9 ms·
Do vendors actually want to let users update the software on their devices though? I would have thought new shiny software was a nice incentive to get customer
by GordonS 10y ago
Do vendors actually want to let users update the software on their devices though?
I would have thought new shiny software was a nice incentive to get customers to upgrade to a new phone?
- jeron 10y agocustomers would be more inclined to buy from a vendor that does use Treble
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoBy this logic, shouldn't the Nexus/Pixel phones be a lot more popular than they are?
- s73ver 10y agoThey can't become popular if they're difficult to buy.
- therealmarv 10y agoexactly
- croon 10y agoI haven't looked at the numbers, but they're unavailable in a lot of countries, and are kind of expensive since a few generations.
- therealmarv 10y agoEnd customers don't even know that Nexus/Pixel phones exist (because you mostly cannot buy them everywhere) and they don't know the benefit from such devices and they also don't care deeply enough.
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoI agree that the Nexus phones are advertised poorly, but the Pixels have a lot of advertising in the carrier's stores here in Canada. The Rogers where I got my last phone, for example, had a dedicated display in the middle of the store for the Pixel phones.
- prophesi 10y agoThere's also the issue that the Nexus line were perfect budget phones, while the Pixels are high-end. So even with much better advertising, cost becomes the Pixels barrier to entry.
- GordonS 10y agoTotally agree with this. Nexus was good performance for an affordable price. Pixel is so much more expensive that Nexus owners are likely to balk at the price tag.
- Eridrus 10y agoAnd Google can't keep up with demand for Pixels: http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/03/14/nearly-5-months-google-still-cant-keep-pixel-stock/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/03/14/nearly-5-months-goog...
- archvile 10y agoThey might be, if people actually knew that they existed...
- joshmarinacci 10y agoThe way people buy phones is a lot more complicated. Most people pick a carrier first, and then the phone; and most people buy their phone from their carrier store (or a carrier booth at a place like Costco). Thus the consumer choices are controlled by the carrier. If a carrier doesn't want to sell a Pixel phone, then few will be sold, regardless of what consumers might 'want'. Apple is obviously an exception to this due to their own advertising and stores.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pjmlp 10y agoNot in Europe, generally. Most countries have more pre-paid users than on contracts, so we get our phones from computer or phone stores instead of carrier stores.
- petecox 10y agoEven Google abandons their products after a couple of releases. Perhaps better supported than other manufacturers but I'm running 7.1.2 on a Nexus 4 only through Lineage OS.
- MBCook 10y agoWould they? Or would 99% of them not know about this kind of stuff until it was too late? A huge percent of people with Android phones think they're Google phones (not Motorola or Huawei or Acer or whatever), so if they decide to avoid their old 'brand' wouldn't they try to avoid Android? Of course if they know they have a Samsung they can avoid that, but... This is what, the third or fourth try at fixing this problem? It needs fixing, but I'm rather skeptical at this point. Just because the hardware interface doesn't need to be re-created doesn't mean the vendors will ship updates. It will just be waiting on something else like vendor/carrier software customization that they're not going to bother with because they'd rather work on the new model. Good luck Google. This would be a great thing for everyone. I just don't hold much hope.
- jm_l 10y agoCompanies are incentivized in the long term to make good products. This incentive usually eclipses incentives that our (often justified) anti-corporate suspicions invent.
- bluehazed 10y agoJudging by the sheer number of devices running outdated Android versions and the consumer unfriendly tactics such as locked bootloaders, carrier-locked modems, bloatware, and sometimes even tracking software (fair to call this spyware?) employed by carriers and manufacturers I'd say that incentive to produce good products rarely eclipses these supposedly "invented" negative incentives. That said, Treble looks like a good step in the right direction. Maybe things will improve in the future.
- GordonS 10y agoI'd like to believe that. But profits rule. Smartphone usage must be pretty close to saturation point, in the developed world at least. Samsung, Apple etc release a new, expensive device every year, and it's natural that they are going to want existing customers to upgrade. I think the only way Android users (of non-Google devices, that is) are going to get software upgrades is if Google somehow forces vendors to do it.
- petra 10y agoIt might be enough for a single vendor to "break ranks" and go with treble to have a decent effect. Xiaomi did so with their large batteries, for example.
- GordonS 10y agoI'm more an Android guy, so I don't have an iPhone (except for testing on mobile apps I'm working on), and so I don't know what the update situation is like. But my (limited!) understanding is that when they release new iOS versions they are available at least a couple of generations back - is that correct? Or if you buy a network locked phone is it up to the network?
- ethbro 10y agoWe'll find out when the first vendor inevitably abuses a feature in the interface to specifically make their phone un-upgradable.
- Godel_unicode 10y ago> un-upgradable. I believe you mean "differentiated" :)
- madez 10y agoProduct differentiation is an underestimated evil of our time.
- mtgx 10y agoSome would argue it was what killed Nokia, too. It chose to go with Windows Phone to "be different", even though Android and iOS were already established and WP didn't have much of a market share.
- digi_owl 10y agoIt was pretty much what strangled the community efforts surrounding Maemo as well. Core pieces of early Maemo, like power management, was closed source, for "differentiation".
- sowbug 10y agoVTS is meant to address that concern.
