12 ms·
Star Citizen Raised $148M from Fans, and Now It’s Raising Concerns
- ungzd 10y ago"Space exploration" games have strange tendency for hyper-hype and scams, for example recently released No Man's Sky.
- jontro 10y agoI have friends who enjoy No Man's Sky very much. Don't buy into the "mass rage" that spreads from some small number of people crying out loud.
- chc 10y agoI personally love the movie Spice World. I've known people who enjoyed literally getting punched. The fact that you know someone who enjoys something doesn't mean that thing is generally well-loved. I accept that Spice World was not a very popular movie. That doesn't take away from my enjoyment of it, but my enjoyment also doesn't negate its lack of popularity.
- TillE 10y agohttp://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/no-mans-sky/critic-reviews http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/no-mans-sky/critic-reviews
- coralreef 10y agoMostly negative across 73k reviews. I'll grant there is a lot of bandwagon hating, and that art is subjective. But this is the best data we have to use as a proxy for quality. http://store.steampowered.com/app/275850/No_Mans_Sky/#app_reviews_hash http://store.steampowered.com/app/275850/No_Mans_Sky/#app_re...
- abritinthebay 10y agoSteam reviews? Yeah, there's never any good reviews for a backlashed Steam game. Steam as a platform is great, but as a community it's a bigger dumpster fire than 4chan.
- chc 10y agoYou're not wrong that it could reflect an angry minority, but it's far more reliable than "I know a couple of people who liked that," which is the competing metric in this case.
- abritinthebay 10y agoNot really. That's actually a better metric in most cases if you a) trust the person saying it and b) trust their ability to review friends choices. Quite frankly I find Steam reviews to be one of the worst possible metrics and would trust the octopus that picked world cup winners more than Steam reviews.
- chc 10y ago> That's actually a better metric in most cases if you a) trust the person saying it and b) trust their ability to review friends choices. How so? Whether or not I trust someone has no obvious bearing on whether their opinion closely matches the general consensus. For example, I know someone who likes the 1990 version of Night of the Living Dead better than the original. I absolutely believe her on this point. But it would be ludicrous for me to say, based on her preferences, that the 1990 version is widely considered the definitive Night of the Living Dead.
- jontro 10y agoFeels like the conversation got pretty off topic. If a game is entertaining is a matter of personal preference of course. It's another thing entirely to call a game a scam. Looking at the subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/NoMansSkyTheGame/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NoMansSkyTheGame/ it looks like there is a healthy community playing a lot and game updates are released regularly. My initial point was to give a different view and to try to stop the negative feedback loop this game always gets.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoAny other examples? On the contrary, Elite Dangerous was received quite well. There is hype and scams all around in crowdfunded games, not just space ones, like Yogscast and Godus.
- Yuioup 10y agoBattlecruiser 3000AD?
- Ralfp 10y agoBefore Star Citizen, Chris Roberts was working on Space Exploration/Trade/Combat game for Digital Anvil and Microsoft Game Studios - the Freelancer. He was ambitious, the features planned for game involved: - dynamic economy based by station/planetary production of goods, demand and supply (influenced by distances and space piracy) - known actors lending their voices to characters - hundreds of items and ships - massive universe filled with mysteries and lore What happened instead was Microsoft stepping into the project and forcing changes to make ship plausible within a year due to continuous delays. Chris left the project. Universe was cut to 50 systems, bulk of characters gets killed off quickly after appearing in the plot, or have few spoken lines. There are omissions in items, like only only single top-class shield, whereas in every lower class there were three types of shields. Some commodities are sold on planet or few, but not bought anywhere in the universe, being useless for trade. Engine supports ship animations and plenty of ship models implement those, but they were eventually disabled. Etc. ect. But game shipped, and besides cut content, it actually delivered quality experience, and even if it lacked replaybility, content or sandbox features of X-Universe games, it contained stateful multiplayer that resulted in game having long live in multiplayer thanks to Role-Playing mods and communities build around those.
- fapjacks 10y agoImagine what CR could do with ample time and money... Aaaand that's Star Citizen! It's been very exciting watching CR work, and playing the stuff he's built and released already for Star Citizen. Absolutely incredible opportunity to be a part of. I'm very happy.
