3 ms·
That is a pretty well presented argument for mass unemployment. But it suffers from all such arguments in that is extrapolates "today" into "tomorrow" without a
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
That is a pretty well presented argument for mass unemployment. But it suffers from all such arguments in that is extrapolates "today" into "tomorrow" without acknowledging that there are literally billions of variables at work.
A simple example of the challenges this sort of reasoning present; assume you're a being that perceives time very slowly, perhaps your lifetime is a mere 100 milliseconds rather than 100 years. But your perception is fairly good and you can observe and measure things several yards away in all direction. And you're living in seawater near the beach. Through out your entire life, and for several generations, the amount of seawater above your head has been growing and growing. You believe that eventually there will be sea water "as far as you can observe" above your head.
As an outside observer with a different time scale and perception, we "see" that this being is part of an ocean wave that once the mass of water above the center of gravity moves ahead of it because of water below being slowed by the the beach, the wave will 'crash' and fall into foam.
Now if we could explain this to the creature in the wave, or if the creatures there had some sort of stored history, they might know that in the past there have been waves and the waves have crashed and that the seawater never extended so far into the sky. And there might be debates because some waves reached a height that was higher than any other wave in recorded history and so maybe this time, this time the wave would grow forever.
Except from our time spanning view we realize that all of those fears and understandings arise from the the short lifetimes of the creatures versus the longer time of a wave cycle, and so few creatures will ever encounter another who has experienced "the crash".
These unemployment doomsday articles suffer from a similar myopia. Yes, technology does advance, and yes, it changes how people are employed and what it takes to be employed. Technology shifts however have not resulted in a 'net loss' of employment opportunities when looked at in the full view, ever.
So rather than focus on the 'loss of jobs' let us focus on "transition" support. I point out to people all of the time that we have tremendous gaps between supply and demand in what have historically been called "the trades."
The reality of that was brought home to me when I started a bathroom remodeling project in Las Vegas. For that project I need a plumber, an electrician, and a mason. Three classic 'trades'. I cannot find three people that I can schedule who are licensed contractors, any sooner than 6 months from now. They are all booked up, and as a result leaving money on the table from unfilled demand.
What is more, Las Vegas has very affordable housing. It was hit hard by the mortgage crisis and house prices have still not recovered in large parts of the city. So it isn't like a plumber can't afford to live in the city.
I really think we need to stop stressing out that the number of retail cashier jobs are going away and start figuring out why people aren't able to train for the jobs that are available and going unfilled.
- chillwaves 10y agoAnd how do you think large scale disruption of current job markets will affect the amount of demand for a skilled tradesman? You could have done away with most of your comment and just left the last bit.
- partisan 10y agoI take your point about the myopia in this article, but as humans, we spend all day extrapolating on the limited information we see. We cross the street on the assumption that no rock will fall out of the sky and hit us. Do we know there isn't a rock flying in at that moment? No, but we weren't hit in the entire lifetime preceding that moment. So we cross the street. Or another example: It's 2007 and my home's value is double what it was last year. And it's been that way for the past few years. Of course it will continue this way forever. And so on. We can only consider the variables we are able to account for. You can't go into a state of inaction because you haven't considered all of the variables. You'll never do anything if that were the case. Articles of this nature help to illustrate that the problem exists. Before we can focus on the "transition" support, we have to acknowledge and agree that there is, in fact, a problem. You might know there is an impending shift because we witness it (and create it) within the tech bubble, but the world at large is just coming to learn that change is coming. Kiosks at the movie theater are a natural extension of existing technology. It doesn't change the world. It's part of the process, but it's so minute that we don't consider there used to be 3 ticket sellers where there is only one now. It's the slow burn of progress before the inevitable shift that will come quickly and won't be entirely understood until after the fact. And as you said, we don't know what is coming, exactly, so how can we describe the solutions now? Truthfully, from your example, I take it to mean that you are facing the same problem every employer has: finding skilled labor. It's the case now and it will be the case in the future. These are the inefficiencies of a market-based economy. They present opportunities for those who can capitalize on them. Those plumbers should be charging more.
- wvenable 10y ago> Technology shifts however have not resulted in a 'net loss' of employment opportunities when looked at in the full view, ever. This rebuttal suffers from the same problem, it extrapolates "yesterday" into "tomorrow". A computer isn't the same sort of thing as a steam-powered mill or a printing press. A robot isn't a tractor. When we create machines that are simply better at work than humans both physically and mentally -- there isn't anywhere to go from there. There will always be jobs for people but we're eliminating jobs at a fast pace and there isn't anything replacing it. We aren't doing new things that require new jobs; we're doing the same things more efficiently with less people. This should lead to the future utopia of old science fiction but we will need to re-define what it means to be a functioning member of society.