13 ms·
Cannes Will Ban Streaming-Only Movies from Competition
- anoops 10y agoAnd in the process kill creativity.
- thegayngler 10y agoThat will just force Netflix, Apple, Amazon and others to start producing their own movies. It will have the opposite effect.
- wmf 10y agoIsn't Netflix already producing their own movies which is what the dispute is all about? Now what Netflix/Amazon need is their own film festival and awards show (never mind, apparently the Streamy Awards is already a thing).
- harryf 10y agoEither that or they launch their own film festival to eclipse Cannes.
- dragonwriter 10y agoYou mean, I think, that it will force them to start distributing them in movie theaters (well, French theaters, but possibly more if other awards follow suit.) Which is possible. Alternatively, as those platforms become more important movie distribution venues, it will reduce the relevance of Cannes and other festivals/awards that exclude films distributed by streaming alone (or "not in theaters", which isn't exactly the same thing.)
- wapz 10y agoI think your second point is much more on. Think about MTV movie awards. I don't think it existed 20 years ago (just checked and it started 24 years ago but I never heard about it that long ago) and came about because of the unhappiness with the academy awards. If all the award ceremonies start excluding streaming movies and the same quality movies are being released I can assure you we will see a Netflix Movie Awards or Streaming Movies Awards come to fruition.
- smohare 10y agoIndeed, Cannes' policy will only serve to degrade its relevance.
- leereeves 10y agoI doubt it will force Netflix to show movies in theaters. Cannes is almost irrelevant, commercially, while Netflix is one of the most powerful movie promoters.
- 1ba9115454 10y ago- Any film that wishes to compete in Competition at Cannes will have to commit itself to being distributed in French movie theaters. This new measure will apply from the 2018 edition of the Festival International du Film de Cannes onwards. Makes sense. I guess they want potential winners to be viewable by the people and not appear to be promoting netflix as the only option.
- joeblubaugh 10y agoHowever, France also has a law that streaming services can't show a movie until 36 months after theatrical release.
- eridius 10y agoWhy is such a draconian rule enshrined in law?
- wwalser 10y agoRegulatory capture. Is that the right phrase?
- thaumasiotes 10y agoRegulatory capture would usually refer to an industry gaining control of the body that is nominally supposed to regulate it, like if the FCC was captured by broadcasters or the SEC was captured by banks. Movie production isn't what I would think of as a regulated industry; this seems more like regular lobbying.
- alexc05 10y agoIf you search the definition of regulatory capture you get: >Regulatory capture is a form of government failure that occurs when a regulatory agency, created to act in the public interest, instead advances the commercial or political concerns of special interest groups that dominate the industry or sector it is charged with regulating. Specifically in this case however, the "public interest" could be described as the preservation and promotion of French culture. Which in this case, could be argued IS served by the regulation that awards can only be given to the product which shows in French theaters. Since we'd have to note that it also means that it must pass all relevant French classification regulations. Now, I'm Canadian and we have a series of laws called "can-con" (which stands for Canadian content) where all licensed broadcasters must show a certain proportion of their shows as approved can-con (based on the proportion of the creative staff who are Canadians). This does have an effect on shoring up the difference in culture. I mean - so - maybe that results in Trailer Park Boys - but come on! That episode where Rush shows up? Pure gold. I think the requirement to restrict to cinema-only is a bit of a sledgehammer solution but I personally see the point and think it's overall a good thing.
- kayoone 10y agoI guess it kind of makes sense because the Streaming-Only movies are not available to the general public in cinemas and require a paid subscription. "Normal" movies have a one-time fee too and these competitions are free advertising for every winner, but in the case of Streaming they are essentially free advertising for a movie subscription.
- tehlike 10y agoYou can always pay 9.99 or whatever the price and cancel after one month. Still cheaper than movies.
- cosmeen 10y agoYou forgot that the first month is free :)
- kayoone 10y agoYes, but general public doesn't know this and Netflix is not going around advertising this with high priority. Getting/Cancelling the subscription on a per movie basis is not the intended use of Netflix anyway, so it's gaming the system and netflix allows it.
- cheeze 10y agoThe general public doesn't realize they can sign up for a month long subscription of something and cancel it? Are you serious? How is that gaming the system at all?
- LoSboccacc 10y agoPsychology 101: People sign up for just a month. Don't cancel immediately after watching the movie they want, because they want to use the paid month in full. After two/three weeks the brain phases out the expiration date and the subscription renews. "But reminders!" the reader would complain so let me preempt that: not many person actually set reminders for this kind of stuff - part because 'it's only a month' part because not everyone is as phone dependent as techhies and mbas types. For internet and social? Sure. For reminding every little detail in life? Hardly. Especially since outside apple setting a reminder is still a subpar experience.