- 10y ago
- GVIrish 10y agoI don't think No Man's Sky was scam so much as it was a game where the hype far outran what was realistically possible. I mean, there's only so much a small indie studio can get done in a year or two, so people expecting the moon were just being unreasonable. In the case of Star Citizen we're deep into gold-plating territory, wouldn't be surprised if it became a Duke Nukem Forever. But even then, Chris Roberts is genuinely trying to deliver a game, even if his ambitions may have gotten too large to deliver.
- canada_dry 10y agoExactly. I call this the "Segway effect". It is when the hype far exceeds any possible realistic product.
- dkns 10y agoThe owner/lead developer (I don't know what position exactly Sean Murray holds) straight up lied about features in NMS (e.g. multiplayer) that weren't there nor will be ever added so I'd say it was a scam.
- AnOscelot 10y agoIf it's a scam, he's not scamming very well. A scammer would have taken the big payday and done little else. Whereas Hello Games has released a couple of large updates, and quite a few smaller updates / bugfixes, with more planned. The evidence largely points to a developer who is good at his core job, but inexperienced at managing hype. And who was overly optimistic about what he and his team can accomplish in X amount of time. Based on how Hello Games is acting & communicating now, I think they've learned their lesson. And I sympathise a little with them because I was once the overly optimistic team lead in my younger days, and had to get burnt a few times before I learned my lesson.
- sjg007 10y agoIf he's smart he's making a documentary/movie about it.
- 10y ago
- 013a 10y agoStar Citizen is a lot of hype. But its not a scam. Even in the case that it fails and a product is never produced, that doesn't mean its a scam. A scam requires up-front intent. They went big. They could have stopped at the few million they raised on Kickstarter, but they knew they'd need more to accomplish their vision.
- Nomentatus 10y agoI adore No Man's Sky, which accomplished something magical, and keeps expanding. I'd put games and DLC that are cheap imitations of what came before in the scam category; and there's probably less of that in SF games.
- al_chemist 10y agoThat's why they should never release Star Citizen. If they do, everybody will be disappointed. If they continue to release alpha previews, they can live on donations forever and all the fans will be still happy.
- apozem 10y agoFar from it for me to take anything away from Star Citizen hopefuls - I hope the game comes out and is good and fans have fun with it. But when I look at the mind-numbing scope and ambition of the project... It will be very impressive if they can deliver everything promised, as good as promised.
- ocdtrekkie 10y ago"Everything" promised is a completely unrealistic expectation. Even much smaller games with much more constrained concepts make changes during development to make a practical, functional product. They've already broken some "promises" and will surely break more. The question will be, yes, if it reaches the level of scope and experience they're aiming for, even if specific goals change along the way.
- ehnto 10y agoThat's why I am glad I backed though. We don't need another safe bet AAA war game. There is truly new ground being broken in the technology side of the project and that will filter out into the rest of the gaming industry, filling the metaphorical toolbelt with new tools. The engineering is the biggest time sink so far and it's not surprising it's creeped and taken longer than expected. They have invented novel approaches to new problems and that is worth every dollar I backed to see happen.
- yellow_postit 10y agoI've played a lot of Elite: Dangerous it is unclear how much new ground is actually being broken here. I'm looking forward to and hoping SC succeeds, but let's not ignore the competitors that have already delivered.
- ehnto 10y agoI would recommend looking at some of the more recent tech focussed ATV episodes. There is a lot more to SC than there is in Elite, which is not to detract from Elite at all. It is a different game and excels where it aims to. The underlying theme though is that SC is built of very finite systems that all interact with eachother. When Chris Roberts talks about fidelity it is often misconstrued to be about graphical fidelity. But it is equally applicable to the systems fidelity. In theory, after you have placed a cargo crate of goods in the cargohold of your ship and taken off, a pirate could shoot out your generator, hop out of their seat and pick up a gun off their gun rack, EVA to your ship, enter through a hole blasted into your hull and grab the individual crates to move to their ship. Later the pirate will store the crates in their homestead on a planet nearby, or pawn the goods at a market. Meanwhile you are left to fix your generator and ponder deep space. But the fact that you could steal the crate from a disabled ship isn't because they put in a crate stealing game mechanic . It's simply intrinsic in the way they are developing the item interaction system and physics systems in the game. That wasn't a great example but hopefully it conveys what I am trying to convey. This comment is also an example of how No Mans Sky disappointed everyone. Community based hyperbole. But I used only current features or 3.0 features to make it up so here is hoping. In the 2.5 Alpha you can already disable a generator, you can already EVA and board a ship. In 3.0 there will be planets, planet outposts and markets, cargo to steal and nefarious people to steal it.
