm really getting into a good place, I increase the time, if it seems I'm going to be done soon, I decrease it. Reasonable expectations. > Using self-discipline techniques help in the short term, but in the long term I find them harmful. This seems a case of Stockdale's Paradox: http://ndoherty.com/stockdale-paradox/ http://ndoherty.com/stockdale-paradox/
- Imagenuity 10y agoHaving discovered some of these techniques through trial and error, it is helpful to see some research backing up and expanding on keeping the creativity flowing. Positive constructive daydreaming (PCD), exercise, taking a shower, napping, and more are helpful for getting access to more inspiration than just your conscious thinking can give you. Others have studied this, including John Cleese, as detailed in his lecture on Creativity: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EMj_CFPHYc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EMj_CFPHYc
- alexpetralia 10y agoThe science behind "ego depletion" is at very least controversial, namely because the effect has not been reproduced in subsequent experiments. * Wikipedia provides a good summary of replication attempts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion#Reproducibility_controversy_and_conflicting_meta_analyses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion#Reproducibility_... * Slate covered the topic here: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story/2016/03/ego_depletion_an_influential_theory_in_psychology_may_have_just_been_debunked.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story... * And here is a recent, large replication study: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691616652873 http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/174569161665287... As a result, I would hesitate before using "ego depletion" as an excuse for rationalizing a lack of self-control (eg. giving into "cheat foods" or being irritable/impulsive). Whether or not "ego depletion" is real, science has not yet adequately validated the theory. Moreover, there is a risk to accepting the theory as true: because one believes in "ego depletion," one can rationalize a lower degree of self-control, which may have been higher otherwise. This creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. I think it is fair to assume that, given the current research, "ego depletion" is no more than a reasonable hypothesis. It is possible that willpower may not fit the "finite resource" model at all.
- opportune 10y agoI completely agree and I've taken issue with this as well. This is something that is hugely susceptible to confirmation bias for the exact reason you stated: mere exposure to the concept will allow people to rationalize performing the behavior even if they wouldn't before. Not only that, but think of all the cultures/jobs where it is normal for people to work much more than the typical 40 hour work week we are accustomed to. Do 18 year old Vietnamese fishermen working 80 hour weeks suffer from "ego depletion" the same way 18 year old college students do in the US? Probably not. It may be an element of our culture / upbringing that we put more emphasis on leisure, and not some psychological or neurological "need".
- gregatragenet3 10y agoI think you bring up a good example. I think a typical contract web developer in a western country is much more at risk for ego depletion then the Vietnamese fisherman example. One of the factors of ego depletion is decision fatigue. If the fisherman does not fish that day, he and his offspring go hungry, and if that decision is repeated they will starve to death. So not really a decision, not one that a rational being would make. If the web developer goofs off on reddit today, instead of looking for new contracting work he won't go hungy.. He can probably coast for a little bit.. Actually, he could potentially just go on welfare, but then he'd have to live in a worse part of town. If he moved in with friends he could work less hours a week and have more leisure time, etc. Lots of choices to make. Novelty is another ego depleter. The fisherman has done it day-in-day-out for years, probably his father and grandfather as well. It's muscle memory and he's on autopilot. The web developer is constantly novelty fatigued, learning new clients' environments and the latest web framework fads which change month by month. His day has no routine. As a contractor it is much more difficult for me, and probably I'm the most lazy and restless after coming off a project, with a decent balance in the bank. I am much more focused and mentally sure when the bank balance is low and I'm chasing down business because if I don't find something it'll get uncomfortable quick. Contrast that to when I was in the gulf of Papagayo, miles from shore, on a small sailboat in the middle of a storm. There was no ego depletion. I never thought 'well, should I continue battling the sea to keep this boat afloat and going to my destination?' There's no ego there, only survival. Does the Vietnamese fisherman have the harder life by most metrics? Absolutely. However there are downsides to the modern western world.
- zo7 10y agoIt's interesting to see research suggesting that this might be helpful, since I feel like I've stumbled on something similar. Lately I've had several instances where I've been completely stuck on a problem, so I'd stop everything and take a long hike on a trail or through some mountains. After taking a day of just literal wandering, I've found I'd be able to finally make progress on what I was working on once I pick it back up again, where I otherwise felt like I was hitting a wall. It's felt like my mind does some unconscious processing when I allow it to take a break, so it's encouraging to see some evidence to support that.
- RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u 10y agoI'm not a (neuro-, or any other) scientist, but I'm suspicious of the common narrative that sleeping on the problem => unconscious background processing => solution to the problem. IMO, when you're "stuck" you're basically in a local minima that's not good enough. With computers you just restart at a random point and continue, but people are really bad at being random. Moreover, there's the: don't think about an elephant right now => you just thought of an elephant, "problem". That is, the more you've been thinking about the problem a certain way, trying to force yourself to think differently only reinforces the original line of thought, leading back to the same local minima. Thus, IMO the more likely mechanism that walking away from a problem and coming back to it later leads to a better solution, is more that you get a better random restart, and you have time to forget the prior line of thought, so you're more likely to think differently / explore a different branch of the search tree.