- skdotdan 10y agoThey definitely want to be able to do so in a fast, cheap way. Another thing is whether they will actually be fair with the updates, but I'm sure that Project Treble will reduce Android's fragmentation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kllrnohj 10y agoIt's worth keeping in mind which vendors are being talked about here. Treble fixes the problem of "manufacturer who didn't do any customization can't update because Qualcomm never updated their drivers & friends" by ensuring that the level that the Qualcomms, Nvidias, etc... build against is forwards-compatible. So small manufacturer can just take a new android source drop from google and plop it on top of the binaries they originally got from qualcomm or whoever and tada! done. It doesn't help with the "OEM injected so much 'customization' that it's a disaster to move forward and will forever be abandonware"
- zanny 10y agoIf only a project existed to support devices beyond what the original manufacturers were willing to put out with singular consistent releases across all hardware. Oh yeah, Lineage. If only the company that made the OS actually supported the effort to perpetually support devices with a single OS the way Android should have been from day 1.
- oridecon 10y agoThe problem is that you have to trust Lineage's (just an example) developers and release process. If you want Google Apps installed you need to trust another 3rd party like http://opengapps.org http://opengapps.org or https://microg.org/ https://microg.org/. At this point I'm not so sure what's better: an updated OS or one full of known exploits.
- zifnab06 10y agoWhy wouldn't they be trustable? You always have the option of building it yourself. (disclaimer, I'm one of the leads & run their infrastructure)
- oridecon 10y agoLike I said, it was just an example. I don't have the time or knowledge to review an entire custom ISO and after that another ISO from the Gapps provider that I choose. I'm sure there are some tricks to cut down the review process time but anyway. It's a trade-off. I'm installing custom software to improve security, but at the same time, can I trust that this solution won't be a source of malware? I hope this didn't came out as accusatory, I was just trying to show another aspect of using custom ROMs.
- maxsilver 10y agoNot every vendor has an 18 month refresh cycle -- not everyone is just selling disposable phones and tablets A lot of people want longer Android support -- especially enterprise installations, which want to pay for software on 4-8 year hardware cycles, but the short length of Android's current support prevents them from doing this. There are lots of Qualcomm / Freescale chips running Android inside Airplane Seatbacks, and Hotel Kiosks, and Business Wall Signage, and more that simply will not be replaced for many many years. Today, Board OEMs are essentially forbidden from updating these, even if they want to (since Qualcomm / Freescale won't release the tools they need). After Treble, OEM Vendors will at least have the option of updating these devices, even without Qualcomm / Freescale / etc's permission.
- GordonS 10y agoYes, enterprise-size companies want this, especially with regards to security. But companies of that size buy Samsung or/and Apple (in general, I'm sure there are exceptions). Now, with the prices of these devices they are not exactly what I would call 'disposable', but (for Samsung at least, I can't say for Apple) update availability is highly dependant on the network carrier. I think Google needs to somehow force the availability of updates, regardless of whether the vendor wants to use updated software as a selling point for their latest phone - maybe Treble is a step towards that.
- maxsilver 10y ago> But companies of that size buy Samsung or/and Apple (in general, I'm sure there are exceptions). That's not really what I'm talking about. I'm not talking about corporate issued Samsung Galaxy Tablets. I'm talking about Android embedded into other products. Companies, of any size, don't buy Samsung or Apple for this because neither of those companies really exist in those markets at all. I'm talking about devices like the Delta Kiosk you use to print your Airline tickets. The self-service checkout machine you use at WalMart. The LCD panel in the wall of an corporate HQ that shows all Outlook meetings scheduled in that room. The newer Smart TVs in Hotel Rooms that let you order pay-per-view and food to your room's bill. Many of those devices also run Android, and have no upgrade path even though their OEMs desperately want one. Project Treble helps them out, even more so than it might for smaller phone companies (like say HTC).
- neogodless 10y agoIf we look back through history, we'll see Compaq computers with awful software pre-installed... even bundles including ISP software (AOL, Juno, anyone?) But then we started to see Signature edition computers without bloatware (and Microsoft moving to make it easier to remove the extra software.) We can only hope that phones follow this trajectory. And maybe more quickly, as they can learn from the past. Sure, computer manufacturers liked new versions of Windows pushing computer purchases, but now we're at a point where Windows 10 exists, and updates are something not even the consumer can block.
- remir 10y agoA "Signature Edition" of Android would be interesting.
- happycube 10y agoThey did that for a while with Google Play Editions...
- danieldk 10y agoIndeed. And supposedly, the Android Silver program was going to continue this [1], but failed. [1] http://www.androidcentral.com/android-silver http://www.androidcentral.com/android-silver
- remir 10y agoDidn't last very long, unfortunately. I think it's because the average consumer doesn't even know what Android is and a lot of folks buy their phone at their carrier's store. In other words, there wasn't enough people that cared about this stuff to be viable.
- icebraining 10y agoIsn't that Nexus/Pixel?
- remir 10y ago
- jsz0 10y ago> Do vendors actually want to let users update the software on their devices though? Apple does because they can still generate revenue off old devices via AppStore sales and services. Also used / hand-me-down iPhones expand their user base by serving the low-end of the market. Android OEM's on the other hand get basically nothing from Google and don't want desirable used / hand-me-down devices devaluing their own low-end models. They can't even try to negotiate a more sustainable arrangement with Google because there's no viable alternatives to Android.