- mabbo 10y agoI feel like crowdfunding sites ought to force each campaign to have a 'maximum funding' value they have to choose. That would both force the people building whatever it is they want to build to consider just how much money is too much, and also signal to those funding the project the kind of ambition the builder has.
- 013a 10y agoNearly all of Star Citizen's crowdfunding came from their own website, not Kickstarter. The Kickstarter "only" raised a few million dollars.
- pinum 10y agoA sibling comment pointed out that they did their own fundraising, but this is still a good point. The limit could be set to the highest defined stretch goal + n% to compensate for non-payers.
- ehnto 10y agoConsidering the crowdfunding platform makes its money from these kinds of runaway successes in funding, I don't suspect they have much incentive to offer such a feature.
- paulcole 10y agoAmazing delusional quote, "But imagine — the game I can build with $140 million is going to be very different to the one I could build with $10 million." Yes, it sounds like the $140 million game is not going to get made at all.
- Romanulus 10y agoImagine that... give people lots of money up front and no (or very low quality) work gets produced!
- pzh 10y agoThis is where the value of frugality really shines. The more money you have, the more bogged down in extra features and additional complexity you can get because of excess ambition or feeling of duty to your supporters. It seems that because of overfunding, these guys are already suffering from the second-system effect even without having built a first system to begin with. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second-system_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second-system_effect
- pfarnsworth 10y agoYes, feature creep at it's finest. Although this doesn't sound like creep it sounds like a full on race. It won't ever get completed.
- GVIrish 10y agoYeah I think we're far past the gold-plating stage and into platinum-plating territory. At least they've delivered playable content to backers but expanding the scope so dramatically also dramatically increases the chances of never delivering.
- dntbgoat 10y agoHow have people not yet realized that supporting a video game hype train will end in disappointment
- canada_dry 10y agoIt reminds me of the people who put significantly larger amounts of money into the "Aido" home robot - a heap of unrealistic promises in an unrealistic timeframe for an unrealistic price - it's way behind schedule but has yet to pull the rug out. (More on Aido here: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/aido-next-gen-home-robot--2#/comments https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/aido-next-gen-home-robot-...)
- sjg007 10y agoSomeone should start a kickstarter to investigate scams on kickstarter..
- djsumdog 10y agoI funded The Way and it was eventually released.
- bsder 10y agoProgramming is hard. Who could have known that? AAA studios don't act the way they do just for the sake of being an asshole.
- ehnto 10y agoNot to mention it took two years to build the AAA team to begin with. Also, immense scope creep. The game to be delivered is nothing like the game people backed originally, and hopefully that's a good thing.
- yellow_postit 10y agoUntil a game is delivered isn't it premature to label it a AAA team?
- screecwe 10y agoAAA refers to production quality of a game. The quality of what we're seeing is already AAA.
- ehnto 10y agoI think it is safe to say it is a AAA team, or at least it is the size and consistency of one. They have some very talented people working there. Whether or not they put together a AAA game I guess is to be seen!
- faragon 10y agoI wish Star Citizen to success. At least, the idea of a massive multi-player in the space, with economics, politics, roles, etc. it is very interesting, in my opinion.
- sjg007 10y agoUmm.. have you not seen Eve Online?
- faragon 10y agoWow, no, thank you! :-)
- scott_s 10y agoEve is a game I have never played, but enjoy reading about. It may be the largest, longest running economic simulation out there. Two good stories: https://www.polygon.com/features/2014/2/24/5419788/eve-online-thrilling-boring https://www.polygon.com/features/2014/2/24/5419788/eve-onlin... and https://www.polygon.com/2016/3/31/11334014/eve-online-war https://www.polygon.com/2016/3/31/11334014/eve-online-war
- arikr 10y agoOh dear. Reminds me of: https://twitter.com/mcgd/status/850347746452099072 https://twitter.com/mcgd/status/850347746452099072 "When the kleenex box is full, you take two. When it's almost empty, you might use one twice. That's why oversized financings are bad." It seems like the better route would be for them to make the $10 million game, and then to ramp up from there.
