20 ms·
Why would you expect inflation? All sane UBI proposals don't create money, they just move money from rich people to poor people. If you're a Friedman discipl
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
Why would you expect inflation? All sane UBI proposals don't create money, they just move money from rich people to poor people. If you're a Friedman disciple, then "inflation is a monetary phenomenon" and we can stop there.
If we're moving money from rich people to poor people, perhaps we'll see the prices of stuff rich people buy go down and the prices of stuff poor people buy go up.
The vast majority of stuff poor people buy is demand limited, not supply limited, so if poor people start buying more PS4's, Sony will just make more.
I'll also assert that food is demand limited, we have lots more capacity to increase production than people think. It doesn't matter though; the problem with poor people in the United States is that they eat too much, not that they eat too little.
The only thing that might see price movement is housing. That's definitely supply limited in many places. But maybe UBI will encourage people to move from high cost areas where UBI isn't sufficient to live on to low cost areas where it is. And movement will only happen in the margins -- most of the poor in the States already have a place to live, so demand shouldn't increase that much.
- nateberkopec 10y agoMV = PQ. Money * Velocity = Price level * Quantity of goods and services. Friedman assumes the velocity of money is constant (good assumption), so really the only why you can cause inflation is to increase the supply of money, M. UBI increases the velocity of money by moving money from low-consumption, high-investment rich people to high-consumption, low-investment poor-to-middle-class people. Increase money velocity, and you'll see price inflation to compensate.
- pyoung 10y agoBut if we are demand constrained as opposed to supply constrained for most consumer goods, than you will see an increase in 'Q', not 'P'.
- mjevans 10y agoEnergy, time and space. Distance is effort, both in energy and time. Space is already constrained by historical distributional of 'valuable' lands, and restrictions on new ones. There's nowhere left to go out and just settle that someone else doesn't already claim somehow. (Yes, if you go out of the solar system you might claim that... but that's literally how bad the issue is.) The real solution is increasing supply. Yes, UBI will help individuals, but society must actively balance to ensure that there is enough supply in the markets to maintain liquidity. Otherwise (as we see with housing) flow seizes and prices dramatically rise.
- pyoung 10y agoEnergy: It's getting cheaper and cheaper thanks to competing technologies. California's wholesale rate went negative (due to solar) for the first time ever in April. If you are unemployed and on UBI, you have more freedom to to take advantage of time-of-use rates. Or better yet, hook up some cheap solar panels and some lead-acid batteries and make your own energy. Time: If you are unemployed and on UBI, you have more free time. If prices spike for food, then you can always grow your own. If prices spike for gasoline, then ride a bike. Space: With UBI, you no longer need to cram into a handful of high-growth economic areas. You can move to cheaper areas, grow your own food, and ride a bike everywhere. People with a lot of free time, and not a lot of money, will be a lot more price sensitive than in our current environment (where time = money). If prices rise due to inflation, they will either do without, or find/create a substitute.
- omginternets 10y agoWhat is meant by "velocity" in this context? I'm unfamiliar with the term.
- desdiv 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money
- imh 10y agoWould adopting UBI correspond to a one-time step increase in velocity that sits constant again afterwards?
- nateberkopec 10y agoProbably, yes. But the question is how much of a bump in prices that translates to - how much of the UBI will it wipe out?
- haltingthoughts 10y agoHousing, Education, Healthcare are supply limited and pretty important to the poor and UBI doesn't fix that.
- vkou 10y agoThere is no law of economics that says the latter two have to be supply limited, to the grotesque extent that they are. I'll give you housing though. One of the reasons housing is expensive, though, is because it is closely tied to job opportunities.
- haltingthoughts 10y agoExactly, there are many laws that result in those being very supply limited.
- vkou 10y agoI strongly doubt that. Which laws do this for education? Could you point me to a couple? There isn't some sinister cabal of teachers, that restricts supply, for the purposes of keeping their wages high. There isn't a grotesque system of receipts payable, and the user not paying the real price of service, and hidden, unitemizable fees at my local high school (Two of those do, however, start appearing when you go to university.) There is more then enough education to go around. The problem is that it's not evenly distributed. I'm not talking about sending every kid to Harvard, here. Healthcare certainly has people restricting its supply, but also has the exact same problem. We have the budgets for it, we have the doctors, and nurses to provide it - but we don't provide it very evenly.
- redahs 10y agoHousing is expensive because public spending is currently paid for using taxes on labor and its products rather than taxes on land. Public spending on infrastructure and services raises land values, as parks, police, and fire departments make locations more attractive to live in. This subsidizes landholders and allows them to charge higher rent whenever these services are paid for by a tax on labor rather than a tax on land. With a land value tax, landholders have to privately invest in improving the private property on their land, such as expanding the supply of housing units, in order to increase their profits. Without a land value tax, landholders can earn greater rent and profit without actually privately investing in improving their property. They simply have to lobby for higher public spending paid for via taxes on income or consumption and then they can raise rents without competing to improve their supply.
- CJKinni 10y ago> All sane UBI proposals don't create money, they just move money from rich people to poor people I'm not very educated in this, so correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding was that while UBI doesn't create money, but it can move money from people with a lower ratio of money-spent to money-made, to people with a higher ratio. If that's the case, the money that's actively being used should increase.