- zo7 10y agoExcept that's the point of the article – PCD/napping/etc works because the default mode network of your brain is more active when you're at rest than when it's focusing on something, and that it seems to be doing some "housekeeping" in your brain so to speak. I don't think it's much like a minima, because I can go home, run some errands, cook dinner, surf the internet, read, etc, but when I'd come back the next morning I'd be just as stuck as the day before. For me it wasn't until I explicitly tried to do nothing (i.e. wander, as opposed to distracting yourself with other tasks) that I made progress. (of course this is just anecdotal experience – not trying to frame this as The Way but found it interesting that there's some research about it)
- marak830 10y agoAs someone who is on the last day of a 6 day 14 hours per day straight, oh I can attest to this. The quality of the meals I'm sending out (plating and decoration wise) is nowhere near as good as it is on Mondays. I need more chef's :-p
- theprop 10y agoI'd like the authors to try Vipassana's 10 day retreats -- it's free and for ten days you meditate, don't speak, and don't use any electronic devices. Not sure if there's any more focus than that! You'll survive...and afterwards probably thrive :-D.
- crawfordcomeaux 10y agoDo you suppose the results you predict are from learning how to "unfocus" and naturally interweaving the skill with focused time back in the daily grind?
- qarioz 10y agoVipassana meditation emphasis is not on focus. Samatha meditation purpose is solely focus.
- akvadrako 10y agoHuh, when I did it there was a strong focus on focus. First focus on the breath, later on a general part of the body and finally on a pinpoint.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- m3kw9 10y agoIn other words, rest.
- markpapadakis 10y ago"Focus is a matter of deciding what not to do" --John Carmack
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cammil 10y agoDon't believe a word of this. Test your own mind. Don't make conclusions. Only ask questions and observe. This stuff cannot be explained. And it cannot be logically thought about. It must be seen and experienced. Don't doubt what i have to say. Go check for yourself.
- cammil 10y agoI should have known better.
- Dylan16807 10y ago"cannot be explained" just means you're bad at explaining, sorry.
- cammil 10y agoDoes it though? Has language covered all aspects of the knowable universe?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aaimnr 10y agoThere's so many things wrong in this article... They should just leave the 'take a nap' advice. If the focusing drains energy from the mind, it's the wrong kind of focus. Real concentration (buddhists call it samadhi) doesn't come from forcing your other parts of mind to do what "you" (the small, narrative mind-process) want, but rather to unify the whole mind around single intention. This state is not only stable, it's more efficient, because there's just one thing to do rather than tens of conflicting intentions. It's more efficient and calm than Default Network Mode, which is basically a garbage can for the mind. You don't even have to get into buddhism, there's a lot that science already knows about eg. the flow state, which is a mini-samadhi. Also, Judson Brewer discovered that DNM is not fundamentally 'default', as it doesn't activate for long-term meditation practitioners. Such people (some of them really high functioning) report that great thoughts just come to them out of nowhere. Clinging to the thought forcefully only reinforces the illusion that 'we' are thinking it, which is not true and counterproductive, as it obstructs the dynamics of the mind. Just let the mind figure the problem out and let you know when it's done. DMN is an impostor that pretends that everything done by the various diverse mind processes is done by the narrative fiction centered around the feeling of 'I'. It's not, it's highly distributed, there's no driver and no center. The more we think otherwise, the more force we have to put to make the mind obedient.
- wruza 10y ago(Didn't read tfa) In my experience, flow state tends to be toxic and socially harmful with time. After weeks of practicing, once you're in, there is no easy way to exit it without sleeping (in the morning you're at risk falling in there again). I discussed this effect elsewhere and it confirmed. Sometimes I forcefully retain my mind in normal mode with "expensive" focus, because further plans require to be communicable and alive. It is not "for free" to me in neither way. Am I using it wrong? Is meditation and samadhi a better version of the flow in this regard?
- throw_away_elec 10y agoThere is a concept called "laya" or "mano laya". If you are stuck in this, it might lead to stuff like this. Samadhi is completely different - referring to a deep meditation state without particularly concentrating on anything. Flow results from deeply being engaged in something or concentration.
- fyolnish 10y agoIs "psychological halloweenism" a thing?
- appleflaxen 10y agoThis is basically just an advertisement for pseudoscientific nonsense by a medical doctor that should know better. How can the Harvard Business Review publish this kind of hocum without flagging it as an advert?
- vorotato 10y agoCan only take so much focus until what? What happens? Do I go insane? Die?