- tracker1 10y agoThat was my initial thought as well.. build the $10m game, ensure appropriate hooks for expansion.. then build lots of expansions... open contests to fund developer expansions from other dev groups... There's lots of more effective ways this could be done then to try to release a 9-figure game from the start.
- schmich 10y agoI've found this to be true not just of financing and money but of scheduling and time as well [1]. I wouldn't be surprised if this applies to many other resources, like employees in a company. For example, given the task of building a complex system under a time constraint, it's easy to exhaust the time granted, be it a week, a month, or a year. A complex system can always be more perfect, so you can always spend more time on making it better. A limited resource (e.g. a week) can force you to focus on the essential solution whereas an abundance (e.g. a month) can lead to frivolous design and overengineering. The antidote seems to be organizational restraint, concrete milestones, and constant readjustment to keep in line with greater goals. Scope creep, perfect-as-enemy-of-good, and bike shedding are all aspects of this behavior. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law
- SkyMarshal 10y agoActually the best route is to simply have a CEO/CFO who recognize this problem and are self-disciplined enough to divide the project into stages, and prioritize/triage what goes into each stage, starting with an MVP that can launch and actually provide revenue to fund subsequent stages. This overspending problem happens a lot in startups too (though VCs sometimes pressure startups to burn fast for various reasons having to do with the next round, which isn't really a factor with Star Citizen and crowdfunded projects). It's crazy there aren't more widely recognized best practices for teaching founders how to handle this issue.
- tracker1 10y agoI'm not sure why they didn't just "Build the $10m game" and release that, then spend the rest on expansions to that game. Would have been a much more predictable approach (assuming the original game is setup to be appropriately expandable.
- ryandrake 10y agoOr build the $10M game and return the remaining $130M to the backers, proportionally? My question is: What would he do if he got an extra $300M? Increase the scope even more? At what point do you stop increasing scope and concentrate on shipping a product?
- giobox 10y agoHow big a 'cut' does Roberts himself take as well? Given this endeavor is built entirely on the charity of the backers, I would really hope he isn't taking a percentage, but sadly wouldn't be surprised either if he is.
- fgonzag 10y agoWhy wouldn't he? All you are doing is buying something unreleased for a discount because of the built in risk. He gets to do whatever he wants with the money left over as long as he meets the stated goals.
- giobox 10y agoI think many people would argue that ethically/morally it's somewhat questionable - he's taken donations, not investment, and as such lacks any of the oversight/due diligence external investment usually attracts. Similarly, I doubt even a majority of backers actually understand the business/charity model they are putting money into - that we are now at 9 figures certainly suggests these are not "sophisticated investors". Was keeping a large amount of the cash for himself a stated goal? probably not, hence my curiosity. His business occupies a grey area between business endeavor and charity. Me in his shoes, I'd sure as hell feel bad taking a chunk of the donations. I'd have no issue with him pocketing the profits of traditional sales, should he ever reach that point - no one who donated was under the illusion a return would occur, but they should perhaps quite rightly expect that their donation at least pay for development, not lining Robert's pockets. I think it's also debatable the extent to which backers have "bought" anything, let alone received a discount.
- sbov 10y agoIt seems like a safer use of extra funding is for free expansions. It may seem unfair to take $140 million and build a $10 million game, but people funded you with your $10 million game, deadlines included, in mind.
- manarth 10y agoIt may seem unfair to take $140 million and build a $10 million game If a film spent $10M, and turned $140M at the box office, it would be seen as a success, rather than a con. Should a game be any different?
- wang_li 10y agoIt shouldn't be any different, however, this situation is: If a film spent $140M and turned $10M at the box office, it would be seen as an utter failure. Should a game be any different?
- kevinmchugh 10y agoGiven that games have different funding models and expectations w/r/t release dates, yes.
- megablast 10y agoGood point, except they are promising more to reach each funding goal.
- screecwe 10y ago
- thesuitonym 10y agoThis will probably not be a well-liked response but I'm going to post it anyway. I preordered Star Citizen back in 2012 or 2013. Whenever the original Kickstarter was. I've kind of forgotten about it. I've never preordered another game--or anything really. And I don't think this was a bad experience. I haven't received a game yet, but I have played some demos that were really fun. I've seen hours of content (Sure, that content is freely available, but so is NPR), read some great stories, and had some great conversations about the game. In 2013 I paid $60 for a game I have not yet played. That year I also went to a casino one night with $80 in my pocket. Both times I came away with nothing but a fun experience and some stories. In both cases I feel like I paid for some entertainment and received it. This isn't a post to excuse vaporware titles on Steam Greenlight or preordering broken-on-launch games. Quite the contrary. I won't buy EA games until at least a year after they come out. I will NEVER buy a pre-release game on Steam. But I bought Star Citizen. I took a gamble, and I had some fun. I wouldn't have done that if I didn't think there would be some fun along the way. Star Citizen could never come out, and I wouldn't really feel cheated, because I still got something out of it.