- grasshopperpurp 10y agoYes, that's one of the problems we're already facing, as I understand it. Too much of the money is in too few hands, and it's not being circulated back into the economy the way that it would be if that money was spread out among more individuals.
- DougBTX 10y agoWhat do you mean by, "actively being used" though? The rich tend to want a return on their money, "invested" seems like a type of use, even if it is passive. Crazy hypothetically, if it reduced the money available for investment, it might raise the interest rate on loans, reducing the rate of lending, so reducing the total money supply.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI'm not sure that the rich usually invest in terms of making loans available, so I don't think your concern will happen. What might happen is a decrease in investment, which might lead to a decrease in economic growth. (Or, alternately, to a decrease in the rate of installation of automation, which might preserves jobs...)
- prostoalex 10y ago> I'm not sure that the rich usually invest in terms of making loans available, Outside of the $100+ trillion bond market the examples are indeed hard to come by.
- Retric 10y ago
- mamon 10y agoThe problem with taking money from the rich and giving it to the poor is that you undermine riches' motivation. If you limit the prize, then you also limit amount of effort that one is willing to make to get it. Therefore, after UBI is introduced on mass scale we might see a slow but steady decline in economic activity: fewer new companies started, fewer investments made, riches focusing on tax evasion and moving their business abroad instead of just running and developing it, resulting in recession. Of course you can go with nuclear option and forfeit all their properties at once, in the name of social justice (does that ring a bell?) but you can only do it once, and eventually will run out of the money seized this way.
- zimzam 10y agoThis assumes that the primary reason to start a company is to become fantastically wealthy, which I would contest. Sure, most founders want to get rich, but I'd assert most would be just as happy to end up in the 8 figure range ($10's of millions) as they would in the 9-10 figure range. (And such a reduction would require taxes on a scale far beyond what UBI would require) Few people are going to consider starting a company and then sit down, calculate their tax burden as a billionaire and decide that it isn't worth starting Apple, Facebook or Google.
- rhino369 10y agoFounders might looking for a good living and glory, but VC's for example are looking to really capitalize on 100X growth.
- ThatGeoGuy 10y agoTo play devil's advocate: you may not need VC's as much in a UBI world. You don't have to worry about income if your startup fails, so you're less likely to play the VC lottery in hopes that you can ride the funding into a successful exit.
- orthecreedence 10y ago
- milesvp 10y agoThere's inflation that the CPI tracks. And then there's inflation in a given sector, or product group. Basically inflation happens any time you shift the money supply around, be it with government regulation, or with economic booms or "gold rushes" (just look at what happened in the shale boom town economies). I can guarantee that there will be inflation in areas of the market that cater to poorer people. There is a pretty basic economics law that says when demand for goods go up (aka more money chasing a good) it's price will tend to go up relative to to the "price elasticity" for the good. Things like basic food stuffs will get more expensive, because there will be more money chasing it. Rents will go up, since disproportionately more poor people rent. Hopefully much of this will be offset by people being free to move to cheaper cities, since they no longer need to worry about work income as much. Alcohol and tobacco will likely get more expensive as well. You're right, in that eventually production will ramp up to meet increased demand, but it's usually not 1 to 1 increase, which means you'll still have higher prices in the long term (though it does happen occasionally where increased demand leads to lower prices because the volume allows for economies of scale in production). UBI isn't likely to be the silver bullet that many think it will be. All the experiments have been short term, and inflationary pressures can be small and can take time to take effect. Also the UBI experiments have been in smaller countries, where social aspects may be coming into play. I'd really like UBI to work, since I dream of having enough basic money to sustain me so I can work on some of the science and engineering that interest me but might not have short term value, but my economics background give me an intuition that it can't be as successful as people think it will be. It'll likely be a beast that will require constantly increasing benefits as price levels rise to adjust to the new equilibriums, with ever fewer reasons to do the work necessary to fuel the costs. Maybe we're approaching a post scarcity world, but economics says no such thing is possible, that there is always something that is scarce that people will compete for.
- pg314 10y ago> Things like basic food stuffs will get more expensive, because there will be more money chasing it. Rents will go up, since disproportionately more poor people rent. Why would demand go up? Do you think these people are currently not eating and living in the streets?
- redahs 10y ago> Why would you expect inflation? All sane UBI proposals don't create money, they just move money from rich people to poor people. If UBI is funded via taxes on labor and its products (income and consumption taxes) then one should expect further inflation in housing prices, and ultimately the transfer of money from productive workers and entrepeneurs to unproductive landholders and mortgage lenders. If you don't want this transfer to occur, then you need to fund it via a land value tax, which does not allow landholders to charge higher rent in proportion to increased public spending. If you are funding UBI via increased taxes on income and consumption rather than land, then you run the risk of making the majority of people poorer if housing, rent, and mortgage costs increase faster than their UBI transfer payments increase.
- prostoalex 10y ago> they just move money from rich people to poor people That seems pretty cool if you're US, but what about Chad or Tajikistan where there are no rich people of the Forbes 1,000 variety and primary employment happens to be in government services? The closest examples we have are resource-rich USSR and Venezuela, both of which did not do well inflation-wise. The jury is still out on Norway or Saudi Arabia.