- raverbashing 10y agoI wonder how hard it is to produce a "digital cinema" cut of a movie. Probably not too expensive in the grand scheme of things It is mostly a non-issue
- nandemo 10y agoThe technical ability to show the films in movie theaters isn't the issue. The problem is that Netflix hasn't arranged for the movies to be actually shown in French movie theaters: > The two movies included in Cannes’ lineup this year are slated for theatrical bows stateside, but according to the festival’s official statement, “no agreement has been reached” to get the moves into French cinemas
- wtf_is_up 10y agowtf I hate art sourced from Netflix now
- sctb 10y agoPlease stop posting unsubstantively. https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- uhhhhhhh 10y agoWow, that's short sighted. Force streaming services to release in French theaters, force customers to pay someone else to watch the movie, and subject the streaming services to draconian french regulations on when they can stream that movie. So as Netflix, Amazon, and other streaming services take off, cannes will become less and less relevant as more and more movies are funded and produced by streaming services until cannes is that old french indy festival that was replaced with a more modern and movie viewer friendly festival.
- ekianjo 10y agoCannes losing relevancy is nothIng new. it was already old fashioned 20 years ago.
- quadrige 10y agoFrench cinema's current position in the world is mainly due to these kinds of stricts regulations, that allow small films to compete with big budget movies for the viewers' attention, and small theaters with big networks. Netflix, iTunes etc. are not just "normal" players in the film production business, they are also marketplaces fighting for distribution exclusivity, and they need to be regulated as such.
- sametmax 10y agoAs a french, I can tell you that what's french regulations are protecting is mostly garbage nobody wants to watch. For one "Amelie", you have a 1000 "les petits mouchoirs". Well I don't want my taxes to pay to protect those. Let the market decide. I already pay 13 euros for a freaking movie while I paid 5 times less 20 years ago. Netflix provides way better content than the french industry. French youtubers produce way better content that the traditional french medias. The independant scene, only getting scraps from this so called "cinema protection" does more creative content. Let the dinausores die please.
- quadrige 10y ago"Amélie" is by no means a small film, just take a look at Jean-Pierre Jeunet's other films' budget to get a sense of it. By small films I mean for example : - Sayônara by Kôji Fukada - Un avant-poste du progrès by Hugo Vieira da Silva - Psiconautas by Pedro Rivero and Alberto Vázquez Those are just 3 titles coming up from Allocine that launched this week in theaters. None of them will be on Netflix. Regarding the ticket price, it's indeed around 11-13 in big circuits, but around 7 in small independant theaters, so that's a reason more to encourage them.
- ameen 10y agoStreaming services are the future of media. If Cannes wants to be irrelevant then so be it. The hype surrounding Cannes was overrated anyways. France isn't even a major market to be making that kinds of demands. I foresee a major festival/competition for Streaming only media attended by A-list celebrities in the future.
- quadrige 10y ago>I foresee a major festival/competition for Streaming only media attended by A-list celebrities in the future. Sounds awful, why would you restrain a festival to only one method of distribution? Cannes is certainly overrated but they focus on authors first and foremost, and that's what led them to their current position.
- ameen 10y agoBecause the alternatives exist in plenty. There isn't a single respectable "Streaming only" festival/competition. Content produced for streaming services can be radically different from traditional studio content. Rather than think of it as a restraint it would be a celebration of the difference compared to traditional content. The "restriction" would allow for streaming only content to be on the forefront than be eclipsed by traditional media which still dominates the charts.
- orclev 10y agoInteresting perspective. I can't help but think of what happened with E3 and PAX. E3 decided that they wanted to be an industry only event and banned the general public and all but a handful of elite media companies. In reaction Penny-Arcade launched PAX as an E3 replacement for the general public, one that also focused more specifically on gaming than E3 had been. PAX was almost immediately a roaring success and E3 continued to slide into obscurity. It will be interesting if we see a similar dynamic play out here, with say Netflix launching a Streaming Media Festival or something.
- mbanzi 10y agoThe cannes festival can make any kind of demands it feels like irrelevant of the perceived market. Size of audience is not the only indicator of the value of a film. At the locarno film festival for example they show films who get very limited release, that doesn't make them less relevant for the art of cinema.
- jchampem 10y agoAs a Frenchman, it makes sense to me. Imho, watching a movie at home or in a theater are totally different experiences. At home you can get interrupted by anything (phone call, email, notification), whereas in a theater the risk of getting interrupted by something external are lower. (I agree though, that I could airplane-mode my devices at home.) Also, the ambience in a theater is much more different than at home, especially for comedy and horror genre.
- kagamine 10y agoEven with Airplane mode (or aeroplane mode as I like to call it) you can't stop my cat wanting to be let out/let in/ out/in/fed/out/in. A cinema is like an oasis of calm.