- locust101 10y agoThis might be true for this particular game but the lack of checks and balances on kickstarter is troubling.
- Xeoncross 10y agoThe number of checks and balances people keep adding when someone is bad is taking it's toll on some industries. Safe guards are good up to a point... then eventually it gets ridiculous.
- trimbo 10y ago> the lack of checks and balances on kickstarter is troubling The check and balance you're looking for is traditional capital investment, I think? Because if all things on Kickstarter clear a bar of "this is a sound business", then those projects probably wouldn't need Kickstarter. edit: for clarity
- 1_2__3 10y agoWith apologies to Mister Sinclair: It is very difficult to make a developer finish a game when his salary depends on not finishing it.
- tyingq 10y agoIf most of that $148M came in via KickStarter, their cut is 5%, so almost $7.5 million, on a single project. Really good ROI for a low-to-medium complexity website, and a company of 129 employees.
- scandox 10y agoThe article says only 2 million came via Kickstarter. The rest came through CIG's website.
- wavefunction 10y agoI think $2,000,000 was the initial Kickstarter target. I remember their finally tally from Kickstarter being higher than that.
- biot 10y agoNo need to rely on memory. From the KickStarter page [0]: "$2,134,374 pledged of $500,000 goal". However, it looks like the graphic showing $6M achieved combines the $2M from KickStarter plus additional funds they raised directly on their site. [0] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/cig/star-citizen https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/cig/star-citizen
- wavefunction 10y agoCIG raised about $6,000,000 on KickStarter if I recall correctly. Almost all of the crowdfunds came after they moved off KickStarter to their website: robertsspaceindustries.com
- acemarke 10y agoOff the top of my head, the initial month of crowdfunding raised approximately $6.5M, with roughly $2.5M via Kickstarter and $4M via the RSI website.
- 10y ago
- sergiotapia 10y agoStar Citizen will probably release when Overgrowth and Day Z come out of Early Access alpha.
- wavefunction 10y agoFunny, people expressing their "concerns" became a bit of a meme on the Start Citizen forums in the early days. As far as the meat of the article, I've been following Star Citizen as a backer since the Kickstarter days. My take on the history of the game's development is that Cloud Imperium Games was kind of unfocused and spinning some wheels for a while at the start as they attempted to build a AAA studio from scratch by partnering with smaller outsourcing firms for animation and modeling work. I think they misfired on some of their choices of early partners but that seems to have ended and they seem to be focused and moving forward. The thing a lot of people forget is that the game was initially going to be: "you log in, you spawn in your ship/you are your ship/and...dogfight". As well, many of the ambitious features that they've been successfully implementing like seamless travel across millions of kms of volumetric space were player requests. I know I requested the ability to fly from space to planet surfaces and also expressed that I would be content to wait longer for the game's release if that was possible. I don't really have sympathy for the folks who feel cheated or abused because from my experience, CIG has bent over backwards many times. Anyways, I'll get off the soapbox. I'm optimistic and the game is already fun, with only a limited amount of the full content to come (especially in June when they launch an expanded PU).
- ehnto 10y agoI agree, it has definitely been a community driven scope creep as far as I am concered. We are getting what we asked for. Some of the communication has been disappointing but everyone is learning here, this is a big and new undertaking and there is no protocol. I also don't understand how anyone could possibly want a worse game sooner outside of plain impatience. If you wait longer and the game is delivered near spec, it will be a better experience than if we get it earlier and sacrifice some features. To have both is ridiculous, it's not like they are twiddling their thumbs over there. They are progressing as fast as they can.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- raesene9 10y agoIIRC Star citizen got started in funding around the same time as Elite:Dangerous. It seems that the E:D approach has worked out rather better, in that they delivered an initial playable game that was rather lacking in some areas , and have been incrementally adding to that game over time in terms of both features and platforms supported.
