6 ms·
Ma Bell's monopoly has never been "natural". It has been enforced by FCC, ever since FCC was formed for that specific purpose in 1934. Even before that, ICC thr
by jessaustin 10y ago
Ma Bell's monopoly has never been "natural". It has been enforced by FCC, ever since FCC was formed for that specific purpose in 1934. Even before that, ICC through the Kingsbury Commitment had adopted an ill-considered and unjustified hands-off policy with respect to Ma Bell's anticompetitive actions.
- warcher 10y agoJesus, yes, how did I have to scroll down this far before I read "ATT was a government monopoly"? Google doesn't have a monopoly on anything. They have the best search engine, but I can switch in seconds. Likewise the rest of their products all have very well established and really quite functional competitors. That I don't use, cause I like the big G, but I could if they annoyed me too much.
- amelius 10y agoThe whole issue of Google being a monopoly is silly. Fact of the matter is that they have a huge influence on the entire economy, and this influence is orders of magnitude greater than any other company.
- Shivetya 10y agofollow the money. they are a monopoly if it can generate penalties and further the careers of politicians with regulatory powers.
- cobbzilla 10y agoYou're describing regulatory capture, and it doesn't require a monopoly at all, merely deeply-entrenched players with effective lobbyists. Many, many industries engage in regulatory capture without having a single monopolist, e.g. pharma, defense, even say the SF housing market.
- digi_owl 10y agoYeah, the whole "monopoly" word brings stuff to mind that is more a distraction than useful.
- gozur88 10y ago"Orders of magnitude"? That's a stretch. I doubt Google has as much influence as major broadcasters.
- maverick_iceman 10y ago>this influence is orders of magnitude greater than any other company. This is silly, Facebook and Amazon's influence is comparable, if not more. And I'm not even talking about the banks.
- ellyagg 10y agoBut new and small businesses can't switch where they go to raise awareness, which always seems to be an underappreciated consequence of Google's monopoly. You either have to buy Google ads or do SEO, and if you SEO, Google can pull the rug out from under you at any moment and you have no recourse.
- jhall1468 10y agoConsumer protections are for the consumer, not businesses. Plenty of companies have managed to get brand awareness without Google. If you build your business to be entirely dependent on a single point-of-entry, then your business can have the "rug" pulled out by whatever the owner of that point is.
- lallysingh 10y agoThere are lots of competing vendors for display ads. You can also advertise on facebook and Bing. For search ads, I donno. If 1 tv channel was by far the most popular, would ads on it make them an illegal monopoly for businesses that wanted to advertise?
- notatoad 10y agoIn the context of deciding whether google is a monopoly or not, splitting the advertising market into "search ads" and "display ads" feels pretty artificial. Google has a monopoly on search ads in the same way that McDonald's has a monopoly on the Big Mac.
- 10y ago
- nickik 10y agoI don't quite understand what you are saying. It seem like your saying there is no natural monopoly but rather a government enforced one. Then you seem to say that the ICC did not stop 'anti-competitive' behavoir. I'm not sure what that means, all companies are against their competition. If there is not a natural monopoly why would any government agency have to do anything?
- ubernostrum 10y agoThe Bell System was allowed to exist as a monopoly because it was assumed telephone service would produce a natural monopoly. The US government stepped in to regulate it because of the lack of effective competition, and the result was a pretty cozy situation for AT&T for many years. Eventually the prevailing theories changed, and AT&T was forcibly broken up by an antitrust suit.
- jessaustin 10y agoA monopoly is a seller with few or no competing sellers. In many cases this is bad for consumers, so many governments have taken steps to dismantle some monopolies or ameliorate their bad effects. It's not clear that "natural monopoly" is a category that has any members, but the theory is that a natural monopoly is a monopoly such that dismantling it would have other bad effects that would be worse than the direct bad effects of the monopoly. That is the falsehood that various judges and regulators have countenanced over the century that they have refused to dismantle Ma Bell, while continuing to police other monopoly situations.
- cat199 10y agoNatural monopoly in this context is only a falsehood if one ignores the 'bad effects' of govt losing its capability of easy universal surveillance...
- Nav_Panel 10y ago> the theory is that a natural monopoly is a monopoly such that dismantling it would have other bad effects that would be worse than the direct bad effects of the monopoly Hm? That's not what it means. Natural Monopoly actually has a very clear Economics 101 definition: "[a]n industry in which multi-firm production is more costly than production by a monopoly"[1]. Or, paraphrased, a natural monopoly is one where fixed costs/barriers to entry are so high that it is difficult to have competition. It seems that in your OP, you're implying that a "natural monopoly" is one that arises without intervention -- this is often the opposite of the case, governments intentionally create and support natural monopolies when they can identify them. Telephone service is a great example. Laying physical wires costs a lot of money. Laying the physical wires is probably the most expensive part of providing telephone service. Having multiple companies in competition would result in costs rising for everyone, because the cost to lay the wires is the same for each company, but each company has fewer subscribers to pay off those costs. In this case, a regulated monopoly is the best thing for consumers, with the idea that government regulation would offset the issues that come from monopoly status. "Utilities" as a whole are typically natural monopolies. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly#Formal_definition_of_a_natural_monopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly#Formal_defini... (R.I.P. William Baumol)
- ggggtez 10y agoI was a bit surprised myself. It's not illegal to write a chrome extension that blocks ads (yet), but if you try to cut off money from phone companies, you can be sure you'll get jail time...
- ilanco 10y ago> if you try to cut off money from phone companies, you can be sure you'll get jail time What do you mean by that?
- guelo 10y agoFunny how just about every country in the world ended up with a telephone monopoly.
- jessaustin 10y agoJust about all of them tried drug prohibition too. Don't underestimate the power of USA's poor example...
- Thrillington 10y agoEvery new method of radically increasing information transfer speeds is ripe for monopoly.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 10y agoAT&T did not become a monopoly by government action. The Kingsbury Commitment was an agreement by the government not to take antitrust action against AT&T, not an agreement to prevent others from trying to compete with AT&T. The Communications Act of 1934 did solidify AT&T's monopoly by basically freezing in place the status quo. But AT&T became a monopoly in the first place by natural means.
- jessaustin 10y agoI find this reply to be in complete factual agreement with my original post. You've chosen to emphasize a point which seems unimportant, however. Rockefeller didn't use the government to build Standard Oil into a monopoly. It was a monopoly nonetheless, and the courts still broke it up.