- pvdebbe 10y agoComplete opposite for me. Theaters are full of people who react audibly at the wrong things, chatter, phones... I loathe all that and won't see movies on theaters on that principle. I don't have any urges to check phone, imdb or anything like that during a movie. I usually have a break in the middle of a movie for more tea or bathroom. Besides that, a mere $1500 audio setup is enough to beat theater in terms of sound. Screen is the only thing that the theaters have going on, but I've been satisfied with my 42".
- invaliduser 10y agoI am not defending the position that banning netflix from Canne is right, because they have several high quality shows, so it's a pity, but note that in France the movie theaters audience is very respectful of the experience, and there is barely any inconvenience for the viewers (no chatters, no phones, no buzzing, it's pretty strict -- except in movies targeting children, because well, children are children and it's hard for them not to talk sometimes)
- pvdebbe 10y agoYou are right. The culture matters a lot. Maybe I'd tolerate French theaters better than I tolerate American or Finnish theaters.
- BugsJustFindMe 10y agoJust from reading the headline, my initial thought was "But Netflix also does DVDs, so they'll probably be fine?" But it turns out that the headline isn't a fully accurate representation of the article's message. > From now on, if you want to compete at Cannes, your movie had better be released in French movie theaters That's quite a bit more specific.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI don't think it's a bad thing to release movies outside streaming services. I think it's a bad thing to release in different periods in the world. Ps. Yes, I'm protecting theatres ( also small ones) on that. Yes, I have Netflix. No, it shouldn't last 4 months or more after being shown in theatres to stream them, perhaps 2 months at maximum
- manquer 10y agoBut why should theatres be protected ? .. They are just the distribution medium , not the art itself
- NicoJuicy 10y agoEven while they cost more, they give a lot of people jobs. Not everything needs to be as sufficient as possible. ( eg. Robots are taking over jobs in China at a high rate, while they already were very cheap considering globally)
- bentruyman 10y agoI imagine a late 1800's version of you would also require car owners to use their horse and buggy exclusively at least once a week because it will "give a lot of people jobs". That's some sloppy reasoning.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoBuy car or buy a horse is the same and vastly different of the point I was making. Not everything needs to go to the international companies. I'm also not against car sharing, buy a car to share or to have is also a bought car. Prereleasing a movie in theatres is not that bad for everyone, giving the exclusive streaming rights to one streaming party is much worse. Ps. Already a lot of movie renters are out of business, but I wouldn't protect them as I do with cinemas.
- manquer 10y agoBut why should theatres be protected ? .. They are just the distribution medium , not the art itself
- bolololo12 10y agoFrance has strong communist influences, that's why it is how it is
- thanksgiving 10y agoYou say it like Communism is a bad thing. Many people who have spent more than a moment thinking about it see the Communism scare for that it is - a scare tactic.
- shaftoe 10y agoMany people who have lived under actual communist governments see communism for what it is - evil.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- richardwhiuk 10y agoMany people who have lived under actual capitalist governments see capitalism for what it is - evil.
- saiya-jin 10y agoyet they are completely free to complain, or move to greener pastures of their choice. good luck doing that in some gulags or concentration camps of 'better' regimes. gotta love heroes from behind the keyboard that never grew up actually oppressed - it must be so easy to ignore benefits you have and just radiate hate because whatever. to sum up - no, capitalism is not evil. it ain't perfect, but much better than any other real alternative out there. if you hate it so much, why not man up and move somewhere better for you? you will make place for somebody who actually wants to live in it. or change that evil capitalism. but that's hard, easier to just complain from behind the keyboard, right?
- thanksgiving 10y agoIt is possible for communists to be evil but Communism can't be any more evil than anything else. There is mismanagement of public money everywhere. There are people who abuse their position of power everywhere. I can agree if someone says it is impractical but to say it is evil is just misplaced anger. Even if Communism is evil, it is still true that the people orchestrating the red scares were evil as well.
- timwaagh 10y agoits their competition. their rules. they get paid by the cinemas probably so it makes sense to ban competition which is killing cinemas.
- cies 10y agoFirst they ignore you, then ... bla bla bla ... then you win! — Some cool person that might not have even said it http://www.snopes.com/first-they-ignore-you http://www.snopes.com/first-they-ignore-you
- 5_minutes 10y agoNetflix will in a few years be completely "incontournable". Give it a few more years and Cannes will have no other choice then to allow their movies.
- znpy 10y ago«we like art, but only art painted with oil colours on canvas»
- iamben 10y agoIn other news, the music industry decides not to acknowledge any songs with a digital only release. Good luck stuffing the genie back in the bottle. [sigh] Filing this under 'terrible ideas'.
- ceejay 10y agoI imagine the next logical step would be for Netflix to start having their own (inclusive) movie competitions, and in the process more than likely become far more relevant than the exclusive competitions.
- koolba 10y agoThey should buy a cheap French theater and show each film there.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoSounds like Netflix should open their own competition up then.
- bingomad123 10y agoLooks like Multiplex lobby is pretty powerful in France.