- fapjacks 10y agoAs someone that bought heavily into both games, I have to be honest here when I say that E:D was a great short-term game, like many of those single-player games we're all used to. I quickly hit the grind part of E:D and stopped playing it. I should mention here that I'm an "explorer" subtype of game player, so the grind doesn't do it for me. On the other hand, I am a very early backer of Star Citizen, and I regularly (about once a week, which is a lot for me) play the alpha and because I'm also an Imperator subscriber, I get rental credits for new ships and weapons and stuff, so there's always something new for me to try. Then there's also the knowledge that the full persistent universe ("game") is yet to come. I've got a lot of ships to fly, and an organization/clan with lots of RL friends to fly missions with. I'm stoked for all the accompanying lore being built into Star Citizen. This universe already feels lived in and detail-oriented. I am confident that I could play for a long time and still not hit the end of the road to satisfy my inner "explorer" player subtype.
- mustacheemperor 10y agoI own elite dangerous and after visiting the subreddit after the last patch I really don't have much confidence in frontier anymore. It's becoming clear the game's codebase will never be able to support some of its ambitious promises (like not being your ship) and the features that are being implemented are shallow and broken, and then never further developed by frontier. I think E:D succeeded at initially playable but is failing to scale. It's a really fun experience in VR but I'd much rather it had stayed in closed development a year or two longer if that's what it would have taken for it to have real depth.
- xxr 10y agoAm I correct in my understanding that every dollar pledged essentially pushes the release further into the future since the developer is on the hook to add something extra with that dollar? Not that each dollar comes with a signed and sworn commitment, but more that the $500,000 game probably would have been out and actively enjoyed already.
- giobox 10y agoI may be misunderstanding too, but every time I read another story on Star Citizen's development, it certainly seems that way, and Robert's own comments suggest he will keep spending every dollar to make "the best possible" game. It certainly suggests that even if he isn't legally on hook to spend it all, he will try. He's arguably painted himself into an unfortunate corner by not imposing a fund raising cap - morally/ethically you could argue he has no choice but to try to spend all the dollars - to simply pocket 'the extra' cash would leave a bad taste in backers mouths I imagine, especially when they are effectively donations. I can't help but feel that when he reached 9 figures Roberts maybe should have considered closing the donations for a while...
- fapjacks 10y agoI understand what you're saying, but... Why should it, though? The Linux kernel is an example of a project that's been ongoing for decades. If Star Citizen puts out a product/service that fulfills the basic requirements -- and they will; at some point they'll reset the persistent universe and it will be very much "live", even while they continue development -- why should they stop iterating on top of it to add new features or other bells and whistles? I would much prefer a situation where Chris Roberts is the good king (a la Linus) of a project that evolves over the rest of his life into a truly remarkable and unique and world-changing game. How fun would that be? I think there's a lot of pressure from industry insiders who have LOTS of money riding on The Old Way of doing things that want to see CR fail. I'd love to see not only CR succeed -- and in many ways he already has -- but to continually succeed for as long as possible.
- djsumdog 10y agoBut couldn't he have done iterative releases instead? Give all the backers more that just a little demo, but a real mini-game that demos the tech and can keep gamers occupied for a few days. Slowly add more onto it? Or maybe release the game in 3 different parts? I haven't played any of the demos but it does look like a really impressive game. I probably won't play it as I don't like MMORPGs, but I did really enjoy his earlier work in the Wing Commander series.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoIt seems to me that Star Citizen is more about the journey than the actual game. I'm sure it'll be released at some point, but the fact that people are able to justify their purchase says a lot about the game and the community.
- brilliantcode 10y agoMy theory is scope creep. These guys have done a good job of convincing people that they can live the ultimate space exploration fantasy that's been talked about since the 80s. It's the ultimate simulation. We know very little about space and even fiction (ex. star wars) seems to generate even more demand. As people got excited and started throwing money at them, so did the scope obviously. I love Star Citizen's attention to detail but it's suffice to say that they've hit people's patience.
- kelvin0 10y agoI used to work in a small indie game studio (in the PS2 days) and the games we made had tight deadline (less than 12 months usually from start to finish). And even with such time and money constraints Scope creep would always rear it's ugly head. I can only image what goes on when the devs are let loose in the SC candy store with so much money and wanting to live up to the hype(so to speak). Scopeageddon, for sure.
- jlarocco 10y agoNo theory required: > “I’m already building the best game I can,” said Mr. Roberts, who acknowledged the bumps. “But imagine — the game I can build with $140 million is going to be very different to the one I could build with $10 million. If I can build a bigger and more robust experience, I will.” My guess is they keep going until donations taper off and they're about to run out of money, then rush out a massively buggy release that disappoints everybody.
- brilliantcode 10y agoSo basically, a crowd funded No Man's Sky
- aeturnum 10y agoThe Star Citizen tech is really impressive looking. I love watching their demo videos because they just look amazing. Their development process seems inefficient from afar. They've switched engines at least once, maybe twice? They've announced titles that then kind of fade into the background. They build really detailed systems for simulating light / gravity / thrust in ways that seem impressive & unrelated to gameplay. It kind of reminds me of Overgrowth, though with a whole lot more money (and charging users a whole lot more as well). I'd be interested to see, in 5 years or so, what the final-ish product looks like (I don't mean they're 5 years from release, I mean in 5 years they'll be past release).
- acemarke 10y agoThey never actually "switched engines". They've been on CryEngine since the beginning. They've heavily customized large portions of it, to the point that I think one of the devs estimated it was only 50% original code left. They also actually bought a full license to the CryEngine source, and stopped taking any real updates from new versions of CryEngine as the codebases diverged. They did recently announce that they were "switching" to Amazon's Lumberyard engine, but Lumberyard is itself a particular fork of CryEngine. The switch was primarily about branding and sponsorship. CryTek has been having serious financial issues, while Amazon is busy putting resources into Lumberyard. CIG also just switched all their backend cloud computing from GCE to AWS, and I'm sure they're getting a deal on AWS costs as part of the switch from "CryEngine" to "Lumberyard". If by "titles that fade into the background" you mean the Squadron 42 single-player campaign... yes and no. Yes, they've been deliberately very quiet about that, because as a single-player game they'd like it to actually be meaningfully new and interesting on release. Also yes, backers are getting a bit antsy wondering where SQ42 progress actually stands at this point. However, it's not like they've abandoned development on SQ42.
- Taylor_OD 10y agoI ended up with a free copy of Star Citizen when I bought a graphic card. At the point when I got it there wasnt much to do. I somehow still get weekly email updates from them but I've been expecting them to stop over the last 9 months or so because it seems the full game will never be finished.
- BEEdwards 10y agoGTA 5 took 5 years to developed, they've proposed a much more ambitious game. I'm not saying they're going to accomplish they're goal, but their dev time isn't even approaching unimaginable yet.
- ehnto 10y agoThey also didn't have a team sitting and waiting. They have had to build a 300 head team so they weren't at full productivity until year two or three.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fapjacks 10y agoI'm a High Admiral backer from November of 2012, and I feel like I've got my money's worth, and I'm not really concerned about the opinions of people that haven't put skin in the game. "This game is taking forever to be developed!" I suppose if your frame of reference is every blockbuster made by every enormous shitty studio conglomerate, sure. But saddle up or shut up as far as I'm concerned. Play what's available, read the development timeline so you actually know what's going on with development and what's happened so far, and then I'll take any of these criticisms seriously. It's pretty stupid the number of people saying things like "I paid my thirty dollars a couple of years ago and I still can't play!" Well that's your fault for not looking before you leap. You have known two things if you've read the packaging before you bought the beans: 1) Development is ongoing and the final game is not released, 2) Development timeline is not rigid and inflexible like it is for giant studios cranking out titles. This is Chris Roberts being given ample time and money to create a magnum opus. That is what it's been the whole time, and what it's been advertised as since the beginning. Outsider opinion is worth nothing.
- kelvin0 10y agoAs a High Admiral backer, you could also be a in High Commitment Bias? Not trying to be offensive. https://www.aqr.org.uk/glossary/commitment-bias https://www.aqr.org.uk/glossary/commitment-bias
- fapjacks 10y agoI thought about preempting your post specifically, because every time I mention that I've put investment into the game, someone mentions it. I think if you dig into my post history, you will find about six posts exactly like yours, link to more information included. Let me put it this way: I don't gamble with the rent money. That money is gone, and I'm not counting on a return. This is the way I think when it comes to this kind of thing, because any gains I see are a wonderful surprise. I started changing my psychology when I started going to war in my twenties: As I went out expecting to get hit, it was always a wonderful surprise when we didn't. It's pretty cool how that works for funding Kickstarter projects!
- palisade 10y agoNo one seems to understand. This is Chris F'ing Roberts. He's bringing us the Wing Commander sequel of our dreams. This isn't some random trying to scam people. He lives and breaths the entire space genre. Every space game owes him a debt of gratitude, because they took all of their concepts from his early games. If he can't do it, no one can. I wholeheartedly am behind his efforts, and if he needs another hundred million to make it happen then that is what it will take. I don't think I'm alone in this viewpoint.
- mwfj 10y agoMy guess: Star Citizen will eventually raise 500M USD. No full game resembling the original promises will ever be delivered. The "investors" will keep saying that with just a little more time, things will be perfect
- arca_vorago 10y agoI haven't bought into SC yet, but I do support them and have confidence they will deliver something worthwhile eventually. Right now my main reason for support is that they are planning to go Vulkan only, and Vulkan is what is going to allow gnu+linux to become a real competitor in the pc gaming market.
- gavanwoolery 10y agoThe original Wing Commander: Privateer had about 20 core team members and cost (guesstimating) around $3 million to make, inflation adjusted. To put that in perspective, Fallout 4 cost around $150m to make (IIRC), and that was an amazingly frugal budget for such a large game (Several AAA titles have budgets twice that large). To be honest, I would have been happy with something along the budget of the original Privateer. And that would have probably left him lots of wiggle room to experiment and engage in research-esque goals. I cant be too angry at him for being ambitious, or even changing his goals, but the #1 thing Roberts did wrong IMO was accelerating to AAA-style development and growing the team to 400 large before even really knowing what he wanted to develop. Spending a $100k+ on mocap and acting as early as he did is like producing a movie and then writing the script for it after the fact.
- acemarke 10y agoI would say that Chris Roberts has always had a very good idea of the game he _wanted_ to build, but but the original plan was to only build part of what he really wanted. When the crowdfunding kept coming in, it enabled him to go straight for building the game as he envisioned it, rather than iterating after release. It's also worth noting that CIG only hit 400 employees fairly recently. I know some of their major presentations have included employee counts over time, so you could dig up the exact numbers if you wanted to. I _think_ they had roughly 50 at the end of 2013, and maybe 150-ish at the end of 2014?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gavanwoolery 10y agogood points :)
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoI bought into SC when they promised Linux support. All this cool stuff that people are getting to play with early is Windows-only. I have significantly less patience with Star Citizen because so far as I'm concerned they've broken their promise.
- Neeek 10y agoI feel you. It's not a reason I originally backed for but I've been increasingly more linux focused so it's something I'd love to see. PCI passthrough with KVM looks to be the solution for now, but it does mean having a chunk of machine resources reserved for windows :(
- screecwe 10y agoWhy would you think Linux support would be something they would prioritize for a game that's not even finished yet? That stuff comes at the end of the development, not the middle.
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoI'm suspicious of your account. Regardless, if you have $148 million dollars you can support Linux whenever you damn well please.
- bobbles 10y agoThey have been upfront about plans and missed targets for the entire duration - communication is why people are still happy
- jhanschoo 10y agoI'm not a backer, but it seems to me that Star Citizen is progressing well. There's still active development and progress to the actual game, there's been several demos released, there's been constant communication. As long as they continually scheduling and releasing new Alpha builds incorporating their growing world as they flesh it out, I don't see cause for concern.
- botskonet 10y agoI hadn't heard about this game until right after No Man's Sky, which ruined my eagerness to back/pre-order things. Except for Everspace I have no backed or pre-ordered anything else, forcing myself to wait. As a developer working on a Steam game, I've decided not to let myself down this path. Kickstarter is tempting, but I'd rather release something when it's ready and build from there - if someone pays me, I want it to be for a product they can have now.
- acemarke 10y agoJust for point of reference, here's today's episode of the weekly "Around the Verse" video update series, showing what the UK studio has been working on: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADB-wpvTD0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADB-wpvTD0k . Just watching the initial UK update segment, looks like we've got examples of lighting effects, ship design and implementation, object interaction, and a lot more. I have no problems with people questioning CIG's ability to hit deadlines, or wondering what exactly the status of Squadron 42 is. Those are totally fair critiques. But, as long as they keep showing progress updates like this, I'm perfectly content to sit back and let them make the game we want them to make :)